The widespread view that the refugee crisis has sparked unprecedented levels of European Union politicisation has rarely been backed by systematic empirical evidence. We investigate this claim using a novel dataset of several thousand user comments posted below articles of German regional media outlets on Facebook. Despite considerable European Union authority in the policy area, extensive media coverage of the crisis and the rise of a populist party in Germany, our results suggest that the politicisation of Europe remains low among social media users, especially when compared to national and subnational levels of governance. When talking about Europe, users hardly refer to European Union institutions or policies. Instead, other member states and notions of the geographic or cultural space dominate the debate.
ArltDWollingJ (2017)
Die Flüchtlingsdebatte in den Medien aus der Perspektive der Bevölkerung. Media Perspektiven6: 325–337.
2.
ArzheimerK (2015)
The AfD: Finally a successful right-wing populist Eurosceptic party for Germany?West European Politics38(3): 535–556.
3.
BaglioniSHurrelmannA (2016)
The Eurozone crisis and citizen engagement in EU affairs.West European Politics39(1): 104–124.
4.
BarisioneMCeronA (2017) A Digital Movement of Opinion? Contesting Austerity Through Social Media.
London:
Palgrave.
5.
BayerischerRundfunk (2016) Informationen fürs Leben: BR-Studie zum Vertrauen in die Medien.
München:
Bayerischer Rundfunk.
6.
BlankG andLutzC (2017)
Representativeness of social media in Great Britain: Investigating Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, Pinterest.American Behavioral Scientist61(7): 741–756.
7.
BoomgaardenHGVliegenthartR (2009)
How news content influences anti-immigration attitudes: Germany, 1993–2005.European Journal of Political Research48(4): 516–542.
8.
BoomgaardenHGSchuckARTElenbaasMet al. (2011).
Mapping EU attitudes: Conceptual and empirical dimensions of Euroscepticism and EU support.European Union Politics12(2): 241–266.
9.
BossettaMSegestenDTrenzH-J (2017) Engaging with European politics through Twitter and Facebook: Participation beyond the national? In: Mauro B and Asimina M (eds) Social Media and European Politics. London: Palgrave, pp.53–76.
10.
BörzelTA (2016)
From EU governance of crisis to crisis of EU governance: Regulatory failure, redistributive conflict and Eurosceptic publics.JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies54: 8–31.
11.
BörzelTARisseT (2018)
From the euro to the Schengen crises: European integration theories, politicization, and identity politics.Journal of European Public Policy25(1): 83–108.
Bund Deutscher Zeitungsverleger (2018) Die deutschen Zeitungen in Zahlen und Daten 2018.
Berlin:
Bund deutscher Zeitungsverleger.
14.
De WildeP (2012)
Politicisation of the EU budget: Conflict and the constraining dissensus.West European Politics35(5): 1075–1094.
15.
De WildeP (2014)
The operating logics of national parliaments and mass media in the politicisation of Europe.The Journal of Legislative Studies20(1): 46–61.
16.
De WildePZürnM (2012)
Can the politicization of European integration be reversed?JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies50(1): 137–153.
17.
De WildePLeupoldASchmidtkeH (2016)
Introduction: The differentiated politicisation of European governance.West European Politics39(1): 3–22.
18.
De WildePMichailidouATrenzH-J (2013) Contesting Europe.
Colchester:
ECPR Press.
19.
GrandeEHutterS (2016)
Beyond authority transfer: Explaining the politicisation of Europe.West European Politics39(1): 23–43.
20.
HabermasJ (2004) Der gespaltene Westen.
Frankfurt a.M.:
Suhrkamp.
21.
HattonTJ (2017)
Public opinion on immigration in Europe: Preference versus salience. IZA Discussion Paper Series10838: 1–35.
22.
HoeligS (2016)
Social participation in online news usage in Europe and its underlying causes: Individual versus structural factors.European Journal of Communication31(4): 393–410.
23.
HoogheL andMarksG (2018)
Cleavage theory meets Europe’s crises: Lipset, Rokkan, and the transnational cleavage.Journal of European Public Policy25(1): 109–135.
24.
HoogheLMarksG (2009)
A postfunctionalist theory of European integration: From permissive consensus to constraining dissensus.British Journal of Political Science39(1): 1–23.
25.
HöglingerD (2016)
The politicisation of European integration in domestic election campaigns.West European Politics39(1): 44–63.
26.
HurrelmannAGoraAWagnerA (2015)
The politicization of European integration: More than an elite affair?Political Studies63(1): 43–59.
27.
Institut für empirische Medienforschung (2015) Jahr 2015 - TV-Monitoring, Trendanalysen, Senderprofile, Sendeplatzprofile, Programminnovationen. Available at: www.ifem.de/infomonitor (accessed 22 August 2017).
28.
KalogeropoulosANegredoSPiconeIet al. (2017)
Who shares and comments on news? A cross-national comparative analysis of online and social media participation.Social Media + Society3(4): 1–12.
29.
KaunertCLeonardS (2012)
The European Union Asylum Policy after the Treaty of Lisbon and the Stockholm programme: Towards supranational governance in a common area of protection?Refugee Survey Quarterly31(4): 1–20.
30.
KoopmansRStathamP (2010) The Making of a European Public Sphere. Media Discourse and Political Contestation.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
31.
KriesiH (2016)
The politicization of European integration.JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies54, 32–47.
32.
KuhnTvan ElsasEHakhverdianAet al. (2016)
An ever wider gap in an ever closer union: Rising inequalities and Euroscepticism in 12 West European democracies, 1975–2009.Socio-Economic Review14(1): 27–45.
33.
LarssonAO (2018)
Assessing “the regulars”—and beyond.Journalism Practice12(5): 605–623.
34.
LaurentsyevaNLudolphL (2017) EU asylum and refugee policy. In: Lücke M, Ademmer E, Akgüç M, Barslund M, Di Bartolomeo A, Benček D, Groll D, Hoxhaj R, Lanati M, Laurentsyeva N, Ludolph L, Rahim A, Thiele R, Schneiderheinze C, Stöhr T and Venturini A (eds) Sharing Responsibility for Refugees and Expanding Legal Immigration. Kiel: Kiel Institute for the World Economy, pp.35–39.
35.
LeeE-J (2012)
That's not the way it is: How user-generated comments on the news affect perceived media bias.Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication18(1): 32–45.
36.
LeupoldA (2016)
A structural approach to politicisation in the Euro crisis.West European Politics39(1): 84–103.
37.
LutzC (2016)
A social milieu approach to the online participation divides in Germany. SocialMedia and Society2(1): 1–14.
38.
MöhringW (2015) Lokaljournalismus im Fokus der Wissenschaft.
Düsseldorf:
Landesmedienanstalt Nordrhein-Westfalen, pp.1–160.
39.
NewmanNFletcherRLevyDALet al. (2016) Reuters Institute Digital News Report 2016.
Oxford:
Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism.
40.
NielsenJH (2016)
Personality and Euroscepticism: The impact of personality on attitudes towards the EU.JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies54(5): 1175–1198.
41.
OfferhausAMollenAHeppA (2014) Europe is already all around, but no one notices: The Europeanization of public spheres in regional newspaper reporting. TranState Working Papers, No. 183. Bremen: Collaborative Research Center 597.
42.
RauhC (2016) A Responsive Technocracy?
Colchester:
ECPR Press.
43.
RauhC (2015)
Communicating supranational governance? The salience of EU affairs in the German Bundestag, 1991–2013.European Union Politics16(1): 116–38.
44.
RauhCDe WildeP (2017)
The opposition deficit in EU accountability: Evidence from over 20 years of plenary debate in four member states. European Journal of Political Research13(4): 487–423.
45.
RisseT (2010) A Community of Europeans?
Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press.
46.
RisseT (2013)
Solidarität unter Fremden?KFG Working Paper Series50: 1–22.
47.
RisseT (2015) Introduction. In: TRisse (ed) European Public Spheres.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, pp.1–25.
48.
SchelterSBiessmannFZobelMet al. (2016) Structural patterns in the rise of Germany’s new right on Facebook. In: 2016 IEEE 16th International Conference on Data Mining Workshops (ICDMW). pp.440–445. DOI: 10.1109/ICDMW.2016.0069.
49.
SchimmelfennigFLeuffenDRittbergerB (2015)
The European Union as a system of differentiated integration: Interdependence, politicization and differentiation.Journal of European Public Policy22(6): 764–782.
50.
SchmidtkeH (2016)
The differentiated politicisation of European tax governance.West European Politics39(1): 64–83.
51.
Schmitt-BeckR (2017)
The “Alternative für Deutschland in the Electorate”: Between single-issue and right-wing populist party.German Politics26(1): 124–148.
52.
ServentARTraunerF (2014)
Do supranational EU institutions make a difference? EU asylum law before and after “communitarization.”Journal of European Public Policy28(1): 1–21.
53.
SpoonJ-J (2012)
How salient is Europe? An analysis of European election manifestos, 1979–2004.European Union Politics13(4): 558–579.
54.
SpringerNEngelmannI andPfaffingerC (2015)
User comments: Motives and inhibitors to write and read.Information Communication and Society18(7): 798–815.
55.
SteinfeldNSamuel-AzranTLev-OnA (2016)
User comments and public opinion: Findings from an eye-tracking experiment.Computers in Human Behavior61(C): 63–72.
56.
WonkaA (2016)
The party politics of the Euro crisis in the German Bundestag: Frames, positions and salience.West European Politics39(1): 125–144.
57.
ZürnM (2016)
Opening up Europe: Next steps in politicisation research.West European Politics39(1): 164–182.
58.
ZürnMBinderMEcker-EhrhardtM (2012)
International authority and its politicization.International Theory4(01): 69–106.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
