Operationalizing and navigating ambiguity – Land-making and fisherfolk negotiations in the land-water frontier of Karachi

Abstract

This paper discusses how land and real estate development in Karachi's land-water frontiers operates through the calculated production and management of ambiguity. As in several other postcolonial cities, the natural coastline of Karachi is currently being reimagined as a waterfront development, fit for a “world-class” coastal city. However, this reclamation threatens its mangrove ecosystems and its deep-rooted fisherfolk communities. Based on the political ecology literature on urban frontiers, i.e., zones that are claimed by dominant actors for development and therefore presented as underdeveloped and unoccupied, the analysis specifically focuses on the role of ambiguity and ambivalence. While ambiguity is natural, in particular in land-water environments, it is strategically used by actors in ambivalent governance practices and three dimensions can be discerned: (1) discursive, (2) legal, as well as (3) physical ambiguity. Using interviews and a variety of documents, we explore the jhoola landscapes in the backwaters of Karachi, to study how ambiguity and ambivalence are produced, operationalized and then navigated. Our study argues that in the land-water frontiers, discursive frontiering, regulatory inbetweenness and physical ambiguity are all implicated in the process of land-making and development in the backwaters of Karachi. Avoiding a binary distinction between powerful and marginalized actors, we also show how the state is not a monolith in the production of land-water frontiers and that local communities also actively interact and navigate the production of ambivalence in such land-water frontiers.

Keywords

Frontiering urban political ecology ambivalence ambiguity environmental governance coastal urbanization Global South

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agencies (2021) KPT conducts study to develop port, improve marine ecology. Daily Times. Available at: https://dailytimes.com.pk/796123/kpt-conducts-study-to-develop-port-improve-marine-ecology/.

Ahmed

(2011) Kakapir village : Fishermen fear the elusive ‘ mangrove mafia ‘ and eco-devastation. The Express Tribune. Karachi. Available at: https://tribune.com.pk/story/229508/kakapir-village-fishermen-fear-the-elusive-‘mangrove-mafia’-and-eco-devastation.

Akhtar

Rashid

(2021) Dispossession and the militarised developer state: Financialisation and class power on the agrarian–urban frontier of Islamabad, Pakistan. Third World Quarterly 42(8): 1866–1884.

Anand

(2022) TOXICITY 1: On ambiguity and sewage in Mumbai’s urban sea. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 46(4): 687–697.

Anand

(2023) Anthroposea: Planning future ecologies in Mumbai ‘ s wetscapes. EPD: Society and Space 41(4): 683–706.

Anand

Wiggin

Kamath

, et al. (2022) ENDURING HARM: Unlikely comparisons, slow violence and the administration of urban injustice. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 46(4): 651–659.

Anwar

(2012) State power, civic participation and the urban frontier: The politics of the commons in Karachi. Antipode 44(3): 601–620.

Anwar

(2014) Urban transformations: Brokers, collaborative governance and community building in Karachis periphery. South Asian History and Culture 5(1): 75–92.

Anwar

(2018) Receding rurality, booming periphery: Value struggles in Karachi’s agrarian-urban frontier. Economic and Political Weekly 53(12): 46–54.

10.

Anwar

Anjum

Abdullah

, et al. (2021) Land, Governence & the Gendered Politics of Displacement in Urban Pakistan.

11.

Anwar

Viqar

(2014) Producing cosmopolitan Karachi: Freedom, security and urban redevelopment in the post-colonial metropolis. South Asian History and Culture 5(3): 328–348.

12.

Appadurai

Breckenridge

(2009) Foreword. In: Soak: Mumbai in an Estuary. New Delhi: Rupa & Co, 1–3.

13.

Ayub

(2021a) CPEC panel okays ambitious Karachi coastline plan. 26 September. Karachi. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1648433.

14.

Ayub

(2021b) Macchar Colony dwellers don’t want to be ‘deceived in name of uplift’. DAWN Newspaper, 26 September. Karachi. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1648503.

15.

Beresnev

Phung

Broadhead

(2016) Mangrove-related policy and institutional frameworks in Pakistan, Thailand and Viet Nam. Available at: http://sar-climate.adpc.net/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/PKOTHBP6.pdf.

16.

Best

(2012) Bureaucratic ambiguity. Economy and Society 41(1): 84–106.

17.

Bhan

(2009) ‘This is no longer the city I once knew’. Evictions, the urban poor and the right to the city in millennial Delhi. Environment and Urbanization 21(1): 127–142.

18.

Bhattacharyya

(2015) History of eminent domain in colonial thought and legal practice. Economic and Political Weekly 50(50): 45–53.

19.

Bhattacharyya

(2018) Empire and Ecology in the Bengal Delta: The Making of Calcutta. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

20.

Burte

Kamath

(2017) The violence of worlding producing space in neo-liberal Durban, Mumbai and Rio de Janeiro. Economic and Political Weekly 52(7): 66–74.

21.

Business Recorder (2011) KPT project to conserve mangroves. Available at: https://www.brecorder.com/news/3880491.

22.

Business Recorder (2024) PCJCCI praises induction of KCCDZ project into CPEC. Lahore: Xxxx. Available at: https://www.brecorder.com/news/40291025.

23.

Chatterjee

(1993) The Nation and Its Fragments: Colonial and Postcolonial Histories. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.

24.

Chitra

(2021) Waste’s translations. American Ethnologist 48: 337–356.

25.

Choi

(2022) Slippery ontologies of tidal flats. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space 5(1): 340–361.

26.

DAWN Newspaper (2024) ‘Demolition of my life’: Chronicling the horrors of forced evictions in Pakistan. DAWN Newspaper. Karachi. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1835207.

27.

Dewan

Nustad

(2023) ‘Fluid dispossessions’: Contested waters in capitalist natures. Ethnos 89(3): 389–400.

28.

Dharejo

(2011) The Politics of Murder. Available at: http://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/the-politics-of-murder/.

29.

Erb

(2012) The dissonance of conservation: Environmentalities and the environmentalisms of the poor in eastern Indonesia. Raffles Bulletin of Zoology 25: 11–23.

30.

Fazal

(2024) DAWN Investigatins : Building sandcastles in Karachi’s waters. DAWN Newspaper, 2 December. Karachi. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1868178.

31.

Ferdoush

(2022) Flexible land: The state and its citizens’ negotiation over land ownership. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences 130(February): 46–58.

32.

Gandy

(2022) Urban political ecology: A critical reconfiguration. Progress in Human Geography 46(1): 21–43.

33.

Goldman

(2011) Speculating on the next world city. In: Roy

Ong

(eds) Worlding Cities: Asian Experiments and the Art of Being Global. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, 227.

34.

Government of Pakistan (2010) NATIONAL FOREST POLICY 2010. Pakistan. Available at: https://sindhforests.gov.pk/admin/MediaLibrary/NationalForest Policy 2010.pdf.

35.

Government of Pakistan (2023) National Adaptation Plan. Available at: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ZjO2EtBo8fgSQBE_lYDlOHueSr0Dk_z6/view.

36.

Graeber

(2015) The Utopia of Rules: On Technology, Stupidity, and the Secret Joys of Bureaucracy. Brooklyn/London: Melville House.

37.

Gururani

(2023) Situating suburban ecologies in the global south: Notes from India’s urban periphery. In: Kaika

Mandler

(eds) Turning up the Heat - Urban Political Ecology for a Climate Emergency. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 169–185.

38.

Hasan

(2020) Why Karachi Floods. DAWN Newspaper, 6 September. Karachi. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1578061/why-karachi-floods.

39.

Hasan

Ahmed

Raza

, et al. (2015) Karachi: The Land Issue. Karachi: Oxford University Press.

40.

Hasan

(2019) Slow but steady destruction of mangrove cover around Karachi - Pakistan - DAWN.COM. DAWN Newspaper. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1461469 (accessed 10 April 2024).

41.

Hasan

(2022) Authorities keep turning a blind eye to mangroves elimination along Karachi ‘ s coastline. DAWN Newspaper, 21 January. Karachi. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1670575.

42.

Hull

(2008) Ruled by records: The expropriation of land and the misappropriation of lists in Islamabad. American Ethnologist 35(4): 501–518.

43.

Hull

(2012) Government of Paper: The Materiality of Bureaucracy in Urban Pakistan. Berkeley/Los Angeles/London: University of California Press.

44.

Human Rights Watch (2024) “I Escaped with Only My Life” - Abusive Forced Evictions in Pakistan. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/media_2024/05/pakistan0524web.pdf.

45.

Hussain

(2021) Game changing bombast. DAWN Newspaper. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1651931.

46.

Ilyas

(2017) Toxic river passing through city threat to publichealth. DAWN Newspaper. Karachi. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1334341.

47.

Ilyas

(2023) Karachi losing mangrove cover due to land allotment, Senate panel told. DAWN Newspaper, 12 October. Karachi. Available at: https://www.dawn.com/news/1780530/karachi-losing-mangrove-cover-due-to-land-allotment-senate-panel-told.

48.

Kadfak

Oskarsson

(2017) The shifting sands of land governance in peri-urban Mangaluru, India: Fluctuating land as an ‘informality machine’ reinforcing rapid coastal transformations. Contemporary South Asia 25(4): 399–414.

49.

Kaika

Keil

Mandler

, et al. (eds) (2023) Turning up the Heat - Urban Political Ecology for a Climate Emergency. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

50.

Kamath

Tiwari

(2022) Ambivalent governance and slow violence in Mumbai’S Mithi River. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 46(4): 674–686.

51.

Karachi Port Trust (2010) Environmental Impact Assessment of reconstruction of berth 15-17A including SRBís-1 & 2 on East Wharves at Karachi Port. Karachi. Available at: https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/zh/909431468325761083/pdf/E24650EA0Pakis1rovement0Project1EIA.pdf.

52.

Khaleej Times (2021) Inclusion of Karachi coastal zone in CPEC a game-changer. 27 September. Karachi. Available at: https://www.khaleejtimes.com/asia/inclusion-of-karachi-coastal-zone-in-cpec-a-game-changer.

53.

Khalil

Van Acker

Vanoutrive

(2025) Sustainability worlding in the global south – worlding and environmentalities in kakapir fishing village, Pakistan. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences 164(August): 104325.

54.

Khan

(2021) No Title. Twitter, 26 September. Available at: https://x.com/ImranKhanPTI/status/1442074114957606912?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1442074114957606912%7Ctwgr%5E8a28d01d1a27b003fa293a30b3c73200d41c0a87%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Ftribune.com.pk%2Fstory%2F2322047%2Fpm-term (accessed 27 October 2024).

55.

Khan

(2022) Pakistan’s Sindh province declares two islands ‘protected forests’ amid ownership dispute. Arab News. Karachi. Available at: https://www.arabnews.pk/node/2017361/pakistan.

56.

Khan

(2022) Making Manora Shine. DAWN Newspaper. Karachi. Available at: https://epaper.dawn.com/DetailImage.php?StoryImage=01_05_2022_523_001.

57.

Kotek

(1999) Divided cities in the European cultural context. Progress in Planning 52(3): 227–237.

58.

Krause

(2017) Towards an amphibious anthropology of Delta life. Human Ecology 45(3): 403–408.

59.

Krause

(2022) Rhythms of wet and dry: Temporalising the land-water nexus. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences 131(March 2017): 252–259.

60.

Kristof

LKD

(1959) The nature of frontiers and boundaries. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 49(3): 269–282.

61.

Lahiri-Dutt

(2014) Beyond the water-land binary in geography : Water / lands of Bengal re-visioning hybridity. ACME: An International E-Journal for Critical Geographies 13(3): 505–529.

62.

Lawhon

Ernstson

Silver

(2014) Provincializing urban political ecology: Towards a situated UPE through African urbanism. Antipode 46(2): 497–516.

63.

Legg

(2008) Ambivalent improvements: Biography, biopolitics, and colonial Delhi. Environment and Planning A 40(1): 37–56.

64.

(2014) What is land ? Assembling a resource for global investment. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 39(4): 589–602.

65.

Mahmood

(2017) Sindh Environmental Protection Agency approves cutting down of 800 mangrove trees. Global Village Space, 21 September. Available at: https://www.globalvillagespace.com/sindh-environmental-protection-agency-approves-cutting-down-of-800-mangrove-trees/.

66.

Marshall

(2016) Deconstructing aqua nullius: Reclaiming aboriginal water rights and communal identity in Australia. Indigenous Law Bulletin 8(26): 9–14.

67.

Master Plan Group of Offices (2007) Karachi Strategic Development Plan 2020. Karachi: CDGK.

68.

Ministry of Maritime Affairs (2022) Follow-Up Meeting Follow-up Meeting on USD 3.1 Billion Karachi Coastal Comprehensive Development Zone (KCCDZ) development project with China Road and Bridge Corporation (CRBC) held at Ministry of Maritime Affairs today. Available at: https://www.moma.gov.pk/Detail/YTczYWVlMjktYjRkMC00MmQ1LWI2ZDEtZmU4NzVjMTg3YTc1 (accessed 20 October 2024).

69.

Nugent

(2004) Governing states. In: Nugent

Vincent

(eds) A Companion to the Anthropology of Politics. Oxford: Blackwell, 198–215.

70.

Omar

(2016) The coast is clear: The vanishing mangrove forest of Karachi. Herald, 7 June. Karachi. Available at: https://herald.dawn.com/news/1153410.

71.

Pullan

(2011) Frontier urbanism: The periphery at the centre of contested cities. The Journal of Architecture 16(1): 15–35.

72.

Rademacher

Cadenasso

Pickett

STA

(2019) From feedbacks to coproduction: Toward an integrated conceptual framework for urban ecosystems. Urban Ecosystems 22(1): 65–76.

73.

Ranganathan

(2015) Storm Drains as Assemblages: The Political Ecology of Flood Risk in Post-Colonial Bangalore. 1–21.

74.

Rodgers

(2006) The state as a gang: Conceptualizing the governmentality of violence in contemporary Nicaragua. Critique of Anthropology 26(3): 315–330.

75.

Roy

(2003) City Requiem, Calcutta: Gender and the Politics of Poverty. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

76.

Roy

(2009a) The 21st-century metropolis: New geographies of theory. Regional Studies 43(6): 819–830.

77.

Roy

(2009b) Why India cannot plan its cities: Informality, insurgence and the idiom of urbanization. Planning Theory 8(1): 76–87.

78.

Safransky

(2014) Greening the urban frontier: Race, property, and resettlement in Detroit. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences 56: 237–248.

79.

Shamim

(2024) Pakistan’s storm Asna: Legend of the Karachi saint who can ‘stop cyclones’. Al Jazeera. Karachi. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2024/8/30/pakistans-storm-asna-legend-of-the-karachi-saint-who-can-stop-cyclones.

80.

Siddiqi

(2023) The sisyphean cycle of inequitable state production : State, space, and a drainage project in Pakistan. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 41(5): 866–883.

81.

Sultana

(2022) The unbearable heaviness of climate coloniality. Political Geography 99(2022): 102638.

82.

Swyngedouw

(2006) Circulations and metabolisms: (hybrid) natures and (cyborg) cities. Science as Culture 15(2): 105–121.

83.

Tassadiq

(2024) Colonial laws, postcolonial infrastructures: Land acquisition, urban informality, and politics of infrastructural development in Pakistan. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 42(3): 401–421.

84.

The Express Tribune (2021a) PM terms inclusion of KCCDZ in CPEC ‘game changer’. 26 September. Islamabad. Available at: https://tribune.com.pk/story/2322047/pm-terms-inclusion-of-kccdz-in-cpec-game-changer.

85.

The Express Tribune (2021b) Sindh govt urged to add Buddu Bundal islands in protected list. 24 September. Karachi. Available at: https://tribune.com.pk/story/2321722/sindh-govt-urged-to-add-buddu-bundal-islands-in-protected-list.

86.

The News (2024a) Karachi’s coastline could become dead zone for seafood if pollution is not checked. Karachi. Available at: https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/1221149-karachi-s-coastline-could-become-dead-zone-for-seafood-if-pollution-is-not-checked.

87.

The News (2024b) Pakistan, China boost ties with KCCDZ. Lahore. Available at: https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/1162211-pakistan-china-boost-ties-with-kccdz.

88.

Tsing

(2000) Inside the economy of appearances. Public Culture 12(1): 115–144.

89.

Tzaninis

Mandler

Kaika

, et al. (2021) Moving urban political ecology beyond the ‘urbanization of nature’. Progress in Human Geography 45(2): 229–252.

90.

Unesco/IOC (1994) Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission International Workshop on Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM). Karachi.

91.

WWF (2005a) Sandspit Village Development Plan.

92.

WWF (2005b) Study on Knowledge, Attitudes & Practices of Fisherfolk Communities about Fisheries and Mangrove Resources.

93.

Youdelis

(2013) The competitive (dis)advantages of ecotourism in Northern Thailand. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences 50: 161–171.