The state capture of Russian non-bank financial institutions and markets after the 2008 crisis

Abstract

This article explores the expansion of the Russian state into financial markets after the 2008 global financial crisis. The main argument is that the Russian state has been unable to pursue its own developmental agenda in the sector despite increased regulation and state takeovers. While independent private market participants were pushed aside by state-controlled financial intermediaries, the state failed to follow its own policy strategy towards establishing an international financial centre in Moscow. Instead, the Russian financial market institutions were rendered into a vehicle for inter-bank lending under control of the Central Bank of Russia. Data from Russian stock market and corporate bond market trading highlights the trend. The study discusses the role played by informal power networks in redistribution of state-controlled resources and financial flows, and how this factor influenced the state regulation of financial markets in Russia.

Keywords

Russian financial market state intervention post-2008 crisis policy Central Bank of Russia developmental state Russian network state Moscow International Financial Centre

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abramov

(2008) Krizis rossiiskogo fondovogo rynka 2008 goda: Vneshnie factory ili vnutrennie mekhanizmy? Ekonomicheskaya Politika 6: 125–152.

Abramov

(2010) Rossiiskii finansovyi rynok v 2009-2009 godakh: Dinamika, antikrizisnaya podderzhka, institutsional'nye problemy. In: Sinel'nikov-Murylev

(eds) Obzor Sostoyaniya Rossiiskoi Ekonomiki. 2009-2010: Tendentsii i Perspektivy, Moscow: Prospekt.

Abramov

(2012) Finansovye rynki i finansovye instituty. In: Sinel'nikov-Murylev

(eds) Rossiiskaya Ekonomika v 2011 Godu: Tendentsii i Perspektivy, Moscow: Prospekt.

Abramov

(2013) Finansovye rynki i finansovye instituty. In: Sinel'nikov-Murylev

(eds) Rossiiskaya Ekonomika v 2012 Godu: Tendentsii i Perspektivy, Moscow: Institut Gaidara.

Abramov

(2014) Finansovye rynki i finansovye instituty. In: Sinel'nikov-Murylev

(eds) Rossiiskaya Ekonomika v 2013 Godu: Tendentsii i Perspektivy, Moscow: Institut Gaidara.

Baev

(2011) Crooked hierarchy and reshuffled networks: Reforming Russia's dysfunctional military machine. In: Kononenko

Moshes

(eds) Russia as a Network State: What Works in Russia when State Institutions Do not?, Cambridge: Palgrave Macmillan.

Belyaev

(2009) Smena ligi: Interview. Vestnik NAUFOR 6: 4–11.

Chernykh

(2008) Ultimate ownership and control in Russia. Journal of Financial Economics 88: 169–192.

Chernykh

(2011) Profit or politics? Understanding renationalizations in Russia. Journal of Corporate Finance 17: 1237–1253.

10.

Cimoli

Dosi

Stiglitz

(2010) Industrial Policy and Development: The Political Economy of Capabilities Accumulation, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

11.

Connolly

(2013) State industrial policy in Russia: The nanotechnology industry. Post-Soviet Affairs 29: 1–30.

12.

Danilov

(2011) Nastoyashchich buinych malo. Ekspert 29: 32–36.

13.

Danilov

(2012) Ostanovit' monstra!. Ekspert 46: 62–66.

14.

Dvoretskaia

(2008) Capital market finance for the nonfinancial sector. Problems of Economic Transition 51: 49–62.

15.

Evans

(1995) Embedded Autonomy: States & Industrial Transformation, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

16.

Evans

(2014) The developmental state: Divergent responses to modern economic theory and the twenty-first-century economy. In: Williams

(eds) The End of the Developmental State?, New York, NY: Routledge.

17.

Florio

(2002) Economists, privatization in Russia and the waning of the ‘Washington Consensus’. Review of International Political Economy 9: 359–400.

18.

Gavrilenko

(2012) Bol'shaya Sdelka, Moskva: Alor.

19.

Government of Russia (2008) Strategiya razvitiya finansovogo rynka Rossiiskoi Federatsii na period do 2020 goda. Available at: www.rg.ru/2009/01/27/strategiya-dok.html (accessed 1 April 2015).

20.

Government of Russia (2009) Plan meropriyatii po sozdaniyu mezhdunarodnogo finansovogo tsentra v Rossiiskoi Federatsii. 11 July 2009. Available at: www.mfc-moscow.com/index.php?id=13 (accessed 1 April 2015).

21.

Government of Russia (2013) Plan meropriyatii (“Dorozhnaiya karta”) Sozdanie mezhdunarodnogo finansovogo tsentra i uluchshenie investitsionnogo klimata v Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Available at: http://government.ru/media/files/41d4744634530e3dbbe8.pdf (accessed 1 April 2015).

22.

Hanson

(2006) Changing the rules of the economic game in post-Soviet Russia. In: Kangaspuro

Smith

(eds) Modernisation in Russia since 1900, Helsinki: Finnish Literature Society.

23.

Ignat'ev

(2013) Odinnadtsat' protsentov organizatsii ne platiyat nalogov. Vedomosti. , 20 February.

24.

Kirdina

Vernikov

(2013) Evolution of the banking system in the Russian context: An institutional view. Journal of Economic Issues 47: 2, 475–483.

25.

Kononenko

(2011) Introduction. In: Kononenko

Moshes

(eds) Russia as a Network State: What Works in Russia when State Institutions Do not?, Cambridge: Palgrave Macmillan.

26.

Kryshtanovskaya

(2005) Anatomiya Rossiiskoi Elity, Moscow: Zacharov.

27.

Kryshtanovskaya

White

(2011) The formation of Russia's network directorate. In: Kononenko

Moshes

(eds) Russia as a Network State: What Works in Russia when State Institutions Do not?, Cambridge: Palgrave Macmillan.

28.

Kuznetsova

Kuznetsov

Mirkin

(2011) The rocky road to modernity: 20 years of the Russian capital market. Thunderbird International Business Review 53: 661–673.

29.

Ledeneva

(2013) Can Russia Modernise?: Sistema, Power Networks and Informal Governance, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

30.

Mal'ginov

Radygin

(2013) Institutsional'nye problemy: Sostoyanie gosudarstvennogo sektora i privatizatsiya. In: Sinel'nikov-Murylev

(eds) Rossiiskaya Ekonomika v 2012 Godu: Tendentsii i Perspektivy, Moscow: Institut Gaidara.

31.

Mal’tsev

(2009) ‘U dvuh nyanek’. Finans 36: 50–52.

32.

Mal'tsev

Goryanov

(2010) Osen' 2008-go: Istinnoye litso krizisa. Finans 33: 8–13.

33.

MIFC (Moscow International Financial Centre), UK-Russia Liaison Group (2013) Challenges for Long-term Finance in Russia, Moscow: MIFC Taskforce, The City UK. Available at: http://www.mfc-moscow.com/assets/files/analytics/uk-ru_Challenges_for_long-term_finance_in_Russia. pdf (accessed February 2015).

34.

Ministry of Economic Development (2009) Kontseptsiya sozdaniya mezhdunarodnogo finansovogo tsentra v Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Available at: www.mfc-moscow.com/index.php?id=13 (accessed March 2015).

35.

Mirkin

Kuznetsova

Kuznetsov

(2013) The financial depth of emerging markets: The case of Russia. Competition & Change 17: 156–175.

36.

NAUFOR (National Association of Securities Market Participants) (2008) Rossiiskii fondovyi rynok i sozdanie mezhdunarodnogo finansovogo tsentra, Moscow: NAUFOR.

37.

NAUFOR (2014) Rossiiskii fondovyi rynok 2013: Sobytiya i fakty, Moscow: NAUFOR.

38.

Netreba

(2011) FSFR menyaet rukovodstvo naletu. Kommersant. 11 April.

39.

Okimoto

(1989) Between MITI and the Market: Japanese Industrial Policy for High Technology, Stanford: Stanford University Press.

40.

Oleinik

(2011) Vlast i Rynok: Sistema Sotsial'no-Ekonomicheskogo Gospodstva v Rossii 'Nulevykh' Godov, Moscow: ROSSPEN.

41.

Ortmann

(2011) The Russian network state as a great power. In: Kononenko

Moshes

(eds) Russia as a Network State: What Works in Russia when State Institutions Do not?, Cambridge: Palgrave Macmillan.

42.

Papchenkova

Trifonov

Rozhkov

(2012) Novye polnomochiya dlya TsB. Vedomosti. , 24 September.

43.

Puffer

McCarthy

(2007) Can Russia's state managed, network capitalism be competitive? Institutional pull versus institutional push. Journal of World Business 42: 1–13.

44.

Rutland

(2013) Neoliberalism and the Russian transition. Review of International Political Economy 20: 332–362.

45.

Sakwa

(2009) The Quality of Freedom: Khodorkovsky, Putin, and the Yukos Affair, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

46.

Schoenman

(2014) Networks and Institutions in Europe's Emerging Markets, Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

47.

Solnick

(1998) Stealing the State: Control and Collapse in Soviet Institutions, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

48.

Sprenger

(2010) State ownership in the Russian economy: Its magnitude, structure and governance problems. ICEF Working Paper. February. Available at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1311223 (accessed 1 April 2015).

49.

Steen

(2003) Political Elites and the New Russia: The Power Basis of Yeltsin's and Putin's Regimes, London & New York: Routledge.

50.

Vardanyan

(2008) Rynok nahoditsya v reanimatsii: Interv'yu s predsedatelem soveta direktorov gruppy kompanii Troika Dialog Rubenom Vardanyanom. Vedomosti. , 9 October.

51.

Vernikov

(2012) The impact of state-controlled banks on the Russian banking sector. Eurasian Geography and Economics 53: 250–266.

52.

Vernikov

(2014) “National Champions” in Russia's Banking Services Market. Problems of Economic Transition 57: 3–25.

53.

Viktorov

(2013) Corporate raiding in post-Soviet Russia. Baltic Worlds 6: 4–8.

54.

Viktorov

(2015) The state, informal networks and financial market regulation in post-Soviet Russia, 1990-2008. Soviet and Post-Soviet Review 42: 5–38.

55.

Wade

(2004) Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization, 2nd ed. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

56.

Warwick

(2013) Beyond industrial policy: Emerging issues and new trends. OECD Science, Technology and Industry Policy Papers. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/5k4869clw0xp-en (accessed 1 March 2015).

57.

Wedel

(2003) Clans, cliques and captured states: Rethinking ‘Transition’ in Central and Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union. Journal of International Development 15: 427–440.

58.

Wedel

(2009) Shadow Elite: How the World's New Power Brokers Undermine Democracy, Government, and the Free Market, New York, NY: Basic Books.

59.

Wegren

(2012) Agriculture. In: Wegren

(eds) Return to Putin's Russia: Past Imperfect, Future Uncertain, Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

60.

Woo

(1991) Race to the Swift: State and Finance in Korean Industrialization, New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

61.

World Bank (2012) Analysis and Diagnosis of the Financial, Regulatory and Institutional Policies Required for Becoming an International Financial Center, Washington, DC: The World Bank.

62.

World Bank (2013) Rethinking the Role of the State in Finance. Global Financial Report 2013, Washington, DC: The World Bank.

63.

Yakovlev

Sobolev

Kazun

(2014) Means of production versus means of coercion: Can Russian business limit the violence of a predatory state? Post-Soviet Affairs 30: 171–194.