Abstract
Objective:
To determine whether or not wave/interval dispersions in electrocardiography (ECG) are increased, and to define whether wave and interval dispersions are correlated with carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) levels.
Methods:
ECG, complete blood count, and biochemical parameters were taken from 87 patients with carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning as well as 90 control patients with similar age, gender, and body mass index distribution. COHb levels were recorded in CO-poisoning patients. The COHb levels and the relationships with ECG parameters were studied.
Results:
Pmax, Pmin, Pd, PRmax, PRmin, PRd, QTmax, QTmin, QTd, cQTmax, cQTmin, cQTd, Tmax, Tmin, and Td in ECG were higher in intoxicated patients than the control group (p < 0.05 for all). Pearson’s correlation analyses showed moderately significant positive correlations between COHb level and Pmax (r = 0.224; p = 0.037) and Pd (r = 0.222; p = 0.039). The receiver–operator characteristic (ROC) curve showed that a Pd value of 38 ms determined by ECG separates patients with a COHb ≥ 20% with area under the ROC curve of 0.78 (95%CI = 0.71–0.83), a sensitivity of 67.9% (95%CI = 59.4–75.6), a specificity of 95% (95%CI = 83.0–99.2], a positive predictive value of 97.9% (95%CI = 92.5–99.7), and a negative predictive value of 46.3% (95%CI = 35.3–57.7.)
Conclusion:
A significant increase in wave/interval dispersions in the ECG of CO-poisoning patients compared with controls may show that not only a part is affected but both atrium and the ventricles as a whole are affected by hypoxic ischemia. When COHb levels of the patients are unavailable, P dispersion on ECG may show CO poisoning level of the patient.
Introduction
Carbon monoxide (CO) is a colorless, odorless gas. 1 CO poisoning is one of the most common types of poisoning, and it is the leading cause of death by poisoning worldwide. 2 The symptoms can be minimal, even with extremely high levels of carboxyhemoglobin (COHb), as experiments on animals show. 3 In patients suffering from CO poisoning, obtaining COHb levels is extremely important by means of medical and legal aspects. For example, COHb levels >20% is an indication for hyperbaric oxygen (O2) therapy, and it is also an evidence of threatened life judicially. 4 However, it is a fact that COHb levels can only be measured in large hospitals.
Dispersion is defined as the difference between the maximum and minimum waves/intervals in electrocardiography (ECG). Nowadays, dispersion is studied in various illnesses. Recently, an increase in corrected QT (cQT) and P dispersion has been reported in patients with both acute and chronic CO exposure. 5,6
Our primary aim in this case–control study was to determine whether or not wave/interval dispersions in ECG are increased. Our secondary aim is to define whether wave and interval dispersions in ECG correlated with COHb levels. In this way, we may define objective ECG criteria of the patients with CO poisoning whose COHb levels are unavailable.
Materials and methods
Study population and protocol
The university ethics committee approved the study, and informed consents were collected from the patients. Personal folders of 334 patients with CO poisoning, who were admitted to the Emergency Department (ED) of Atatürk University Faculty of Medicine between the years 2009 and 2012 (39 months), were cross sectionally examined. Of them, 239 patients were excluded due to unavailable ECG and body mass index (BMI) data. ECG, complete blood count (CBC), and biochemical parameters were taken from 87 patients with CO poisoning as well as 90 control patients with similar age, gender, and BMI distribution. Complete blood counts were evaluated with Beckman Coulter LH 780 hematology analyzer. Biochemical parameters were assessed using Cobas 6000 (Roche). COHb levels were recorded in CO-poisoning patients. The COHb levels and the relationships with ECG parameters were studied. A total of 17 patients with unstandardized ECG and/or unavailable dispersion analyze on ECG were later excluded. The control group consisted of healthy patients older than 16 years with minor trauma such as ankle sprain, finger injuries, and so on who were admitted to ED and volunteered to participate in the study.
The initial blood levels of hematocrit, hemoglobin, partial pressure of carbon dioxide, partial pressure of oxygen, sodium, potassium, chloride, calcium, magnesium, lactate, bicarbonate, base excess, and pH were measured for both patients with CO poisoning and control group. Also, COHb levels were measured for intoxicated patients.
For both the controls and patient groups, the following ECG measurements were interpreted:
Heart rate: (HR, beats/min), Pmax−Pmin = P dispersion (Pd, ms) PRmax−PRmin = PR dispersion (PRd, ms) QTmax−QTmin = QT dispersion (QTd, ms) Corrected QTmax−corrected QTmin = corrected QT dispersion (cQTd, ms) Tmax−Tmin = T dispersion (Td, ms)
ECG from both groups was measured with the individual measuring blinded to the clinical exposure by the authors KK and YA.
Inclusion criteria
All the patients were older than 16 years with a BMI between 20 and 30 and in sinus rhythm and none were taking medications that cause ECG abnormalities like antiarrhythmic, antihistamines, tricyclic antidepressants, or antipsychotics.
Exclusion criteria
Subjects with thyroid function abnormalities, systemic or pulmonary hypertension, coronary artery disease, valvular heart disease, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, patients who had pacemakers, significant anemia, cardiac failure, or abnormal ECG were excluded.
CO measurement
CO was assessed by measuring blood COHb level from arterial blood using the Cobas b 221 Blood Gas System (Roche Diagnostics, Inc., Indianapolis, Indiana, USA).
ECG measurements
A 12-lead surface ECG was obtained from all patients while in the supine position at rest with 1 mV/cm amplitude and 25 mm/s rate. The patients were allowed to breathe freely but asked to refrain from speaking or coughing during recording. Durations, Pd, QTd, and cQTd were calculated according to the method followed by Sari et al. 5 P and/or T wave dispersion was calculated by subtracting the minimum P and/or T wave duration from the maximum P and/or T wave duration. The PR interval was defined as the time from the beginning of the P-wave to the beginning of the QRS complex. We found the shortest and longest PR intervals in the leads and measured the PRd as the difference between maximum and minimum PR intervals according to the method followed by Shah et al. 7 QTd was defined as the difference between the longest and shortest QT intervals; rate correction was performed with the Bazett’s formula: corrected QTd (cQTd) = QTd/√(R–R interval) in milliseconds. In all patients, derivations were excluded if the beginning or the ending of the wave could not be clearly identified. Wave durations were measured using a magnifying lens and a 0.5-mm-scale precision ruler. Intra- and interobserver coefficients of variation (the standard deviation of differences between two observations divided by the mean value and expressed as a percentage) were found to be fewer than 5% for all measurements.
Statistical analysis
Continuous variables are expressed as median and categorical data are expressed as percentages. The student’s t test was used for comparing continuous variables and the χ 2 test was used to analyze categorical data. The correlation analyses between continuous variables were performed using the Pearson’s correlation test. A two-tailed p < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant. A receiver–operator characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was used to determine the predictive accuracy of the Pd and Pmax for detecting COHb ≥ 20% in patients with CO poisoning. All statistical studies were carried out with the SPSS program (version 20.0, SPSS Inc., Chicago, Illinois, USA).
Results
A total of 87 patients with acute CO poisoning and 90 control patients with similar age, gender, and BMI distribution were enrolled (Table 1). In the intoxication group, the source of CO were natural gas in 6.9% (n = 6), water heater in 31% (n = 27), stove in 58.6% (n = 51), and fire in 3.4% (n = 3). Patients applied to the emergency service on average 1.5 h after poisoning. ECG was taken within 20 min in the ED. Mean time delay for admitting to hospital was 3.1 ± 1.2 h in patients with CO poisoning. There was no difference between the two groups with respect to laboratory analyses (p > 0.05 for each laboratory parameter mentioned above). All the dispersion measurements in ECG were higher in intoxicated patients than the control group (Table 1).
Comparative analysis of clinical and electrocardiograph of CO poisoning and the control group.
BMI: body mass index; COHb: carboxyhemoglobin; HR: heart rate; Pmax: P-wave maximum dispersion; Pmin: P-wave minimum dispersion; Pd: P-wave dispersion, PRmax: PR wave maximum dispersion; PRmin: PR wave minimum dispersion; PRd: PR wave dispersion; QTmax: QT wave maximum dispersion; QTmin: QT wave minimum dispersion; QTd: QT wave dispersion; cQTmax: corrected QT wave maximum dispersion; cQTmin: corrected QT wave minimum dispersion; cQTd: corrected QT wave dispersion; Tmax: T wave maximum dispersion; Tmin: T wave minimum dispersion; Td: T wave dispersion; CO: carbon monoxide.
For the intoxicated patients, Pearson’s correlation analyses showed weak positive correlations between COHb level and Pmax (r = 0.224; p = 0.037) and Pd (r = 0.222; p = 0.039; Figure 1). There was no correlation between COHb level and HR (r = 0.035; p = 0.751), Pmin (r = 0.059; p = 0.586), PRmax (r = 0.138; p = 0.204), PRmin (r = 0.15; p = 0.167), PRd (r = −0.066; p = 0.544), QTmax (r = −0.072; p = 0.509), QTmin (r = −0.049; p = 0.651), QTd (r = −0.089, p = 0.414), cQTmax (r = −0.015; p = 0.892), cQTmin (r = 0.006; p = 0.959), cQTd (r = −0.046; p = 0.670), Tmax (r = 0.115; p = 0.28), Tmin (r = 0.148; p = 0.170), and Td (r = −0.088; p = 0.415) on ECG. In the poisoning group, Pmax was positively correlated with Pd (p < 0.001), although not with age (p = 0.094). Pd was also not associated with age (p = 0.175). The ROC curve showed that a Pd value of 38-ms determined by ECG separates patients with a COHb ≥ 20% with area under the ROC curve (AUC) of 0.78 95% (95%CI = 0.71–0.83), a sensitivity of 67.9% (95%CI = 59.4–75.6), a specificity of 95% (95%CI = 83.0–99.2), a positive predictive value of 97.9% (95%CI = 92.5–99.7), and a negative predictive value of 46.3% (95%CI = 35.3–57.7; Figure 2). The Pd duration value was found to be above 38 ms in 83 patients (95.4%) with CO poisoning and none in the control group (p < 0.0001). On the ROC curve, the AUC of the Pmax with the optimum cut off point of 96 ms for predicting a COHb level of ≥20% was 0.629 (95%CI = 0.553–0.700; z statistic = 2.466; significance level P (area = 0.5) = 0.0136). The sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative likelihood ratios (LR+ and LR−, respectively) of this optimum cut off point was 59.12% (CI% = 50.4–67.4%), 75% (CI% = 58.8–87.3%), 2.36 (CI% = 1.9–3.0), and 0.55 (CI% = 0.3–1.0), respectively.

Linear positive correlation between blood COHb level and Pd. COHb: carboxyhemoglobin; Pd: P-wave dispersion.

ROC curve analysis the AUC of the Pd for predicting a COHb level of ≥20%. ROC: receiver–operator characteristics; AUC: area under ROC curve; COHb: carboxyhemoglobin; Pd: P-wave dispersion.
Discussion
To the best of our knowledge, this study presents the largest series in terms of comparison of laboratory and ECG findings of CO-poisoning cases to the control group. 5,6,8 This study revealed two significant outcomes: first, we found that all wave durations and dispersions were significantly prolonged in ECG in adult patients with acute CO poisoning compared with the control group. This finding might indicate that the heart is globally (both atriums and ventricles) affected by hypoxia-related CO poisoning; second, among detected dispersions, atria-originated Pmax and P-wave dispersions showed a positive linear relationship with the level of COHb. Here, the question of “What level of CO poisoning is demonstrated by Pmax and Pd?” arises. According to the literature, Pmax and Pd indicate a COHb level of ≥ 20% because COHb < 20% is anticipated as mild poisoning, 9 –11 and this value is considered as the threshold for hyperbaric O2 therapy. 4 Furthermore, a COHb level of ≥20% is also the threshold in terms of occurrence of central nervous system effects. The effects of CO on cognitive performance have generally been equivocal at COHb levels of 5–20%. 12 Seizures occur significantly more often in patients with a COHb level of ≥ 20%. 13 In this regard, we investigated the efficiency of Pmax and Pd in terms of demonstration patients with COHb level of ≥ 20%, and Pd was found to show a 95% specificity in achieving this.
As COHb levels may not correlate with symptoms, clinical condition might mislead physicians to determine the severity of the poisoning. 3 Many hospital laboratories cannot measure COHb because they do not have CO oximeters. In such instances, blood samples are often sent to outside laboratories or with a transported patient for measurement at the receiving hospital. 14 Therefore, the ECG that is widely used in health care facilities and even in ambulances can be utilized as a noninvasive, inexpensive, easily accessible tool indicating the severity of CO poisoning. In clinical forensic medical practice, the severity of such poisonings must be reported to the judicial authorities. Assessment of Pd/Pmax in ECG provides opportunity to determine the severity of the poisoning even in cases without a measured COHb level, especially in retrospective investigations. In the present study, since the sensitivity and specificity of Pd were found to be significantly higher than Pmax for determining a COHb level of ≥ 20%, Pd was anticipated to be more useful in terms of showing COHb levels.
P-wave duration in ECG is related to impulse conduction speed and the atrial dimension in normal individuals. 15 Elongation of the P-wave duration reflects left atrial expansion, left atrial hypertension, and conduction anomalies. 16 P-wave dispersion for normal adults has been reported as 27–30 ms in the literature. 17,18 Pd reflects the heterogeneity of electrical conduction in the atria. Distention of the atria due to pressure, volume overload, electrolyte imbalance, or increase in sympathetic activity is a main cause for the increase in Pd. Pmax and Pd increase in the following patient groups: atrial fibrillation, 19,20 acute alcohol intake, 16 hyperthyroidism, 21 coronary artery disease, 22 hypertension, 23 atrial septal defect, 24 patients with Sendrom X, 25 diastolic dysfunction, 26 dilated cardiomyopathy, 27 congestive heart failure, 28 migraine attacks, 29 in children with pulmonary arterial hypertension, 30 in the elite athletes, 31,32 and in atrial arrhythmias. 8
The relationship between Pd and CO poisoning has been previously studied. Sari et al. examined 44 indoor barbecue workers and 47 control subjects. They found that there were significant correlations between COHb level and Pd, QTmax, QTd, and cQTd. 5 Cevik et al. found a correlation between reversible increases in QTd, cQTmax, cQTd, Pmax, and Pd in the ECG and COHb levels in acute CO-poisoning patients. 6 Recently, Hanci et al. examined 30 CO-poisoning patients and 30 controls. 8 They found that in patients with acute CO poisoning, the ECG analyses shows that Pd, cQT, and cQTd durations were significantly prolonged when compared with the control group. They concluded that patients with acute CO poisoning need close follow-up because of arrhythmias. However, this study seems to be the first for revealing a high specificity correlation between Pd and blood COHb levels.
In previously conducted studies, the reason for high Pd in CO poisoning was attributed to increased adrenergic activity, changed conduction and refractory times, increase in sympathetic activity and myocardial damage, and decrease in left ventricle systolic function. 5,6,8 Gunduz et al. found that P-wave dispersion increases in diastolic dysfunction, and this increase was not related to the severity or cause of diastolic dysfunction. 26 This association between the COHb levels and changes in electrical conduction in the atrium of intoxicated patients with diminished diastolic dysfunction (abnormal cQT dispersion) and lower ejection fraction 33,34 can be clarified with this pathophysiology: the left atrium is directly exposed to pressure in the left ventricle that increases with decreasing left ventricle compliance. The left atrium pressure increases to maintain adequate filling 35 and the increased atrial wall tension leads to chamber dilatation and stretching of the atrial myocardium. This causes a change in the geometry of the atrial fibrils and also in the left atrium wall leading to a disturbance in the interatrial conduction and an inhomogeneous conduction of the sinus impulse. 36
Limitations
As there are studies that show that P-wave duration and Pd are influenced by age, sex, and BMI,
30,37
there are also studies that these were not associated with P-wave parameter values.
38
Pd values of >40 ms were found to be correlated with atrial fibrillation, with a sensitivity of 74–83% and specificity of 81–85%.
19
However, the present study revealed higher specific relationship of Pd and CO poisoning. We obtained a higher specificity rate for Pd allegedly because our series comprised young-aged and healthy individuals. The severity of CO poisoning should not only be judged by the serum level of COHb but also by detailed medical history and physical examination.
11
P-wave parameters and Pd may vary due to external influences such as seasonal effects
39
or internal influences such as anxiety, sleep deprivation, and autonomic function.
40
The manual calculation of Pd on paper ECG may have influenced our results. Analyzing the ECG using digitally stored ECGs displayed on a high-resolution computer screen, or a high-resolution digitizing board with a specialized software package might be more consistent and acceptable.
8
Conclusion
A significant increase in wave/interval dispersions in ECG of CO-poisoning patients compared with the controls may show that not only a part is affected but also both atrium and the ventricles as a whole are affected by hypoxic ischemia. All wave durations and dispersions were significantly prolonged in ECG in adult patients with acute CO poisoning compared with the control group, which might indicate that the heart was globally (both atriums and ventricles) affected by hypoxia-related CO poisoning. Using ECG, P dispersions assessment is valuable to determine the severity of poisoning, especially in situations where COHb level measurement is unavailable. Pd ≥ 38 ms, in cases where COHb level is ≥20%,have 95% specificity if other conditions that increase Pd has been ruled out.
Footnotes
Conflict of interest
The authors declared no conflicts of interest.
Funding
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
