This paper reviews systematically literature on school leadership in the context of Indonesian education from 2004 to 2019. Its purpose is to investigate major issues which exist in the school leadership practices in Indonesia and propose some sustainable solutions so that educational policymakers, stakeholders and scholars can improve their awareness and knowledge of school leadership. Eight core international EDLM (educational leadership and management) journals were used as the source of the literature. Additionally, a high-quality journal with the indexation of Scopus and Social Sciences Citation Index, Asia Pacific Journal of Education (APJE), was included. The literature search yielded 16 articles that were reviewed. This study reports several crucial issues that need to have serious attention paid to them, including a lack of capacity to lead and manage schools, insufficiency of published studies, and the inappropriateness of principal selection processes. The suggested solutions for these problems consist of developing principal training centres in all the provinces of Indonesia, conducting more collaboration with overseas scholars, and improving principal selection procedures. Contributions for theory, practices and further study are provided.
AndrewsR (2005) The place of systematic reviews in education research. Education53(4): 399–416.
2.
BandurA (2012) School-based management developments: challenges and impacts. Journal of Educational Administration50(6): 845–873.
3.
BandurA (2018) Stakeholders’ responses to school-based management in Indonesia. International Journal of Educational Management32(6): 1082–1098.
4.
BangayC (2005) Private education: relevant or redundant? private education, decentralisation and national provision in Indonesia. Compare35(2): 167–179.
5.
BushT (2007) Educational leadership and management: theory, policy, and practice. South African Journal of Education27(3): 391–406.
6.
BushT (2014) School leadership in Europe: growing the field. Educational Management Administration and Leadership42(4 S): 3–4.
7.
BushT (2016) Preparing new principals: professional and organisational socialisation. Educational Management Administration and Leadership44(1): 3–5.
8.
BushT (2018) Preparation and induction for school principals: global perspectives. Management in Education32(2): 66–71.
9.
BushTGloverD (2014) School leadership models: what do we know?School Leadership and Management34(5): 553–571.
10.
BushTGloverD (2016) School leadership and management in South Africa: findings from a systematic literature review. International Journal of Educational Management30(2): 211–231.
11.
BushTHamidSANgAKaparouM (2018) School leadership theories and the Malaysia education blueprint: findings from a systematic literature review. International Journal of Educational Management32(7): 1245–1265.
12.
Daldrup-LinkHE (2018) Writing a review article - are you making these mistakes?Nanotheranostics2(2): 197–200.
13.
DamanikEAldridgeJ (2017) Transformational leadership and its impact on school climate and teachers’ self-efficacy in Indonesian high schools. Journal of School Leadership27(2): 269–296.
14.
DinhamSAndersonMCaldwellBWeldonP (2011) Breakthroughs in school leadership development in Australia. School Leadership and Management31(2): 139–154.
15.
Dixon-WoodsMCaversDAgarwalS, et al. (2006) Conducting a critical interpretive synthesis of the literature on access to healthcare by vulnerable groups. BMC Medical Research Methodology6(35): 1–13.
16.
DrysdaleLGurrD (2011) Theory and practice of successful school leadership in Australia. School Leadership and Management31(4): 355–368.
17.
FlessaJBramwellDFernandezMWeinsteinJ (2017) School leadership in Latin America 2000–2016. Educational Management Administration and Leadership46(2): 182–206.
18.
Ganon-ShilonSSchechterC (2017) Making sense of school leaders’ sense-making. Educational Management Administration and Leadership45(4): 682–698.
19.
GumusSBellibasMSEsenMGumusE (2018) A systematic review of studies on leadership models in educational research from 1980 to 2014. Educational Management Administration and Leadership46(1): 25–48.
20.
GumusSBellibasMSGumusEHallingerP (2020) Science mapping research on educational leadership and management in Turkey: a bibliometric review of international publications. School Leadership & Management40(1): 23–44.
21.
GurmuTG (2019) Primary school principals in Ethiopia: selection and preparation. Educational Management Administration and Leadership48: 651–681.
22.
HallingerP (2013) A conceptual framework for systematic reviews of research in educational leadership and management. Journal of Educational Administration51(2): 126–149.
23.
HallingerPBryantDA (2013) Accelerating knowledge production on educational leadership and management in East Asia: a strategic analysis. School Leadership and Management33(3): 202–223.
24.
HallingerPBryantDA (2013) Review of research publications on educational leadership and management in Asia: a comparative analysis of three regions. Oxford Review of Education39(3): 307–328.
25.
HallingerPBryantDA (2016) Exploring features of highly productive research contexts in Asia: a comparison of knowledge production in educational leadership in Israel and Hong Kong. Asia Pacific Journal of Education36(1): 165–184.
26.
HallingerPChenJ (2015) Review of research on educational leadership and management in Asia: a comparative analysis of research topics and methods, 1995–2012. Educational Management Administration and Leadership43(1): 5–27.
27.
HallingerPWalkerA (2017) Leading learning in Asia – emerging empirical insights from five societies. Journal of Educational Administration55(2): 130–146.
28.
HallingerPHosseingholizadehR (2019) Exploring instructional leadership in Iran: a mixed methods study of high- and low-performing principals. Educational Management Administration and Leadership48: 595–616.
29.
HallingerPLeeTHTSzetoE (2013) Review of research on educational leadership and management in Hong Kong, 1995-2012: topographical analysis of an emergent knowledge base. Leadership and Policy in Schools12(3): 256–281.
30.
HallingerPWalkerATrungGT (2015) Making sense of images of fact and fiction: a critical review of the knowledge base for school leadership in Vietnam. Journal of Educational Administration53(4): 445–466.
31.
HaririHMonypennyRPrideauxM (2012) Principalship in an Indonesian school context: can principal decision-making styles significantly predict teacher job satisfaction?School Leadership and Management32(5): 453–471.
32.
HaririHMonypennyRPrideauxM (2014) Leadership styles and decision-making styles in an Indonesian school context. School Leadership and Management34(3): 284–298.
33.
HaririHMonypennyRPrideauxM (2016) Teacher-perceived principal leadership styles, decisionmaking styles and job satisfaction: how congruent are data from Indonesia with the anglophile and western literature?School Leadership and Management36(1): 41–62.
34.
HarrisAJonesMAdamsDCheahK (2019) Instructional leadership in Malaysia: a review of the contemporary literature. School Leadership & Management39(1): 76–95.
35.
HarsoyoYAstutiCWRRahayuCWE (2019) Competency and values of local wisdom of high school principals. Cakrawala Pendidikan38(3): 565–577.
36.
Hendarman (2015) Revolusi kinerja kepala sekolah [Revolution of school principal performance]. Jakarta, Indonesia: Indeks.
37.
HeywardMOCannonRASarjono (2011) Implementing school-based management in Indonesia: impact and lessons learned. Journal of Development Effectiveness3(3): 371–388.
38.
HsiaoHCLeeMCTuYL (2013) The effects of reform in principal selection on leadership behavior of general and vocational high school principals in Taiwan. Educational Administration Quarterly49(3): 421–450.
39.
HuberSGHiltmannM (2010) The recruitment and selection of school leaders – first findings of an international comparison. In: HuberSG (ed) School Leadership – International Perspectives. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 303–330.
JamesCFitzgeraldSFellowsTGoodallJBatlleICJonesJ (2019) Primary school headteacher recruitment and selection in England: the processes and the problematic aspects. School Leadership and Management39(5): 478–495.
42.
JawasU (2017) The influence of socio-cultural factors on leadership practices for instructional improvement in Indonesian schools. School Leadership and Management37(5): 500–519.
43.
KristiansenSPratikno (2006) Decentralising education in Indonesia. International Journal of Educational Development26(5): 513–531.
44.
KulophasDHallingerP (2019) Leading when the mouth and heart are in unison: a case study of authentic school leadership in Thailand. International Journal of Leadership in Education24(2): 145–156.
45.
LeeJCKPangNSK (2011) Educational leadership in China: contexts and issues. Frontiers of Education in China6(3): 331–341.
46.
LeeMHallingerP (2012) National contexts influencing principals’ time use and allocation: economic development, societal culture, and educational system. School Effectiveness and School Improvement23(4): 461–482.
47.
LeithwoodKJantziD (2005) A review of transformational school leadership research 1996–2005. Leadership and Policy in Schools4(3): 177–199.
48.
LeithwoodKHarrisAHopkinsD (2019) Seven strong claims about successful school leadership revisited. School Leadership and Management40(4): 1–18.
49.
Lumban GaolNT (2017) Teori dan implementasi gaya kepemimpinan kepala sekolah [Theory and implementation of school principal leadership styles]. Kelola: Jurnal Manajemen Pendidikan4(2): 213–219.
50.
MulyaniHMeirawanDRahmadaniA (2020) Increasing school effectiveness through principals’ leadership and teachers’ teaching performance, is it possible?Cakrawala Pendidikan39(2): 279–292.
51.
NgDFSNguyenDTWongBKSChoyWKW (2015) A review of Singapore principals’ leadership qualities, styles, and roles. Journal of Educational Administration53(4): 512–533.
52.
NguyễnHTHallingerPChenCW (2018) Assessing and strengthening patterns of instructional leadership among primary school principals in Vietnam. International Journal of Educational Management32(3): 396–415.
53.
OanceaAPringR (2008) The importance of being thorough: on systematic accumulations of “what works” in education research. Journal of Philosophy of Education42(S1): 15–39.
54.
OdhiamboGHiiA (2012) Key stakeholders’ perceptions of effective school leadership. Educational Management Administration and Leadership40(2): 232–247.
55.
OplatkaIArarK (2017) The research on educational leadership and management in the Arab world since the 1990s: a systematic review. Review of Education5(3): 267–307.
56.
PanHWChenP (2011) Challenges and research agenda of school leadership in Taiwan. School Leadership and Management31(4): 339–353.
57.
PanHWNyeuFChenJS (2015) Principal instructional leadership in Taiwan: lessons from two decades of research. Journal of Educational Administration53(4): 492–511.
58.
ParkerLRaihaniR (2011) Democratizing Indonesia through education? Community participation in Islamic schooling. Educational Management Administration and Leadership39(6): 712–732.
59.
PeredaPLucchesiAMendesKBresolinA (2019) Evaluating the impact of the selection process of principal in Brazilian public schools. Nova Economia29(2): 591–621.
PontBNuscheDMoormanH (2008) Improving school leadership, vol. 1 policy and practice. Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.
62.
Raihani (2008) An Indonesian model of successful school leadership. Journal of Educational Administration46(4): 481–496.
63.
RaihaniRGurrD (2006) Value-driven school leadership: an Indonesian perspective. Leading & Managing12(1): 121–134.
64.
RobinsonPLoweJ (2015) Literature reviews vs systematic reviews. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health39(2): 103.
65.
RomanowskiMHSadiqHAbu-TinehAMNdoyeAAqlM (2019) Principal selection for Qatar’s government schools: policy makers’, principals’ and teachers’ perspectives. Educational Management Administration and Leadership48: 893–915.
66.
RosseJLevinR (2003) The Jossey-Bass Academic Administrator’s Guide to Hiring. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
67.
ShengnanLHallingerP (2020) Unpacking the effects of culture on school leadership and teacher learning in China. Educational Management Administration and Leadership49: 214–233.
68.
ShulhanM (2018) Leadership style in the madrasah in Tulungagung: how principals enhance teachers’ performance. International Journal of Educational Management32(4): 641–651.
69.
SofoFFitzgeraldRJawasU (2012) Instructional leadership in Indonesian school reform: overcoming the problems to move forward. School Leadership and Management32(5): 503–522.
70.
SomantriC (2018) Decentralization and effective educational leadership: expectation versus reality. Indonesian Research Journal in Education2(2): 19–36.
71.
SomantriC (2020) Kepemimpinan pendidikan anak usia dini di Indonesia: Kajian literatur [Early childhood educational leadership in Indonesia: a literature review]. In: HasbiM (ed) Bunga rampai pendidikan anak usia dini [A potpourri of early childhood education]. Jakarta, Indonesia: Ministry of Education and Culture, pp. 163–180.
72.
SumintonoBSheyoputriEYAJiangNMisbachIFJumintono (2015) Becoming a principal in Indonesia: possibility, pitfalls and potential. Asia Pacific Journal of Education35(3): 342–352.
73.
SumintonoBHaririHNugrohoPJIzzatiUASriyantoJ (2019) The role of districts in supporting school leaders’ instructional leadership: a view and experience from a developing country. Journal of Educational Administration57(5): 591–600.
74.
SumintonoBHidayatRPatrasYESriyantoJIzzatiUA (2019) Leading and managing schools in Indonesia: historical, political and socio-cultural forces. In: HaironSGohPJW (eds) Perspectives on School Leadership in Asia Pacific Contexts. Singapore: Springer, pp. 31–45.
75.
TianMHuberSG (2019) Mapping the international knowledge base of educational leadership, administration and management: a topographical perspective. Compare51: 4–23.
76.
TimorT (2017) Do teachers need to be leaders? perceptions of educational leadership and management in the Israeli secondary educational system. School Leadership and Management37(1–2): 94–119.
77.
UhbiyatiN (2015) A competency-based model of the human resource development management of ustadz at salaf boarding school. International Journal of Educational Management29(5): 695–709.
78.
WalkerAHallingerP (2015) A synthesis of reviews of research on principal leadership in East Asia. Journal of Educational Administration53(4): 554–570.
79.
WalkerAHuRQianH (2012) Principal leadership in China: an initial review. School Effectiveness and School Improvement23(4): 369–399.
80.
WiyonoBB (2018) The effect of self-evaluation on the principals’ transformational leadership, teachers’ work motivation, teamwork effectiveness, and school improvement. International Journal of Leadership in Education21(6): 705–725.
81.
YasinBMustafaF (2020) The correlation between school principal competence and teachers’ social behaviours. Indonesian Research Journal in Education4(1): 151–170.
82.
YeighTLynchDTurnerDProvostSCSmithRWillisRL (2018) School leadership and school improvement: an examination of school readiness factors. School Leadership and Management39(5): 434–456.
