Abstract
Background
Fabry disease is an X-linked lysosomal storage disorder due to impaired activity of alpha-galactosidase A with intracellular accumulation of globotriaosylceramide. Associated small fiber pathology leads to characteristic pain in Fabry disease. We systematically assessed sensory system, physical activity, metabolic parameters, and morphology of male and female mice with alpha-galactosidase A deficiency (Fabry ko) from 2 to 27 months of age and compared results with those of age- and gender-matched wild-type littermates of C57Bl/6J background.
Results
From the age of two months, male and female Fabry mice showed mechanical hypersensitivity (
Conclusions
Mice with alpha-galactosidase A deficiency show age-dependent and distinct deficits of the sensory system. alpha-galactosidase A-deficient mice seem to model human Fabry disease and may be helpful when studying the pathophysiology of Fabry-associated pain.
Background
Fabry disease (FD) is an X-linked lysosomal storage disorder caused by deficient or absent activity of the enzyme alpha-galactosidase A (α-GAL) due to mutations in the encoding
Methods
Ethic statement
All experiments were approved by the Bavarian State authorities (Regierung von Unterfranken, # 54/12). Mice were held at the animal facilities of the Department of Neurology, University of Würzburg, and were fed standard chow (commercially prepared complete diet). Animal use and care were in accordance with the institutional guidelines.
Mice
We investigated 215 naïve Fabry ko mice (89 male, 126 female) with a targeted disruption of the
Behavioral tests
Behavioral tests were performed by an experienced investigator (LB) unaware of the study objectives and of genotype. The von-Frey test based on the up-and-down method was used to test for the paw
Paw
Paw
Statistical analysis
For statistical analysis and graph design, SPSS software Version 23 was employed (Ehningen, Germany). Data distribution was tested using histograms and the Kolmogorov–Smirnov test. The parametric Student’s t-test was applied with LED post hoc analysis. Data are expressed as mean and standard error of the mean and are illustrated as bar graphs. Data were stratified for age groups (2, 6–9, 12–15, ≥18 months) and gender. When no intergroup difference was present between data of male and female mice (which was the case in the sensory tests), then an additional assessment was performed pooling data of male and female α-GAL and WT littermates, respectively, and comparing young (2 months) and old (≥18 months) age groups of both genotypes.
Results
Young and old Fabry ko mice are hypersensitive to tactile stimulation
Male (Figure 1(a)) and female (Figure 1(b)) Fabry ko mice showed mechanical hypersensitivity in the von-Frey test when compared with WT littermates ( Paw withdrawal thresholds to mechanical stimulation. Bar graphs show the results of the von-Frey test in naïve 2, 6–9, 12–15, and ≥18 months old α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) male (a) and female (b) mice. Male and female Fabry ko mice show reduced mechanical withdrawal thresholds when compared with their WT littermates starting at the age of two months and lasting up to ≥18 months of age. In (c) results of male and female naïve 2 and ≥18 months old α-GAL deficient Fabry ko and WT mice are averaged each. Young and old Fabry ko mice show reduced mechanical withdrawal thresholds when compared with their WT littermates. Fabry ko: 2 months (9 male, 17 female), 6–9 months (29 male, 44 female), 12–15 months (22 male, 10 female), ≥18 months (29 male, 55 female). WT: 2 months (6 male, 6 female), 6–9 months (13 male, 8 female), 12–15 months (36 male, 16 female), ≥18 months (25 male, 16 female). F = female; M = male; mo = months; *
Fabry ko have age-dependent heat hyper- and hyposensitivity and constant hyposensitivity to cold
Two months old male (Figure 2(a)) and female (Figure 2(b)) Fabry ko mice had lower heat withdrawal latencies, i.e., increased sensitivity to heat, compared to WT littermates (male: Paw withdrawal latencies to heat stimulation. Bar graphs show the results of the heat test in naïve 2, 6–9, 12–15, and ≥18 months old α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) male (a) and female (b) mice. Two months old male and female Fabry ko mice show shorter withdrawal latencies when compared with their WT littermates. In both genders, heat withdrawal latencies increased with aging and were longer in ≥18 months old Fabry KO mice compared to WT littermates. In (c) results of male and female naïve 2 and ≥18 months old α-GAL deficient Fabry ko and WT mice are averaged each. While young Fabry ko mice show heat hypersensitivity, old Fabry ko mice develop heat hyposensitivity with increased paw withdrawal latencies to heat stimulation when compared with their WT littermates. Fabry ko: 2 months (7 male, 17 female), 6–9 months (31 male, 35 female), 12–15 months (23 male, 22 female), ≥18 months (24 male, 44 female). WT: 2 months (6 male, 6 female), 6–9 months (35 male, 33 female), 12–15 months (34 male, 13 female), ≥18 months (25 male, 20 female). F = female; M = male; mo = months; n.s. = not significant; *
Two months old male (Figure 3(a)) and young and old female (Figure 3(b)) Fabry ko mice were hyposensitive to cold stimulation ( Paw withdrawal latencies to cold stimulation. Bar graphs show the results of the cold test in naïve 2, 6–9, 12–15, and ≥18 months old α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) male (a) and female (b) mice. Young male Fabry ko mice of two months of age had longer paw withdrawal latencies to cold stimulation than WT mice. Female Fabry ko mice (2 months, 12–15 months, ≥18 months) had longer cold withdrawal latencies compared to their WT littermates. In (c) results of male and female naïve 2 and ≥18 months old α-GAL deficient Fabry ko and WT mice are averaged each. Young and old Fabry ko mice show cold hyposensitivity with increased paw withdrawal latencies to cold stimulation when compared with their WT littermates. Fabry ko: 2 months (7 male, 14 female), 6–9 months (31 male, 36 female), 12–15 months (24 male, 20 female), ≥18 months (32 male, 58 female). WT: 2 months (5 male, 6 female), 6–9 months (36 male, 28 female), 12–15 months (32 male, 20 female), ≥18 months (26 male, 21 female). F = female; M = male; mo = months; *
Male Fabry ko mice show impaired gait with aging
Of the determined gait parameters (stride width, stride length on the right and left side, and stride angle), only stride angle showed an intergroup difference (other data not shown). Old male Fabry ko mice had a larger stride angle than young Fabry ko mice and WT littermates ( Gait analysis. Bar graphs show the results of the analysis of stride angle in α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) mice. Old male mice (a) had a larger stride angle when ≥15 months of age compared to young mice and to WT littermates. No intergroup difference was found in female mice (b). (c) Schematically illustrates the assessment of two pairs of mouse paw prints for stride angle A°. Fabry ko: ≤6 months (6 male, 6 female), ≥15 months (3 male, 3 female). WT: ≤6 months (6 male, 6 female), ≥15 months (9 male, 3 female). A° = stride angle; F = female; M = male; mo = months; **
Except for young female mice, Fabry ko mice have a higher body weight than WT littermates
Body weight of male Fabry ko mice was higher compared to WT littermates particularly in older age groups ( Development of weight. Bar graphs show the development of body weight over time in α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) male (A) and female (B) mice. Male Fabry ko mice were heavier than their WT littermates particularly in older age groups (12–15 months: 
Fabry mice are physically equally to less active but lose more weight during a one-week treadmill experiment
In the one-week treadmill experiment, young male (Figure 6(a)) and female (Figure 6(a)) Fabry ko mice showed similar physical performance as their WT littermates. Male ( Physical activity in a one-week treadmill experiment. Bar graphs show the results of the treadmill experiment giving the rotations per day in α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) male (a) and female (b) mice. While 2–15 months old mice did not differ from their WT littermates, old (≥18 months) male and female Fabry ko mice were physically less active than their WT littermates. Fabry ko: 2 months (13 male, 18 female), 6–9 months (45 male, 29 female), 12–15 months (31 male, 18 female), ≥18 months (46 male, 48 female). WT: 2 months (10 male, 10 female), 6–9 months (46 male, 22 female), 12–15 months (36 male, 21 female), ≥18 months (29 male, 11 female). F = female; M = male; mo = months; n.s. = not significant; * Chow intake in a one-week treadmill experiment. Bar graphs show chow intake during the one-week treadmill experiment in α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) male (a) and female (b) mice. Except for 12–15 months old male Fabry ko mice that had a lower chow intake compared to their WT littermates, no difference was found for other age groups and also in female Fabry ko mice compared to WT littermates. Fabry ko: 2 months (13 male, 18 female), 6–9 months (45 male, 29 female), 12–15 months (31 male, 18 female), ≥18 months (46 male, 48 female). WT: 2 months (10 male, 10 female), 6–9 months (46 male, 22 female), 12–15 months (36 male, 21 female), ≥18 months (29 male, 11 female). F = female; M = male; mo = months; *** Weight change in a one-week treadmill experiment. Bar graphs show the weight change during the one-week treadmill experiment in α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) male (a) and female (b) mice. Male Fabry ko mice lost more weight in the treadmill than their WT littermates, while weight loss in female mice was not different between genotypes except for old female Fabry ko mice compared to their WT littermates. Fabry ko: 2 months (13 male, 18 female), 6–9 months (45 male, 29 female), 12–15 months (31 male, 18 female), ≥18 months (46 male, 48 female). WT: 2 months (10 male, 10 female), 6–9 months (46 male, 22 female), 12–15 months (36 male, 21 female), ≥18 months (29 male, 11 female). F = female; M = male; mo = months; *


Fabry ko mice show signs of spontaneous pain behavior
Fabry ko mice showed the following spontaneous behavior: when sitting on a wire mesh and upon stimulation with a von-Frey filament, mice shifted their paws to the inner walls of the covering plexiglass boxes and preferred keeping them on the glass surface (Video 1). Also, mice tended to hold up their paws and toes while seated or while standing on their hind paws during exploratory behavior; the latter leads to backward falls (Video 2).
Fabry ko mice develop orofacial dysmorphism with aging
Similar to patients with FD,
12
Fabry ko mice developed orofacial dysmorphism with aging. Old Fabry ko mice had a prominent snout with an enlarged tongue and elongated teeth with an widened gap between the front teeth when compared with young ko mice and WT littermates (Figure 9).
Orofacial dysmorphisms. Photographs show the snout and teeth of 3 (a, c) and 21 months old male α-GAL deficient (Fabry ko) and wild-type (WT) mice. Fabry ko mice have an elongated snout, enlarged tongue and teeth, and a prominent gap between the front teeth.
Discussion
This is the first study systematically investigating the sensory system, physical activity, metabolic parameters, and morphology of a large cohort of male and female α-GAL-deficient mice as a model for FD from the age of 2 months up to 27 months. Our study is also the first in comparing data to WT littermate mice of reported (here C57Bl/6J) background and using an extensive battery of behavioral tests and phenotypical observation overcoming previous drawbacks of studies with low numbers of experimental animals, focus on one gender, few and early age groups, and data comparisons with non-littermate WT mice. We also provide first data on spontaneous pain behavior of α-GAL-deficient mice (Video 2) and on age-dependent orofacial dysmorphism mimicking one characteristic clinical finding in Fabry patients.
Using the same mouse model, 5 heat hyposensitivity was described in a previous study in 6 and 12 months old α-GAL deficient male mice compared to “control” mice of unreported background and littermate status using the hot plate test. 13 Lakoma et al. 14 provided behavioral data of two and three months old male α-GAL-deficient mice compared to WT mice. In these young mice, the authors found mechanical hypersensitivity in the von-Frey test, heat hypersensitivity in the hot plate test, and cold hyposensitivity using the acetone test and the cold plate test, 14 which matches our data of young (i.e., two months old) mice. Controversially, heat hyposensitivity was described already in 3 and 11 months old α-GAL deficient male mice 5 using the hot plate test; however, here results were compared with non-littermate WT mice of 129S6/SvEvTac origin. 15 In a recent study, the same group investigated a different type of α-GAL-deficient mice 16 from 3 to 17 months of age and compared heat withdrawal latencies in the hot plate test with non-littermate 129S6/SvEvTac mice and without gender differentiation. 17 The authors report increased heat withdrawal latencies in these α-GAL ko mice 16 from the age of 3 months with a further increase at 12 to 17 months. 17
Following our α-GAL deficient mouse cohort up to 27 months of age until the animals died spontaneously, we additionally show that while mechanical hypersensitivity and cold hyposensitivity persist, heat hypersensitivity turns to hyposensitivity with aging. Although not directly comparable, these findings are in line with sensory findings in FD patients. Using quantitative sensory testing, thermal hyposensitivity has been described in several studies18–20 and evoked pain with mechanically hypersensitive palmar, and plantar skin is frequently reported by FD patients. 4 The observed spontaneous behavior of our α-GAL deficient mouse cohort (see Videos 1 and 2) is of particular interest further underlining the sensory hypersensitivity of these mice, even though interpretation can only be made with caution. Physical activity is one of the major pain triggers in FD patients. 4 Interestingly, old mice with α-GAL deficiency were physically less active in the treadmill experiment than their WT littermates (Figure 6), but despite also similar chow intake (Figure 7) showed more severe weight loss (Figure 8). Although no direct conclusions can be drawn from this observation, the reduction in physical activity and increased loss of weight may hint toward a reduction in well-being, e.g. due to an increase in painful sensations during the exercise and might, therefore, also parallel patient behavior.
Mice investigated in this study were originally created by targeted disruption of the
One crucial aspect when comparing different studies on the behavior of α-GAL-deficient mice over time is that the so far published data were obtained in different α-GAL deficient5,16 and non-littermate WT mouse strains (e.g., 129S6/SvEvTac versus C57Bl/6J background). Even when performing the exact same tests, a change in genetic background may lead to diverse results. See, for instance, heat withdrawal latency of 25 s in 12 weeks old WT mice of C57Bl/6J background in Figure 2 of Lakoma et al. 14 resulting in heat hypersensitivity of α-GAL-deficient mice versus 15 s in 12 weeks old WT mice of 129S6/SvEvTac background in Figure 5 of Bangari et al., 17 resulting in apparent heat hyposensitivity of α-GAL-deficient mice, although the results of the α-GAL-deficient mice are the same in both studies with approximately 20 s each. Additionally, the use of non-littermate WT control mice makes data comparison difficult. Different reactions in the same tests are known for different WT mouse strains and substrains,27,28 supporting the importance of the use of littermate WT mice to ensure equal conditions.
It is intriguing that orofacial dysmorphic changes develop in Fabry ko mice similar to those in Fabry patients. 12 The reasons for these morphological changes that mainly reflect tissue enlargement are not known.
Our data have implications for future studies. First, the α-GAL deficient mouse 5 phenotype has similarities with findings in patients with FD; however, disease phenotype in naïve mice is mild. Therefore, new mouse models with an additional increase in Gb3 production 29 and thus faster and higher increase in tissue Gb3 load have been developed meanwhile and might open new avenues in future FD pathophysiology research—for the price of a less physiological development. Second, the α-GAL deficient mouse model displays an age-dependent and differential change in sensory and motor functions. This is particularly important and needs to be considered in future studies. Third, no gender difference is present for sensory tests in young and old α-GAL-deficient mice, thus gene disruption leads to a sensory phenotype that is not altered by female gender.
Conclusions
Our study provides the so far largest and most detailed data set on the longest time period of α-GAL-deficient mice sensory, motor, and metabolic development. We show that mice with α-GAL deficiency develop age-dependent and distinct deficits of the sensory system modeling human FD. This data set will help to differentially design and interpret the results of future studies on the pathophysiology of pain in FD.
Footnotes
Acknowledgement
The authors thank Helga Brünner and Katharina Meder for technical assistance.
Authors contributions
NÜ and CS contributed to the study design, data assessment, and manuscript preparation. LB contributed to the behavioral testing. DH contributed to the data assessment and manuscript preparation. LH contributed to the behavioral testing, data assessment, and manuscript preparation.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: The study was financially supported by research funds of the Interdisciplinary Center for Clinical Research (Interdisziplinäres Zentrum für Klinische Forschung, IZKF) of the University of Würzburg (N.Ü.: N-260). N.Ü. and C.S. are funded by the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme 2013–2017 (“ncRNAPain,” grant agreement number 602133).
