Abstract
To determine the effect of rotor eccentricity on the vibration of multistage pumps, a five-stage centrifugal pump with vaned diffusers was selected to experimentally measure the vibration characteristics under both stable condition and unstable condition due to the rotor eccentricity. The results show that the rotor eccentricity results in an irregular orbit of the rotor axis, which is diffused outward. As the flow rate increases, the peak amplitude of the rotor axis’ orbit first decreases and then increases, and the peak amplitude at the design flow rate is minimized. The main vibration frequencies of rotor axis’ orbit are the axis passing frequency and a secondary high frequency. After rotor eccentricity occurs, all monitoring point vibrations increase by different degrees, the increments of axial vibration are particularly obvious, and the characteristic frequencies of the pump increase.
Keywords
Introduction
Multistage centrifugal pumps are widely used in architecture, hot water circulation, coal mine emergency drainage, sewage treatment, petrochemicals and other fields. Many scholars have investigated multistage centrifugal pumps. Wilson et al.
1
analyzed the effects of viscosity and two phases, namely, liquid and gas fluids, on a multistage electrical submersible pump and obtained a series of curves representing the pump performance degradation. Cui et al.
2
numerically analyzed the unsteady radial force in multistage centrifugal pumps with double volute and investigated the relevance of static pressure, radial force and radial vibration. Babayigit et al.
3
studied the effect of balance holes and leakages (clearances) on the performance of a multistage pump. Wang et al.
4
proposed a method to optimize the design of a typical multistage centrifugal pump based on an energy loss model and computational fluid dynamics (CFD). Jiang et al.
5
constructed five diffusers with different axial widths based on the area ratio principle. Tan et al.
6
experimentally investigated the effects of the clocking effect on the performance and vibration intensity of a five-stage centrifugal pump. Shibata et al.
7
studied the diffuser rotating stall, observed positive
Multistage centrifugal pumps are becoming increasingly high-power and high-speed and thus require better operation stability. An eccentric rotor will have unstable pump operation in the long term, which may cause bearing wear and cracks on the rotor surface. Therefore, it is very important to study the operating characteristics of multistage centrifugal pumps experiencing eccentricity. Some scholars have investigated rotor eccentricity. Tabatabaei et al. 13 used a modified winding function theory to simulate a salient-pole synchronous generator and obtained stator and rotor winding distribution with dynamic eccentricity between the stator and rotor. Zhu et al. 14 adopted a nonlinear finite element method to calculate the no-load branch voltage waveform of a synchronous generator with an eccentric rotor and skewed stator slots. Dorrell et al. 15 provided a new theory to analyze the interactions between harmonic field components due to static and dynamic rotor eccentricity in three-phase induction motors.
Vibration is a significant feature after rotor eccentricity occurs. Therefore, scholars have researched the vibration characteristics of multistage centrifugal pumps. Wang et al. 16 experimentally measured the vibration characteristics of a five-stage pump under noncavitation condition and cavitation condition and analyzed the effect of cavitation on pump vibration. Moreover, they 17 measured the pressure pulsation, vibration and noise of the five-stage centrifugal pump at different flow rates. Lu et al. 18 studied the axis orbit and vibration spectrum of a cantilever multistage centrifugal pump at zero flow rate, the design flow rate and a large flow rate. Zhang et al. 19 presented a method for rolling bearing fault diagnosis based on variational mode decomposition and investigated the simulated vibration signal of the proposed fault model by fast Fourier transform (FFT) and envelope analysis. Wang et al. 20 adopted fractional oscillators to deal with noise in the vibration. Ren et al. 21 proved that residual calculations between the frequency and amplitude of a nonlinear oscillator could be further simplified without losing accuracy.
However, research on multistage centrifugal pump operating characteristics when experiencing rotor eccentricity is still inadequate. To provide a reference for the further study on operating characteristics under rotor eccentricity, the effect of rotor eccentricity on the vibration of a five-stage centrifugal pump with vaned diffusers at different flow rates was analyzed.
Test device and energy characteristics experiment
Test bench
The design parameters of the five-stage centrifugal pump with vaned diffusers are as follows. Flow rate

Structure of a five-stage centrifugal pump. 1. Shaft. 2. Suction section. 3. First-stage impeller. 4. Second-stage impeller. 5. Vaned diffuser. 6. Discharge section. 7. Balance disc. 8. Bearing seat. 9. Middle part. 10. Pump foot.

Schematic of the five-stage centrifugal pump test.
Energy characteristics experiment
Figure 3 shows the energy characteristics experiment curves of the five-stage centrifugal pump with vaned diffusers. It can be seen from Figure 3 that, at the design flow rate, the head is 165.4 m and the efficiency is 72.8%. The maximum efficiency point is at 1.1

Energy characteristic curves of the pump.
Test instruments
In this experiment, an eddy current sensor which is a noncontact linear displacement measuring sensor, mainly composed of a front end device, an extension cable and a probe, obtained rotor axis’ orbit displacement value data. It measures the change in distance between the metal object and the end of the probe, and processes it into an electrical signal.
The INV9832 piezoelectric three-axis acceleration sensor was adopted to measure the vibration of the five-stage pump. The INV3020C system was used to collect the vibration signals. The sampling frequency was 12.8 kHz and the sampling time was 40 s.
Distribution of monitoring points and data processing method
Distribution of the rotor axis’ orbit sensors
The pump shaft rotor axis’ orbit is in a two-dimensional plane. Therefore, two sensors need to be installed on the same plane of the pump shaft to collect data. To attach and adjust the sensors, a sensor fixing bracket was made that adjusts in any direction to measure vertical and horizontal axial orbits. The sensor fixing bracket is installed on the pump block with a magnetic base. Figure 4 is a picture of the rotor axis’ orbit sensor location near the bearing at the connection between the pump and the motor. The horizontal and vertical eddy current displacement sensors are arranged to obtain the horizontal and vertical displacement value for rotor axis’ orbits with time. In this experiment, the distance between the probe and the pump shaft is 1 mm.

Location of rotor axis’ orbit sensors.
Distribution of vibration monitoring points
The vibration measurement method in the manuscript follows the Chinese standard “Pump vibration measurement and evaluation method (GB/T29531-2013)”. Six vibration monitoring points (V1–V6) were set in this experiment. The bearing near the outlet of the five-stage pump was defined as B1, and the bearing close to the coupling of the five-stage pump was defined as B2. The monitoring point V1 was located at bearing B1, and V2 was located at bearing B2. Monitoring points V3 and V4 were located in the inlet and outlet flanges of the pump, respectively, V5 (near the outlet of the pump) and V6 (near the coupling of the pump) were located on the two symmetrical pump feet. Figure 5 shows the monitoring points V2, V4 and V5, where the sensors were magnetically mounted.

Distribution of monitoring points. (a) V2. (b) V4. (c) V5.
Data processing method
Vibration acceleration was integrated into vibration velocity by the integral function in the Distributive Analysis Stata Package (DASP) software. The time domain diagram of the rotor axis’ orbit and vibration signals was converted into a frequency domain diagram by Fourier transformation. Vibration velocity was defined as the root mean square of vibration velocity to evaluate the level of overall vibration. The calculated value of vibration intensity
Results and analysis
Rotor axis’ orbits
Stable condition
Figure 6 shows the rotor axis’ orbit of the five-stage centrifugal pump under stable conditions. It can be seen that the shapes and sizes of the rotor axis’ orbit at 0.6

Rotor axis’ orbit under stable conditions. (a) 0.6
Figure 7 shows the time domain of the rotor axis’ orbit in the five-stage centrifugal pump under stable conditions. It can be seen that the waveforms at 0.6

Time domain characteristics of rotor axis’ orbit under stable conditions. (a) X direction. (b) Y direction.
Figure 8 shows the frequency spectrogram of the rotor axis’ orbit in the five-stage centrifugal pump under stable conditions. In the frequency range from 0 to 150 Hz, the main frequency of the rotor axis’ orbit vibrations at 0.6

Frequency spectrogram of rotor axis’ orbit under stable conditions. (a) X direction. (b) Y direction.
Unstable condition due to the rotor eccentricity
To study the five-stage centrifugal pump rotor axis’ orbit under rotor eccentricity, the motor rotor axis was set parallel but 0.75 mm away from the pump axis.
Figure 9 shows the rotor axis’ orbit of the five-stage centrifugal pump under unstable condition due to the rotor eccentricity. It can be seen that the rotor axis’ orbits at 0.6

Rotor axis’ orbit under unstable conditions due to the rotor eccentricity. (a) 0.6
Figure 10 shows the time domain of the five-stage centrifugal pump under unstable conditions due to the rotor eccentricity. It can be seen that the waveforms of the rotor axial orbit in the X and Y directions at 0.6

Time domain characteristics of rotor axis’ orbits under unstable conditions due to the rotor eccentricity. (a) X direction. (b) Y direction.
Figure 11 shows the frequency spectrogram of the rotor axis’ orbit of the five-stage centrifugal pump under unstable conditions due to the rotor eccentricity. In the frequency range from 0 to 150 Hz, at 0.6

Frequency spectrogram of rotor axis’ orbit under unstable conditions due to the rotor eccentricity. (a) X direction. (b) Y direction.
Vibration characteristics
Vibration characteristics at 0.6Qd
To study the relationship between frequency and the APF, a dimensionless frequency number

Vibration velocity spectrograms at 0.6
Vibration characteristics at 0.8Qd
Figure 13 gives the vibration velocity spectrograms of monitoring points V1 through V6 at 0.8

Vibration velocity spectrograms at 0.8
Vibration characteristics at 1.0Qd
Figure 14 shows the vibration velocity spectrogram of six monitoring points V1 through V6 at 1.0

Vibration velocity spectrograms at 1.0
After rotor eccentricity occurs, the characteristic frequency increases correspondingly, with corresponding peaks from 1APF to 12APF. There are many characteristic frequencies between 4APF and 8APF whose amplitudes are not large. This is because when rotor eccentricity occurs, instability is enhanced, causing the friction between the rotor and stator to increase. Meanwhile, the difference in blade numbers between the first and secondary impellers results in additional characteristic frequencies.
Vibration characteristics at 1.2Qd
Figure 15 shows the vibration velocity spectrogram of six monitoring points V1 through V6 at 1.2

Vibration velocity spectrograms at 1.2
Vibration intensity
Table 1 shows the vibration intensity of monitoring points at 1.0
Vibration intensity at 1.0
Tables 2 to 4 show the vibration intensities of all monitoring points during 0.6
Vibration intensity at 0.6
Vibration intensity at 0.8
Vibration intensity at 1.2
Conclusions
The vibration of the five-stage centrifugal pump with vaned diffusers under stable conditions and unstable conditions due to the rotor eccentricity was measured and analyzed. Some conclusions are as follows. At 0.6 At the design flow rate, the vibration amplitudes of all the monitoring points in horizontal, vertical and axial directions under rotor eccentricity increase to different degrees. Among these, the increase of axial vibration amplitude is particularly obvious. After rotor eccentricity occurs, the instability increases, and the characteristic frequencies increase correspondingly. There are many characteristic frequencies between 4APF and 8APF. The vibration intensity of monitoring point V2 at bearing B2 is obviously larger than those of other monitoring points. For the off-design flow rates, after the rotor eccentricity occurs, the vibration velocities of monitoring points V2 and V3 significantly increase at 0.8
This manuscript experimentally studies the influence of rotor eccentricity on the vibration characteristics in the five-stage centrifugal pump with vaned diffusers. However, a theoretical analysis of the vibration characteristics of the pump was not considered. Therefore, in subsequent research, a comprehensive study with theoretical analysis, CFD simulation and experimental verification of vibration characteristics in the pump needs to be carried out.
Footnotes
Declaration of conflicting interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: This work was supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 51579117 and 51779108), Six Talent Peaks Project in Jiangsu Province of China (Grant No. 2018-GDZB-154) and Priority Academic Program Development of Jiangsu Higher Education Institutions (PAPD).
