The aim of this article is to examine the relationship between nursing practice
and the recording of practice. We outline the main findings of a Cochrane
systematic review on nursing records, discussing the indications from the
included studies that compared computerized nursing care planning with
paper-based systems. Qualitative research on nursing records systems, and other
survey evidence, is collated to answer questions on the format of the record
(structured versus free text, for what type of practice), occasions when
information exchange about nursing care may not and should not be recorded
formally, and the effective organization of the nursing record. We conclude that
more research is required to answer these questions, as it seems that
computerization does not always bring the expected benefits, and outcomes for
patient care are not clear.
Currell R
,
Urquhart C.Nursing record systems: effects on nursing practice and health care outcomes
. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews2003; (3); CD002099.
2.
Hardey M
,
Payne S
,
Coleman P.‘Scraps’: hidden nursing information and its influence
on the delivery of care
. Journal of Advanced Nursing2000; 32 (1);
208-214
.
3.
Stausberg J
,
Koch D
,
Ingernerf J
,
Betzler M.Comparing paper-based with electronic patient records: lessons learned
during a study on diagnosis and procedure codes
. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association2003; 10 (5);
470-477
.
4.
Daly J M
,
Buckwalter K
,
Maas M.Written and computerized care plans: organizational processes and effect on
patient outcomes
. Journal of Gerontological Nursing2002; 28 (9);
14-23
.
5.
Ammenwerth E
,
Eichstädter H R
,
Pohl U
,
Rebel S
,
Ziegler S. Arandomized evaluation of a computer-based nursing documentation system
. Methods of Information in Medicine2001; 40 (2);
61-68
.
6.
Spranzo L. Effects of computerized nurse care planning on selected health
care effectiveness measures. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Maryland, 1993.
7.
Public Health Resource Unit
. CASP appraisal tool for qualitative research.
Milton Keynes Primary Care Trust
. http://www.phru.nhs.uk/casp/qualitat.htm. Critical Appraisal
Skills Programme, 2002.
8.
Stevens B.Development and testing of a pediatric pain management sheet
. Pediatric Nursing1990; 16 (6);
543-548
.
Kinn S
,
Hood K.A falls risk-assessment tool in an elderly care environment
. British Journal of Nursing2001; 10 (7);
440-449
.
11.
Hansebo G
,
Kihlgren M
,
Ljunggren G.Review of nursing documentation in nursing home wards: changes after
intervention for individualized care
. Journal of Advanced Nursing1999; 29 (6);
1462-1473
.
12.
Nordyke R A
,
Kulikowski C A.An informatics-based chronic disease practice: case study of a 35-year
computer-based longitudinal record system
. Journal of the American Medical Informatics
Association!1998; 5;
88-103
.
13.
Allen D.Record-keeping and routine nursing practice: the view from the wards
. Journal of Advanced Nursing1998; 27;
1223-1230
.
14.
Payne S
,
Hardey M
,
Coleman P.Interactions between nurses during handovers in elderly care
. Journal of Advanced Nursing2000; 32 (2);
277-285
.
15.
Jones A
,
Henwood F
,
Hart A
,
Gerhardt C.Resistance at the frontline: the case of Electronic Patient Records (EPRs)
in maternity services. In
Bryant J
ed. Current Perspectives in Healthcare Computing 2003 (HC 2003), 24-26
March 2003, Harrogate48-56.
Swindon: BCS Health Informatics Committee
, 2003.
16.
Young P M
,
Leung R M
,
Ho L M
,
McGhee S M.An evaluation of the use of hand-held computers for bedside nursing care
. International Journal of Medical Informatics2001; 62 (2-3);
189-193
.
17.
Hardiker N.The PEN&PAD nursing record system. 2000.
http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/mig/projects/old/penPad/nursing.html, 1 January 2004.
18.
Chung L H
,
Chong S
,
French P.The efficiency of fluid balance charting: an evidence-based management project
. Journal of Nursing Management2002; 10;
103-113
.
19.
Ammenwerth E
,
Mansmann U
,
Iller C
,
Eichstädter R
.
Factors affecting and affected by user acceptance of computer-based nursing
documentation: results of a two-year study
. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association2003; 10 (1);
69-84
.
20.
Kerr M P.A qualitative study of shift handover practice and function from a
socio-technical perspective
. Journal of Advanced Nursing2002; 37 (2);
125-134
.
21.
Clausson E
,
Petersson K
,
Berg A.School nurses’ view of schoolchildren’s health and
their attitudes to document it in the school health record: a pilot study
. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences2003; 17 (4);
392-398
.
22.
Pederson C
,
Bjerke T.Pediatric pain management: a research-based clinical pathway
. Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing1999; 18 (3);
42-51
.
23.
Nahm R
,
Poston I.Measurement of the effects of an integrated, point-of-care computer system
on quality of nursing documentation and patient satisfaction
. Computers in Nursing2000; 18 (5);
220-229
.
24.
Mason C.Guide to practice or ‘load of rubbish’? The influence
of care plans on nursing practice in five clinical areas in Northern Ireland
. Journal of Advanced Nursing1999; 29 (2);
380-387
.
25.
Jones A.Implementation of hospital care pathways for patients with schizophrenia
. Journal of Nursing Management2000; 8;
215-225
.
26.
Murphy K
,
Cooney A
,
Casey D
,
Connor M
,
O’Connor J
,
Dineen B.The Roper, Logan and Tierney (1996) model: perceptions and
operationalization of the model in psychiatric nursing within a Health Board
in Ireland
. Journal of Advanced Nursing2000; 31 (6);
1333-1341
.
27.
Martin A
,
Hinds C
,
Felix M.Documentation practices of nurses in long-term care
. Journal of Clinical Nursing1999; 8;
345-352
.
28.
Björvell C
,
Wredling R
,
Thorell-Ekstrand I.Improving documentation using a nursing model
. Journal of Advanced Nursing2003; 43 (4);
402-410
.
29.
Lee T T
,
Yeh C H
,
Ho L H.Application of a computerized nursing care plan system in one hospital:
experiences of ICU nurses in Taiwan
. Journal of Advanced Nursing2002; 39 (1);
61-67
.
30.
Timmons S. Resistance to computerised care planning systems by nurses in the
NHS. PhD thesis, Anglia Polytechnic University, 2001.
31.
Timmons S
,
Miller S.A comparative study of resistance to nursing computer systems
. ITIN2002; 14 (3);
2-7
.
32.
Hardiker N R.Logical ontology for mediating between nursing intervention terminology systems
. Methods of Information in Medicine2003; 42 (3);
265-270
.
33.
Goorman E
,
Berg M.Modelling nursing activities: electronic patient records and their discontents
. Nursing Inquiry2000; 7 (1);
3-9
.
34.
Clamp S
,
Heathfield H
,
Felton D.From ERDIP to ICRS: lessons learnt from the evaluation of the South
Staffordshire EHR project
. British Journal of Healthcare Computing & Information Management2003; 20 (10);
31-33
.
