Based on 21 in-depth interviews with chief executive officers (CEOs) and board chairs leading 900,000 people in large financial firms in Europe, this study surfaces the acknowledgment of strategic errors in top executives’ narratives as a broad theme associated with strategy change. This theme is intriguing because errors are typically associated with negative connotations undermining leaders’ self-image and credibility. More specifically, this study identifies in top executives’ error narratives a dialectic process consisting of mobilizing errors and de(if)fusing errors or distancing themselves from them; the paper models seven narrative practices within the process. As a first contribution to narrative research on strategy and change, this study introduces strategic errors as a narrative trigger in top executives’ retrospective accounts of strategy change, frequently associated with the plausible economic failure of their firms. Second, while extant research generally focuses on the coherence of individual narratives, this study adds on the relatively rare studies recognizing a dialectic in individual narratives on change.
Amankwah-AmoahJ (2016) An integrative process model of organisational failure. Journal of Business Research69(9): 3388–3397.
2.
AmisJBarneyJMahoneyJT, et al (2020) From the editors: Why we need a theory of stakeholder governance—And why this is a hard problem. Academy of Management Review45(3): 499–503.
3.
BalogunJJohnsonG (2004) Organizational restructuring and middle manager sensemaking. Academy of Management Journal47(4): 523–549.
4.
BalogunJBartunekJMDoB (2015) Senior managers’ sensemaking and responses to strategic change. Organization Science26(4): 960–979.
5.
BarryDElmesM (1997) Strategy retold: Toward a narrative view of strategic discourse. Academy of Management Review22(2): 429–452.
6.
BrislinRW (1979) Translation and content analysis of oral and written materials. In: TriandisHCBerryJW (eds) Handbook of Crosscultural Psychology: Methodology, vol. 2. Boston, MA: Allyn Bacon, pp. 389–444.
7.
CarrollJSChristiansonMKFreseM, et al (2021) From the editors—Errors in organizations: New frontiers in research and practice. Academy of Management Discoveries7(4): 451–460.
ClandininDJConnellyFM (2000) Narrative Inquiry: Experience and Story in Qualitative Research. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
10.
CloutierCLangleyA (2020) What makes a process theoretical contribution?Organization Theory1(1): 902473.
11.
CowleyCDenyerDKutschE, et al (2021) Constructing safety: Reconciling error prevention and error management in oil and gas and petrochemical operations. Academy of Management Discoveries7(4): 554–580.
12.
DahlJWerrA (2021) Sharing errors where everyone is perfect: Culture, emotional dynamics, and error sharing in two consulting firms. Academy of Management Discoveries. Epub ahead of print 14 December. DOI: 10.5465/amd.2019.0188.
13.
DaileySLBrowningL (2014) Retelling stories in organizations: Understanding the functions of narrative repetition. Academy of Management Review39(1): 22–43.
14.
DalpiazERindovaVRavasiD (2016) Combining logics to transform organizational agency: Blending industry and art at Alessi. Administrative Science Quarterly61(3): 347–392.
15.
DameronSTorsetC (2014) The discursive construction of strategists’ subjectivities: Towards a paradox lens on strategy: Towards a paradox lens on strategy. Journal of Management Studies51(2): 291–319.
16.
DavisJPEisenhardtKMBinghamCB (2009) Optimal structure, market dynamism, and the strategy of simple rules. Administrative Science Quarterly54(3): 413–452.
17.
DawsonPBuchananD (2005) The way it really happened: Competing narratives in the political process of technological change. Human Relations58(7): 845–865.
18.
de La VilleV-IMounoudE (2010) A narrative approach to strategy as practice: Strategy making from texts and narratives. In: GolsorkhiDRouleauLSeidlD, et al. (eds) Cambridge Handbook of Strategy as Practice. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press, pp. 183–197.
19.
DenisJ-LDompierreGLangleyA, et al (2011) Escalating indecision: Between reification and strategic ambiguity. Organization Science22(1): 225–244.
20.
DenisJ-LLamotheLLangleyA (2001) The dynamics of collective leadership and strategic change in pluralistic organizations. Academy of Management Journal44(4): 809–837.
FarjounM (2019) Strategy and dialectics: Rejuvenating a long-standing relationship. Strategic Organization17(1): 133–144.
28.
FentonCLangleyA (2011) Strategy as practice and the narrative turn. Organization Studies32(9): 1171–1196.
29.
FinkelsteinSSanfordSH (2000) Learning from corporate mistakes: The rise and fall of Iridium. Organizational Dynamics29(2): 138–148.
30.
FlemingA (1929) On the antibacterial action of cultures of a penicillium, with special reference to their use in the isolation ofB. influenzae. British Journal of Experimental Pathology10(3): 226–236.
31.
FreseMKeithN (2015) Action errors, error management, and learning in organizations. Annual Review of Psychology66(1): 661–687.
GergenMGergenKJ (2003) Qualitative inquiry: Tensions and transformations. In: DenzinNKLincolnYS (eds) The Landscape of Qualitative Research: Theories and Issues. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, pp. 1025–1046.
34.
GioiaDAChittipeddiK (1991) Sensemaking and sensegiving in strategic change initiation. Strategic Management Journal12(6): 433–448.
35.
GolsorkhiDRouleauLSeidlD, et al (2015) Cambridge Handbook of Strategy as Practice, 2nd edn.Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press.
36.
GoodmanPSRamanujamRCarrollJS, et al (2011) Organizational errors: Directions for future research. Research in Organizational Behavior31: 151–176.
37.
GrossTZilberTB (2020) Power dynamics in field-level events: A narrative approach. Organization Studies41(10): 1369–1390.
38.
HofmannDAFreseM (2011a) Errors, error taxonomies, error prevention and error management: Laying the groundwork for discussing errors in organizations. In: HofmannDAFreseM (eds) Errors in Organizations. New York: Psychology Press, pp. 1–44.
39.
HofmannDAFreseM (eds) (2011b) Errors in Organizations. New York: Psychology Press.
40.
HumphreysMBrownAD (2002) Narratives of organizational identity and identification: A case study of hegemony and resistance. Organization Studies23(3): 421–447.
41.
IngardiIMeyerCVerdinP (2021) Narrative genres in error and failure stories: A multimodal study of F**kup nights videos. Academy of Management Discoveries7: e0220.
42.
JensenMCMecklingWH (1979) Rights and production functions: An application to labor-managed firms and codetermination. The Journal of Business52(4): 469–506.
43.
JensenMCMurphyKJ (1990) Performance pay and top-management incentives. Journal of Political Economy98(2): 225–264.
44.
JohnsonGLangleyAMelinL, et al (2007) Strategy as Practice: Research Directions and Resources. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
45.
KotterJP (2008) A Sense of Urgency, 1st edn. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business Review Press.
46.
KüpersWMantereSStatlerM (2013) Strategy as storytelling: A phenomenological collaboration. Journal of Management Inquiry22(1): 83–100.
47.
LaineP-MVaaraE (2007) Struggling over subjectivity: A discursive analysis of strategic development in an engineering group. Human Relations60(1): 29–58.
48.
LangleyAMezianiN (2020) Making interviews meaningful. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science56(3): 370–391.
49.
LeiZNavehE (2023) Unpacking errors in organizations as processes: Integrating organizational research and operations management literature. Academy of Management Annals17: e0066.
50.
LeiZNavehENovikovZ (2016) Errors in organizations: An integrative review via level of analysis, temporal dynamism, and priority lenses. Journal of Management42: 1315–1343.
51.
LindeC (2009) Working the Past: Narrative and Institutional Memory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
52.
MaSSeidlD (2018) New CEOs and their collaborators: Divergence and convergence between the strategic leadership constellation and the top management team. Strategic Management Journal39(3): 606–638.
53.
MaSSeidlDMcNultyT (2021) Challenges and practices of interviewing business elites. Strategic Organization19(1): 81–96.
54.
McDonaldRGaoC (2019) Pivoting isn’t enough? Managing strategic reorientation in new ventures. Organization Science30(6): 1289–1318.
55.
MacleanMHarveyCChiaR (2012) Sensemaking, storytelling and the legitimization of elite business careers. Human Relations65(1): 17–40.
56.
MacleanMHarveyCGolantBD, et al (2020) The role of innovation narratives in accomplishing organizational ambidexterity. Strategic Organization19: 693–721.
57.
MantereSWhittingtonR (2021) Becoming a strategist: The roles of strategy discourse and ontological security in managerial identity work. Strategic Organization19(4): 553–578.
MilesMBHubermanAMSaldanaJM (2013) Qualitative Data Analysis: A Methods Sourcebook, 3rd revised edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
60.
MorseJMClarkL (2019) The nuances of grounded theory sampling and the pivotal role of theoretical sampling. In: BryantACharmazK (eds) The SAGE Handbook of Current Developments in Grounded Theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, pp. 145–166.
PlattCC (1992) Cases of cases. . . of cases. In: RaginCCBeckerHS (eds) What Is a Case? Exploring the Foundations of Social Inquiry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 21–52.
63.
PutnamLLFairhurstGTBanghartS (2016) Contradictions, dialectics, and paradoxes in organizations: A constitutive approach. The Academy of Management Annals10(1): 65–171.
64.
RaffaelliRDeJordyRMcDonaldRM (2022) How leaders with divergent visions generate novel strategy: Navigating the paradox of preservation and modernization in Swiss watchmaking. Academy of Management Journal65(5): 1593–1622.
65.
ReasonJ (1990) Human Error, 1st edn. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press.
66.
ReichertzJ (2019) Abduction: The logic of discovery of grounded theory—An updated review. In: BryantACharmazK (eds) The SAGE Handbook of Current Developments in Grounded Theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, pp. 259–281.
RiessmanCK (2008) Narrative Methods for the Human Sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
69.
RouleauLBalogunJ (2011) Middle managers, strategic sensemaking, and discursive competence: Middle managers and strategic sensemaking. Journal of Management Studies48(5): 953–983.
70.
SaldanaJ (2012) The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers, 2nd edn.Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
71.
SchildtHMantereSCornelissenJ (2020) Power in sensemaking processes. Organization Studies41(2): 241–265.
72.
SchildtHAMantereSVaaraE (2011) Reasonability and the linguistic division of labor in institutional work. Journal of Management Inquiry20(1): 82–86.
73.
SchreierM (2018) Sampling and generalization. In: FlickU (ed.) The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Data Collection. London: SAGE, pp. 84–97.
74.
SecklerCFischerSRosingK (2021) Who adopts an error management orientation? Discovering the role of humility. Academy of Management Discoveries7(4): 461–481.
SonensheinS (2010) We’re changing—Or are we? Untangling the role of progressive, regressive, and stability narratives during strategic change implementation. Academy of Management Journal53(3): 477–512.
77.
StoutenJRousseauDMDe CremerD (2018) Successful organizational change: Integrating the management practice and scholarly literatures. Academy of Management Annals12: 752–788.
TalebNN (2007) The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable, 1st edn. New York: Random House.
80.
TimmermansSTavoryI (2022) Data Analysis in Qualitative Research: Theorizing with Abductive Analysis. Chicago, IL; London: University of Chicago Press.
81.
VaaraELangleyA (2021) Communicative perspectives on strategic organization. Strategic Organization19(4): 541–552.
82.
VaaraESonensheinSBojeD (2016) Narratives as sources of stability and change in organizations: Approaches and directions for future research. Academy of Management Annals10(1): 495–560.
83.
WenzelMKochJ (2018) Strategy as staged performance: A critical discursive perspective on keynote speeches as a genre of strategic communication. Strategic Management Journal39(3): 639–663.
84.
WhittingtonR (1996) Strategy as practice. Long Range Planning29(5): 731–735.
85.
WhittleAMuellerF (2012) Bankers in the dock: Moral storytelling in action. Human Relations65(1): 111–139.
86.
WhittleAGilchristAMuellerF, et al (2021) The art of stage-craft: A dramaturgical perspective on strategic change. Strategic Organization19(4): 636–666.
87.
WuXLiYYuY (2023) CEO inside debt and employee workplace safety. Journal of Business Ethics182(1): 159–175.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
