Cardiovascular profile of pharmacological agents used for the management of polycystic ovary syndrome

Abstract

Women with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) have an adverse metabolic profile with an increased risk of prediabetes and type 2 diabetes (T2DM); however, it is unclear if PCOS is associated with increased cardiovascular events in later years independent of the presence of T2DM. Many therapies have been used to treat the differing facets of PCOS, including those for menstrual irregularity, hirsutism, acne and anovulatory infertility. The aim of this review was to evaluate the cardiovascular profiles associated with the medications used in the management of PCOS and evaluate whether they have cardiovascular benefit, detriment or are neutral. The medications reviewed include oral contraceptive pills, antiandrogens, clomiphene and drugs specifically used in diabetes therapy; metformin, glitazones, dipeptidyl peptidase IV inhibitors and glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonists. This review concludes that therapies that are used to treat these patients appear not to add to the cardiovascular risk and that there is no evidence that any interventional medical therapy may prevent the onset of diabetes in patients with PCOS, though in the case of metformin, this agent may be beneficial in preventing development of gestational diabetes.

Introduction

Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) is the most common endocrine disorder among reproductive-aged women, and a recent systematic analysis suggests that the prevalence is between 6% (National Institutes of Health criteria) and 10% (Rotterdam and Androgen Excess Society guidelines). ¹ PCOS leads to irregular periods, infertility and increased androgen levels causing hirsutism and acne.^2,3 Women with PCOS show increased cardiovascular risk through a higher incidence of hypertension, an adverse lipid profile, and insulin resistance (IR).^4,5 Obesity affects the majority of women with PCOS, and they have a higher prevalence of impaired glucose tolerance (IGT), reported as 4.7%, and a higher prevalence of type 2 diabetes (T2D), reported as 2.4–5.1% in cross-sectional studies, compared with a baseline prevalence of diabetes in non-PCOS women of 1%.^6–8 A diagnosis of PCOS is said to confer a 5–10-fold increased risk of developing T2D and recent guidelines report IGT in obese and nonobese women with PCOS in the United States of America in 30–35% and 10–15%, respectively, with an additional 3–10% and 1–2%, respectively, having T2DM. ⁹ A recent Finnish study suggested that obese but not nonobese PCOS women were at an increased risk of T2D; ¹⁰ however, up to 60% of women with PCOS have insulin resistance, up to 40% have impaired glucose tolerance and 10% may develop T2D by the age of 40 years. ¹¹

Prediabetes is associated with the combination of IR and beta cell dysfunction, and it is reported that 5–10% of people with prediabetes convert to T2D, though this may differ by population. ¹²

Metabolic syndrome is comprised of obesity, dyslipidemia, hypertension and IR that is associated with increased cardiovascular risk, particularly if diabetes supervenes. ¹³ PCOS patients have a higher prevalence of metabolic syndrome, while women with metabolic syndrome have features more commonly of PCOS; ¹⁴ however, when weight matched with controls, obesity and IR are independently associated with metabolic syndrome in PCOS. ¹⁵ It has been suggested that metformin may be beneficial for those women with PCOS with metabolic syndrome or IGT to be combined with lifestyle advice and weight loss.^9,13

There is a 2.7-fold increased risk in endometrial cancer development that is related to unopposed estrogen exposure through chronic anovulation, which is addressed by ensuring endometrial protection and that regular withdrawal bleeds occur. ¹⁶ There is no increase in breast cancer, though there is the suggestion that ovarian cancer may be increased but that oral contraceptive use is protective; however, the medications used in the treatment of PCOS do not appear to have an excess cancer risk associated with them. ¹⁶

It is clear that those women with PCOS have an increased cardiovascular risk, with many studies reporting surrogate measures of atherosclerosis, including increased carotid intima media thickness, more angiographic coronary artery disease, increased endothelial dysfunction and a multitude of serum risk marker changes.^17,18 However, contradictory results from observational population studies make it difficult to assess the potential for PCOS to enhance cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Initial studies in patients with PCOS undergoing wedge resection suggested that there was no increase in cardiovascular mortality. ¹⁹ Conversely, the Nurses’ Health Study has shown that women with a history of menstrual irregularity have an increased risk of both nonfatal and fatal coronary heart disease, ²⁰ although PCOS was not diagnosed specifically in that study. A large United Kingdom (UK) general practice dataset of women with PCOS (over 21,000 participants) reported that there was no evidence of an increase in cardiovascular disease. ⁷ Conversely, a retrospective study on a database of 2301 PCOS patients over an 11-year period with a total follow-up time of over 12,000 person-years reported that there was an increased prevalence rate for both myocardial infarction and angina from the age of 45–54 years of 1.9% and 2.6% respectively and from 55 years to 64 years of 6.0% for both. The clinical aspects that need to be addressed in PCOS are shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1.

Therapeutic targets in polycystic ovary syndrome and pharmacological treatment (not all may be licensed in different countries). Targets in italics are those not specifically addressed clinically. GLP-RA: Glucagon like peptide receptor agonist; CPAP: Continous positive airway pressure.

It is therefore unclear whether PCOS confers an increased cardiovascular morbidity and mortality per se or whether this may be due to the development of diabetes and contributed to by obesity related parameters. One facet that has not been well described is the positive and negative cardiovascular risk conferred by the medications that are used as therapies in PCOS and are summarized in Table 1. The aim of this review was to evaluate the cardiovascular profiles associated with the medications used in the management of PCOS and evaluate whether they have cardiovascular benefit, detriment or are neutral.

Table 1.

Therapy used in PCOS and possible cardiovascular impact.

Classes of antidiabetic agents	Possible cardiovascular impact	References
Hormone contraception	Estrogen-containing OCPs may potentially have an adverse cardiovascular risk, increased risk of hypertension and dyslipidemia, elevated inflammatory markers, decreased insulin sensitivity	Sathyapalan and Atkin; 17 Randeva and colleagues; 18 Solomon and colleagues; 20 de Bastos and colleagues 21
Spironolactone	Decrease in triglycerides, increase in HDL and decreased insulin resistance. Cardiovascular benefits in patients with established cardiovascular disease	Christakou and colleagues; 22 Lidegaard and colleagues; 23 Okoroh and colleagues 24
Finasteride	No data on the benefits or detriments of this treatment on cardiovascular risk, only studies in men	Anand and colleagues 25
Flutamide	Decreases in the LDL/HDL ratio, total cholesterol and triglycerides	Zulian and colleagues 26
Metformin	Decrease in oxidative damage, inflammation and improvement in endothelial dysfunction. Cardiovascular benefit shown in diabetes; prevention of diabetes	Velazquez and colleagues; 27 Legro and colleagues; 28 Insel and colleagues 29
Thiazolidinediones (glitazones):	Reduction in insulin resistance, alteration in visceral to subcutaneous fat ratio, improved endothelial function	Day; 30 Ferwana and colleagues; 31 Cho and colleagues 32
DPP IV inhibitors/ GLP-1 receptor agonists	Very few studies. Weight loss with GLP-1RAs and potential cardiovascular benefit in diabetes	Ahren; 33 Gautier and colleagues; 34 Jensterle and colleagues 35
SGLT2 inhibitor	Studies awaited in PCOS to determine if the cardiovascular benefit seen in diabetes translates to PCOS	Pi-Sunyer and colleagues 36
Clomiphene	ECG QT interval decrease that may be protective for cardiovascular events	Dickey and colleagues 37

DPP, dipeptidyl peptidase; ECG, electrocardiograph; GLP, glucagon-like peptide; GLP-1RA, GLP-1 receptor agonist; HDL, high density lipoprotein; LDL, low density lipoprotein; OCP, oral contraceptive; PCOS, polycystic ovary syndrome; SGLT2, sodium–glucose co-transporter type 2.

Hormonal contraception

Combined oral contraceptives (OCPs) are often used as first-line therapy in women with PCOS to address menstrual regularity, acne and hirsutism. It has been well recognized that the long-term use of estrogen-containing OCPs may have an adverse cardiovascular risk, but whether this translates into additional cardiovascular risk in these patients is unclear. ³⁸

Oral contraceptives are associated with hypertension, dyslipidemia and an elevated C-reactive protein (hs-CRP), a marker of inflammation. ²¹ In addition, there is an increased risk of developing metabolic syndrome. ²¹ The decreased insulin sensitivity associated with their use depends on the progestin used, with fourth generation progestins being less impactful, ³⁹ and those containing cyproterone being associated with increased insulin secretion. ⁴⁰ All of these features are associated with obese patients with PCOS and with the increased risk of developing prediabetes and T2D;^6,7 however, a Cochrane meta-analysis suggested that OCPs did not affect glucose tolerance, though the evidence reviewed was not comprehensive. ⁴¹ The effect of OCPs on lipid parameters depends on the progestin component, with estrogen increasing high density lipoprotein (HDL) and triglycerides while decreasing low density lipoprotein (LDL) and total cholesterol. Those progestins with an androgenic profile are associated with a lower HDL and increased LDL cholesterol, the converse occurring with less androgenic preparations. ²²

Studies on the use of OCPs and alternate cardiovascular risk indices have shown that they are associated with increased hs-CRP, as a marker of inflammation, as well as elevated advanced glycation end products that are associated with increased cardiovascular risk, though whether these effects are offset or exacerbated by the metabolic effects of OCPs remains unclear. ²² However, no studies have addressed long-term OCP use in patients with PCOS to determine if there is an accelerated development of diabetes or other cardiovascular risk indices.

The risk of developing vein thromboembolism (VTE) with OCP use has been well established and increases with both obesity and age. ²¹ Oral contraceptives containing desogestrel, gestodene, or drospirenone were associated with a significantly higher risk of venous thrombosis than oral contraceptives with levonorgestrel. ²³ A higher rate of VTE is reported in those women with PCOS treated with OCPs, ²⁴ and in another study the risk of VTE was increased two-fold in PCOS with OCPs but was 1.5 fold higher without OCP use. ⁴² From a clinical perspective, many women use OCPs for short periods of time and, given the youth of these patients, the additional cardiovascular risk is likely to be clinically irrelevant. However, these studies suggest that long-term use in older obese patients with PCOS may not be beneficial for cardiovascular risk.

Antiandrogens

Spironolactone

Spironolactone is an aldosterone antagonist that binds to the testosterone receptor and is used in PCOS for the reduction of hirsutism. In patients with established cardiovascular disease and heart failure, spironolactone has been shown to be beneficial. ²⁵ In a number of small studies, spironolactone therapy was shown to decrease triglycerides, increase HDL and decrease IR in patients with PCOS ²⁶ and normalize endothelial dysfunction, ⁴³ though in combination with an OCP there were no cardiovascular risk advantages. ⁴⁴ Spironolactone may therefore have some cardioprotective benefit, but there are no medium to long-term clinical trials to advise on this in PCOS, though it may be of clear benefit in heart failure patients.

Finasteride

Finasteride is a 5-α-reductase inhibitor that inhibits the type 2 isoform, specifically leading to a reduction in the production of dihydrotestosterone, thereby leading to a decrease in hirsutism. Primarily used in men for the treatment of benign prostatic hypertrophy and prostatic cancer, a large cohort population concluded that there was no adverse cardiovascular risk in men. ⁴⁵ This is likely to also be the case in women, but there are no data to confirm this.

Flutamide

Flutamide is a nonsteroidal antiandrogen that competes for the binding of testosterone to its receptor and is primarily used in men to treat prostate cancer. It has been used in PCOS for the treatment of hirsutism and studies report significant decreases in the LDL/HDL ratio, total cholesterol and triglycerides that would appear to confer cardiovascular benefit. ⁴⁶ However, a serious limitation of therapy with flutamide is the rare occurrence of fatal hepatic necrosis, perhaps mediated by mitochondrial dysfunction.

Metformin

This guanidine-derived biochemical compound exerts anti-hyperglycemic effects via an increase in cellular insulin sensitivity and peripheral glucose uptake, a decrease in hepatic gluconeogenesis, and a reduction in the amount of glucose reabsorbed by the intestine and up-regulation of GLUT-4. ⁴⁷ However, its exact mechanism of action remains unclear, but adenosine monophosphate-activated protein kinase activation can explain many aspects of its effects. ⁴⁸ Metformin is a first-line treatment for glycemic control in patients with T2D, its major mechanism being a reduction in IR ⁴⁹ via its action on the liver. Given the increased insulin found in PCOS, metformin is used in PCOS where it improves menstrual regularity, though fertility may not be enhanced.^27,28 Metformin’s potential to reduce diabetes incidence was shown in the diabetes prevention study ²⁹ though this was not as effective as lifestyle intervention. Currently, the early use of metformin in PCOS to prevent diabetes remains unclear, though its role in gestational diabetes has been advocated. ⁵⁰ Metformin’s cardiovascular benefits in T2D were shown in the UK Prospective Diabetes study. ⁴⁹ This retrospective study involving 645,710 participants concluded that a decreased risk of atrial fibrillation in T2D patients resulted in those who used metformin ⁵¹ and this was attributed to metformin’s protective role against oxidative damage. However, this decreased risk was diminished after prolonged use of metformin for more than 3 years according to the same study.

Metformin has been shown to improve additional cardiovascular indices of inflammation with the reduction of CRP, advanced glycation end products ⁵² , soluble markers of inflammation and endothelial dysfunction. ⁵³ Unfortunately, there are no long-term studies looking at the cardiovascular benefit of metformin in PCOS, compounded by the issue that this is an unlicensed indication for metformin use and often used for short periods of time; however, the impact of metformin on cardiovascular disease is uncertain. ⁵⁴

Thiazolidinediones (glitazones)

Thiazolidinediones (TZDs) or glitazones are a group of oral antidiabetic agents that primarily act as selective agonists for PPAR-γ peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPAR-γ) and then modify the expression of various enzymes and proteins involved in metabolic pathways. ³⁰ TZDs have pleiotropic therapeutic effects in many metabolic disorders and improve insulin sensitivity and glucose absorption in peripheral tissues leading to their hypoglycemic effects. ⁵⁵ Pioglitazone is the only drug in this class available since the withdrawal of rosiglitazone (due to an increase in cardiovascular events) and troglitazone (due to liver toxicity). However, pioglitazone has been associated with bladder cancer. ³¹

Both pioglitazone and rosiglitazone have been shown to reduce IR in PCOS^32,56 and a meta-analysis confirmed the improvement in IR even though body weight increased. ⁵⁷ Treatment with glitazones have shown improvements in cardiovascular risk indices in PCOS with a decrease in visceral adiposity, lower triglyceride levels and higher adiponectin levels,^56,58 and with improvement in endothelial function. ⁵⁹ While it is clear that a beneficial cardiovascular risk may result from pioglitazone therapy, all of the studies to date have been small, short term or focused on an improvement in menstrual regularity and ovulation. It is therefore unknown whether long-term treatment of patients with PCOS would prevent the onset of T2D or improve cardiovascular events, though the PROActive and IRIS trials suggested a reduced risk of myocardial infarction and stroke. ⁶⁰

Incretin mimetics

Glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) is a hormone secreted from the L-cells of the small intestine in response to oral intake that stimulates a glucose-dependent insulin response. ³³ GLP-1 is rapidly degraded in the circulation to its inactive form by the enzyme dipeptidyl peptidase (DPP) IV ³⁴ that contributes to a short half-life and limits its clinical use.^61,62 Circulating GLP-1 may be prolonged by use of oral DPP IV inhibitors that result in physiological levels of GLP-1 or by use of the injectable GLP-1 receptor agonists (GLP-1RAs), resulting in pharmacological levels.

GLP-1 receptor agonists

Studies using Glucagon like peptide-1 receptor agonists (GLP-1 RA) have been undertaken with exenatide ⁶³ and with liraglutide,^35,64,65 and both therapies showing a decrease in weight, together with the suggestion of a decrease in testosterone levels. Large clinical trials on their cardiovascular safety are currently underway and the results of the exenatide EXSCEL trial confirmed cardiovascular safety. ⁶⁶ However, the LEADER study on liraglutide reported that the first occurrence of death from cardiovascular causes, nonfatal myocardial infarction, or nonfatal stroke among patients with T2D was lower with liraglutide than with placebo. ⁶⁷ This suggests that this group of drugs may have promise in the treatment of women with PCOS, leading to a decrease in weight and potentially offering cardiovascular protection. However, the cost of this therapy is likely to be too great and so will be restricted to aiding weight loss alone. ³⁶

DPP IV

DPP IV inhibitors inhibit DPP IV enzyme activity resulting in higher endogenous GLP-1 levels. There have been very few studies on the use of DPP IV inhibitors in women with PCOS, although alogliptin has been shown to improve IR in patients with PCOS. ⁶⁸ Since this class of drugs is weight neutral and their mechanism of action does not address any of the parameters directly in PCOS, few trials have been undertaken. However, they are largely well tolerated from a cardiovascular viewpoint, with the larger studies using sitagliptin (TECOS), saxagliptin (SAVOR-TIMI) and alogliptin (EXAMINE) showing no additional cardiovascular events, although there is still an unanswered question on hospitalization for heart failure. ⁶⁹

Sodium–glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2) inhibitors

Sodium–glucose co-transporter type 2 (SGLT2) inhibitors are a group of newly introduced antidiabetic drugs that inhibit glucose reuptake in the renal proximal tubule and lower blood glucose by inducing glycosuria, ⁷⁰ and decreasing weight. The cardiovascular safety profiles of two SGLT2 inhibitors, empagliflozin and canagliflozin, were studied in the EMPA-REG and CANVAS trials respectively. ⁷¹ Both studies showed benefit of treatment with SGLT2 inhibitors, with a decrease in cardiovascular deaths, as well as a decrease in the incidence of myocardial infarction and stroke.^72,73 These drugs may have promise in the treatment of PCOS but there are no trials to date and it is unclear if these agents have a direct cardiovascular effect.

Clomiphene

Clomiphene is commonly used in women with PCOS to address consequent anovulatory infertility. Clomiphene is a selective estrogen receptor modulator that competitively binds to the estrogen receptor. The main action of clomiphene is at the level of the hypothalamus, where it binds to the estrogen receptor resulting in its depletion, consequently blocking the negative feedback effect of circulating endogenous estradiol. ³⁷

While clomiphene is only usually used for 5 days continuously in any one menstrual cycle, it has been reported that those patients on clomiphene as therapy for infertility showed a negative correlation between the length of the QT interval and the increased levels of estradiol in these patients. This decrease in QT interval may be protective, as it would decrease the risk of developing cardiac arrhythmias in patients with long QT intervals, which can have fatal consequences. ⁷⁴ This observation can help explain the different outcomes in the two studies assessing the length of QT interval in PCOS patients noted above, as it is unclear if patients were on clomiphene therapy, which may have influenced the results.

PCOS and QT dispersion

The QT interval is the time during the cardiac cycle when ventricles are depolarizing and repolarizing. Prolongation of the QT interval arises from a dysfunction in the potassium channel responsible for the repolarization phase, therefore prolonging the duration of depolarization of the myocyte. This increase leads to the development of arrhythmias and syncope and may lead to sudden cardiac death. ⁷⁵

Studies have reported the length of the QT interval in PCOS patients, though with contradictory results. One study compared 25 patients with PCOS to 22 control participants based on their testosterone and estradiol levels, as well as insulin levels, and correlated those levels with QT length and QT dispersion. There was an increased QT in patients with PCOS associated with increased testosterone levels. ⁷⁶ Conversely, others have reported that in 119 PCOS patients with a median age of 32 years compared with 64 control group participants, there was a decrease in the QT interval despite the increased levels of testosterone in patients with PCOS. ⁷⁷ This controversy has not been resolved by further studies on the length of the QT interval in patients with PCOS; however, animal studies have correlated a decrease in the QT interval with increased levels of testosterone. ⁷⁷ It remains to be seen whether the therapeutic reduction of testosterone may therefore impact on the QT interval. In addition, spironolactone could potentially cause hyperkalemia which, in turn, could cause QT shortening.

Conclusion

While PCOS is associated with a plethora of cardiovascular risk factors, it is still unclear whether there are inherently increased cardiovascular events. The therapies that have been described in this review that are used to treat these patients, appear not to add to that cardiovascular risk and, indeed, in the case of metformin, may be beneficial. To date, the new therapies in diabetes, DPP IV and GLP-1RAs, appear not to have a place in the direct treatment of PCOS features, other than as treatments to effect weight loss using liraglutide, and SGLT2 inhibitors have yet to be evaluated.