Are equal educational opportunities sufficient to narrow long-standing economic and racial inequalities in achievement? In this article, I test the hypothesis that poor and minority students benefit less from effective elementary school teachers than do their nonpoor and white peers, thus exacerbating inequalities. I use administrative data from public elementary schools in North Carolina to calculate value-added measures of teachers’ success in promoting learning, and I assess benefits for different students. Results suggest that differential benefits of effective teachers uniquely exacerbate black–white inequalities but do not contribute to economic achievement gaps. Racial differences are small, on average, relative to the benefits for all groups; are not explained by differences in prior achievement; and are largest for low-achieving students. Teacher-related learning opportunities are crucial for all students, but these results point to a disconnect between typical school learning opportunities and low-achieving minority students.
Bacher-HicksAndrewKaneThomas J.StaigerDouglas O.2014. Validating Teacher Effect Estimates Using Changes in Teacher Assignments in Los Angeles. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research. Retrieved May28, 2015 (http://www.nber.org/papers/w20657).
2.
BerghLinda van denDenessenEddieHornstraLisetteVoetenMarinusHollandRob W.2010. “The Implicit Prejudiced Attitudes of Teachers Relations to Teacher Expectations and the Ethnic Achievement Gap.”American Educational Research Journal47(2):497–527.
3.
BoydD.LankfordH.LoebS.RonfeldtM.WyckoffJ.2010. “The Role of Teacher Quality in Retention and Hiring: Using Applications to Transfer to Uncover Preferences of Teachers and Schools.”Journal of Policy Analysis and Management30(1):88–110.
4.
CalarcoJessica McCrory. 2014a. “Coached for the Classroom: Parents’ Cultural Transmission and Children’s Reproduction of Educational Inequalities.”American Sociological Review79(5):1015–37.
5.
CalarcoJessica McCrory. 2014b. “The Inconsistent Curriculum Cultural Tool Kits and Student Interpretations of Ambiguous Expectations.”Social Psychology Quarterly77(2):185–209.
6.
CarrollJohn B.1963. “A Model of School Learning.”Teachers College Record64(8), 722–33.
7.
ChettyRajFriedmanJohn N.RockoffJonah E.2014. “Measuring the Impacts of Teachers I: Evaluating Bias in Teacher Value-added Estimates.”American Economic Review104(9):2593–2632.
8.
ClotfelterCharles T.LaddHelen F.VigdorJacob. 2005. “Who Teaches Whom? Race and the Distribution of Novice Teachers.”Economics of Education Review24(4):377–92.
9.
ClotfelterCharles T.LaddHelen F.VigdorJacob L.2006. “Teacher–Student Matching and the Assessment of Teacher Effectiveness.”Journal of Human Resources41(4):778–820.
10.
ColemanJames S.et al. 1966. Equality of Educational Opportunity. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
11.
CondieScottLefgrenLarsSimsDavid. 2014. “Teacher Heterogeneity, Value-added and Education Policy.”Economics of Education Review40:76–92.
12.
CondronDennis J.2009. “Social Class, School and Non-school Environments, and Black/White Inequalities in Children’s Learning.”American Sociological Review74(5):683–708.
13.
CondronDennis J.RoscignoVincent J.2003. “Disparities Within: Unequal Spending and Achievement in an Urban School District.”Sociology of Education76(1):18–36.
14.
Covay MinorElizabethDesimoneLaura M.PhillipsKristie J. R.SpencerKailey. 2015. “A New Look at the Opportunity-to-learn Gap across Race and Income.”American Journal of Education121(2):241–69.
15.
CrosnoeRobertMorrisonFredBurchinalMargaretPiantaRobertKeatingDanielFriedmanSarah L.Clarke-StewartK. Alison, the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Early Child Care Research Network. 2010. “Instruction, Teacher–Student Relations, and Math Achievement Trajectories in Elementary School.”Journal of Educational Psychology102(2):407–17.
16.
CunhaFlavioHeckmanJames. 2007. “The Technology of Skill Formation.”American Economic Review97(2):31–47.
17.
DeeThomas S.2004. “Teachers, Race, and Student Achievement in a Randomized Experiment.”Review of Economics and Statistics86(1):195–210.
18.
DowneyDouglas B.CondronDennis J.2016. “Fifty Years since the Coleman Report: Rethinking the Relationship between Schools and Inequality.”Sociology of Education89(3):207–20.
19.
DowneyDouglas B.von HippelPaul T.BrohBeckett A.2004. “Are Schools the Great Equalizer? Cognitive Inequality during the Summer Months and the School Year.”American Sociological Review69(5):613–35.
20.
DowneyDouglas B.PribeshShana. 2004. “When Race Matters: Teachers’ Evaluations of Students’ Classroom Behavior.”Sociology of Education77(4):267–82.
21.
EgaliteAnna J.KisidaBrianWintersMarcus A.2015. “Representation in the Classroom: The Effect of Own-race Teachers on Student Achievement.”Economics of Education Review45:44–52.
22.
EngelMimiClaessensAmyFinchMaida A.2013. “Teaching Students What They Already Know? The (Mis)Alignment between Mathematics Instructional Content and Student Knowledge in Kindergarten.”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis35(2):157–78.
23.
EversonKimberlee C.2017. “Value-added Modeling and Educational Accountability: Are We Answering the Real Questions?”Review of Educational Research87(1):35–70.
24.
FitzpatrickMaria D.GrissmerDavidHastedtSarah. 2011. “What a Difference a Day Makes: Estimating Daily Learning Gains during Kindergarten and First Grade Using a Natural Experiment.”Economics of Education Review30(2):269–79.
25.
FoxLindsay. 2015. “Playing to Teachers’ Strengths: Using Multiple Measures of Teacher Effectiveness to Improve Teacher Assignments.”Education Finance and Policy11(1):70–96.
26.
FryerRoland GLevittSteven D.2004. “Understanding the Black–White Test Score Gap in the First Two Years of School.”Review of Economics and Statistics86(2):447–64.
27.
GaddisS. Michael. 2013. “The Influence of Habitus in the Relationship between Cultural Capital and Academic Achievement.”Social Science Research42(1):1–13.
28.
GamoranAdam. 1987. “The Stratification of High School Learning Opportunities.”Sociology of Education60(3):135–55.
29.
GamoranAdamNystrandMartinBerendsMark. 1995. “An Organizational Analysis of the Effects of Ability Grouping.”American Educational Research Journal32:687–715.
30.
GershensonSethHoltStephen B.PapageorgeNicholas W.2016. “Who Believes in Me? The Effect of Student–Teacher Demographic Match on Teacher Expectations.”Economics of Education Review52:209–24.
31.
GlazermanStevenProtikAliTehBing-RuBruchJulieMaxJeffrey. 2013. Transfer Incentives for High-performing Teachers: Final Results from a Multisite Randomized Experiment (NCEE 2014-4003). Washington, DC: National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance. Retrieved June1, 2015 (http://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED544269).
32.
GoldhaberDanLaveryLesleyTheobaldRoddy. 2015. “Uneven Playing Field? Assessing the Teacher Quality Gap between Advantaged and Disadvantaged Students.”Educational Researcher44(5):293–307.
33.
GuarinoCassandra M.ReckaseMark D.WooldridgeJeffrey M.2015. “Can Value-added Measures of Teacher Performance Be Trusted?”Education Finance and Policy10(1):117–56.
34.
HanushekEric A.RivkinSteven G.2010. “Generalizations about Using Value-added Measures of Teacher Quality.”American Economic Review100(2):267–71.
35.
HorvatErin McNamaraB. WeiningerElliotLareauAnnette. 2003. “From Social Ties to Social Capital: Class Differences in the Relations between Schools and Parent Networks.”American Educational Research Journal40(2):319–51.
36.
IrizarryYasmiyn. 2015. “Utilizing Multidimensional Measures of Race in Education Research: The Case of Teacher Perceptions.”Sociology of Race and Ethnicity1(4):564–83.
37.
IrvineJacqueline Jordan. 1990. Black Students and School Failure: Policies, Practices, and Prescriptions. New York: Greenwood Press.
IsenbergEricMaxJeffreyGleasonPhilipPotamitesLizSantillanoRobertHockHeinrichHansen.Michael2013. Access to Effective Teaching for Disadvantaged Students. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. Retrieved December2, 2014 (http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/pubs/20144001/).
40.
JenningsJennifer L.DemingDavidJencksChristopherLopuchMayaSchuelerBeth E.2015. “Do Differences in School Quality Matter More Than We Thought? New Evidence on Educational Opportunity in the Twenty-first Century.”Sociology of Education88(1):56–82.
41.
JenningsJennifer L.DiPreteThomas A.2010. “Teacher Effects on Social and Behavioral Skills in Early Elementary School.”Sociology of Education83(2):135–59.
42.
KalogridesDemetraLoebSusannaBéteilleTara. 2013. “Systematic Sorting: Teacher Characteristics and Class Assignments.”Sociology of Education86(2):103–23.
43.
KaneThomas J.McCaffreyDaniel F.MillerTreyStaiger.Douglas O.2013. Have We Identified Effective Teachers? Validating Measures of Effective Teaching Using Random Assignment. Seattle: Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Retrieved December2, 2014 (http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED540959.pdf).
44.
KaneThomas J.StaigerDouglas O.2008. “Estimating Teacher Impacts on Student Achievement: An Experimental Evaluation.”National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper Series No. 14607. Retrieved December2, 2014 (http://www.nber.org/papers/w14607).
45.
KilgoreSusan B.PendletonWilliam W.1993. “The Organizational Context of Learning: Framework for Understanding the Acquisition of Knowledge.”Sociology of Education66(1):63–87.
46.
KoedelCoryMihalyKataRockoffJonah E.2015. “Value-added Modeling: A Review.”Economics of Education Review47:180–95.
47.
KonstantopoulosSpyros. 2009. “Effects of Teachers on Minority and Disadvantaged Students’ Achievement in the Early Grades.”Elementary School Journal110(1):92–113.
48.
Ladson-BillingsGloria. 1995. “Toward a Theory of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy.”American Educational Research Journal32(3):465–91.
49.
Ladson-BillingsGloria. 2006. “From the Achievement Gap to the Education Debt: Understanding Achievement in U.S. Schools.”Educational Researcher35(7):3–12.
50.
LankfordH.LoebS.WyckoffJ.2002. “Teacher Sorting and the Plight of Urban Schools: A Descriptive Analysis.”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis24(1):37–62.
51.
LareauAnnette. 1989. Home Advantage: Social Class and Parental Intervention in Elementary Education. London: Falmer Press.
52.
LareauAnnetteHorvatErin McNamara. 1999. “Moments of Social Inclusion and Exclusion Race, Class, and Cultural Capital in Family–School Relationships.”Sociology of Education72(1):37–53.
53.
LareauAnnetteWeiningerElliot B.2003. “Cultural Capital in Educational Research: A Critical Assessment.”Theory and Society32:567–606.
McKownClarkWeinsteinRhona S.2008. “Teacher Expectations, Classroom Context, and the Achievement Gap.”Journal of School Psychology46(3):235–61.
61.
MorrisEdward W.2005. “‘Tuck In That Shirt!’ Race, Class, Gender, and Discipline in an Urban School.”Sociological Perspectives48(1):25–48.
62.
NyeBarbaraKonstantopoulosSpyrosHedgesLarry V.2004. “How Large Are Teacher Effects?”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis26(3):237–57.
63.
PennerEmily K.2016. “Teaching for All? Teach for America’s Effects across the Distribution of Student Achievement.”Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness9(3):259–82.
64.
PiantaRobert C.BelskyJayHoutsRenateMorrisonFred, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Early Child Care Research Network. 2007. “Opportunities to Learn in America’s Elementary Classrooms.”Science315(5820):1795–96.
65.
RaudenbushStephen W.2004. “What Are Value-added Models Estimating and What Does This Imply for Statistical Practice?”Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics29(1):121–129.
66.
RaudenbushStephen W.EschmannRobert D.2015. “Does Schooling Increase or Reduce Social Inequality?”Annual Review of Sociology41(1):443–70.
67.
RaudenbushStephen W.WillmsJ. Douglas. 1995. “The Estimation of School Effects.”Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics20(4):307–35.
68.
ReadyDouglas D.WrightDavid L.2011. “Accuracy and Inaccuracy in Teachers’ Perceptions of Young Children’s Cognitive Abilities: The Role of Child Background and Classroom Context.”American Educational Research Journal48(2):335–60.
69.
ReardonSean F.2011. “The Widening Academic Achievement Gap between the Rich and the Poor: New Evidence and Possible Explanations.” Pp. 90–115 in Whither Opportunity? Rising Inequality, Schools, and Children’s Life Chances, edited by DuncanG. J.MurnaneR. J.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
70.
ReardonSean F.GalindoClaudia. 2009. “The Hispanic–White Achievement Gap in Math and Reading in the Elementary Grades.”American Educational Research Journal46(3):853–91.
71.
RivkinSteven G.HanushekEric A.KainJohn F.2005. “Teachers, Schools, and Academic Achievement.”Econometrica73(2):417–58.
72.
RobinsonKeithHarrisAngel L.2014. The Broken Compass: Parental Involvement with Children’s Education. Retrieved October13, 2016 (http://site.ebrary.com/id/10823661).
73.
RoscignoVincent J.AinsworthJames W.1999. “Race, Cultural Capital, and Educational Resources: Persistent Inequalities and Achievement Returns.”Sociology of Education72(3):158–78.
74.
RothsteinJ.2010. “Teacher Quality in Educational Production: Tracking, Decay, and Student Achievement.”Quarterly Journal of Economics125(1):175–214.
75.
SorensenAage. 1970. “Organizational Differentiation of Students and Educational Opportunity.”Sociology of Education43(4):355–76.
76.
SorensenAage B.1989. “Schools and the Distribution of Educational Opportunities.”Research in the Sociology of Education and Socialization8:3–26.
77.
SorensenAage B.HallinanMaureen T.1977. “Reconceptualization of School Effects.”Sociology of Education50(4):273–89.
78.
StanovichKeith E.1986. “Matthew Effects in Reading: Some Consequences of Individual Differences in the Acquisition of Literacy.”Reading Research Quarterly21(4):360–407.
79.
TachLaura MarieFarkasGeorge. 2006. “Learning-related Behaviors, Cognitive Skills, and Ability Grouping When Schooling Begins.”Social Science Research35(4):1048–79.
80.
ValenzuelaAngela. 1999. Subtractive Schooling: U.S.-Mexican Youth and the Politics of Caring. Albany: State University of New York Press.
81.
WangJia. 1998. “Opportunity to Learn: The Impacts and Policy Implications.”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis20(3):137–56.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
