Frontline nurses who care for patients with COVID-19 work in stressful environments, and many inevitably struggle with unanticipated ethical issues. Little is known about the unique, ethically sensitive issues that nurses faced when caring for patients with COVID-19.
Aim
To better understand how frontline nurses who care for patients with COVID-19 experience ethical issues towards others and themselves.
Methods
Systematic review of qualitative evidence carried out according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-analyses on ethical literature (PRISMA-Ethics). The electronic databases PubMed, Embase, Cinahl, Web of Science, Philosopher's Index, and Scopus were queried to identify candidate articles. Articles appearing from March 1, 2020 to December 31, 2022 were considered if they met the following inclusion criteria: (1) Published qualitative and mixed method studies and (2) ethical issues experienced by nurses caring for patients with COVID-19. We appraised the quality of included studies, and data analysis was guided by QUAGOL principles.
Findings
Twenty-six studies meeting our inclusion criteria for how nurses experience ethical issues were characterised by two key themes: (1) the moral character of nurses as a willingness to respond to the vulnerability of human beings and (2) ethical issues nurses acted as barriers sometimes, impeding them from responding to requests of vulnerable human beings for dignified care.
Conclusion
Our review provides a deeper understanding of nurses’ experiences of ethically sensitive issues, while also highlighting the critical need for adjustments to be made at organisational and societal levels. Ethical issues that emerged in situations where organisational and situational constraints impeded nurses' ethical responses to patients’ appeals suggests that early practical support should be made available to resolve ethical issues recognised by nurses. Such support contributes to protecting and promoting not only the dignity of patients with COVID-19 but also of fellow humans in need during crisis.
World Health Organization. Listings of WHO’s response to COVID-19 [Internet]. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization, 2020.
2.
BuchanJCattonHShafferF. Sustain and Retain in 2022 and Beyond. Int Counc Nurses. 2022; 71: 1–71.
3.
International Council of Nurses. Annex: COVID-19 and the global nursing workforce: impacts on World Health Organization regions. The global voice of nursing, 2022.
4.
LiuXZhengJLiuK, et al.Hospital nursing organizational factors, nursing care left undone, and nurse burnout as predictors of patient safety: actural equation modeling analysis. Int J Nurs Stud2018; 86: 82–89.
5.
LeeSEScottLDDahintenVS, et al.Safety culture, patient safety, and quality of care outcomes: a literature review. West J Nurs Res2019; 41: 279–304.
6.
MorleyGGradyCMcCarthyJ, et al.Covid-19: ethical challenges for nurses. Hastings Cent Rep2020; 50: 35–39.
7.
PeterEVariathCMohammedS, et al.Nurses’ experiences of their ethical responsibilities during coronavirus outbreaks: a scoping review. Can J Nurs Res2022; 54: 246–260.
8.
JangYOhY. Impact of ethical factors on job satisfaction among Korean nurses. Nurs Ethics2019; 26: 1186–1198.
9.
KimYOhYLeeE, et al.Impact of nurse-physician collaboration, moral distress, and professional autonomy on job satisfaction among nurses acting as physician assistants. Int J Environ Res Publ Health2022; 19: 661.
10.
WoodsM. Moral distress revisited: the viewpoints and responses of nurses. Int Nurs Rev2020; 67: 68–75.
11.
KimMOhYKongB. Ethical conflicts experienced by nurses in geriatric hospitals in South Korea: “If You Can’t Stand the Heat, Get Out of the Kitchen”. Int J Environ Res Publ Health2020; 17: 4442.
12.
EpsteinEGHamricAB. Moral distress, moral residue, and the crescendo effect. J Clin Ethics2009; 20: 330–342.
13.
MuzGErdoğan YüceG. Experiences of nurses caring for patients with COVID‐19 in Turkey: a phenomenological enquiry. J Nurs Manag2021; 29: 1026–1035.
14.
AlloubaniAKhaterWAkhu-ZaheyaL, et al.Nurses’ ethics in the care of patients during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Front Med2021; 8: 589550.
15.
LiuXYXuYYChenYY, et al.Ethical dilemmas faced by frontline support nurses fighting COVID-19. Nurs Ethics2022; 29: 7–18.
16.
HallgrenJLarssonMKjellenM, et al.Who will do it if I don’t?’ Nurse anaesthetists’ experiences of working in the intensive care unit during the COVID-19 pandemic. Aust Crit Care2022; 35: 52–58.
17.
SriharanAWestKJAlmostJ, et al.COVID-19-related occupational burnout and moral distress among nurses: a rapid scoping review. Nurs Leadersh (Tor Ont)2021; 34: 7–19.
18.
GastmansC. A fundamental ethical approach to nursing: some proposals for ethics education. Nurs Ethics2002; 9: 494–507.
19.
GastmansCDierckx de CasterleBSchotsmansP. Nursing considered as moral practice: a philosophical-ethical interpretation of nursing. Kennedy Inst Ethics J1998; 8: 43–69.
20.
GastmansC. Care as a moral attitude in nursing. Nurs Ethics1999; 6: 214–223.
KeenAGeorgeAStuckBT, et al.Nurse perceptions of a nurse family liaison implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic: a qualitative thematic analysis. Intensive Crit Care Nurs2022; 70: 103185.
23.
VoultsosPTsompanianADeligianniM, et al.A qualitative study of nursing practitioners' experiences with COVID-19 patients dying alone in Greece. Front Public Health2022; 10: 981780.
24.
PeterEMohammedSKillackeyT, et al.Nurses’ experiences of ethical responsibilities of care during the COVID-19 pandemic. Nurs Ethics2022; 29(4).
25.
SilvermanHJKheirbekREMoscou-JacksonG, et al.Moral distress in nurses caring for patients with Covid-19. Nurs Ethics2021; 28: 1137–1164.
26.
FirouzkouhiMAlimohammadiNKakoM, et al.Ethical challenges of nurses related COVID-19 pandemic in inpatient wards: an integrative review. Ethics Med Public Health2021; 18: 100669.
27.
GebreheatGTeameH. Ethical challenges of nurses in COVID-19 pandemic: integrative review. J Multidiscip Healthc2021; 14: 1029–1035.
28.
Emami ZeydiAGhazanfariMJSanandajFS, et al.Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): a literature review from a nursing perspective. Biomedicine2021; 11: 5–14.
29.
RonyMKKIslamKAlamgirHM. Coping strategies that motivated frontline nurses while caring for the COVID-19 patients during the pandemic: a scoping review. J Nurs Manag2022; 30: 1881–1891.
30.
AydogduALF. Ethical dilemmas experienced by nurses while caring for patients during the COVID-19 pandemic: an integrative review of qualitative studies. J Nurs Manag2022; 30: 2245–2258.
31.
RiedelP-LKrehAKulcarV, et al.A scoping review of moral stressors, moral distress and moral injury in healthcare workers during COVID-19. Int J Environ Res Publ Health2022; 19: 1666.
32.
HarrisJLBoothACargoM, et al.Cochrane qualitative and implementation methods group guidance series-paper 2: methods for question formulation, searching, and protocol development for qualitative evidence synthesis. J Clin Epidemiol2018; 97: 39–48.
33.
KahrassHBorryPGastmansC, et al.PRISMA-Ethics–Reporting guideline for systematic reviews on ethics literature: development, explanations and examples. Peoria, IL: OSF, 2021.
34.
JametonA. What moral distress in nursing history could suggest about the future of health care. AMA J Ethics2017; 19: 617–628.
35.
MoolaSMunnZSearsK, et al.Conducting systematic reviews of association (etiology): the Joanna Briggs Institute’s approach. Int J Evid Base Healthc2015; 13: 163–169.
36.
BriscoeSBethelARogersM. Conduct and reporting of citation searching in Cochrane systematic reviews: a cross-sectional study. Res Synth Methods2020; 11: 169–180.
37.
HawkerSPayneSKerrC, et al.Appraising the evidence: reviewing disparate data systematically. Qual Health Res2002; 12: 1284–1299.
38.
LorencTPetticrewMWhiteheadM, et al.Crime, fear of crime and mental health: synthesis of theory and systematic reviews of interventions and qualitative evidence. Publ Health Res2014; 2: 1–398.
39.
BraithwaiteJHerkesJLudlowK, et al.Association between organisational and workplace cultures, and patient outcomes: systematic review. BMJ Open2017; 7: e017708.
40.
Dierckx de CasterléBGastmansCBryonE, et al.QUAGOL: a guide for qualitative data analysis. Int J Nurs Stud2012; 49: 360–371.
41.
Dierckx de CasterléBDe VliegherKGastmansC, et al.Complex qualitative data analysis: lessons learned from the experiences with the qualitative analysis guide of Leuven. Qual Health Res2021; 31: 1083–1093.
42.
BergmanLFalkACWolfA, et al.Registered nurses’ experiences of working in the intensive care unit during the COVID‐19 pandemic. Nurs Crit Care2021; 26: 467–475.
43.
GalehdarNKamranAToulabiT, et al.Exploring nurses’ experiences of psychological distress during care of patients with COVID-19: a qualitative study. BMC Psychiatr2020; 20: 489.
44.
JiaYXChenOXiaoZY, et al.Nurses’ ethical challenges caring for people with COVID-19: a qualitative study. Nurs Ethics2021; 28: 33–45.
45.
Ghanbari-AfraLSalamatAHamidiH, et al.Compassion-based care for COVID-19 patients: a qualitative analysis of nurses' perceptions. J Med Ethics Hist Med2021; 14: 19.
46.
Moghaddam-TabriziFSodeifyR. Lived experiences of nurses in the care of patients with COVID-19: a study of hermeneutic phenomenology. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res2021; 26: 537–543.
47.
RheaumeABreauMBoudreauS. A critical incident study of ICU nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic. Nurs Ethics2022; 29: 317–329.
48.
HeydarikhayatNGhanbarzehiNShahkaramzehiZ, et al.Nurses’ lived experiences of caring for patients with COVID-19: a phenomenological study. J Res Nurs2022; 27: 313–327.
49.
LeeNYLeeHJ. South Korean nurses’ experiences with patient xare at a COVID-19-designated hospital: growth after the frontline battle against an infectious disease pandemic. Int J Environ Res Publ Health2020; 17: 9015.
50.
SlettmyrASchandlAAndermoS, et al.Spontaneous ethics in nurses’ willingness to work during a pandemic. Nurs Ethics2022; 29: 1293–1303.
51.
MailaniFMuthiaRHurianiE, et al.The challenges of intensive care unit nurses caring for COVID-19 patients in Indonesia: a qualitative study. Nurs Med J Nursing2022; 12: 233–248.
52.
AkkusYKaracanYGuneyR, et al.Experiences of nurses working with COVID-19 patients: a qualitative study. J Clin Nurs2021; 31: 1243–1257.
53.
AbbasiniaMNorouzadehRAdib-HajbagheryM, et al.Nurses’ experiences of providing ethical care to the patients with COVID-19: a phenomenological study. Ethics Med Public Health2022; 22: 100717.
54.
KaracaTÖzkanSA. Intensive care nurses’ ethical challenges caring for people with COVID-19: a qualitative study. Acıbadem Üniversitesi Sağlık Bilimleri Dergisi2021; 12: 753–759.
55.
González-GilMTOter-QuintanaCMartínez-MarcosM, et al.The value of human resources: experience of critical care nurses during the COVID-19 epidemic. Enfermería Intensiva2022; 33: 77–88.
56.
LemmoDVitaleRGirardiC, et al.Moral distress events and emotional trajectories in nursing narratives during the COVID-19 pandemic. Int J Environ Res Publ Health2022; 19: 8349.
57.
MelnikovSKaganIFelizardoH, et al.Practices and experiences of European frontline nurses under the shadow of COVID-19. Nurs Health Sci2022; 24: 405–413.
58.
SlettmyrAArmanMAndermoS, et al.Intensive care nurses’ lived experience of altruism and sacrifices during the Covid-19 pandemic: a phenomenological study. J Adv Nurs2023; 79: 244–253.
59.
RezaeeNMardani-HamoolehMSerajiM. Nurses’ perception of ethical challenges in caring for patients with COVID-19: a qualitative analysis. J Med Ethics Hist Med2020; 13: 23.
60.
PeterEVariathCMohammedS, et al.Nurses’ experiences of their ethical responsibilities during coronavirus outbreaks: a scoping review. Can J Nurs Res2022; 2022: 8445621221080153.
61.
LuoYFengXWangD, et al.Experience of clinical nurses engaged in caring for patients with COVID-19: a qualitative systematic review and meta-synthesis. J Clin Nurs2023; 32: 5258–5273.
62.
VanlaereLGastmansC. Ethics in nursing education: learning to reflect on care practices. Nurs Ethics2007; 14: 758–766.
63.
BlissSBaltzlyDBullR, et al.A role for virtue in unifying the ‘knowledge’ and ‘caring’ discourses in nursing theory. Nurs Inq2017; 24: e12191.
64.
LazenbyM. Caring matters most : the ethical significance of nursing. New York: Oxford University Press, 2017.
65.
NortvedtP. Sensitive judgement: an inquiry into the foundations of nursing ethics. Nurs Ethics1998; 5: 385–392.
66.
JooJYLiuMF. Nurses’ barriers to caring for patients with COVID-19: a qualitative systematic review. Int Nurs Rev2021; 68: 202–213.
67.
MiltonCL. The ethics of human dignity: a nursing theoretical perspective. Nurs Sci Q2008; 21: 207–210.
68.
NådenDErikssonK. Understanding the importance of values and moral attitudes in nursing care in preserving human dignity. Nurs Sci Q2004; 17: 86–91.
69.
International Council of Nurses. The ICN code of ethics. Geneva, Switzerland: International Council of Nurses, 2021.
70.
LawlessJA. Dignity in the work lives of clinical nurses. Southampton, UK: University of Southampton, 2009.
71.
StievanoABellassSRoccoG, et al.Nursing’s professional respect as experienced by hospital and community nurses. Nurs Ethics2018; 25: 665–683.
72.
StievanoASabatinoLAffonsoD, et al.Nursing’s professional dignity in palliative care: exploration of an Italian context. J Clin Nurs2019; 28: 1633–1642.
73.
CombrinckYVan WykNCMogaleRS. Preserving nurses’ professional dignity: Six evidence‐based strategies. Int Nurs Rev2022; 69: 106–113.
74.
ValizadehLZamanzadehVHabibzadehH, et al.Threats to nurses’ dignity and intent to leave the profession. Nurs Ethics2018; 25: 520–531.
75.
AbbasiAKhachianAEbadiA, et al.Threats to professional dignity of Iranian clinical nurses: a qualitative study. Nurs Open2023; 10: 2366–2375.
76.
KhademiMMohammadiEVanakiZ. Nurses’ experiences of violation of their dignity. Nurs Ethics2012; 19: 328–340.
77.
McKennaH. Covid-19: ethical issues for nurses. Int J Nurs Stud2020; 110: 103673.
78.
JuujärviSRonkainenKSilvennoinenP. The ethics of care and justice in primary nursing of older patients. Clin Ethics2019; 14: 187–194.
79.
JurchakMGracePJLeeSM, et al.Developing abilities to navigate through the Grey Zones in complex environments: nurses’ reasons for applying to a clinical ethics residency for nurses. J Nurs Scholarsh2017; 49: 445–455.
80.
HamaidehSH. Moral distress and its correlates among mental health nurses in Jordan. Int J Ment Health Nurs2014; 23: 33–41.
81.
DormanJDRaffin BouchalS. Moral distress and moral uncertainty in medical assistance in dying: a simultaneous evolutionary concept analysis. London, UK: Wiley Online Library, 2020.
82.
McCarthyJGastmansC. Moral distress: a review of the argument-based nursing ethics literature. Nurs Ethics2015; 22: 131–152.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
