Schools with very few and relatively low-performing marginalized students may be most likely to trigger social identity threats (including stereotype threats) that contribute to racial disparities. We test this hypothesis by assessing variation in the benefits of a self-affirmation intervention designed to counteract social identity threat in a randomized trial in all 11 middle schools in Madison, Wisconsin. We find that school context moderates the benefits of self-affirmation for black and Hispanic students’ grades, with partial support among standardized achievement outcomes. Self-affirmation reduced the very large racial achievement gap in overall grade point average by 12.5 percent in high-threat school contexts and had no effect in low-threat contexts. These self-affirmation activities have the potential to help close some of the largest racial/ethnic achievement gaps, though only in specific school contexts.
BerendsMarkLucasSamuel R.PeñalozaRoberto V.2008. “How Changes in Families and Schools Are Related to Trends in Black-white Test Scores.” Sociology of Education81(4):313-44.
2.
BormanGeoffrey D.GriggJeffreyHanselmanPaul. 2014. “An Effort to Close Achievement Gaps at Scale through Self-affirmation.” Unpublished manuscript submitted for publication.
3.
CarterPrudence L.2006. “Straddling Boundaries: Identity, Culture, and School.” Sociology of Education79(4):304-28.
4.
CohenGeoffrey L.GarciaJulio. 2008. “Identity, Belonging, and Achievement: A Model, Interventions, Implications.” Current Directions in Psychological Science17(6):365-69.
5.
CohenGeoffrey L.GarciaJulioApfelNancyMasterAllison. 2006. “Reducing the Racial Achievement Gap: A Social-psychological Intervention.” Science313(5791):1307-10.
6.
CohenGeoffrey L.GarciaJulioPurdie-VaughnsValerieApfelNancyBrzustoskiPatricia. 2009. “Recursive Processes in Self-affirmation: Intervening to Close the Minority Achievement Gap.” Science324(5925):400-403.
7.
CondronDennis J.RoscignoVincent J.2003. “Disparities Within: Unequal Spending and Achievement in an Urban School District.” Sociology of Education76(1):18-36.
8.
CookJonathan E.Purdie-VaughnsValerieGarciaJulioCohenGeoffrey L.2012. “Chronic Threat and Contingent Belonging: Protective Benefits of Values Affirmation on Identity Development.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology102(3):479-96.
9.
CornellStephen Hartmann Douglas. 2007. Ethnicity and Race: Making Identities in a Changing World. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
10.
DaviesPaul G.SpencerSteven J.SteeleClaude M.2005. “Clearing the Air: Identity Safety Moderates the Effects of Stereotype Threat on Women’s Leadership Aspirations.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology88(2):276-87.
11.
DowneyDouglas B.2008. “Black/White Differences in School Performance: The Oppositional Culture Explanation.” Annual Review of Sociology34:107-26.
12.
FordhamSignithiaOgbuJohn U.1986. “Black Students’ School Success: Coping with the “Burden of ‘Acting White.’”Urban Review18(3):176-206.
13.
FryerRoland G.TorelliPaul. 2010. “An Empirical Analysis of ‘Acting White.’”Journal of Public Economics94(5/6):380-96.
14.
HanushekEric A.KainJohn F.RivkinSteven G.2009. “New Evidence about Brown v. Board of Education: The Complex Effects of School Racial Composition on Achievement.” Journal of Labor Economics27(3):349-83.
15.
HanushekEric A.RivkinSteven G.2009. “Harming the Best: How Schools Affect the Black-white Achievement Gap.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management28(3):366-93.
16.
HarrisAngel L.2011. Kids Don’t Want to Fail: Oppositional Culture and the Black-white Achievement Gap. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
17.
HermanMelissa R.2009. “The Black-white-other Achievement Gap: Testing Theories of Academic Performance among Multiracial and Monoracial Adolescents.” Sociology of Education82(1):20-46.
18.
InzlichtMichaelBen-ZeevTalia. 2000. “A Threatening Intellectual Environment: Why Females Are Susceptible to Experiencing Problem-solving Deficits in the Presence of Males.” Psychological Science11(5):365-71.
19.
JencksChristopherPhillipsMeredith. 1998. The Black-white Test Score Gap. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
20.
KaoGraceThompsonJennifer S.2003. “Racial and Ethnic Stratification in Educational Achievement and Attainment.” Annual Review of Sociology29:417-42.
21.
KrayLaura J.ShirakoAiwa. 2011. “Stereotype Threat in Organizations.” Pp. 173-87 in Stereotype Threat: Theory, Process, and Application, edited by InzlichtM.SchmaderT.New York: Oxford University Press.
22.
LewisAmanda E.2003. Race in the Schoolyard Negotiating the Color Line in Classrooms and Communities. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
23.
LoganJohn R.MincaElisabetaAdarSinem. 2012. “The Geography of Inequality: Why Separate Means Unequal in American Public Schools.” Sociology of Education85(3):287-301.
24.
MagnusonKatherine A.WaldfogelJane. 2008. Steady Gains and Stalled Progress: Inequality and the Black-white Test Score Gap. New York: Russell Sage.
25.
MickelsonRoslyn ArlinBottiaMartha CeciliaLambertRichard. 2013. “Effects of School Racial Composition on K-12 Mathematics Outcomes: A Metaregression Analysis.” Review of Educational Research83(1):121-58.
26.
MurphyMary C.SteeleClaude M.GrossJames J.2007. “Signaling Threat: How Situational Cues Affect Women in Math, Science, and Engineering Settings.” Psychological Science18(10):879-85.
27.
MurphyMary C.TaylorValerie Jones. 2011. “The Role of Situational Cues in Signaling and Maintaining Stereotype Threat.” Pp. 17-33 in Stereotype Threat: Theory, Process, and Application, edited by InzlichtM.SchmaderT.New York: Oxford University Press.
28.
NguyenHannah-Hanh D.RyanAnn Marie. 2008. “Does Stereotype Threat Affect Test Performance of Minorities and Women? A Meta-analysis of Experimental Evidence.” Journal of Applied Psychology93(6):1314-34.
29.
PerryPamela. 2002. Shades of White: White Kids and Racial Identities in High School. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
30.
Purdie-VaughnsValerieSteeleClaude M.DaviesPaul G.DitlmannRuthCrosbyJennifer Randall. 2008. “Social Identity Contingencies: How Diversity Cues Signal Threat or Safety for African Americans in Mainstream Institutions.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology94(4):615-30.
31.
SchmaderToniBeilockSian. 2011. “An Integration of Processes That Underlie Stereotype Threat.” Pp. 34-50 in Stereotype Threat: Theory, Process, and Application, edited by InzlichtM.SchmaderT.New York: Oxford University Press.
32.
SchmaderToniJohnsMichaelForbesChad. 2008. “An Integrated Process Model of Stereotype Threat Effects on Performance.” Psychological Review115(2):336-56.
33.
SekaquaptewaDeniseThompsonMischa. 2003. “Solo Status, Stereotype Threat, and Performance Expectancies: Their Effects on Women’s Performance.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology39(1):68-74.
34.
ShermanDavid K.HartsonKimberly A.BinningKevin R.Purdie-VaughnsValerieGarciaJulioTaborsky-BarbaSuzanneTomassettiSarahNussbaumA. DavidCohenGeoffrey L.2013. “Deflecting the Trajectory and Changing the Narrative: How Self-affirmation Affects Academic Performance and Motivation under Identity Threat.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology104(4):591-618.
35.
SpencerSteven J.SteeleClaude M.QuinnDiane M.1999. “Stereotype Threat and Women’s Math Performance.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology35(1):4-28.
36.
StaigerAnnegret Daniela. 2006. Learning Difference: Race and Schooling in the Multiracial Metropolis. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
37.
SteeleClaude M.AronsonJoshua. 1995. “Stereotype Threat and the Intellectual Test-performance of African-Americans.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology69(5):797-811.
38.
SteeleClaude M.SpencerSteven J.AronsonJoshua. 2002. “Contending with Group Image: The Psychology of Stereotype and Social Identity Threat.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology34:379-440.
39.
TysonKarolyn. 2011. Integration Interrupted: Tracking, Black Students, and Acting White after Brown. New York: Oxford University Press.
40.
TysonKarolynCastellinoDomini R.DarityWilliam. 2005. “It’s Not ‘a Black Thing’: Understanding the Burden of Acting White and Other Dilemmas of High Achievement.” American Sociological Review70(4):582-605.
41.
WaltonGregory M.SpencerSpencer J.2009. “Latent Ability: Grades and Test Scores Systematically Underestimate the Intellectual Ability of Negatively Stereotyped Students.” Psychological Science20(9):1132-39.
42.
YeagerDavid S.WaltonGregory M.2011. “Social-psychological Interventions in Education: They’re Not Magic.” Review of Educational Research81(2):267-301.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
