The Form and Function of STEM Research Mentoring: A Mixed-Methods Analysis Focusing on Ethnically Diverse Undergraduates and Their Mentors

Abstract

This mixed-methods study examines mentoring relationships in an ethnically diverse sample of undergraduates in majors related to science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM). Guided by an intersectionality framework, we examined whether features of research mentoring differ at the intersection of ethnicity and gender. Survey data from undergraduates (N = 486; 76% members of underrepresented ethnic groups; 66% women) revealed ethnic and gender variation in the amount of mentoring that participants reported receiving. Findings also showed that higher levels of instrumental mentoring at the study’s outset predicted higher STEM self-efficacy 1 year later. This finding was not moderated by ethnicity or gender, suggesting that instrumental mentoring bolsters self-efficacy among students from diverse backgrounds. To supplement the quantitative findings, we collected open-ended data from a subset of participants’ mentors (N = 97). Thematic analysis of these data provides insight into the range of strategies that mentors used to bolster students’ STEM self-efficacy.

Keywords

STEM higher education mentor self-efficacy racial and ethnic differences

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Association of University Women (AAUW). (2010). Why so few? Women in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. Washington, DC: Author.

Aschbacher

P. R.

Roth

E. J.

(2010). Is science me? High school students’ identities, participation, and aspirations in science, engineering, and medicine. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 47, 564–582. doi:10.1002/tea.20353

Arnett

J. J.

(2004). Emerging adulthood: The winding road from the late teens through the twenties. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Bandura

(1997). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. New York, NY: Freeman.

Beasley

M. A.

Fischer

M. J.

, (2012). Why they leave: The impact of stereotype threat on the attrition of women and minorities science, math and engineering majors. Social Psychology of Education, 15, 427–448. doi:10.1007/s11218-012-9185-3

Blake-Beard

Bayne

M. L.

Crosby

F. J.

Muller

C. B.

(2011). Matching by race and gender in mentoring relationships: Keeping our eyes on the prize. Journal of Social Issues, 67, 622–643.

Bordes

Arredondo

(2005). Mentoring first-year Latina/o college students. Journal of Hispanic Higher Education, 4, 114–133. doi:10.1177/1538192704273855

Braun

Clarke

(2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3, 77–101.

Chemers

M. M.

(2001). Leadership effectiveness: An integrative review. In Hogg

Tindale

(Eds.), Blackwell handbook of social psychology: Group processes (pp. 376–399). Oxford, England: Blackwell.

10.

Chemers

M. M.

Zurbriggen

E. L.

Syed

Goza

B. K.

Bearman

(2011). The role of efficacy and identity in science career commitment among underrepresented minority students. Journal of Social Issues, 67, 469–491.

11.

Chinn

P. W. U.

(1999). Multiple worlds/mismatching meanings: Barriers to minority women engineers. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 36, 621–636.

12.

Collins

P. H.

(2000). Black feminist thought. New York, NY: Routledge.

13.

Cooper

C. R.

(2011). Bridging multiple worlds: Cultures, identities, and pathways to college. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

14.

Crenshaw

(1989). Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A Black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum, 1, 139–167.

15.

Creswell

J. W.

(2014). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

16.

Creswell

J. W.

Shope

Plano Clark

V. L.

Green

D. O.

(2006). How interpretive qualitative research extends mixed methods research. Research in the Schools, 13, 1–11.

17.

Diekman

A. B.

Steinberg

(2013). Navigating social roles in pursuit of important goals: A communal goal congruity account of STEM pursuits. Social and Personality Compass, 7, 487–501. doi:10.1111/spc3.12042

18.

Eby

L. T.

Allen

T. D.

Hoffman

B. J.

Baranik

L. E.

Sauer

J. B.

Baldwin

… Evans

S. C

. (2013). An interdisciplinary meta-analysis of the potential antecedents, correlates, and consequences of protégé perceptions of mentoring. Psychological Bulletin, 139, 441–476. doi:10.1037/a0029279

19.

Eby

L. T.

Butts

M. M.

Durley

Ragins

B. R.

(2010). Are bad experiences stronger than good ones in mentoring relationships? Evidence from the protégé and mentor perspective. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 77, 81–92. doi:10.1016/j.jvb.2010.02.010

20.

Eby

L. T.

McManus

S. E.

Simon

S. A.

Russell

J. E. A.

(2000). The protégé’s perspective regarding negative mentoring experiences: The development of a taxonomy. Journal of Vocation Behavior, 57, 1–21. doi:0.1006/jvbe.1999.1726

21.

Erikson

E. E.

(1968). Identity: Youth and crisis. New York, NY: Norton.

22.

Etzkowitz

Kemelgor

Uzzi

(2000). Athena unbound: The advancement of women in science and technology. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

23.

Feng

(2009). Testing an integrated model of advice giving in supportive interactions. Human Communication Research, 35, 115–129. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2958.2008.01340.x

24.

Fifolt

M. M.

Abbott

(2008). Differential experiences of women and minority engineering students in a cooperative education program. Journal of Women and Minorities in Science and Engineering, 14, 253–267.

25.

Fifolt

M. M.

Serby

(2010). Mentoring in cooperative education in preparing protégés for STEM professions. Journal of STEM Education, 11, 7–26.

26.

Gloria

T. A.

(2003). Environmental, social, and psychological experiences of Asian American undergraduates: Examining issues of academic persistence. Journal of Counseling & Development, 81, 93–105.

27.

hooks

(1984). Feminist theory: From margin to center. Cambridge, MA: South End Press.

28.

Hunter

Laursen

S. L.

Seymour

(2005). Becoming a scientist: The role of undergraduate research in students’ cognitive, personal, and professional development. Science Education, 91, 36–74. doi:10.1002/sce.20173

29.

Hurtado

(1996). The color of privilege: Three blasphemies on race and feminism. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

30.

Jacobi

(1991). Mentoring and undergraduate academic success: A literature review. Review of Educational Research, 61, 505–532.

31.

Kram

K. E.

(1985). Mentoring of work: Developmental relationships in organizational life. Glenview, IL: Scott Foresman.

32.

Landivar

L. C.

(2013). Disparities in STEM employment by sex, race, and Hispanic origin: American Community Survey reports. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau.

33.

Lave

Wenger

(1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

34.

Lee

J. M.

Ransom

(2011). The educational experiences of young men of color: A review of research, pathways, and progress. New York, NY: The College Board.

35.

Lent

R. W.

Brown

S. D.

(2006). On conceptualizing and assessing social cognitive constructs in career research: A measurement guide. Journal of Career Assessment, 14, 12–35. doi:10.1177/1069072705281364

36.

Lent

R. W.

Brown

S. D.

Sheu

Schmidt

Brenner

B. R.

Gloster

C. S.

… Lyons

(2005). Social cognitive predictors of academic interests and goals in engineering: Utility for women and students at Historically Black Universities. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 52, 84–92. doi:10.1037/0022-0167.52.1.84

37.

Liang

Bogat

G. A.

Duffy

(2014). Gender in mentoring relationships. In DuBois

D. L.

Karcher

M. J.

(Eds.), Handbook of youth mentoring (pp. 159–174). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. doi:10.4135/9781412996907.n11

38.

Liang

Tracy

Kauh

Taylor

Williams

L. M.

(2006). Mentoring Asian and Euro-American college women. Multicultural Counseling and Development, 34, 143–155. doi:10.1002/j.2161-1912.2006.tb00034.x

39.

Litzler

Samuelson

C. C.

Lorah

J. A.

(2014). Breaking it down: Engineering student STEM confidence at the intersection of race/ethnicity and gender. Research in Higher Education, 55, 810–832. doi:10.1007/s11162-014-9333-z

40.

Lohfink

M. M.

Paulsen

M. B.

(2005). Comparing the determinants of persistence for first generation and continuing-generation students. Journal of College Student Development, 46, 409–428. doi:10.1353/csd.2005.0040

41.

MacPhee

Farro

Canetto

S. S.

(2013). Academic self-efficacy and performance of underrepresented STEM majors: Gender, ethnic, and social class patterns. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, 13, 347–369. doi:10.1111/asap.12033

42.

Marra

R. M.

Rodgers

K. A.

Shen

Bogue

(2010). Women engineering students and self-efficacy: A multi-year, multi-institution study of women engineering student self-efficacy. Journal of Engineering Education, 98, 27–38.

43.

Mayseless

Keren

(2014). Finding a meaningful life as a developmental task in emerging adulthood: The domains of love and work across cultures. Emerging Adulthood, 2, 63–73. doi:10.1177/2167696813515446

44.

McKeen

Bujaki

(2007). Gender and mentoring. In Ragins

B. R.

Kram

K. E.

(Eds.), The handbook of mentoring at work: Theory, research, and practice (pp. 197–222). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

45.

Mortimer

J. T.

Zimmer-Gembeck

M. J.

Holmes

Shanahan

M. J.

(2002). The process of occupational decision making: Patterns during the transition to adulthood. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 61, 439–465. doi:10.1006/jvbe.2002.1885

46.

National Academy of Sciences [NAS], National Academy of Engineering, & Institute of Medicine. (2010). Rising above the gathering storm, revisited: Rapidly approaching category 5. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.

47.

National Academy of Sciences [NAS], National Academy of Engineering, & Institute of Medicine. (2011). Expanding underrepresented minority participation. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.

48.

O’Brien

K. E.

Biga

Kessler

S. R.

Allen

T. D.

(2010). A meta-analytic investigation of gender differences in mentoring. Journal of Management, 36, 537–554. doi:10.1177/0149206308318619

49.

Ong

Wright

Espinosa

L. L.

Orfield

(2011). Inside the double bind: A synthesis of empirical research on undergraduate and graduate women of color in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. Harvard Educational Review, 81, 172–208.

50.

Phinney

J. S.

Campos

C. M. T.

Kallemeyn

D. M. P.

Kim

(2011). Processes and outcomes of a mentoring program for Latino college freshmen. Journal of Social Issues, 67, 599–621.

51.

President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology. (2012). Engage to excel: Producing one million additional college graduates with degrees in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. Washington, DC: Author.

52.

Ranta

Dietrich

Salmela-Aro

(2014). Career and romantic relationship goals and concerns during emerging adulthood. Emerging Adulthood, 2, 17–26. doi:10.1177/2167696813515852

53.

Robnett

R. D.

(2016). Gender bias in STEM fields: Variation in prevalence and links to STEM self-concept. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 40, 65–79. doi:10.1177/0361684315596162

54.

Robnett

R. D.

Chemers

M. M.

Zurbriggen

E. L.

(2015). Longitudinal associations among undergraduates’ research experience, self-efficacy, and identity. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 42, 847–867. doi:10.1002/tea.21221

55.

Robnett

R. D.

Thoman

S. A.

(2017). STEM success expectancies and achievement among women in STEM majors. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 52, 91–100. doi:10.1016/j.appdev.2017.07.003

56.

Sadler

T. D.

Burgin

McKinney

Ponjuan

(2010). Learning science through research apprenticeships: A critical review of the literature. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 47, 235–256. doi:10.1002/tea.20326

57.

Sáenz

V. B.

Ponjuan

(2011). Men of color: Ensuring the academic success of Latino males in higher education. Washington, DC: Institute for Higher Education Policy.

58.

Sánchez

Colón-Torres

Feuer

Roundfield

K. E.

Berardi

(2014). Race, ethnicity, and culture in mentoring relationships. In DuBois

D. L.

Karcher

M. J.

(Eds.), Handbook of youth mentoring (pp. 145–158). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. doi:10.4135/9781412996907.n10

59.

Schippers

(2008). Doing difference/doing power: Negotiations of race and gender in a mentoring program. Symbolic Interaction, 31, 77–98. doi:10.1525/si.2008.31.1.77

60.

Seymour

Hewitt

N. M.

(1997). Talking about leaving: Why undergraduates leave the sciences. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

61.

Syed

(2010). Developing an integrated self: Academic and ethnic identities among ethnically diverse college students. Developmental Psychology, 46, 1590–1604. doi:10.1037/a0020738

62.

Syed

Azmitia

Cooper

C. R.

(2011). Identity and academic success among underrepresented ethnic minorities: An interdisciplinary review and integration. Journal of Social Issues, 67, 442–468. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-4560.2011.01709.x

63.

Syed

Goza

Chemers

M. M.

Zurbriggen

E. L.

(2012). Individual differences in preferences for matched ethnic mentors among high achieving ethnically diverse adolescents in STEM. Child Development, 83, 896–910. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.2012.01744.x

64.

Syed

Mitchell

L. L.

(2013). Race, ethnicity, and emerging adulthood: Retrospect and prospects. Emerging Adulthood, 1, 83–95. doi:10.1177/2167696813480503

65.

Syed

Nelson

S. C.

(2015). Guidelines for establishing reliability when coding narrative data. Emerging Adulthood, 3, 375–387. doi:10.1177/2167696815587648

66.

Tenenbaum

H. R.

Crosby

F. J.

Gliner

M. D.

(2001). Mentoring relationships in graduate school. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 59, 326–341. doi:10.1006/jvbe.2001.1804

67.

Tsui

(2007). Effective strategies to increase diversity in STEM fields: A review of the literature. The Journal of Negro Education, 76, 555–581.

68.

Turner

C. S. V.

González

J. C.

Wong(Lau)

(2011). Faculty women of color: The critical nexus of race and gender. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 4, 199–211. doi:10.1037/a0024630

69.

U.S. Department of Education. (2013). STEM attrition: College students’ paths into and out of STEM fields (NCES 2014-001). Washington, DC. Retrieved January 2, 2017, from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2014001rev

70.

Van Soom

Donche

(2014). Profiling first-year students in STEM programs based on autonomous motivation and academic self-concept and relationship with academic achievement. PLoS One, 9, 1–13. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0112489

71.

Walton

G. M.

Cohen

G. L.

(2007). A question of belonging: Race, social fit, and achievement. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 92, 82–96. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.92.1.82

72.

Wang

M.-T.

Degol

(2013). Motivation pathways to STEM career choices: Using expectancy-value perspective to understand individual and gender differences in STEM fields. Developmental Review, 33, 304–340. doi:10.1016/j.dr.2013.08.001

73.

Watt

H. M.

(2006). The role of motivation in gendered educational and occupational trajectories related to maths. Educational Research and Evaluation, 12, 305–322. doi:10.1080/13803610600765562

74.

Wells

A. V.

Horn

(2015). The Asian American college experience at a diverse institution: Campus climate as a predictor of sense of belonging. Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice, 52, 149–163. doi:10.1080/19496591.2015.1041867

75.

Williams

J. C.

Phillips

K. W.

Hall

E. V.

(2014). Double jeopardy? Gender bias against women of color in science. Retrieved August 10, 2017, from http://www.uchastings.edu/news/articles/2015/01/williams-double-jeopardy-report.php

76.

Woodcock

Bairaktarova

(2015). Gender-biased self-evaluations of first-year engineering students. Journal of Women and Minorities in Science and Engineering, 21, 255–269.

77.

Yosso

T. J.

(2005). Whose culture has capital? A critical race theory discussion of community cultural wealth. Race, Ethnicity, and Education, 8, 69–91. doi:10.1080/1361332052000341006

78.

Zhang

A. Y.

Snowden

L. R.

Sue

(1998). Differences between Asian and White Americans’ help seeking and utilization patterns in the Los Angeles area. Journal of Community Psychology, 26, 317–326.