There is growing interest in the role that principals play as school leaders. Exploring how principals build their professional leadership identity is crucial to understanding their influence on school performance. A systematic review was conducted to examine how educational leaders develop their professional identity. Our objectives were: (a) to identify the factors that determine how educational leaders develop their professional identity; (b) to identify shared traits of educational leadership identity; and (c) to describe the implications that the results obtained may have for research and professional practice. A literature search on Web of Science (WOS), SCOPUS and Education Resources Information Center (ERIC) yielded a total of 38 articles published in international journals. Thematic analysis was conducted using the Nvivo software package. Emerging topics include: leadership identity of school principals as the key to educational success; influence of politics and context on the construction of principals’ professional identity; race- and gender-based barriers to the development of leadership identity; and the influence of experience, training and transition on the construction of a professional leadership identity.
AasMVavikM (2015) Group coaching: A new way of constructing leadership identity?School Leadership and Management35(3): 251–265.
2.
AkkermanSFMeijerPC (2011) A dialogical approach to conceptualizing teacher identity. Teaching and Teacher Education27(2): 308–319.
3.
ArmstrongDMitchellC (2017) Shifting identities: Negotiating intersections of race and gender in Canadian administrative contexts. Educational Management Administration and Leadership45(5): 825–841.
4.
ArarKShapiraT (2016) Hijab and principalship: The interplay between belief systems, educational management and gender among Arab Muslim women in Israel. Gender and Education28(7): 851–866.
5.
BahousRBusherHNabhaniM (2016) Teachers’ views of professional learning and collaboration in four urban Lebanese primary schools. Teacher Development20(2): 197–212.
BaumeisterRF (1986) Identity: Cultural Change and the Struggle for Self. New York: Oxford University Press.
8.
BebeauMJMonsonVE (2008) Guided by theory, grounded in evidence: A way forward for professional ethics education. In: NucciLPNarvaezD (eds) Handbook of Moral and Character Education. New York: Routledge, pp. 557–582.
9.
Boris-SchacterSMerrifieldS (2000) Why ‘particularly good’ principals don’t quit. Journal of School Leadership10(1): 84–98.
10.
BothaN (2006) Leadership in school-based management: A case study in selected schools. South African Journal of Education26(3): 341–353.
11.
BredesonPV (1993) Letting go of outlived professional identities: A study of role transition and role strain for principals in restructured schools. Educational Administration Quarterly29(1): 34–68.
12.
BrezichaKBergmarkUMitraDL (2015) One size does not fit all: Differentiating leadership to support teachers in school reform. Educational Administration Quarterly51(1): 96–132.
13.
Browne-FerrignoT (2003) Becoming a principal: Role conception, initial socialization, role-identity transformation, purposeful engagement. Educational Administration Quarterly39(4): 468–503.
14.
BurkePJStetsJE (2009) Identity Theory. New York: Oxford University Press.
15.
BushT (2009) Leadership development and school improvement: Contemporary issues in leadership development. Educational Review61(4): 375–389.
16.
BushT (2018) Preparation and induction for school principals: global perspectives. Management in Education32(2): 66–71.
17.
BushT (2019) Distinguishing between educational leadership and management: Compatible or incompatible constructs?Educational Management Administration & Leadership47(4): 501–503.
18.
CardnoCYoungsH (2013) Leadership development for experienced new zealand principals: perceptions of effectiveness. Educational Management Administration and Leadership41(3): 256–271.
19.
CarpenterBWBukoskiBEBerryMMitchellAM (2015) Examining the social justice identity of assistant principals in persistently low- achieving schools. Urban Education52(3): 287–315.
20.
CastilloFAHallingerP (2018) Systematic review of research on educational leadership and management in Latin America, 1991–2017. Educational Management Administration & Leadership46(2): 207–225.
21.
CEPPE (2013) Learning standards, teaching standards and standards for school principals: a comparative study. OECD Education Working Papers 99. Paris: OECD Publishing.
22.
ColemanM (2000) The female secondary headteacher in England and Wales: Leadership and management styles. Educational Research42(1): 13–27.
23.
ConnollyMMiltonEDaviesAJBarranceR (2018) Turning heads: The impact of political reform on the professional role, identity and recruitment of head teachers in Wales. British Educational Research Journal44(4): 608–625.
24.
CowieMCrawfordM (2008) ‘Being’ a new principal in Scotland. Journal of Educational Administration46(6): 676–689
25.
CrowGDayCMøllerJ (2017) Framing research on school principals’ identities. International Journal of Leadership in Education20(3): 265–277
26.
Cruz C DomingoJLucenaC (2019) School principals and leadership identity: A thematic exploration of the literature. Educational Research61(3): 1–18.
27.
DayCElliotBKingtonA (2005) Reform standards and teacher identity: Challenges of sustaining commitment. Teaching and Teacher Education21(5): 563–577
28.
DayCSammonsPLeithwoodKHopkinsDGuQBrownEAhtaridouE (2011) Successful School Leadership: Linking With Learning and Achievement. Maidenhead: Open University Press/McGraw Hill.
29.
De VriesHBekkersVTummersL (2016) Innovation in the public sector: A systematic review and future research agenda. Public Administration94(1): 146–166.
30.
DicksonMWCastañoNMagomaevaADen HartogDN (2012)Conceptualizing leadership across cultures. Journal of World Business47(4): 483–492.
31.
DubarCL (2000) La Crise des Identités L’interprétation D’une Mutation[The Identity Crisis The Interpretation of a Mutation]. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
32.
DuchauffourH (2013) Transition identitaire des directeurs d’école primaire Trouble et crise de recrutement conséquences d’une formation défaillante?[Transition of identity of primary school principals Trouble and recruitment crisis as a result of inadequate training?]Recherche et Formation3(74): 87–100.
33.
GaldamesSMontecinosCCamposFAhumadaLLeivaMV (2018) Novice principals in Chile mobilizing change for the first time: Challenges and opportunities associated with a school’s readiness for change. Educational Management Administration and Leadership46(2): 318–338.
34.
GoughD (2007) Weight of evidence: A framework for the appraisal of the quality and relevance of evidence. Research Papers in Education22(2): 213–228.
35.
GreerJLSearbyLJThomaSJ (2014) Arrested development? Comparing educational leadership students with national norms on moral reasoning. Educational Administration Quarterly51(4): 511–542.
36.
GumusSBellibasMSEsenMGumusE (2018) A systematic review of studies on leadership models in educational research from 1980 to 2014. Educational Management Administration & Leadership46(1): 25–48.
37.
GuskeyTYoonKS (2009) What works in professional development?Phi Delta Kappan90(7): 495–500.
38.
HallingerP (2013) A conceptual framework for reviews of research in educational leadership and management. Journal of Educational Administration51(2): 126–149
39.
HallingerP (2014) Reviewing reviews of research in educational leadership: An empirical analysis. Educational Administration Quarterly50(4): 539–576
40.
HallingerP (2018) Surfacing a hidden literature: A systematic review of research on educational leadership and management in Africa. Educational Management Administration & Leadership46(3): 362–384.
41.
HallingerPBryantD (2013) Mapping the terrain of educational leadership and management in East Asia. Journal of Educational Administration51(5): 618–637.
42.
HallingerPHeckRH (2010) Collaborative leadership and school improvement: Understanding the impact on school capacity and student learning. School Leadership and Management30(2): 95–110.
HenryFReesTTatorC (2010) The Colour of Democracy: Racism in Canadian Society. Toronto: Nelson Education.
45.
HernándezFMurakamiE (2016) Counter stories about leadership: A Latina school principal’s experience from a less documented view in an urban school context. Education Sciences6(1): 6.
46.
HertzbergSRudnerL (1999) Quality of researchers’ searches of the ERIC database. Education Policy Analysis Archives7: 25.
47.
HurshD (2005) The growth of high-stakes testing in the USA: Accountability, markets and the decline in educational equality. British Educational Research Journal31(5): 605–622.
48.
IbarraH (1999) Provisional selves: Experimenting with image and identity in professional adaptation. Administrative Science Quarterly44(4): 764–791.
49.
JohnsonL (2017) The lives and identities of UK Black and South Asian head teachers: Metaphors of leadership. Educational Management Administration and Leadership45(5): 842–862.
50.
JonesD (2017) Constructing identities: Female head teachers’ perceptions and experiences in the primary sector. Educational Management Administration and Leadershi45(6): 907–928.
51.
LeithwoodKJantziD (2000) Principal and teacher leadership effects: A replication. School Leadership & Management20(4): 415–434.
52.
LeithwoodKJantziD (2008) Linking leadership to student learning: The contributions of leader efficacy. Educational Administration Quarterly44(4): 496–528.
53.
LumbyJEnglishF (2009) From simplicism to complexity in leadership identity and preparation: Exploring the lineage and dark secrets. International Journal of Leadership in Education12(2): 95–114.
54.
LyaKHFarajHWubbelsT (2002) Burn-out among Israeli Arab school principals as a function of professional identity and interpersonal relationships with teachers. InternationalJournal of Leadership in Education5(2): 149–162.
55.
MaguireMBraunA (2019) Headship as policy narration: Generating metaphors of leading in the English primary school. Journal of Educational Administration and History51(2): 103–116.
56.
Méndez-MorseSMurakamiETByrne-JiménezMHernandezF (2015) Mujeres in the principal’s office: Latina school leaders. Journal of Latinos and Education14(3): 171–187.
57.
MifsudD (2015) Circulating power and in/visibility: Layers of educational leadership. Journal of Workplace Learning27(1): 51–67.
58.
MillerPPotterIBennettK, et al. (2015) Crossing the border: Reconstructing and re-aligning teacher and principal identities through a study tour. Journal of Adult and Continuing Education21(1): 31–47.
59.
MøllerJ (2012) The construction of a public face as a school principal. International Journal of Educational Management26: 452–460.
60.
MontecinosCBushTAravenaF (2018) Moving the school forward: Problems reported by novice and experienced principals during a succession process in Chile. International Journal of Educational Development62: 201–208.
61.
MpungoseJ (2010) Constructing principals’ professional identities through life stories: An exploration. South African Journal of Education30: 527–537.
62.
MuijsDHarrisA (2006) Teacher led school improvement: Teacher leadership in the UK. Teaching and Teacher Education22: 961–972.
63.
MurakamiETTornsenM (2017) Female secondary school principals: Equity in the development of professional identities. Educational Management Administration and Leadership45(5): 806–824.
64.
NickensRWashingtonC (2016) Authenticity and the female African American school leader. In: WatsonTNNormoreATH (eds) Racially and Ethnically Diverse Women Leading Education: A Worldview. Advances in Educational Administration Vol. 25. Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing, pp. 235–254.
65.
NotmanR (2017) Professional identity adaptation and the self: Cases of New Zealand school principals during a time of change. Educational Management Administration and Leadership45(5): 759–773.
66.
OECD (2013) Leadership for 21st Century Learning: Educational Research and Innovation. OECD Publishing.
67.
OECD (2014) TALIS 2013 Results: An International Perspective on Teaching and Learning. OECD Publishing.
68.
OrrMTBergBShoreRMeierE (2008) Putting the pPieces tTogether. Education and Urban Society40(6): 670–693.
69.
PayneECSmithMJ (2018) Refusing relevance: School administrator resistance to offering professional development addressing LGBTQ issues in schools. Educational Administration Quarterly54(2): 183–215.
70.
PelletierKL (2010) Leader toxicity: An empirical investigation of toxic behavior and rhetoric. Leadership6(4): 373–389.
71.
PetticrewMRobertsH (2006) Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences. Oxford: Blackwell.
72.
Pont B NuscheDMoormanH (2008) Improving School Leadership: Volume 1: Policy and Practice. Chile: OECD Publishing.
73.
RaynerSM (2018) Leaders and leadership in a climate of uncertainty: A case study of structural change in England. Educational Management Administration and Leadership46(5): 749–763.
74.
ReayDBallS (2000) Essentials of female management: Women’s ways of working in the educational market. Educational Management and Administration28(2): 145–159.
75.
RhodesCBrundrettM (2006) The identification development succession and retention of leadership talent in contextually different primary schools: A case study located within the English West Midlands. School Leadership and Management26(3): 269–287.
76.
RhodesCBrundrettMNevillA (2009) Just the ticket? The national professional qualification and the transition to headship in the east midlands of England. Educational Review61(4): 449–468.
RicoeurP (1996) Self as other. Siglo XXI: Madrid España.
79.
RigbyJG (2015) Principals’ sensemaking and enactment of teacher evaluation. Journal of Educational Administration53(3): 374–392.
80.
RitaccoMBolívarA (2018) School principals in Spain: An unstable identity. International Journal of Educational Leadership and Managment6(1): 18–39.
81.
RiverosAVerretCWeiW (2016) The translation of leadership standards into leadership practices: A qualitative analysis of the adoption of the Ontario Leadership Framework in urban schools. Journal of Educational Administration54(5): 593–608.
82.
RobertsonS (2017) Transformation of professional identity in an experienced primary school principal: A New Zealand case study. Educational Management Administration and Leadership45(5): 774–789.
83.
RuschEAMarshallC (2006) Gender filters and leadership: Plotting a course to equity. International Journal of Leadership in Education9(3): 229–250.
84.
SackneyLWalkerK (2006) Canadian perspectives on beginning principals: Their role in building capacity for learning communities. Journal of Educational Administration44(4): 341–358.
85.
SarthouNF (2016) Key points of discussion in scientific research evaluation: Peer review, bibliometrics and relevance. Revista De Estudios Sociales58: 76–86.
86.
ScheinVE (2001) A global look at psychological barriers to women’s progress in management. Journal of Social Issues57(4): 675–688.
87.
SchleicherA (2012) Preparing Teachers and Developing School Leaders for the 21st Century: Lessons From Around the World. Paris: OECD.
88.
SchutzPAHongJFrancisDC (eds) (2018) Research on Teacher Identity: Mapping Challenges and Innovations. Springer.
89.
ScribnerSCrowG (2012) Employing professional identities: Case study of a high school principal in a reform setting. Leadership and Policy in Schools11(3): 243–274.
90.
ScribnerSMPBradley-LevineJ (2010) The meaning(s) of teacher leadership in an urban high school reform. Educational Administration Quarterly46: 491–522.
91.
SimonSDoleSFarragherY (2019) Custom-designed and safe-space coaching: Australian beginning principals supported by experienced peers form pipeline of confident future leaders. School Leadership and Management39(2): 145–174.
92.
SinhaSHanuscinDL (2017) Development of teacher leadership identity: A multiple case study. Teaching and Teacher Education63: 356–371.
93.
SlayHSSmithDA (2011) Professional identity construction: Using narrative to understand the negotiation of professional and stigmatized cultural identities. Human Relations61(1): 85–107.
94.
SoiniTPietarinenJPyhältöK (2016) Leading a school through change – principals’ hands-on leadership strategies in school reform. School Leadership and Management36(4): 452–469.
95.
SpiesJHeystekJ (2015) Principals’ educational practices in the field of rural villages. Tydskrif vir Geesteswetenskappe55(3): 437–451.
96.
StamopoulosE (2012) Reframing early childhood leadership. Australasian Journal of Early Childhood37(2): 42.
97.
St-PierreM (2005) Decisional partnerships in education and their effects on harmonizing the professional identity of school principals. Education et Francophonie33(1): 111–132.
98.
SugrueC (2015) Unmasking School Leadership: A Longitudinal Life History of School Leaders. Dordrecht: Springer.
99.
ThoitsPVirshupL (1997) Me’s and we’s: Forms and functions of social identities. In: AshmoreRJussimL (eds) Self and Identity: Fundamental Issues. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 106–133.
100.
ThomsonP (2009) School Leadership: Heads on the Block?London: Routledge.
101.
ThoonenEEJSleegersPJCOortFJPeetsmaTTD (2012) Building school-wide capacity for improvement: The role of leadership, school organizational conditions, and teacher factors. School Effectiveness and School Improvement23(4): 441–460.
102.
ToureJDorseyDT (2018) Stereotypes images and inclination to discriminatory action: The white racial frame in the practice of school leadership. Teachers College Record120(2): 37–49.
103.
TredeFMacklinRBridgesD (2012) Professional identity development: A review of the higher education literature. Studies in Higher Education37: 365–384.
UrickABowersAJ (2014) What are the different types of principals across the United States? A latent class analysis of principal perception of leadership. Educational Administration Quarterly50(1): 96–134.
106.
VoorbergWHBekkersVJTummersLG (2015) A systematic review of co-creation and co-production: Embarking on the social innovation journey. Public Management Review17(9): 1333–1357.
107.
WallaceM (1996) A crisis of identity: School merger and cultural transition. British Educational Research Journal22(4): 459–473.
108.
WattsR (1998) From lady teacher to professional: A case study of some of the first headteachers of girls’ secondary schools in England. Educational Management and Administration26(4): 339–351
109.
WengerE (1998) Communities of Practice: Learning Meaning and Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
