Are some voters willing to trade off concerns with policy and identity representation when evaluating political candidates? We conceptualize both policy and identity representation in spatial terms. We examine the utility of our conceptual framework by applying it to recent US presidential elections. In line with our theoretical expectations, we find that Black voters, and especially those who identify strongly with their racial group, not only care less about policy representation than White voters but are also more willing to trade off lower levels of policy representation for increased identity representation. Our theoretical framework has important implications for how representation scholars should model the effects of policy and identity on candidate evaluation at election time. Empirically, our analyses contribute to the growing body of evidence showing that the electoral calculus and representation priorities of Black voters in the US are different from those of White voters.
AlgaraCarlosHaleIsaac. 2019. “The Distorting Effects of Racial Animus on Proximity Voting in the 2016 Elections.” Electoral Studies58: 58–69.
2.
AlvarezR. MichaelBowlerShaunNaglerJonathan. 2000. “Issues, Economics, and the Dynamics of multi-party Elections: the British 1987 General Election.” American Political Science Review94 (1): 131–49.
3.
American National Election Studies. 2014. User’s Guide and Codebook for the ANES 2012 Time Series Study.
4.
BarkerDavidBlockRayJr.JohnsonMarcusLeighleyJan. 2024. “Reducing Racial Asymmetries in the Overreporting of Voter Turnout.” Public Opinion Quarterly88 (3): 1017–31.
5.
BlockRayJr.2011. “Backing Barack Because He’s Black: Racially Motivated Voting in the 2008 Election.” Social Science Quarterly92 (2): 423–46.
6.
BlockRayJr.GolderMattGolderSona N.. 2023. “Evaluating Claims of Intersectionality.” The Journal of Politics85 (3): 795–811.
7.
BoboLawrenceGilliamFranklin D.. 1990. “Race, Sociopolitical Participation, and Black Empowerment.” American Political Science Review84 (2): 377–93.
8.
BoudreauCherylElmendorfChristopher S.MacKenzieScott A.. 2019. “Racial or Spatial Voting? The Effects of Candidate Ethnicity and Ethnic Group Endorsements in Local Elections.” American Journal of Political Science63 (1): 5–20.
9.
BowenDaniel C.ClarkChristopher J.. 2014. “Revisiting Descriptive Representation in Congress: Assessing the Effect of Race on the constituent-legislator Relationship.” Political Research Quarterly67 (3): 695–707.
10.
BroockmanDavid E.2013. “Black Politicians are More Intrinsically Motivated to Advance Blacks’ Interests: A Field Experiment Manipulating Political Incentives.” American Journal of Political Science57 (3): 521–36.
11.
BrowningRufus P.Rogers MarshallDaleTabbDavid H.. 1984. Protest is Not Enough: The Struggle of Blacks and Hispanics for Equality in Urban Politics. University of California Press.
12.
CameronCharlesEpsteinDavidHalloranSharyn O’. 1996. “Do Majority Minority Districts Maximize Black Substantive Representation in Congress?” American Political Science Review90 (4): 794–812.
13.
CanonDavid T.1999. Race, Redistricting, and Representation: The Unintended Consequences of Black Majority Districts. University of Chicago Press.
14.
ClarkChristopher J.2019. Gaining Voice: The Causes and Consequences of Black Representation in American States. Oxford University Press.
15.
ClarkWilliam RobertsGolderMatt. 2023. Interaction Models: Specification and Interpretation. Cambridge University Press.
16.
DawsonMichael C.1994. Behind the Mule: Race and Class in African-American Politics. Princeton University Press.
17.
DawsonMichael C.2001. Black Visions: The Roots of Contemporary African-American Political Ideologies. University of Chicago Press.
18.
DietrichBryce J.HayesMatthew. 2023. “Symbols of the Struggle: Descriptive Representation and Issue-based Symbolism in US House Speeches.” The Journal of Politics85 (4): 1368–84.
19.
DunLindsayJesseeStephen. 2020. “Demographic Moderation of Spatial Voting in Presidential Elections.” American Politics Research48 (6): 750–62.
20.
EulauHeinzKarpsPaul D.. 1977. “The Puzzle of Representation: Specifying Components of Responsiveness.” Legislative Studies Quarterly2: 233–54.
21.
FrymerPaul. 2010. Uneasy Alliances: Race and Party Competition in America. Princeton University Press.
22.
GayClaudine. 2001. “The Effect of Black Congressional Representation on Political Participation.” American Political Science Review95 (3): 589–602.
23.
Goodyear-GrantElizabethTolleyErin. 2019. “Voting for One’s Own: Racial Group Identification and Candidate Preferences.” Politics, Groups, and Identities7 (1): 131–47.
24.
GriffinJohn D.FlavinPatrick. 2007. “Racial Differences in Information, Expectations, and Accountability.” The Journal of Politics69 (1): 220–36.
25.
GriffinJohn D.FlavinPatrick. 2011. “How Citizens and Their Legislators Prioritize Spheres of Representation.” Political Research Quarterly64 (3): 520–33.
26.
GriffinJohn D.NewmanBrian. 2008. Minority Report: Evaluating Political Equality in America. University of Chicago Press.
27.
GroseChristian R.2011. Congress in Black and White: Race and Representation in Washington and at Home. Cambridge University Press.
28.
GroseChristian R.MangumMaruiceMartinChristopher. 2007. “Race, Political Empowerment, and Constituency Service: Descriptive Representation and the Hiring of African-American Congressional Staff.” Polity39 (4): 449–78.
29.
HardenJeffrey J.2016. Multidimensional Democracy: A Supply and Demand Theory of Representation in American Legislatures. Cambridge University Press.
30.
HarrisFredrick C.2012. The Price of the Ticket: Barack Obama and the Rise and Decline of Black Politics. Oxford University Press.
31.
HayesMatthewHibbingMatthew V. 2017. “The Symbolic Benefits of Descriptive and Substantive Representation.” Political Behavior39: 31–50.
32.
HutchingsVincent L.2003. Public Opinion and Democratic Accountability: How Citizens Learn About Politics. Princeton University Press.
33.
HutchingsVincent L.2009. “Change or More of the Same? Evaluating Racial Attitudes in the Obama Era.” Public Opinion Quarterly73 (5): 917–42.
34.
JeffersonHakeem. 2024. “The Curious Case of Black Conservatives: Assessing the Validity of the Liberal-Conservative Scale Among Black Americans.” Public Opinion Quarterly88: 909–32.
35.
JenkeLibbyHuettelScott A.. 2016. “Issues or Identity? Cognitive Foundations of Voter Choice.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences20 (11): 794–804.
36.
JenkeLibbyHuettelScott A.. 2020. “Voter Preferences Reflect a Competition Between Policy and Identity.” Frontiers in Psychology11: 2739.
37.
KeeleLuke J.ShahParu R.WhiteIsmailKayKristine. 2017. “Black Candidates and Black Turnout.” The Journal of Politics79 (3): 780–91.
38.
LublinDavid L.1997. The Paradox of Representation: Racial Gerrymandering and Minority Interests in Congress. Princeton University Press.
39.
McClainPaula D.Johnson CarewJessica D.WaltonEugeneJr.WattsCandis S.. 2009. “Group Membership, Group Identity, and Group Consciousness: Measures of Racial Identity in American Politics?” Annual Review of Political Science12: 471–85.
40.
MillerArthur H.PatriciaGurinGurinGeraldMalanchukOksana. 1981. “Group Consciousness and Political Participation.” American Journal of Political Science25: 494–511.
41.
O’BrienDiana Z.2019. “Female Leaders and Citizens’ Perceptions of Political Parties.” Journal of Elections, Public Opinion, and Parties29 (4): 465–89.
42.
ParkerChristopher Sebastian. 2016. “Race and Politics in the Age of Obama.” Annual Review of Sociology42 (1): 217–30.
43.
PhilpotTasha S.WaltonHanesJr.2007. “One of Our Own: Black Female Candidates and the Voters Who Support Them.” American Journal of Political Science51 (1): 49–62.
44.
PriceMelanye T.2016. The Race Whisperer: Barack Obama and the Political Uses of Race. New York University Press.
45.
Stephens-DouganLaFleur. 2020. Race to the Bottom: How Racial Appeals Work in American Politics. Chicago University Press.
46.
StoutChristopher T.2015. Bringing Race Back In: Black Politicians, Deracialization, and Voting Behavior in the Age of Obama. University of Virginia Press.
47.
StoutChristopher T.LeDanvy. 2017. “Traiting Places: Race and the Evaluation of Black and White Presidential Candidates.” Presidential Studies Quarterly47: 311–35.
48.
StoutChristopher T.BakerKeithBakerMadelyn. 2021. “How Social Desirability Response Bias May Lead to an Overestimation of Obama-Trump Voters.” Public Opinion Quarterly85 (2): 694–705.
49.
SullivanJas M.2010. “Race, Identity, and Candidate Support: a Test of Implicit Preference.” In African-American Political Psychology, edited by PhilpotTasha S.WhiteIsmail K.. Palgrave Macmillan.
50.
TateKatherine. 1994. From Protest to Politics: The New Black Voters in American Politics. Harvard University Press.
51.
TateKatherine. 2004. Black Faces in the Mirror: African Americans and Their Representatives in the US Congress. Princeton University Press.
52.
WaltonHanes. 1985. Invisible Politics: Black Political Behavior. SUNY Press.
53.
WhiteIsmail K.LairdChryl N.. 2020. Steadfast Democrats: How Social Forces Shape Black Political Behavior. Princeton University Press.
54.
YeungEddy S. F.QuekKai. 2025. “Self-Reported Political Ideology.” Political Science Research and Methods13 (2): 412–33.
55.
YoungIris Marion. 2002. Inclusion and Democracy. Oxford University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
