What does it mean to be civic-ready? Uncovering citizenship conceptualizations in US states that require the ‘citizenship test’

Abstract

There is a growing trend within civics education within the United States to adopt the USCIS naturalization civics exam (commonly referred to as the ‘citizenship test’), which consists of 100 multiple choice questions, to determine the civic readiness of students. This study explores civics education within eight US states that have adopted the ‘citizenship test’ model through the lens of citizenship conceptualizations evidenced within their high school civics state standards. Utilizing a directed content analysis, the researcher located more than 230 standards within three citizenship discourse categories: civic republican, liberal, and reconstructionist. Citizenship within the examined state standards, was largely conceptualized as civic republican in orientation (96%) and nested within untroubled assumptions of US society and desires for a common American identity that often crowded out attention to diversity and conflict and in doing so, mirrored exclusionary practices common to standardized, high-stakes assessments including the USCIS naturalization civics exam.

Keywords

citizenship civics education citizenship test social justice state standards

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abowitz

Harnish

(2006) Contemporary discourses of citizenship. Review of Educational Research 76(4): 653–690.

Alabama State Department of Education (2010) Alabama course of study: Social studies. Available at: https://www.alsde.edu/sec/sct/COS/2010%20Alabama%20Social%20Studies%20Course%20of%20Study.pdf (accessed 21 May 2019).

Anderson

Krathwohl

Airasian

, et al. (2000) A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching, and Assessing: A Revision of Bloom’s Taxonomy of Educational Objectives. New York: Longman.

Andreotti

(2014) Soft versus critical global citizenship education. In McCloskey

(ed.) Development Education in Policy and Practice. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 21–31.

Appiah

(2006) Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers. New York: W.W. Norton.

Apple

(1996) The hidden curriculum and the nature of conflict. In: Parker

(ed.) Educating the Democratic Mind. Albany, NY: SUNY Press, 173–200.

Arizona Department of Education (2018) Arizona history and social science standards. Available at: https://cms.azed.gov/home/GetDocumentFile?id=5c76b4ed1dcb2512fcd012fd (accessed 21 May 2019).

Arkansas Department of Education (2014) Civics social studies curriculum framework. Available at: http://www.arkansased.gov/public/userfiles/Learning_Services/Curriculum%20Support/Standards%20and%20Courses/Social_Studies/Civics.pdf (accessed 21 May 2019).

(2009) Social studies, social justice: W(h)ither the social studies in high-stakes testing? Teacher Education Quarterly 36(1): 43–58.

10.

(2014) Common core: Same exclusion, different century. Cloaking Inequality. Available at: http://cloakinginequity.com/2014/02/20/common-core-same-exclusion-different-century/ (accessed 4 July 2019).

11.

Banks

(1997) Educating Citizens in a Multicultural Society. New York: Teachers College Press.

12.

Banks

Nguyen

(2008) Diversity and citizenship education: Historical, theoretical, and philosophical issues. In: Levstik

Tyson

(eds) Handbook of Research in Social Studies Education. New York: Routledge, 137–151.

13.

Beiner

(1995) Theorizing Citizenship. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.

14.

Bohan

(2001) The meaning of citizenship in the 21st century. Theory & Research in Social Education 29(3): 517–523.

15.

Bondy

Johnson

(2018) Race, national exclusions, and the implications for global citizenship. In: Davies

L-C

Kiwan

, et al (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Global Citizenship and Education. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 393–407.

16.

Brennan

Railey

(2017) The civics education initiative: 2015–2017. Available at: https://www.ecs.org/wp-content/uploads/The-Civics-Education-Initiative-2015-2017.pdf (accessed 10 June 2019).

17.

Brown

Crowley

King

(2011) Black civitas: An examination of Carter Woodson’s contributions to teaching about race, citizenship, and the black soldier. Theory and Research in Social Education 39(2): 278–299.

18.

Cardinali

(2018) What your state is doing to beef up education. Available at: https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2018/07/21/624267576/what-your-state-is-doing-to-beef-up-civics-education (accessed 15 June 2019).

19.

Castro

Knowles

(2017) Democratic citizenship education: Research across multiple landscapes and contexts. In: Manfra

Bolick

(eds) The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research. West Sussex: Wiley Blackwell, 287–318.

20.

Center for Information and Research on Civic Learning and Engagement (2013) All together now: Collaboration and innovation for youth civic engagement. The report of the commission on youth voting and civic knowledge. Available at: http://www.civicyouth.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/CIRCLE-youthvoting-individualPages.pdf (accessed 21 June 2019).

21.

Chandler

(2015) Doing Race in Social Studies. Charlotte, NC: Information Publishing.

22.

Chandler

Hawley

(2017) Race Lessons: Using Inquiry to Teach About Race in Social Studies. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.

23.

Cogan

Grossman

Liu

(2000) Citizenship: The democratic imagination in a global/local context. Social Education 64(1): 48–53.

24.

Darragh

Petrie

(2019) ‘I feel like I’m teaching in a landmine’: Teaching in the context of political trauma. Teaching and Teacher Education 80(1): 180–189.

25.

Dejka

(2017a) Nebraska ed board panel delays consideration of ‘civic readiness’ definition, asks for rewrite. Omaha World-Herald, 7 December.

26.

Dejka

(2017b) Nebraska education leaders disagree on proposed ‘civic readiness’ definition. Omaha World-Herald, 7 December.

27.

Dunn

Sondel

Baggett

(2019) ‘I don’t want to come off as pushing an agenda’: How contexts shaped teachers’ pedagogy in the days after the 2016 US presidential election. American Educational Research Journal 56(2): 444–476.

28.

Elo

Kyngäs

(2008) The qualitative content analysis process. Journal of Advanced Nursing 62(1): 107–115.

29.

Epstein

(2009) Interpreting National History: Race, Identity, and Pedagogy in Classrooms and Communities. New York: Routledge.

30.

Gallie

(1956) Essentially contested concepts. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 56(1): 167–198.

31.

Garrison

(2017) Dewey, Derrida, and the genetic derivation of différance. Educational Philosophy and Theory 49(10): 484–494.

32.

Gaudelli

(2003) World Class: Teaching and Learning in Global Times. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.

33.

Gould

(ed.) (2011) Guardian of democracy: The civic mission of schools. Campaign for the Civic Mission of Schools. Available at: https://www.carnegie.org/media/filer_public/ab/dd/abdda62e-6e84-47a4-a043-348d2f2085ae/ccny_grantee_2011_guardian.pdf (accessed 4 July 2019).

34.

Gülalp

(2013) Citizenship and democracy beyond the nation-state? Cultural Dynamics 25(1): 29–47.

35.

Hahn

(2002) Implications of September 11th for political socialization research. Theory and Research in Social Education 30(1): 158–162.

36.

Hansen

(2011) The Teacher and the World: A Study of Cosmopolitanism as Education. New York: Routledge.

37.

Hess

(2009) Controversy in the Classroom: The Democratic Power of Discussion. New York: Taylor and Francis.

38.

Hess

Stoddard

(2007) 9/11 and terrorism: ‘The ultimate teachable moment’ in textbooks and supplemental curricula. Social Education 71(5): 231–236.

39.

Hickman

(1990) John Dewey’s Pragmatic Technology. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

40.

House Bill 2064 (2015) State of Arizona House of Representatives, 52nd Legislature.

41.

Hsieh

Shannon

(2005) Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research 15(9): 1277–1288.

42.

Iasevoli

(2018) Another state to require testing in civics. Curriculum matters. Education Week, 31 July. Available at: https://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/curriculum/2018/06/another_state_to_require_testing.html (accessed 5 July 2019).

43.

Ichilov

(1998) Citizenship and Citizenship Education in a Changing World. London: Woburn Press.

44.

Joe Foss Institute (2019) 100 questions every student should know!. Available at: https://joefossinstitute.org/ (accessed 12 May 2019).

45.

Johnson

(2016) How is citizenship represented in TRSE? A content and discourse analysis. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA.

46.

Jones

Gaventa

(2002) Concepts of Citizenship: A Review. Brighton: Institute of Development Studies.

47.

Journell

(2009) An incomplete history: Representation of American Indians in state social studies standards. Journal of American Indian Education 48(2): 18–32.

48.

Kabeer

(2002) Citizenship and the Boundaries of the Acknowledged Community: Identity, Affiliation and Community. Brighton: Institute of Developmental Studies.

49.

Kahne

Middaugh

(2009) Democracy for some: The civic opportunity gap in high school. In: Youniss

Levine

(eds) Engaging Young People in Civic Life. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt Press, 29–58.

50.

Kahne

Rodriguez

Smith

, et al. (2000) Developing citizens for democracy? Assessing 0pportunities to learn in Chicago’s social studies classrooms. Theory & Research in Social Education 28(3): 311–338.

51.

Kalberg

(1993) Cultural foundations of modern citizenship. In: Turner

(ed.) Citizenship and Social Theory. London: Sage Publications, 91–114.

52.

Kentucky Department of Education (2015) Kentucky academic standards: Social studies. Available at: https://education.ky.gov/Pages/Agency404.aspx?oldUrl=https%3a%2f%2feducation.ky.gov%2fcurriculum%2fstandards%2fkyacadstand%2fDocuments%2fKentucky_Academic_Standards_Social_Studies.pdf (accessed 21 May 2019).

53.

Kymlicka

(1995) Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

54.

Ladson-Billings

(2005) Differing concepts of citizenship: Schools and communities as sites of civic development. In: Noddings

(ed.) Educating Citizens for Global Awareness. New York: Teachers College Press, 69–80.

55.

Legislative Bill 399 (2019) Nebraska 106th Legislature.

56.

Levinson

(2012) No Citizen Left Behind. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

57.

Li-Ching

Alviar-Martin

Sim

, et al. (2011) Civic disparities: Exploring students’ perceptions of citizenship within Singapore’s academic tracks. Theory & Research in Social Education 39(2): 203–237.

58.

Lindsay

(2018) States tackling civic illiteracy in America. Forbes, 30 November. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/tomlindsay/2018/11/30/states-tackling-civic-illiteracy-in-america/#42380b757b75 (accessed 10 June 2019).

59.

Lipset

(1963) Political Man: The Social Bases of Politics. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.

60.

Lister

(2005) ‘Marshall-ing’ social and political citizenship: Towards a unified conception of citizenship. Government and Opposition 40(4): 471–491.

61.

Loring

(2012) The meaning of citizenship: Tests, policy, and English proficiency. The CATESOL Journal 24(1): 198–219.

62.

Marshall

Bottomore

(1950/1992) Citizenship and Social Class. Concord, MA: Pluto Press.

63.

McNamara

Roever

(2006) Language Testing: The Social Dimension. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.

64.

Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (2016) 6-12 Social studies grade level expectations. Available at: https://dese.mo.gov/sites/default/files/curr-mls-standards-ss-6-12-sboe-2016.pdf (accessed 21 May 2019).

65.

Mitchell

Parker

(2008) I pledge allegiance to . . . flexible citizenship and shifting scales of belonging. Teachers College Record 110(4): 775–804.

66.

Mossberger

Tolbert

McNeal

(2008) Digital Citizenship: The Internet, Society, and Participation. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

67.

Mouffe

(2000) Deliberative Democracy or Agonistic Pluralism (Reihe Politikwissenschaft/Political Science Series 72). Vienna: Institute for Advanced Studies.

68.

Mouffe

(2013) Agonistics: Thinking the World Politically. London: Verso.

69.

Murphy

(2019) New law will require Indiana high schoolers to take the US citizenship test. Can you pass it? CNN, 26 April. Available at: https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/26/us/citizenship-test-naturalization-indiana-trnd/index.html (accessed 21 June 2019).

70.

Myers

(2006) Rethinking the social studies curriculum in the context of globalization: Education for global citizenship in the U.S. Theory and Research in Social Education 34(3), 370–394.

71.

National Council for the Social Studies (2018) National standards for the preparation of social studies teachers. Available at: https://www.socialstudies.org/sites/default/files/media/2017/Nov/ncss_teacher_standards_2017-rev9-6-17.pdf (accessed 2 May 2019).

72.

Nebraska Department of Education (2017) Defining civic readiness. Available at: https://www.education.ne.gov/wpcontent/uploads/2017/12/Civic_Readiness_Definition_DRAFT_NDE_11_28_2017.pdf (accessed 19 April 2019).

73.

Noddings

(2005) Educating Citizens for Global Awareness. New York: Teachers College Press.

74.

North Dakota Department of Public Instruction (2007) North Dakota content and achievement standards: Social studies. Available at: http://www.ashley.k12.nd.us/files/2015/10/social-studies-k-12.pdf (accessed 21 May 2019).

75.

Nussbaum

(2007) Cultivating humanity and world citizenship. Available at: http://forum.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/ff0709s.pdf (accessed 14 December 2018).

76.

Ong

(1999) Flexible Citizenship: The Cultural Logics of Transnationality. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

77.

Ong

(2005) (Re)articulations of citizenship. PS: Political Science and Politics 38(4): 697–699.

78.

Osler

Starkey

(2005) Changing Citizenship: Democracy and Inclusion in Education. Maidenhead: Open University Press.

79.

Parker

(1996a) Curriculum for democracy. In: Sober

(ed.) Democracy, Education, and the Schools. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishing, 182–210.

80.

Parker

(1996b) ‘Advanced’ ideas about democracy: Toward a pluralist conception of citizen education. Teachers College Record 98(1): 104–125.

81.

Parker

(2014) Citizenship education in the United States: Regime type, foundational issues, and classroom practice. In: Nucci

Narvaez

Krettenauer

(eds) The Handbook of Moral and Character Education. New York: Routledge, 347–367.

82.

Payne

Adair

Colegrove

, et al. (2019) Reconceptualizing civic education for young children: Recognizing embodied civic action. Education, Citizenship, and Social Justice 15(1): 35–46.

83.

Payne

Journell

(2018) ‘We have those kinds of conversations here. . .’: Addressing contentious politics with elementary students. Teaching and Teacher Education 79(3): 73–82.

84.

Pocock

(1995) The Ideal of citizenship since classical times. In: Beiner

(ed.) Theorizing Citizenship. Albany, NY: SUNY Press, 29–52.

85.

Pontes

Henn

Griffiths

(2017) Youth political (dis)engagement and the need for citizenship education: Encouraging young people’s civic and political participation through the curriculum. Education, Citizenship, and Social Justice 14(1): 3–21.

86.

Rawls

(1999) A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

87.

Reist

(2017) Nebraska ed board holds off on ‘civic readiness’ vote because of state senator’s concerns. Lincoln Journal Star, 7 December.

88.

Ribble

(2011) Digital Citizenship in Schools. Eugene, OR: International Society for Technology in Education.

89.

Rosaldo

(1989) Culture & Truth: The Remaking of Social Analysis. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.

90.

Rosaldo

Flores

(1997) Identity, conflict, and evolving Latino communities: Cultural citizenship in San Jose, California. In: Flores

Benmayor

(eds) Latino Cultural Citizenship: Claiming Identity, Space, and Rights. Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 57–96.

91.

Ross

(2002) Citizenship and the curriculum. In: Scott

Lawson

(eds) Citizenship Education and the Curriculum. Westport, CT: Ablex Publishing, 45–62.

92.

Ross

(2000) Redrawing the lines: The case against traditional social studies instruction. In: Hursh

Ross

(eds) Democratic Social Education: Social Studies for Social Change. New York: Falmer Press, 43–64.

93.

Rubin

(2007) ‘Laboratories of democracy’: A situated perspective on learning social studies in de-tracked classrooms. Theory & Research in Social Education 35(1): 62–95.

94.

Salinas

(2006) Educating late arrival high school immigrant students: A call for a more democratic curriculum. Multicultural Perspectives 8(1): 20–27.

95.

Schmidt

(2013) Claiming our turf: Students’ civic negotiation of the public space of school. Theory & Research in Social Education 41(4): 535–551.

96.

Scott

Lawson

(2002) Citizenship Education and the Curriculum. Westport, CT: Ablex Publishing.

97.

Segall

(2003) Teachers’ perceptions of the impact of state-mandated standardized testing: The Michigan educational assessment program (MEAP) as a case study of consequences. Theory and Research in Social Education 31(3): 287–325.

98.

Shapiro

(2000) National times and other times: Rethinking citizenship. Cultural Studies 14(1): 79–88.

99.

Shapiro

Brown

(2018) The state of civics education. Center for American Progress. Available at: https://cdn.americanprogress.org/content/uploads/2018/02/06085433/CivicsEducation-brief-updated.pdf (accessed 15 May 2019).

100.

Shohamy

(1993) The power of tests: The impact of language tests on teaching and learning. NFLC Occasional Paper. Washington, DC: The National Foreign Language Center at the Johns Hopkins University.

101.

Slate

Jones

Wiesman

, et al. (2008) School mission statements and school performance: A mixed research investigation. New Horizons in Education 56(2): 17–27.

102.

Stanley

(2001) Social studies: Problems and possibilities. In: Stanley

(ed.) Critical Issues in Social Studies Research for the 21st Century. Greenwich, CT: Information Age Publishing, Inc., 1–14.

103.

Stanley

(2010) Social studies and the social order. In: Parker

(ed.) Social Studies Today: Research and Practice. New York: Routledge, 17–24.

104.

Swan

Lee

Grant

(2019) Teaching American slavery through inquiry. Available at: https://www.tolerance.org/magazine/publications/teaching-american-slavery-through-inquiry (accessed 17 June 2019).

105.

Thornton

(2004) Citizenship education and social studies curriculum change after 9/11. In: Woyshner

Watras

Crocco

(eds) Social Education in the Twentieth Century: Curriculum and Context for Citizenship. New York: Peter Lang, 210–220.

106.

Turner

(2009) T.H. Marshall, social rights, and English national identity. Citizenship Studies 13(1): 65–73.

107.

Tyack

(1967) Turning Points in American Educational History. Lexington, MA: Xerox College Publishing.

108.

Urrieta

(2004) Dis-connections in ‘American’ citizenship and the post/neo-colonial: People of Mexican descent and whitestream pedagogy and curriculum. Theory & Research in Social Education 32(4): 433–458.

109.

Utah State Department of Education (2016) Utah core state standards for social studies. Available at: https://www.schools.utah.gov/file/0662e2c7-2be5-4429-9ff3-2c6a8b58d54d (accessed 21 May 2019).

110.

Waters

(1989) Citizenship and the constitution of structured social-inequality. International Journal of Comparative Sociology 30(3–4): 159–180.

111.

Westbrook

(1996) Public schooling and American democracy. In: Soder

(ed.) Democracy, Education, and the Schools. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishing, 125–150.

112.

Westheimer

(2004) Introduction—The politics of civic education. PS: Political Science and Politics 37(2): 231–235.

113.

Westheimer

Kahne

(2004) What kind of citizen? The politics of educating for democracy. American Educational Research Journal 41(2): 237–269.

114.

Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (2018) Wisconsin standards for social studies. Available at: https://dpi.wi.gov/sites/default/files/imce/standards/New%20pdfs/2018_WI_Social_Studies_Standards.pdf (accessed 21 May 2019).

115.

Wonjung Park

(2008) A more meaningful citizenship test: Unmasking the construction of a universalist, principle-based citizenship ideology. California Law Review 96(4): 999–1048.

116.

Young

(1989) Polity and group difference: A critique of the ideal of universal citizenship. Ethics 99(2): 250–274.