Leadership studies and communication studies increasingly overlap in the
emergence of the post-industrial leadership paradigm. This study calls attention
to how different underlying models of communication in leadership theorizing and
program implementation in organizations may cause otherwise progressive theories
to be falsely rejected before realizing their emancipatory potential. We analyze
a leadership initiative in wildland firefighting, inspired by the German
military philosophy of Auftragstaktik, which recommends communicating
`leader's intent'. We show how talk about communication in the organization and
talk about the theory may diverge. Adapting the language of metadiscourse
theory, we explore alternate communication models to expand the practical
metadiscourse of communication to better align it with the theoretical
metadiscourse of leadership it purports to actualize.
Adams, C.
(2002)
`Practitioner Review: The Assessment of Language Pragmatics'
, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry43(8):
973-87.
2.
Andersen, P.
(1986)
`Consciousness, Cognition, and Communication'
, Western Journal of Speech Communication50(1):
87-101.
3.
Anton, C.
(1999)
`Beyond the Constitutive-Representational Dichotomy: The Phenomenological
Notion of Intentionality'
, Communication Theory9(1):
26-57.
4.
Axley, S.R.
(1984)
`Managerial and Organizational Communication in Terms of the Conduit
Metaphor'
, The Academy of Management Review9(3):
428-37.
5.
Barker, R.
(2002) On the Nature of Leadership.
Lanham, MD: University Press of
America.
6.
Cooren, F.
, &
Taylor, J.R.
(1997)
`Organization as an Effect of Mediation'
, Communication Theory7(3):
219-60.
Craig, R.T.
(1999a)
`Communication Theory as a Field'
, Communication Theory9(2):
119-61.
9.
Craig, R.T.
(1999b)
`Metadiscourse, Theory, and Practice'
, Research on Language and Social Interaction32(1-2):
21-9.
10.
Craig, R.T.
, &
Tracy, K.
(1995)
`Grounded Practical Theory: The Case of Intellectual Discussion'
, Communication Theory5(3):
248-72.
11.
DeGrosky, M.T.
(2005) `A Method for Evaluating the Fireline Leadership
Training', Unpublished master's thesis. Fort Hays State
University, Hays, KS,
USA.
12.
DeGrosky, M.T.
(2007) An Evaluation of the L-380 Fireline Leadership
Training: A Report Prepared for the NWCG Leadership Committee Under Contract to
the USDI Bureau of Land Management.
Wisdom, MT
.
13.
Dugan, J.
(2006)
`Involvement and Leadership: A Descriptive Analysis of Socially Responsible
Leadership'
, Journal of College Student Development47(3):
335-43.
14.
Fairhurst, G.T.
(2007) Discursive Leadership: In Conversation With Leadership
Psychology. Los Angeles, CA:
SAGE .
15.
Fairhurst, G.T.
, &
Sarr, R.A.
(1996) The Art of Framing: Managing the Language of
Leadership . New York:
Jossey-Bass.
16.
(German)
Army Command and Control.
(1998, Oct 15) German Army Regulations 100/100.
Bonn
, Germany:
Army Command and Control
.
17.
Grice, H.P.
(1975) `Logic and Conversation', in
P. Cole
&
J. L. Morgan
(eds) Syntax and Semantics, Vol. 3, pp.
41-58. New York:
Academic Press.
18.
Higgs, M.
(2003)
`How Can We Make Sense of Leadership in the 21st Century?'
, Leadership & Organization Development Journal24(5-6):
273-84.
19.
Hollenshead, E.D.
,
Smith, M.
,
Carroll, F.O.
, &
Keller, P.
(2005) Fire Suppression: Foundational Doctrine.
Custer, SD: United States
Department of Agriculture Forest Service Black Hills National
Forest.
20.
Howard, N.
(2001) Evolution of Commander's Intent in the US
Military . Available at
http://www.c4ads.org/files/Intent_USMilitary_v43.pdf
21.
Incident Response Pocket Guide. A Publication of the National Wildfire
Coordinating Group
(2006) PMS [Public Management System] 461 NFES 1077.
Copies can be ordered from the National Interagency Fire
Center, Boise, Idaho.
22.
Jackson, S.
(1992)
`Review of Intentions in Communication (P. Cohen, M. Morgan, &
M. Pollack, eds)'
, Contemporary Psychology37(8):
818-19.
23.
Katambwe, J.M.
, &
Taylor, J.R.
(2006) `Modes of Organizational Integration', in
F. Cooren
,
J. R. Taylor
, &
E. J. Van Every
(eds) Communication as Organizing: Empirical and Theoretical Approaches
to the Dynamic of Text and Conversation, pp. 55-77.
Mahwah, NJ:
Erlbaum.
24.
Kaufman, H.
(1967) The Forest Ranger: A Study in Administrative
Behavior . Baltimore, MD: The Johns
Hopkins University Press. (Original work published
1960).
25.
Keithly, D.M.
, &
Ferris, S.P.
(1999, Autumn)
`Auftragstaktik, or Directive Control in Joint and Command
Operations'
, Parameters: 118-33. Available at
http://www.carlisle.army.mil/usawc/Parameters/99autumn/keithly.htm
26.
Kotterman, J.
(2006)
`Leadership Versus Management: What's the Difference?'
, The Journal for Quality and Participation29(2):
13-17.
27.
Kouzes, J.
, &
Posner, B.
(2007) The Leadership Challenge, 4th edn.
San Francisco, CA:
Wiley .
28.
Langer, E.J.
(1989) `Minding Matters: The Consequences of
Mindlessness-Mindfulness' , in
L. E. Berkowitz
(ed.) Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 22, pp.
137-73. New York:
Academic Press.
29.
Lannamann, J.W.
(1991)
`Interpersonal Communication Research as Ideological Practice'
, Communication Theory1(3):
179-203.
30.
Levelt, W.J.M.
(1989) Speaking: From Intention to Articulation.
Cambridge, MA: MIT
Press.
31.
Martin, A.
(2006, January)
`Complex Challenges and the New Leadership: What's Driving the New
Leadership?'
, Leading Effectively Newsletter . Available at
http://www.ccl.org/leadership/enewsletter/2006/JAN
32.
Martin, A.
(2007)
`The Future of Leadership: Where Do We Go From Here?'
, Industrial and Commercial Training39(1):
3-8.
33.
Martin, A.
, &
Ernst, C.
(2005)
`Leadership, Learning and Human Resource Management: Exploring Leadership
in Times of Paradox and Complexity'
, Corporate Governance5(1):
82-94.
34.
Martin, A.
,
Criswell, C.
,
Downing, K.
,
Morrow, P.
, &
Willburn, P.
(2007a) `What's Next?: A CCL Research White Paper',
Center for Creative Leadership
. Available at http://www.ccl.org
35.
Martin, A.
,
Criswell, C.
,
Downing, K.
,
Morrow, P.
, &
Willburn, P.
(2007b) `The Changing Nature of Leadership: A CCL Research
White Paper',
Center for Creative Leadership
. Available at http://www.ccl.org
36.
Motley, M.T.
(1986)
`Consciousness and Intentionality in Communication: A Preliminary Model and
Methodological Approaches'
, Western Journal of Speech Communication50(Winter): 3-23.
37.
Muhm, G.
(1993) German Tactics in the Italian Campaign, trans A.
Montemaggi. Rome: Edizioni
Civitas . Available at
http://www.larchivio.org/xoom/gerhardmuhm2.htm
38.
Mumby, D.K.
(1997)
`Modernism, Postmodernism, and Communication Studies: A Rereading of an
Ongoing Debate'
, Communication Theory7(1):
1-28.
39.
National Interagency Fire Center.
(2007) `About NIFC'. Available at
http://www.nifc.gov/about_nifc.htm
40.
National Wildfire Coordinating Group Training Working Team Leadership
Committee (NGCW).
(2003a) Leadership: Developing Leaders in Wildland
Fire. Available at http://www.fireleadership.gov
41.
National Wildfire Coordinating Group Training Working Team Leadership
Committee (NWCG).
(2003b) `Leadership Toolbox: Briefing and Intent', Wildland
Fire Leadership Development Program. Available at
http://www.fireleadership.gov (last updated June
2003).
42.
National Wildfire Coordinating Group (NWCG).
( 2007a) `NWCG Organization'. Available at
http://www.nwcg.gov/nwcg_admin/organize.htm
43.
National Wildfire Coordinating Group Training Working Team Leadership
Committee (NWCG).
(2007b) `Leading in the Wildland Fire Service (NFES
2889)'. Available at
http://www.nwcg.gov/pms/pubs/pubs.htm
44.
National Wildfire Coordinating Group Training Working Team Leadership
Committee (NWCG.)
(2008) `Leadership: Developing Leaders in Wildland
Firefighting', Wildland Fire Leadership Development Program . Available at
http://www.fireleadership.gov (last updated Feb
2008).
45.
Nissen, L.
,
Merrigan, D.
, &
Kraft, K.
(2005)
`Moving Mountains Together: Strategic Community Leadership and Systems
Change'
, Child Welfare84(2):
123-41.
46.
Northouse, P.
(2004) Leadership: Theory and Practice, 5th
edn. Los Angeles, CA:
SAGE.
47.
Oliviero, C.
(2001)
`Auftragstaktik and Disorder in Battle: Learning to "See the Battlefield"
Differently'
, The Army Doctrine and Training Bulletin4(2):
57-9.
48.
Pearce, C.
(2004)
`The Future of Leadership: Combining Vertical and Shared Leadership to
Transform Knowledge Work'
, Academy of Management Executive18(1):
47-57.
49.
Pearce, C.,
&
Conger, J.,
eds (2003) Shared Leadership: Reframing the How and Whys of
Leadership, pp. 47-57. Los
Angeles, CA : SAGE.
50.
Putnam, L.L.
, &
Fairhurst, G.T.
(2001) `Discourse Analysis in Organizations: Issues and
Concerns', in
F. Jablin
&
L. L. Putnam
(eds) The New Handbook of Organizational Communication: Advances in
Theory, Research, and Methods, pp. 78-136.
Los Angeles, CA:
SAGE.
51.
Putnam, L.L.
,
Phillips, N.
, &
Chapman, P.
(1996) `Metaphors of Communication and Organization',
in
S. R. Clegg
,
C. Hardy
, &
W. R. Nord
(eds) Handbook of Organizational Studies, pp.
375-408. London :
SAGE.
52.
Pyne, S.J.
(1994, August 8)
`Flame and Fortune: Why Fighting Fire is Different from Fighting
Wars'
, New Republic:
19-20.
53.
Pyne, S.J.
(2004) Tending Fire: Coping With America's Wildfires.
Washington, DC: Island
Press.
54.
Rost, J.R.
(1993) Leadership for the 21st Century.
New York:
Praeger.
55.
Scott, R.L.
(1977)
`Communication as an Intentional, Social System'
, Human Communication Research3(3):
258-68.
56.
Searle, J.R.
(1995) The Construction of Social Reality.
New York: Free
Press.
57.
Shattuck, L.G.
(2000, March-April)
`Communicating Intent and Imparting Presence'
, Military Review:
66-72.
58.
Singh, M.P.
(2000, Aug.)
A Social Semantics for Agent Communication Languages
. Paper presented at the IJCAI Workshop on Agent Communication
Languages.
59.
Smircich, L.
, &
Morgan, G.
(1982)
`Leadership: The Management of Meaning'
, The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science18(3):
257-73.
60.
Stamp, G.H.
, &
Knapp, M.L.
(1990)
`The Construct of Intent in Interpersonal Communication'
, Quarterly Journal of Speech76(August):
282-99.
61.
Straight, M.
(1996, Spring)
`Commander's Intent: An Aerospace Tool for Command and Control?'
, Airpower Journal:
1-11
62.
Taylor, J.R.
(1993) Rethinking the Theory of Organizational Communication:
How To Read an Organization. New York:
Ablex.
63.
Taylor, J.R.
(2006) `Communication As Complex Organizing', in
G. J. Shepherd
,
J. St. John
, &
T. Striphas
(eds) Communication As . . .: Perspectives on Theory, pp.
132-42. Los Angeles, CA:
SAGE.
64.
Thackaberry, J.A.
(2004)
`Discursive Opening and Closing in Organizational Self Study: Culture as
Trap and Tool in Wildland Firefighting Safety'
, Management Communication Quarterly17(4):
319-59.
65.
Thackaberry, J.A.
(2006) `Blaming the Dead: The Ethics of Accident
Investigation in Wildland Firefighting', in
S. K. May
(ed.) Case Studies in Organizations: Ethical Perspectives and
Practices, pp. 265-85. Los Angeles,
CA: SAGE.
66.
Thayer, L.
(1988) `Leadership/Communication: A Critical Review and a
Modest Proposal', in
G. M. Goldhaber
&
G. A. Barnett
(eds) Handbook of Organizational Communication, pp.
231-62. New York:
Ablex.
67.
Tompkins, P.K.
, &
Cheney, G.
(1985) `Communication and Unobtrusive Control in Contemporary
Organizations', in
R. D. McPhee
&
P. K. Tompkins
(eds) Organizational Communication: Traditional Themes and New
Directions, pp. 179-210. Los
Angeles, CA: SAGE.
68.
Tracy, K.
(2002) Everyday Talk: Building and Reflecting
Identities . New York:
Guilford.
69.
TriData Corporation.
(1998) Wildland Firefighter Safety Awareness Study: Phase III
- Key Findings for Changing the Wildland Firefighting Culture .
Arlington, VA: TriData
Corporation .
70.
Watzlawick, P.
,
Beavin, J.
, &
Jackson, D.
(1967) The Pragmatics of Human Communication.
New York: W. W.
Norton.
71.
Weiner, N.
(1965) Cybernetics, Second Edition: The Control and
Communication in the Animal and the Machine.
Cambridge, MA: MIT
Press.
72.
Widder, W.
(2002, Sept.-Oct.)
`Auftragstaktik and Innere Führung: Trademarks of German
Leadership'
, Military Review:
3-9.
73.
Yoos, G.
(1986) `Pragmatics and Critical Thinking', in
D. Sperber
&
D. Wilson
(eds) Relevance: Communication and Cognition, pp.
1-5. Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
74.
Ziegler, J.A.
(2007)
`The Story Behind an Organizational List: A Genealogy of Wildland
Firefighters' 10 Standard Fire Orders'
, Communication Monographs74(4):
415-42.
