This article reconsiders the association between childhood arts participation and cognitive and developmental outcomes. Using data from a large, nationally representative sample with extensive covariates, we employ propensity score weighting to adjust comparisons of children who do and do not participate in arts education (music and performing arts lessons) to address potential confounding from selection into arts education. We examine a broad range of outcomes in adolescence and early adulthood (e.g., GPA, self-esteem, college attendance). Our results show that selection into arts education is at least as strong as any direct effect on outcomes, providing no support for the causal associations between arts participation and cognitive outcomes. We do find that arts education increases arts engagement during young adulthood.
AllisonP. D. (2002). Missing data. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
2.
AnvariS. H.TrainorL. J.WoodsideJ.LevyB. Z. (2002). Relations among musical skills, phonological processing, and early reading ability in preschool children. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 83, 111–130.
3.
BarberB. L.EcclesJ. S.StoneM. R. (2001). Whatever happened to the Jock, the Brain, and the Princess? Young adult pathways linked to adolescent activity involvement and social identity. Journal of Adolescent Research, 16(5), 429–455.
4.
BeckerG. S.TomesN. (1994). Human capital and the rise and fall of families. In BeckerG. S. (Ed.), Human capital: A theoretical and empirical analysis with special reference to education (3rd ed., pp. 257–298). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
5.
BilhartzT. D.BruhnR. A.OlsonJ. E. (1999). The effect of early music training on child cognitive development. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 20(4), 615–636.
6.
BobekD.ZaffJ.LiY.LernerR. M. (2009). Cognitive, emotional, and behavioral components of civic action: Towards an integrated measure of civic engagement. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 30(5), 615–627.
7.
BodovskiK.FarkasG. (2008). “Concerted cultivation” and unequal achievement in elementary school. Social Science Research, 37(3), 903–919.
8.
CaliendoM.KopeinigS. (2008). Some practical guidance for the implementation of propensity score matching. Journal of Economic Surveys, 22(1), 31–72.
9.
CatterallJ.ChapleauR.IwanagaJ. (1999). Involvement in the arts and human development: General involvement and intensive involvement in music and theater arts. Champions of change: The impact of the arts on learning. Los Angeles: Graduate School of Education & Information Studies, University of California at Los Angeles.
10.
ChanA. S.HoY.C.CheungM.-C. (1998). Music training improves verbal memory. Nature, 396(6707), 128.
11.
ChappellS. V.Cahnmann-TaylorM. (2013). No child left with crayons: The imperative of arts-based education and research with language “minority” and other minoritized communities. Review of Research in Education, 37(1), 243–268.
12.
CheadleJ. E. (2008). Educational investment, family context, and children’s math and reading growth from kindergarten through the third grade. Sociology of Education, 81(1), 1–31.
13.
CohenJ. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
14.
ColeS. R.HernánM. A. (2008). Constructing inverse probability weights for marginal structural models. American Journal of Epidemiology, 168(6), 656–664.
15.
CorenblumB.MarshallE. (1998). The band played on: Predicting students’ intentions to continue studying music. Journal of Research in Music Education, 46(1), 128–140.
16.
Costa-GiomiE. (1999). The effects of three years of piano instruction on children’s cognitive development. Journal of Research in Music Education, 47(3), 198–212.
17.
DeciE. L.RyanR. M. (2008). Facilitating optimal motivation and psychological well-being across life’s domains. Canadian Psychology/Psychologie Canadienne, 49(1), 14–23.
18.
EcclesJ. S.BarberB. L. (1999). Student council, volunteering, basketball, or marching band: What kind of extracurricular involvement matters?Journal of Adolescent Research, 14(1), 10–43.
19.
EcclesJ. S.BarberB. L.StoneM.HuntJ. (2003). Extracurricular activities and adolescent development. Journal of Social Issues, 59(4), 865–889.
20.
ElpusK. (2013). Is It the music or is it selection bias? A nationwide analysis of music and non-music students’ SAT scores. Journal of Research in Music Education, 61(2), 175–194.
21.
ElpusK.AbrilC. R. (2011). High school music ensemble students in the United States: A demographic profile. Journal of Research in Music Education, 59(2), 128–145.
22.
FeldmanA. F.MatjaskoJ. L. (2007). Profiles and portfolios of adolescent school-based extracurricular activity participation. Journal of Adolescence, 30, 313–332.
23.
FisherD. (2001). Early language learning with and without music. Reading Horizons, 42(1), 8.
24.
FitzpatrickK. R. (2006). The effect of instrumental music participation and socioeconomic status on Ohio fourth-, sixth-, and ninth-grade proficiency test performance. Journal of Research in Music Education, 54(1), 73–84. doi:10.1177/002242940605400106
25.
ForgeardM.WinnerE.NortonA.SchlaugG. (2008). Practicing a musical instrument in childhood is associated with enhanced verbal ability and nonverbal reasoning. PLoS ONE, 3(10), e3566.
26.
FosterE. M. (2010). Causal inference and developmental psychology. Developmental Psychology, 46(6), 1454–1480. doi:10.1037/a0020204
27.
FredricksJ. A.Alfeld-LiroC. J.HrudaL. Z.EcclesJ. S.PatrickH.RyanA. M. (2002). A qualitative exploration of adolescents and commitment to athletics and the arts. Journal of Adolescent Research, 17(1), 68–97. doi:10.1177/0743558402171004
28.
FredricksJ. A.EcclesJ. S. (2006). Is extracurricular participation associated with beneficial outcomes? Concurrent and longitudinal relations. Developmental Psychology, 42(4), 698.
29.
GardinerM. E.FoxA.KnowlesF.JeffreyD. (1996). Learning improved by arts training. Nature, 381(6580), 284.
30.
GreenfaderC. M.BrouilletteL.FarkasG. (2015). Effect of a performing arts program on the oral language skills of young English learners. Reading Research Quarterly, 50(2), 185–203. doi:10.1002/rrq.90
31.
HallamS. (2010). The power of music: Its impact on the intellectual, social and personal development of children and young people. International Journal of Music Education, 28, 269.
32.
HallamS.PrinceV. (2000). Research into instrumental music services. London: DfEE.
33.
HelmrichB. H. (2010). Window of opportunity? Adolescence, music, and algebra. Journal of Adolescent Research, 25(4), 557–577. doi:10.1177/0743558410366594
34.
HetlandL. (2000, Autumn–Winter). Learning to make music enhances spatial reasoning. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 34, 179–238.
35.
HetlandL.WinnerE. (2001). The arts and academic achievement: What the evidence shows. Arts Education Policy Review, 102(5), 3–6.
36.
HoY.-C.CheungM.-C.ChanA. S. (2003). Music training improves verbal but not visual memory: Cross-sectional and longitudinal explorations in children. Neuropsychology, 17(3), 439–450.
37.
HofferthS.Davis-KeanP. E.DavisJ.FinkelsteinJ. (1998). The child development supplement to the Panel Study of Income Dynamics: 1997 user guide. Ann Arbor: Survey Research Center, Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan.
38.
HurwitzI.WolffP.BortnickB.KokasK. (1975). Nonmusical effects of the kodaly music curriculum in primary grade children. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 8(3), 167–174.
39.
KinneyD. W. (2010). Selected nonmusic predictors of urban students: Decisions to enroll and persist in middle school band programs. Journal of Research in Music Education, 57(4), 334–350. doi:10.1177/0022429409350086
40.
KlinedinstR. E. (1991). Predicting performance achievement and retention of fifth-grade instrumental students. Journal of Research in Music Education, 39(3), 225–238.
41.
LareauA. (2003). Unequal childhoods: Race, class and family life. Berkeley: University of California Press.
42.
LarsonR. W. (2000). Toward a psychology of positive youth development. American Psychologist, 55(1), 170–183.
43.
LernerR. M.DowlingE.AndersonP. M. (2003). Positive youth development: Thriving as the basis of personhood and civil society. Applied Developmental Science, 7(3), 172–180.
44.
LernerR. M.LernerJ. V.AlmerigiJ. B.TheokasC.PhelpsE.GestsdottirS.. . .von EyeA. (2005). Positive youth development, participation in community youth development programs, and community contributions of fifth-grade adolescents: Findings from the first wave of the 4-H Study of Positive Youth Development. Journal of Early Adolescence, 25(1), 17–71. doi:10.1177/0272431604272461
45.
LittleR. J. A.RubinD. B. (2002). Statistical analysis with missing data (2nd ed.). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons.
46.
MagneC.SchonD.BessonM. (2006). Musician children detect pitch violations in both music and language better than nonmusician children: Behavioural and electrophysiological approaches. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 18, 199–211.
47.
MahoneyJ. L.CairnsB. D.FarmerT. W. (2003). Promoting interpersonal competence and educational success through extracurricular activity participation. Journal of Educational Psychology, 95(2), 409.
48.
MehrS. A.SchachnerA.KatzR. C.SpelkeE. S. (2013). Two randomized trials provide no consistent evidence for nonmusical cognitive benefits of brief preschool music enrichment. PLoS ONE, 8(12), e82007. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0082007
49.
MorenoS.BialystokE.BaracR.SchellenbergE. G.CepedaN. J.ChauT. (2011). Short-term music training enhances verbal intelligence and executive function. Psychological Science, 22(11), 1425–1433.
50.
MorenoS.MarquesC.SantosA.SantosM.CastroS. L.BessonM. (2009). Musical training influences linguistic abilities in 8-year-old children: More evidence for brain plasticity. Cerebral Cortex, 19(3), 712–723.
51.
MorrisonS. J. (1994). Music students and academic growth. Music Educators Journal, 81(2), 33–36.
52.
MunteT. F.NagerW.BeissT.SchroederC.ErneS. N. (2003). Specialization of the specialized: Electrophysiological investigations in professional musicians. In AvanziniG.FaienzaC.MinciacchiD.LopezL.MajnoM. (Eds.), The neurosciences and music (pp. 112–117). New York: Academy of Sciences.
PatelA. D. (2009). Music and the brain: Three links to language. In HallamS.CrossI.ThautM. (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of music psychology (pp. 208–216). New York: Oxford University Press.
55.
PiroJ. M.OrtizC. (2009). The effect of piano lessons on the vocabulary and verbal sequencing skills of primary grade students. Psychology of Music, 37(3), 325–347.
56.
RickardN. S.BambrickC. J.GillA. (2012). Absence of widespread psychosocial and cognitive effects of school-based music instruction in 10-13-year-old students. International Journal of Music Education, 30(1), 1–22.
57.
RyanR. M.DeciE. L. (2000). Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations: Classic definitions and new directions. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 25(1), 54–67.
58.
ScalesP.BensonP.RoehlkepartainE. (2011). Adolescent thriving: The role of sparks, relationships, and empowerment. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 40(3), 263–277.
59.
SchaferJ. L. (1997). Analysis of incomplete multivariate data. London: Chapman and Hall.
60.
SchaferJ. L. (1999). Multiple imputation: A primer. Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 8(1), 3–15.
61.
SchellenbergE. G. (2004). Music lessons enhance IQ. Psychological Science, 15(8), 511–514.
62.
SchellenbergE. G. (2006). Long-term positive associations between music lessons and IQ. Journal of Educational Psychology, 98(2), 457.
63.
SchellenbergE. G. (2011). Examining the association between music lessons and intelligence. British Journal of Psychology, 102(3), 283–302. doi:10.1111/j.2044-8295.2010.02000.x
64.
SchellenbergE. G.MorenoS. (2010). Music lessons, pitch processing, and g. Psychology of Music, 38(2), 209–221. doi:10.1177/0305735609339473
65.
SchlaugG.NortonA.OveryK.WinnerE. (2005). Effects of music training on the child’s brain and cognitive development. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1060(1), 219–230.
66.
SchneiderT. W.KlotzJ. (2000). The impact of music education and athletic participation on academic achievement. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Mid-South Educational Research Association, Bowling Green, KY.
67.
SouthgateD. E.RoscignoV. J. (2009). The impact of music on childhood and adolescent achievement. Social Science Quarterly, 90(1), 4–21.
68.
SwardR. (1989, Winter). Band is a family. Today’s Music Educator, 26–27.
69.
ThompsonS. K. (1992). Sampling. New York: Wiley.
70.
VaughnK. (2000). Music and mathematics: Modest support for the oft-claimed relationship. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 34(3/4), 149–166.
71.
WetterO. E.KoernerF.SchwaningerA. (2009). Does musical training improve school performance?Instructional Science, 37(4), 365–374.
72.
WinnerE.CooperM. (2000). Mute those claims: No evidence (yet) for a causal link between arts study and academic achievement. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 34(3/4), 11–75. doi:10.2307/3333637
73.
WinnerE.GoldsteinT.Vincent-LancrinS. (2013). Art for art’s sake? The impact of arts education. Educational Research and Innovation, OECD Publishing. Retrieved from http://www.oecd.org/edu/ceri/arts.htm
74.
WinslerA.GaraT.AlegradoA.CastroS.TavassolieT. (2016). Selection into, and academic benefits from, arts-related elective courses in middle-school among low-income, ethnically diverse youth. Washington, DC: National Endowment for the Arts.
75.
WongP. C.SkoeE.RussoN. M.DeesT.KrausN. (2007). Musical experience shapes human brainstem encoding of linguistic pitch patterns. Nature Neuroscience, 10(4), 420–422.
76.
WooldridgeJ. M. (2009). Introductory econometrics: A modern approach (4th ed.). Mason, OH: South-Western, Cengage Learning.
77.
ZulaufM. (1993). Three-year experiment in extended music teaching in Switzerland: The different effects observed in a group of French-speaking pupils. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 119, 111–121.
