Abstract
Social network theory provides a useful tool to study complex social relationships in animals. The possibility to look beyond dyadic interactions by considering whole networks of social relationships allows researchers the opportunity to study social groups in more natural ways. As such, network-based analyses provide an informative way to investigate the factors influencing the social environment of group-living animals, and so has direct application to animal welfare. For example, animal groups in captivity are frequently disrupted by separations, reintroductions and/or mixing with unfamiliar individuals and this can lead to social stress and associated aggression. Social network analysis of animal groups can help identify the underlying causes of these socially-derived animal welfare concerns. In this review we discuss how this approach can be applied, and how it could be used to identify potential interventions and solutions in the area of animal welfare.
Keywords
References
1.
Dawkins M.S.
(1990 ) Behav. Brain Sci. , 13 , 1 –61 .
2.
Broom D.M.
(1991 ) J. Anim. Sci. , 69 , 4167 –4175 .
3.
Dawkins M.S.
(2004 ) Anim. Welfare , 13 , 3 –7 .
4.
Boissy A.
,
Manteuffel G.
,
Jensen M.B.
,
Moe R.O.
,
Spruijt B.
,
Keeling L.J.
,
Winckler C.
,
Forkman B.
,
Dimitrov I.
, and
Langbein J.
(2007 ) Physiol. Behav. , 92 , 375 –397 .
5.
Ruis M.A.W.
,
te Brake J.H.A.
,
Engel B.
,
Buist W.G.
,
Blokhuis H.J.
, and
Koolhaas J.M.
(2001 ) Physiol. Behav. , 73 , 541 –551 .
6.
Rodenburg T.B.
,
van Hierden Y.M.
,
Buitenhuis A.J.
,
Riedstra B.
,
Koene P.
,
Korte S.M.
,
van der Poel J.J.
,
Groothuis T.G.G.
, and
Blokhuis H.
(2004 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 86 , 291 –298 .
7.
Schroder-Petersen D.L.
, and
Simonsen H.B.
(2001 ) Vet. J. , 162 , 196 –210 .
8.
Erhard H.W.
,
Mendl M.
, and
Ashley D.D.
(1997 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 54 , 137 –151 .
9.
McAdie T.M.
,
Keeling L.J.
,
Blokhuis H.J.
, and
Jones R.B.
(2005 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 93 , 67 –80 .
10.
Lusseau D.
(2003 ) P. Roy. Soc. B , 270 , S186 –S188 .
11.
Croft D.P.
,
Krause J.
, and
James R.
(2004 ) P. Roy. Soc. B , 271 , 516 –519 .
12.
Flack J.C.
,
Girvan M.
,
de Waal F.B.M.
, and
Krakauer D.C.
(2006 ) Nature , 439 , 426 –429 .
13.
McIntosh A.R.
,
Grady C.L.
,
Ungerleider L.G.
,
Haxby J.V.
,
Rapoport S.I.
, and
Horwitz B.
(1994 ) J. Neurosci. , 14 , 655 –666 .
14.
Papp B.
,
Pál C.
, and
Hurst L.D.
(2004 ) Nature , 429 , 661 –664 .
15.
Proulx S.R.
,
Promislow D.E.L.
, and
Phillips P.C.
(2005 ) Trends Ecol. Evol. , 20 , 345 –353 .
16.
Pike T.W.
,
Samanta M.
,
Lindstrom J.
, and
Royle N.J.
(2008 ) P. Roy. Soc. B , 275 , 2515 –2520 .
17.
Asher L.
,
Collins L.M.
,
Ortiz-Pelaez A.
,
Drewe J.A.
,
Nicol C.J.
, and
Pfeiffer D.U.
(2009 ) J. R. Soc. Interface , 6 , 1103 –1119 .
18.
McCowan B.
,
Beisner B.A.
,
Capitanio J.P.
,
Jackson M.E.
,
Cameron A.N.
,
Seil S.
,
Atwill E.R.
, and
Fushing H.
(2011 ) Plos One , 6 , e22350 .
19.
Dufour V.
,
Sueur C.
,
Whiten A.
, and
Buchanan-Smith H.M.
(2011 ) Am. J. Primatol. , 73 , 802 –811 .
20.
Jones H.A.C.
,
Noble C.
,
Damsgard B.
, and
Pearce G.P.
(2011 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 133 , 117 –126 .
21.
Jones H.A.C.
,
Noble C.
,
Damsgard B.
, and
Pearce G.P.
(2012 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 138 , 132 –140 .
22.
Makagon M.M.
,
McCowan B.
, and
Mench J.A.
(2012 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 138 , 152 –161 .
23.
Koene P.
, and
Ipema B.
(2014 ) Animals , 4 , 93 –118 .
24.
Rose P.E.
, and
Croft D.P.
(2015 ) Anim. Welfare , 24 , 123 –138 .
25.
Burman O.
,
Owen D.
,
Abouismail U.
, and
Mendl M.
(2008 ) Physiol. Behav. , 93 , 89 –96 .
26.
Ewbank R.
, and
Meese G.B.
(1971 ) Anim. Prod. , 13 , 685 –693 .
27.
Holinger M.
,
Früh B.
, and
Hillmann E.
(2015 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 165 , 47 –56 .
28.
Simmins P.H.
(1993 ) Anim. Prod. , 57 , 293 –298 .
29.
Barnett J.L.
,
Cronin G.M.
,
McCallum T.H.
,
Newman E.A.
, and
Hennessy D.P.
(1996 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 50 , 121 –133 .
30.
Meese G.
, and
Ewbank R.
(1973 ) Anim. Behav. , 21 , 326 –334 .
31.
Cronin G.
,
Dunshea F.
,
Butler K.
,
McCauley I.
,
Barnett J.
, and
Hemsworth P.
(2003 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 81 , 111 –126 .
32.
Rydhmer L.
,
Hansson M.
,
Lundström K.
,
Brunius C.
, and
Andersson K.
(2013 ) Animal , 7 , 1532 –1541 .
33.
Arey D.
, and
Franklin M.
(1995 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 45 , 23 –30 .
34.
Boyle L.
, and
Björklund L.
(2007 ) Anim. Welfare , 16 , 259 –262 .
35.
Fredriksen B.
,
Lium B.M.
,
Marka C.H.
,
Mosveen B.
, and
Nafstad O.
(2008 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 110 , 258 –268 .
36.
Arey D.S.
, and
Edwards S.A.
(1998 ) Livest. Prod. Sci. , 56 , 61 –70 .
37.
Patison K.P.
,
Swain D.L.
,
Bishop-Hurley G.J.
,
Robins G.
,
Pattison P.
, and
Reid D.J.
(2010 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 128 , 10 –17 .
38.
Gupta S.
,
Earley B.
,
Nolan M.
,
Formentin E.
, and
Crowe M.A.
(2008 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 110 , 229 –243 .
39.
Grant R.
, and
Albright J.
(2001 ) J. Dairy Sci. , 84 , 156 –163 .
40.
Hurst J.L.
,
Barnard C.J.
,
Hare R.
,
Wheeldon E.B.
, and
West C.D.
(1996 ) Anim. Behav. , 52 , 335 –360 .
41.
Duncan I.
, and
Wood-Gush D.
(1972 ) Thwarting of feeding behaviour in the domestic fowl . Anim. Behav. , 20 , 444 –451 .
42.
Ramadan S.G.A.
, and
Von Borell E.
(2008 ) Brit. Poultry Sci. , 49 , 250 –256 .
43.
McAdie T.M.
, and
Keeling L.J.
(2002 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 75 , 147 –159 .
44.
Nicol C.J.
(1995 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 44 , 79 –98 .
45.
Savory C.J.
(1995 ) World. Poultry Sci. J. , 51 , 215 –219 .
46.
Mason G.
, and
Mendl M.
(1993 ) Anim. Welfare , 2 , 301 –319 .
47.
Walker M.
,
Diez-Leon M.
, and
Mason G.
(2014 ) Int. J. Comp. Psychol. , 27 , 80 –100 .
48.
Dawkins M.S.
,
Cain R.
,
Merelie K.
, and
Roberts S.J.
(2013 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 145 , 44 –50 .
49.
Dawkins M.S.
,
Lee H.J.
,
Waitt C.D.
, and
Roberts S.J.
(2009 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 119 , 203 –209 .
50.
Roberts S.J.
,
Cain R.
, and
Dawkins M.S.
(2012 ) J. R. Soc. Interface , 9 , 3436 –3443 .
51.
Boccaletti S.
,
Latora V.
,
Moreno Y.
,
Chavez M.
, and
Hwang D.U.
(2006 ) Phys. Rep. , 424 , 175 –308 .
52.
Croft D.P.
,
James R.
, and
Krause J.
(2008 ) Exploring animal social networks. Princeton University Press , Princeton, New Jersey .
53.
Newman M.E.J.
(2003 ) Siam. Rev. , 45 , 167 –256 .
54.
Freeman L.C.
(1984 ) J. Math. Sociol. , 10 , 343 –360 .
55.
Sih A.
,
Hanser S.F.
, and
McHugh K.A.
(2009 ) Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. , 63 , 975 –988 .
56.
Hansen H.
,
McDonald D.B.
,
Groves P.
,
Maier J.A.K.
, and
Ben-David M.
(2009 ) Ethology , 115 , 384 –396 .
57.
Fewell J.H.
(2003 ) Science , 301 , 1867 –1870 .
58.
Lusseau D.
(2007 ) Evol. Ecol. , 21 , 357 –366 .
59.
Williams R.
, and
Lusseau D.
(2006 ) Biol. Lett. , 2 , 497 –500 .
60.
Levine J.H.
(1972 ) Am. Sociol. Rev. , 37 , 14 –27 .
61.
Liben-Nowell D.
, and
Kleinberg J.
(2008 ) P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 105 , 4633 –4638 .
62.
Newman M.E.J.
(2002 ) Phys. Rev. Lett. , 89 , 208701 .
63.
Scott J.
(2011 ) Soc. Netw. Anal. Min. , 1 , 21 –26 .
64.
Wilson D.S.
(1975 ) P. Natl. A. Sci. , 72 , 143 –146 .
65.
Beisner B.A.
,
Jackson M.E.
,
Cameron A.
, and
McCowan B.
(2011 ) Am. J. Primatol. , 73 , 790 –801 .
66.
Flack J.C.
,
Krakauer D.C.
, and
de Waal F.B.M.
(2005 ) P. Roy. Soc. B , 272 , 1091 –1099 .
67.
McCowan B.
,
Anderson K.
,
Heagarty A.
, and
Cameron A.
(2008 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 109 , 396 –405 .
68.
Edenbrow M.
,
Darden S.K.
,
Ramnarine I.W.
,
Evans J.P.
,
James R.
, and
Croft D.P.
(2011 ) Anim. Behav. , 81 , 551 –558 .
69.
Kleinhappel T.K.
,
Burman O.H.P.
,
John E.A.
,
Wilkinson A.
, and
Pike T.W.
(2014 ) Behav. Ecol. , 25 , 374 –377 .
70.
Krause J.
,
Croft D.P.
, and
James R.
(2007 ) Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. , 62 , 15 –27 .
71.
Krause J.
,
James R.
, and
Croft D.
(2010 ) Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B , 365 , 4099 –4106 .
72.
Corner L.A.L.
,
Pfeiffer D.U.
, and
Morris R.S.
(2003 ) Prev. Vet. Med. , 59 , 147 –167 .
73.
Martinez-Lopez B.
,
Perez A.M.
, and
Sanchez-Vizcaino J.M.
(2009 ) Transbound. Emerg. Dis. , 56 , 109 –120 .
74.
Otterstatter M.C.
, and
Thomson J.D.
(2007 ) Oecologia , 154 , 411 –421 .
75.
Newman M.E.J.
(2004 ) Phys. Rev. E , 70 , 056131 .
76.
Brown R.E.
,
Schellinck H.M.
, and
West A.M.
(1996 ) Physiol. Behav. , 60 , 365 –372 .
77.
Cote I.M.
, and
Poulin R.
(1995 ) Behav. Ecol. , 6 , 159 –165 .
78.
Dunbar R.I.M.
(1998 ) Evol. Anthropol. , 6 , 178 –190 .
79.
Hoogland J.L.
(1995 ) The black-tailed prairie dog: Social life of a burrowing mammal. University of Chicago Press , Chicago .
80.
Wey T.
,
Blumstein D.T.
,
Shen W.
, and
Jordan F.
(2008 ) Anim. Behav. , 75 , 333 –344 .
81.
Whitehead H.
(2008 ) Analyzing animal societies: Quantitative methods for vertebrate social analysis. University of Chicago Press , Chicago .
82.
Krause J.
,
Lusseau D.
, and
James R.
(2009 ) Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. , 63 , 967 –973 .
83.
Borgatti S.P.
,
Everett M.G.
, and
Freeman L.C.
, Ucinet for windows: Software for social network analysis. Analytic Technologies , Harvard .
84.
Butts C.
(2008 ) J. Stat. Softw. , 24 , 1 –36 .
85.
Csardi G.
, and
Nepusz T.
(2006 ) InterJournal, Complex Systems , 1695 .
86.
Coleing A.
(2009 ) Biosci. Horizons , 2 , 32 –43 .
87.
Bode N.W.F.
,
Wood A.J.
, and
Franks D.W.
(2011 ) Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. , 65 , 117 –130 .
88.
Fraser D.
,
Weary D.M.
,
Pajor E.A.
, and
Milligan B.N.
(1997 ) Anim. Welfare , 6 , 187 –205 .
89.
Godfrey S.S.
,
Bull C.M.
,
James R.
, and
Murray K.
(2009 ) Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. , 63 , 1045 –1056 .
90.
Littin K.
,
Acevedo A.
,
Browne W.
,
Edgar J.
,
Mendl M.
,
Owen D.
,
Sherwin C.
,
Wurbel H.
, and
Nicol C.
(2008 ) P. Roy. Soc. B , 275 , 1865 –1874 .
91.
Mench J.A.
, and
Mason G.J.
(1997 ) In:
Appleby M.C.
, and
Hughes B.O.
(eds), Animal Welfare , pp. 127 –141 . CAB International , Wallingford, CT.
92.
Jeppesen L.L.
,
Heller K.E.
, and
Dalsgaard T.
(2000 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 68 , 85 –92 .
93.
Stookey J.M.
, and
Gonyou H.W.
(1994 ) J. Anim. Sci. , 72 , 2804 –2811 .
94.
Burman O.
,
McGowan R.
,
Mendl M.
,
Norling Y.
,
Paul E.
,
Rehn T.
, and
Keeling L.
(2011 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 132 , 160 –168 .
95.
Mendl M.
,
Burman O.H.P.
, and
Paul E.S.
(2010 ) P. Roy. Soc. B , 277 , 2895 –2904 .
96.
Sherwin C.
,
Lewis P.
, and
Perry G.
(1999 ) Brit. Poultry Sci. , 40 , 592 –598 .
97.
Drews C.
(1993 ) Behaviour , 125 , 283 –313 .
98.
Hemelrijk C.K.
,
Wantia J.
, and
Gygax L.
(2005 ) Behaviour , 142 , 1037 –1058 .
99.
Murchison C.
(1935 ) Pedagog. Semin. J. Gen. , 46 , 76 –102 .
100.
Vervaecke H.
,
De Bonte L.
,
Maertens L.
,
Tuyttens F.
,
Stevens J.M.G.
, and
Lips D.
(2010 ) World Rabbit Sci. , 18 , 139 –149 .
101.
Langbein J.
, and
Puppe B.
(2004 ) Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. , 87 , 293 –315 .
102.
Shizuka D.
, and
McDonald D.B.
(2012 ) Anim. Behav. , 83 , 925 –934 .
103.
Curry O.
, and
Dunbar R.I.M.
(2011 ) Biol. Lett. , 7 , 651 –653 .
104.
Abramson G.
, and
Kuperman M.
(2001 ) Phys. Rev. E , 63 , 030901 .