This paper engages in a content analysis of public testimonies available through the Conceivable Future project, a network of individuals from the United States and Canada who seek to bring awareness to the threat climate change poses to reproductive justice. How are these individuals navigating reproductive decision making amid the climate crisis? Specifically focusing on individuals who express that they are choosing not to have children, we explore how emotional experiences, family planning, and environmental concern collide within the Anthropocene. Analysis of testimonies revealed a number of themes. Most people struggled with ethical questions about what it means to be accountable to and responsible for future generations in a warming world. Their concerns were tied to visions of future climate apocalypse and, implicitly and explicitly, to recognition of their own privileges living in North America. Many encountered some form of stigma or social pressure from family, friends, and/or broader society about their choice to remain childfree, sentiments more strongly expressed by women. Ultimately, individuals forgoing having kids express motivations rooted in love and the hope that they can channel their energies into alternative forms of caregiving and/or activism.
AlbertiniMarcoKohliMartin. 2009. “What Childless Older People Give: Is the Generational Link Broken?” Ageing & Society28(8):1261–74.
2.
BalboNicolettaBillariFrancesco C.MillsMelinda. 2013. “Fertility in Advanced Societies: A Review of Research.” European Journal of Population29:1–38.
3.
BarnettLarry D.1971. “Zero Population Growth, Inc.” Bioscience21(14):759–65.
4.
BarnettLarry D.1974. “Zero Population Growth, Inc.: A Second Study.” Journal of Biosocial Science6(1):1–22.
5.
BarnwellAshley. 2022. “Aunting as Family Shadow-work.” Journal of Family History47(3):317–31.
6.
BartlettSheridan. 2008a. “Climate Change and Urban Children: Impacts and Implications for Adaptation in Low- and Middle-Income Countries.” Environment & Urbanization20(2):501–19.
7.
BartlettSheridan. 2008b. “The Implications of Climate Change for Children in Lower-Income Countries.” Children, Youth and Environments18(1):71–98.
8.
BlackstoneAmyStewartMahala Dyer. 2012. “Choosing to be Childfree: Research on the Decision Not to Parent.” Sociology Compass6(9):718–27.
9.
BoivinJackyBuntinLauraKalebicNatashaHarrisonChina. 2018. “What Makes People Ready to Conceive? Findings from the International Fertility Decision-Making Study.” Reproductive BioMedicine and Society Online6:90–101.
10.
BolerMeganMacdonaldAverieNitsouChristinaHarrisAnne. 2014. “Connective Labor and Social Media: Women’s Roles in the ‘Leaderless’ Occupy Movement.” Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies20(4):438–60.
11.
Boluda-VerdúImmaculadaSenent-ValeroMarinaCasas-EscolanoMariolaMatijasevichAliciaPastor-ValeroMaría. 2022. “Fear for the Future: Eco-anxiety and Health Implications, a Systematic Review.”Journal of Environmental Psychology84:101904.
12.
BoydRobert L.1989. “Racial Differences in Childlessness: A Centennial Review.” Sociological Perspectives32(2):183–99.
13.
CafaroPhilip. 2021. “Climate Ethics and Population Policy: A Review of Recent Philosophical Work.” Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change13(2):e748.
14.
CastreeNoel. 2014. “The Anthropocene and Geography I: The Back Story.” Geography Compass8(7):436–49.
15.
ClaytonSusan D.PihkalaPanuWrayBrittMarksElizabeth. 2023. “Psychological and Emotional Responses to Climate Change Among Young People Worldwide: Differences Associated with Gender, Age, and Country.” Sustainability15(4):3540.
16.
CoffeyYumikoBhullarNavjotDurkinJoanneIslamMd ShahidulUsherKim. 2021. “Understanding Eco-anxiety: A Systematic Scoping Review of Current Literature and Identified Knowledge Gaps.” The Journal of Climate Change and Health3:2667–782.
CraddockEmma. 2019. “Doing ‘Enough’ of the ‘Right’ Thing: The Gendered Dimension of the ‘Ideal Activist’ Identity and Its Negative Emotional Consequences.” Social Movement Studies18(2):137–53.
19.
CunsoloAshleeEllisNeville R.2018. “Ecological Grief as a Mental Health Response to Climate Change-Related Loss.” Nature Climate Change8:275–81.
20.
DemetriadesJustinaEsplenEmily. 2008. “The Gender Dimensions of Poverty and Climate Change Adaptation.” IDS Bulletin39(4):24–31.
21.
DohertyThomas J.ClaytonSusan. 2011. “The Psychological Impacts of Global Climate Change.” American Psychologist66(4):265–76.
22.
EhrlichPaul R.EhrlichAnne H.1968. The Population Bomb. New York, NY: MacMillon.
23.
FuXiyaoSchneider-MayersonMatthewMontefrioMarvin Joseph F.2022. “The Reproductive Climate Concerns of Young, Educated Chinese: ‘When the Nest Is Upset, No Egg Is Left Intact.’”Environmental Sociology9(2):200–215.
24.
GalwayLindsay P.FieldEllen. 2023. “Climate Emotions and Anxiety Among Young People in Canada: A National Survey and Call to Action.” The Journal of Climate Change and Health9:100204.
25.
GillespieRosemary. 2000. “When No Means No: Disbelief, Disregard and Deviance as Discourses of Voluntary Childlessness.” Women’s Studies International Forum23(2):223–34.
26.
HarringtonRebecca. 2019. “Childfree by Choice.” Studies in Gender and Sexuality20(1):22–35.
27.
HashemzadehMozhganShariatiMohammedNazariAli MohammedKerametAsfaneh. 2021. “Childbearing Intention and Its Associated Factors: A Systematic Review.”Nursing Open8(5):2354–68.
28.
HedbergTrevor. 2020. The Environmental Impact of Overpopulation: The Ethics of Procreation. London: Routledge.
29.
HelmSabrinaKemperJoya A.WhiteSamantha K.2021. “No Future, No Kids–No Kids, No Future? An Exploration of Motivations to Remain Childfree in Times of Climate Change.” Population and Environment43:108–129.
30.
HouseknechtSharon K.1987. “Voluntary Childlessness.” Pp. 369–95 in Handbook of Marriage and the Family, edited by SussmanM. B.SteinmetzS. K.Boston, MA: Springer US.
31.
JamiesonLynn. 2016. “Families, Relationships and ‘Environment’: (Un)Sustainability, Climate Change, and Biodiversity Loss.” Families, Relationships and Societies5(3):335–55.
LundquistJennifer HickesBudigMichelle J.CurtisAnna. 2009. “Race and Childlessness in America, 1988–2002.” Journal of Marriage and Family71(3):741–55.
37.
LynchIngridMorisonTracyMacleodCatriona IdaMijasMagdalenaToitRyan duSeemanthiniSimi. 2018. “From Deviant Choice to Feminist Issue: A Historical Analysis of Scholarship on Voluntary Childlessness (1920–2013).” Pp. 11–47 in Voluntary and Involuntary Childlessness: The Joys of Motherhood?, edited by SappletonN. Leeds, England: Emerald Publishing Limited.
38.
MansbridgeJane. 2013. “Everyday Activism.” Pp 1–2 in The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia of Social and Political Movements, edited by SnowDavid A.PortaDonatella dellaKlandermansBertMcAdamDoug. Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Retrieved June 5, 2024 (https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470674871.wbespm086.pub2).
39.
McMullenHeatherDowKatharine. 2022. “Ringing the Existential Alarm: Exploring BirthStrike for Climate.” Medical Anthropology41(6–7):659–73.
40.
MilardoRobert M.2009. The Forgotten Kin: Aunts and Uncles. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
MoSilje Marie.2021. “Childfreedom as Climate Action. Experiences of Pronatalist Pressures and Gendered Expectations Among Members of the BirthStrike Movement.” Master’s thesis, The University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
43.
MooreJason W.2016. Anthropocene or Capitalocene? Nature, History, and the Crisis of Capitalism. Oakland, CA: PM Press.
44.
MurtaughPaul A.SchlaxMichael G.2009. “Reproduction and the Carbon Legacies of Individuals.” Global Environmental Change19(1):14–20.
45.
NakkerudErik. 2021. “‘There Are Many People Like Me, Who Feel They Want to Do Something Bigger’: An Exploratory Study of Choosing Not to Have Children Based on Environmental Concerns.” Ecopsychology13(3):200–209.
46.
NakkerudErik. 2024. “Choosing to Live Environmentally Childfree: Private-Sphere Environmentalism, Environmental Activism, or Both?”Current Psychology43:2887–98.
47.
NielsenKristian S.NicholasKimberly A.CreutzigFelixDietzThomasSternPaul C.2021. “The Role of High-Socioeconomic-Status People in Locking In or Rapidly Reducing Energy-Driven Greenhouse Gas Emissions.” Nature Energy6:1011–16.
48.
ObradovichNickMiglioriniRobynPaulusMartin P.RahwanIyad. 2018. “Empirical evidence of mental health risks posed by climate change.” PNAS115(43):10953–58.
49.
O’ShaughnessySaraHuddart KennedyEmily. 2010. “Relational Activism: Reimagining Women’s Environmental Work as Cultural Change.” The Canadian Journal of Sociology35(4):551–72.
50.
ParkKristin. 2002. “Stigma Management Among the Voluntarily Childless.” Sociological Perspectives45(1):21–45.
51.
PearseRebecca. 2017. “Gender and Climate Change.” Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change8(2):e451.
52.
PolletThomas V.KuppensToonDunbarRobin I. M.2006. “When Nieces and Nephews become Important: Differences between Childless Women and Mothers in Relationships with Nieces and Nephews.” Journal of Cultural and Evolutionary Psychology4(2):83–93.
53.
PoortingaWouterWhitmarshLorraineStegLindaBöhmGiselaFisherStephen. 2019. “Climate Change Perceptions and their Individual-Level Determinants: A Cross-European Analysis.”Global Environmental Change55:25–35.
SasserJade. 2018. On Infertile Ground: Population Control and Women’s Rights in the Era of Climate Change. New York, NY: New York University Press.
58.
SasserJade. 2023. “At the Intersection of Climate Justice and Reproductive Justice.” Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change15(1):e860.
59.
SasserJade. 2024. Climate Anxiety and the Kid Question: Deciding Whether to Have Children in an Uncertain Future. Oakland, CA: University of California Press.
60.
Schneider-MayersonMatthew. 2022. “The Environmental Politics of Reproductive Choices in the Age of Climate Change.” Environmental Politics31(1):152–72.
61.
Schneider-MayersonMatthewLeongKit Ling. 2020. “Eco-Reproductive Concerns in the Age of Climate Change.” Climatic Change163:1007–23.
62.
ShapiroGilla. 2014. “Voluntary Childlessness: A Critical Review of the Literature.” Studies in the Maternal6(1):1–15.
WynesSethNicholasKimberly A.2017. “The Climate Mitigation Gap: Education and Government Recommendations Miss the Most Effective Individual Actions.” Environmental Research Letters12(7):074024.
