Abstract
This study examines the use of the ideograph territorial sovereignty by the Times of India (TOI; U.S./New Delhi editions) in its reports on China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Using McGee's (1980) notion of ideograph and Entman’s ( 1993) framing theory, it uncovers a discursive strategy used by elite media for swaying public opinion regarding international and domestic information flow when promoting its preferred “Indian” understanding of the BRI. This study reviews historical uses of the ideograph territorial sovereignty to establish an analysis of the TOI's use of it. Then, following framing theory and a synchronic structure, I explore the ideograph in 40 collected TOI reports by contextualizing relationships supporting and surrounding it.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abraham
I
(2014 ) How India Became Territorial: Foreign Policy, Diaspora, Geopolitics . Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press .
2.
Bagchi
I
(2018 ) Modi did well to pitch India in stand-alone terms at davos .
Times of India
, January 24. Available at : https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/blogs/et-commentary/modi-did-well-to-pitch-india-in-stand-alone-terms-at-davos/?source=app&frmapp=yes&comments=show (accessed 3 March 2021)
3.
Bhabha
HK
(1990 ) Nation and Narration . London : Routledge .
4.
Carragee
M
Roefs
W
(2004 ) The neglect of power in recent framing research . Journal of Communication 54 (2 ): 214 -233 .
5.
Chaudhury
DR
(2017 ) Make India an enemy and you will lose your lifeline, Chinese experts caution Beijing over doklam .
Times of India
, August 2. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/make-india-an-enemy-and-you-will-lose-your-lifeline-chinese-experts-caution-beijing-over-doklam/articleshow/59878139.cms (accessed 3 March 2021)
6.
Chaudhury
DR
(2018 ) PM KP oil’s visit reinforced India’s position as key player in Nepal .
Times of India
, April 10. Available at : https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/pm-kp-olis-visit-reinforced-indias-position-as-key-player-in-nepal/articleshow/63690595.cms(accessed 4 March 2021)
7.
Chhibber
A
(2017 ) India And China need some kind of competitive cooperation rather than an open conflict .
Times of India
, August 28. Available at : https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/blogs/et-commentary/india-and-china-need-some-kind-of-competitive-cooperation-rather-than-an-open-conflict/ (accessed 3 March 2021)
8.
Condit
C
(1990 ) Rhetorical criticism and audiences: The extremes of McGee and leff . Western Journal of Speech Communication 54 (3 ): 330 -345 .
9.
Condit
C
Lucaites
J
(1993 ) Crafting Equality: America's Anglo-African Word . Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press .
10.
Dasgupta
S
(2017 ) China Hints it can rename CPEC if India joins OBOR initiative .
Times of India
, November 24. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/china-shows-interest-in-talking-one-belt-one-road-plan-with-india/articleshow/61771677.cms (accessed 3 March 2021)
11.
Dasgupta
S
(2018 ). India Sticks to its own path, says no to China’s belt & road initiative .
Times of India
, April 25. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/india-sticks-to-its-own-path-says-no-to-chinas-belt-road-initiative/articleshow/63903471.cms (accessed 4 March 2021)
12.
De Freytas-Tamura
K
(2017 ). Kenyans Fear Chinese-backed railway is another ‘lunatic express.’
The New York Times
, June 9. Available at : https://cn.nytimes.com/world/20170609/kenyans-fear-chinese-backed-railway-is-another-lunatic-express/en-us/ (accessed 6 March 2021)
13.
Debroy
B
(2017 ) A new lunatic express: OBOR projects worldwide are stacking the deck for Chinese enterprises and banks .
Times of India
, June 1. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/policypundit/a-new-lunatic-express-obor-projects-worldwide-are-stacking-the-deck-for-chinese-enterprises-and-banks/ (accessed 3 March 2021)
14.
Desai
AR
(2005 ) Social Background of Indian Nationalism , 6th edition . Mumbai, India: Popular Prakashan Ltd
15.
Elden
S
(2010 ) Land, terrain, territory . Progress in Human Geography 34 (6 ): 799 -817 .
16.
Entman
RM
(1993 ) Framing: toward clarification of a fractured paradigm . Journal of Communication 43 (4 ): 51 -58 .
17.ET Edit (2017 ) India And Japan: strategic partners .
Times of India
, September 13. Available at : https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/blogs/et-editorials/india-and-japan-strategic-partners/ (accessed 3 March 2021)
18.
Foss
S
(2018 ) Rhetoric Criticism: Exploration & Practice . 5th edition . Long Grove, IL : Waveland Press, Inc .
19.
Ganguly
S
Bajpai
K
(1994 ) India And the crisis in kashmir . Asian Survey 34 (5 ): 401 -4416 .
20.
Gilani
I
(2020 ) India’s border dispute with neighbors .
Anadolu Agency
, May 31. Available at : https://www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/indias-border-dispute-with-neighbors/1859854# (accessed 21 December 2021)
21.
Hanson
EC
(1995 ) Framing the world news: The Times of India in changing times . Political Communication 12 (4 ): 371 -393 .
22.
Kohli
A
(2017 ) OBOR, doklam and malabar .
Times of India
, July 16. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/Masquerader/obor-doklam-and-malabar/?source=app&frmapp=yes (accessed 3 March 2021)
23.
Kohli
K
(2017 ) Times of India takes down a story the BJP finds embarrassing, again .
The Wire
, September 26. Available at : https://thewire.in/media/times-of-india-vasundhara-raje-bjp-narendra-modi-press-censorship (accessed 9 August 2021)
24.
Lefèbvre
H
(1991 ) The Production of Space (D Nicholson-Smith, Trans.) . New York, NY : Wiley-Blackwell .
25.
Li
Z
McKerrow
RE
(2021 ) Xi jinping’s keynote in the belt and road forum: A pentadic cartography . Critical Discourse Studies 18 (5 ): 504 -518 .
26.
Lin
C
(1984 ) The Rise of the Indian National Independence Movement [印度民族独立运动的兴起 ]. Beijing, China: Peking University Press .
27.
Manela
E
(2007 ) The Wilsonian Moment: Self-Determination and the International Origins of Anticolonial Nationalism . New York, NY: Oxford University Press , Inc.
28.
McGee
MC
(1980 ) The ‘ideograph’: A link between rhetoric and ideology . Quarterly Journal of Speech 66 (1 ): 1 -16 .
29.
McKerrow
RE
(1999 ) Space and time in the postmodern polity . Western Journal of Communication 63 (3 ): 271 -290 .
30.
Methu
S
(2014 ) The Indian migrants who built Kenya’s ‘lunatic line. ’
CNN
, December 11. Available at : https://www.cnn.com/2014/12/11/world/africa/kenya-railways-india/index.html (accessed 6 March 2021)
31.
Mitra
SK
(2006 ) The Puzzle of India‘s Governance: Culture, Context and Comparative Theory . London : Routledge .
32.
Patowary
K
(2019 ) Lunatic express: The railway that gave birth to Kenya . Amusing Planet , March 5. Available at : https://www.amusingplanet.com/2019/03/lunatic-express-train-that-gave-birth.html (accessed 6 March 2021)
33.PTI (2017a ) China Avoids comment on plans to build big dam in PoK .
Times of India
, June 22. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/china/china-avoids-comment-on-plans-to-build-big-dam-in-pok/articleshow/59269113.cms (accessed 3 March 2021)
34.PTI (2017b ) India Should shed ‘strategic anxiety,’ join belt and road initiative: Chinese media .
Times of India
, July 2. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/india-should-shed-strategic-anxiety-join-belt-and-road-initiative-chinese-media/articleshow/59410745.cms (accessed 3 March 2021)
35.PTI (2017c ) CPEC Will aggravate India-Pak tension: US think-tank .
Times of India
, November 29. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/us/cpec-will-aggravate-india-pak-tension-us-think-tank/articleshow/61848347.cms (accessed 3 March 2021)
36.PTI (2017d ) Russia pitches for India’s participation in OBOR .
Times of India
, December 11. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/russia-pitches-for-indias-participation-in-obor/articleshow/62028052.cms (accessed 3 March 2021)
37.
Pulipaka
S
(2017 ) India, Japan and Africa .
Times of India
, September 16. Available at : https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/blogs/et-commentary/india-japan-and-africa/ (accessed 3 March 2021)
38.
Ranganathan
M
(2014 ) Paid news: cocktail of media, business and politics . In:
Rodrigues
UM
Ranganathan
M
(eds) Indian News Media: From Observer to Participant . New Delhi : Sage , 121 -147 .
39.
Raghavan
S
(2010 ) War and Peace in Modern India . London : Palgrave Macmillan .
40.
Rej
A
(2017 ) Trump’s new national security strategy: The good, the bad and the complicated for New Delhi .
Times of India
, December 20. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/toi-edit-page/trumps-new-national-security-strategy-the-good-the-bad-and-the-complicated-for-new-delhi/ (accessed 3 March 2021)
41.
Saksena
P
(2020 ) Building the nation: sovereignty and international law in the decolonization of south Asia . Journal of the History of International Law 23 (1 ): 52 -79 .
42.
Schaffer
HB
(2009 ) The Limits of Influence: America‘s Role in Kashmir . Washington, DC : Brookings Institution Press .
43.
Seib
PM
(1997 ) Headline Diplomacy: How News Coverage Affects Foreign Policy . Westport, CT : Praeger .
44.
Sharma
A
(2012 ) Counterterrorism cooperation in the context of the indo-US strategic partnership: An appraisal . India Quarterly 68 (4 ): 315 -330 .
45.
Sirohi
S
(2017 ) Modi-Trump meet: India and the United States are still on firm footing .
Times of India
, June 27. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/letterfromwashington/modi-trump-meet-india-and-the-united-states-are-still-on-firm-footing/?comments=show (accessed 3 March 2021)
46.
Thapar
K
(2021 ) Watch | ‘hyper-nationalism making India intolerant; muslims feel insecure’: hamid ansari .
The Wire
, February 9. Available at : https://thewire.in/communalism/watch-karan-thapar-hamid-ansari-hyper-nationalism-muslims (accessed 31 August 2021)
47.TNN (2020 ) TOI Sees rise in number of young & upmarket readers .
Times of India
, January 22. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/toi-sees-rise-in-no-of-young-upmarket-readers/articleshow/73504985.cms (accessed 9 August 2021)
48.TOI Edit (2017a ) Abe in ahmedabad: India-Japan partnership can transform development paradigm in India and the region .
Times of India
, September 12. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/toi-editorials/abe-in-ahmedabad-india-japan-partnership-can-transform-development-paradigm-in-india-and-the-region/?source=app&frmapp=yes (accessed 3 March 2021)
49.TOI Edit (2017b ) Chabahar connect: strategic port opens up India’s access to Afghanistan and beyond .
Times of India
, December 4. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/toi-editorials/chabahar-connect-strategic-port-opens-up-indias-access-to-afghanistan-and-beyond/?source=app&frmapp=yes (accessed 3 March 2021)
50.TOI Edit (2018 ) India Shouldn’t join China’s BRI until its reasonable demands are met . Times of India , April 25. Available at : https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/toi-editorials/india-shouldnt-join-chinas-bri-until-its-reasonable-demands-are-met/ (accessed 4 March 2021)
51.
Wagner
C
(2019 ) Facing global China: India and the belt and road initiative . In:
Tramballi
U
Missaglia
N
(eds.), India's Global Challenge: Growth and Leadership in the 21st Century . Milan : Ledizioni LediPublishing , 141 -158 .
52.
Warnick
B
(1995 ) Book reviews: reading, rhetoric, and the texture of public memory . Quarterly Journal of Speech 81 : 237 -265 .