Minimally-invasive correction of ureteropelvic junction obstruction: do retrograde endo-incision techniques still have a role in the era of laparoscopic pyeloplasty?

Abstract

Background:This study was designed to review the long-term results and complications of the two techniques of retrograde endopyelotomy; ureteroscopic holmium laser endopyelotomy versus Acucise endopyelotomy. The results were then compared with the laparoscopic pyeloplasty results from a recent publication.

Patients and methods: The study was conducted retrospectively from January 2004 to July 2007. Seventy-two patients with ureteropelvic junction obstruction (UPJO) underwent retrograde endopyelotomy using either ureteroscopic laser endoincision (42 patients) or fluoroscopic guided hot-wire balloon (Acucise) endoincision (30 patients). Preoperative radiological assessment included intravenous pyelogram (IVP), helical computerized tomography and diuretic renography. The follow-up period ranged from 12 to 42 months. Subjective success was guided by the change in the preoperative flank pain while objective success on radiological evaluation was documented by either nonobstructed curve of diuretic renogram and/or T1/2 less than 10 min.

Results: The mean patient age was 42.6±7.5 years for the laser group and 39.2±15.1 years for the Acucise group (p = 0.24). The operative time was 66.8±22.2 min in the laser group and 59.8±20.3 min in the Acucise group (p = 0.84). By objective standards (renal scan), a total of 56 (77.8%) cases were successful (nonobstructed curve). This number included 34 cases in the laser group (80.9%) and 22 cases in the Acucise group (73.3%) (p = 0.2). Overall 16 failure cases were evident clinically within 1 year of the procedure (eight cases in each group). Most of the failure cases (13/16) presented with clinical obstructive symptoms during the early follow-up period (within 3 months postoperatively) and were then confirmed radiologically (six cases in the laser group and seven cases in the Acucise group) while only three patients had failures at 6, 9 and 11 months postoperatively. There was no statistically significant difference as regards intra-operative complications between the two groups (p = 0.4). Intra-operative bleeding was seen in three cases in the Acucise group while postoperatively it was reported in one case.

Conclusion: The retrograde endopyelotomy approach is safe and effective for the treatment of patients with UPJO. Both ureteroscopic laser and the hot-wire balloon (Acucise) techniques have an important role in the management of UPJO, especially in secondary cases, and they provide comparable long-term objective and subjective outcomes. Laparoscopic pyeloplasty provides far better results but with higher costs, and requires well-equipped centers and involves a long learning curve.

Keywords

ureteropelvic junction obstruction retrograde endoscopy laproscopy

References

Biyani, C.S. , Cornford, P.A. and Powell, C.S. ( 2000) Ureteroscopic endopyelotomy with the Holmium: YAG laser. Mid-term results. Eur Urol 38: 139-143.

Calvert, R.C. , Morsy, M.M. , Zelhof, B. , Rhodes, M. and Burgess, N.A. ( 2008) Comparison of laparoscopic and open pyeloplasty in 100 patients with pelvi-ureteric junction obstruction. Surg Endosc 22: 411-414.

Cheung, M.C. , Lee, F. , Yip, S.K. and Tam, P.C. ( 2001) Outpatient holmium laser lithotripsy using semirigid ureteroscope. Is the treatment outcome affected by stone load? Eur Urol 39: 702-708.

Combe, M. , Gelet, A. and Ramackers, J.M. ( 1997) Endopyelotomy with the Acucise cutting balloon device. Early clinical experience. Eur Urol 31: 389-394.

Conlin, M.J. and Bagley, D.H. ( 1998) Ureteroscopic endopyelotomy at a single setting. J Urol 159: 727-731.

Dimarco, D.S. , Gettman, M.T. , McGee, S.M. , Chow, G.K. , Leroy, A.J. , Selzak, J. et al. (2006) Long term success of antegrade endopyelotomy compared with pyeloplasty at a single institution. J Endourol 20: 707.

Echazarian, C. , Lechevallier, E. and Ortega, J.C. ( 1999) Retrograde Acucise endopyelotomy: long term results. J Endourol 13: 575-580.

El-Nahas, A.R. , Shoma, A.M. , Eraky, I. , El-Kenawy, M.R. and El-Kappany, H.A. ( 2006) Prospective, randomized comparison of ureteroscopic endopyelotomy using holmium: YAG laser and balloon catheter. J Urol 175: 614-618.

Giddens, J.L. and Grasso, M. ( 2000) Retrograde ureteroscopic endopyelotomy using the holmium: YAG laser. J Urol 164: 1509-1512.

10.

Goldfischer, E.R. , Jabbour, M.E. , Stravodimos, K.G. , Klima, W.J. and Smith, A.D. ( 1998) Techniques of endopyelotomy. Br J Urol 82: 1-7.

11.

Grasso, M. , Cohen, T.D. and Preminger, G.M. ( 1996) Long term follow up of Acucise incision of ureteropelvic junction obstruction and ureteral strictures. Urology 47: 317-322.

12.

Kim, F.J. , Herrell, S.D. , Jahoda, A.E. and Albala, D.M. ( 1998) Complications of Acucise endopyelotomy. J Endourol 12: 433-436.

13.

Matin, S.F. , Yost, A. and Streem, S.B. ( 2003) Ureteroscopic laser endopyelotomy: a single-center experience . J Endourol 17: 401-404.

14.

Nakada, S.Y. and Johnson, M. ( 2000) Ureteropelvic junction obstruction. Retrograde endopyelotomy . Urol Clin North Am 27: 677-684.

15.

Rao, G.S. , Nadler, R.B. and Pearle, M.S. ( 1996) Acucise endopyelotomy: assessment of long-term durability . J Urol 156: 1094-1099.

16.

Schwartz, B.P. and Stoller, M.L. ( 1999) Complications of retrograde balloon cautry endopyelotomy . J Urol 162: 1594-1598.

17.

Tawfiek, E.R. , Liu, J.B. and Bagley, D.H. ( 1998) Ureteroscopic treatment of ureteropelvic junction obstruction . J Urol 160: 1643-1646; , discussion 1646-1647.

18.

Thomas, R. and Monga, M. ( 1998) Endopyelotomy. Retrograde ureteroscopic approach. Urol Clin North Am 25: 305-310.

19.

Thomas, R. , Monga, M. and Klein, E.W. ( 1996) Ureteroscopic retrograde endopyelotomy for management of ureteropelvic junction obstruction. J Endourol 10: 141-145.

20.

Tuncay, O.L. , Gupta, M. and Smith, A.D. ( 1997) Open surgical exploration after failed endopyelotomy: a 12-year perspective. J Urol 157: 1613.

21.

Wagner, J.R. , D’Agostino, R. and Babayan, R.K. ( 1996) Renal arterioureteral hemorrhage: a complication of acucise endopyelotomy. Urology 48: 139-142.

22.

Walz, J. , Lecamus, C. and Lechevallier, E. ( 2003) Complications of ‘Acucise’ balloon endopyelotomy . Prog Urol 13: 39-43.

23.

Yanke, B.V. , Lallas, C.D. , Pagnani, C. , McGinnis, D.E. and Bagley, D.H. ( 2008) The minimally invasive treatment of ureteropelvic junction obstruction: a review of our experience during the last decade. J Urol 180: 1397-1402.