Unlocking the Benefits of Gender Diversity: How an Ecological-Belonging Intervention Enhances Performance in Science Classrooms

Abstract

Gender diversity signals inclusivity, but meta-analyses suggest that it does not boost individual or group performance. This research examined whether a social-psychological intervention can unlock the benefits of gender diversity on college physics students’ social and academic outcomes. Analyses of 124 introductory physics classrooms at a large research institution in the eastern United States (N = 3,605) indicated that in classrooms doing “business as usual,” cross-gender collaboration was infrequent, there was a substantial gender gap in physics classroom belonging, and classroom gender diversity had no effect on performance. The ecological-belonging intervention aimed to establish classroom norms that adversity in the course is normal and surmountable. In classrooms receiving the intervention, cross-gender interaction increased 51%, the gender gap in belonging was reduced by 47%, and higher classroom diversity was associated with higher course grades and 1-year grade point average for both men and women. Addressing contextual belongingness norms may help to unlock the benefits of diversity.

Keywords

wise interventions treatment heterogeneity higher education organizational diversity open materials

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aiken

L. S.

West

S. G.

(1991). Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions. Sage Publications, Inc.

Binning

K. R.

Browman

A. S.

(2020). Theoretical, ethical, and policy considerations for conducting social–psychological interventions to close educational achievement gaps. Social Issues and Policy Review, 14, 182–216.

Binning

K. R.

Cook

J. E.

Greenaway

V. P.

Garcia

Apfel

Sherman

D. K.

Cohen

G. L.

(2021). Securing self-integrity over time: Self-affirmation disrupts a negative cycle between psychological threat and academic performance. Journal of Social Issues, 77, 801–823.

Binning

K. R.

Cook

J. E.

Greenaway

V. P.

Garcia

Chen

Apfel

Sherman

D. K.

Cohen

G. L.

(2019). Bolstering trust and reducing discipline incidents at a diverse middle school: How self-affirmation affects behavioral conduct during the transition to adolescence. Journal of School Psychology, 75, 74–88.

Binning

K. R.

Kaufmann

McGreevy

E. M.

Fotuhi

Chen

Marshman

Kalender

Z. Y.

Limeri

Betancur

Singh

(2020). Changing social contexts to foster equity in college science courses: An ecological-belonging intervention. Psychological Science, 31, 1059–1070.

Binning

K. R.

Unzueta

M. M.

(2013). Perceiving ethnic diversity on campus: Group differences in attention to hierarchical representation. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 4, 500–507.

Bjorkquist

Bogdan

A. M.

Campbell

N. L.

Chessey

Cochran

G. L.

Cunningham

Esquivel

J. N.

Gladstone

Gosnell

N. M.

Guruswamy

Hallinen

K. M.

Harris

Johnson

J. L.

Jones

Jorgenson

R. A.

McCullough

McNeese

M. D.

Presley

T. D.

. . . Singh

(2019). Women in physics in the United States: Reaching toward equity and inclusion. In AIP conference proceedings (Vol. 2109, No. 1, p. 050040). American Institute of Physics.

Bowman

N. A.

(2011). Promoting participation in a diverse democracy: A meta-analysis of college diversity experiences and civic engagement. Review of Educational Research, 81, 29–68.

Bryan

C. J.

Tipton

Yeager

D. S.

(2021). Behavioural science is unlikely to change the world without a heterogeneity revolution. Nature Human Behaviour, 5, 980–989.

10.

Canning

E. A.

Limeri

L. B.

(2023). Theoretical and methodological directions in mindset intervention research. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 17, Article e12758. https://doi.org/10.1111/spc3.12758

11.

Chen

Binning

K. R.

Manke

K. J.

Brady

S. T.

McGreevy

E. M.

Betancur

Limeri

L. B.

Kaufmann

(2021). Am I a science person? A strong science identity bolsters minority students’ sense of belonging and performance in college. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 47, 593–606.

12.

Cheryan

Ziegler

S. A.

Montoya

A. K.

Jiang

(2017). Why are some STEM fields more gender balanced than others? Psychological Bulletin, 143, 1–35.

13.

Cialdini

R. B.

Wosinska

Barrett

D. W.

Butner

Gornik-Durose

(1999). Compliance with a request in two cultures: The differential influence of social proof and commitment/consistency on collectivists and individualists. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 25, 1242–1253.

14.

Clark

A. E.

Kashima

(2007). Stereotypes help people connect with others in the community: A situated functional analysis of the stereotype consistency bias in communication. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 93, 1028–1039.

15.

Cohen

G. L.

Garcia

Apfel

Master

(2006). Reducing the racial achievement gap: A social-psychological intervention. Science, 313, 1307–1310.

16.

Cohen

G. L.

Sherman

D. K.

(2014). The psychology of change: Self-affirmation and social psychological intervention. Annual Review of Psychology, 65, 333–371.

17.

Coopersmith

Cook

T. D.

Zurovac

Chaplin

Forrow

L. V.

(2022). Internal and external validity of the comparative interrupted time-series design: A meta-analysis. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 41, 252–277.

18.

Corbett

Hill

(2015). Solving the equation: The variables for women’s success in engineering and computing. American Association of University Women. https://www.aauw.org/app/uploads/2020/03/Solving-the-Equation-report-nsa.pdf

19.

Doucette

Clark

Singh

(2020). Hermione and the secretary: How gendered task division in introductory physics labs can disrupt equitable learning. European Journal of Physics, 41, Article 035702. https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6404/ab7831

20.

Eagly

A. H.

(2016). When passionate advocates meet research on diversity, does the honest broker stand a chance? Journal of Social Issues, 72, 199–222.

21.

Easterbrook

M. J.

Hadden

I. R.

(2021). Tackling educational inequalities with social psychology: Identities, contexts, and interventions. Social Issues and Policy Review, 15, 180–236.

22.

Ferrer

R. A.

Cohen

G. L.

(2019). Reconceptualizing self-affirmation with the trigger and channel framework: Lessons from the health domain. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 23(3), 285–304.

23.

Greenaway

V. P.

Turetsky

K. M.

(2020). Socioecological diversity and inclusion: A framework for advancing diversity science. Current Opinion in Psychology, 32, 171–176.

24.

Grutter v. Bollinger, 539 U.S. 306 (2003). https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/539/306/

25.

Hall

R. M.

Sandler

B. R.

(1982). The classroom climate: A chilly one for women? Project on the Status and Education of Women. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED215628.pdf

26.

Hammarlund

S. P.

Davis

Binning

K. R.

Cotner

(2022). Context matters: How an ecological-belonging intervention can reduce inequities in STEM. BioScience, 72, 387–396.

27.

Harrison

D. A.

Klein

K. J.

(2007). What’s the difference? Diversity constructs as separation, variety, or disparity in organizations. Academy of Management Review, 32, 1199–1228.

28.

Higgins

E. T.

Rholes

W. S.

(1978). “Saying is believing”: Effects of message modification on memory and liking for the person described. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 14(4), 363–378.

29.

Kalender

Z. Y.

Marshman

Schunn

C. D.

Nokes-Malach

T. J.

Singh

(2019a). Gendered patterns in the construction of physics identity from motivational factors. Physical Review Physics Education Research, 15, Article 020119. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.15.020119

30.

Kalender

Z. Y.

Marshman

Schunn

C. D.

Nokes-Malach

T. J.

Singh

(2019b). Why female science, technology, engineering, and mathematics majors do not identify with physics: They do not think others see them that way. Physical Review Physics Education Research, 15, Article 020148. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.15.020148

31.

Lee

S. L.

Kim

Koenka

A. C.

(2021). Concern or comfort with social comparisons matter in undergraduate physics courses: Joint consideration of situated expectancy-value theory, mindsets, and gender. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 67, Article 102023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2021.102023

32.

Leslie

S. J.

Cimpian

Meyer

Freeland

(2015). Expectations of brilliance underlie gender distributions across academic disciplines. Science, 347, 262–265.

33.

Singh

(2021). Effect of gender, self-efficacy, and interest on perception of the learning environment and outcomes in calculus-based introductory physics courses. Physical Review Physics Education Research, 17, Article 010143. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.17.010143

34.

Maceira

H. M.

(2017). Economic benefits of gender equality in the EU. Intereconomics, 52, 178–183.

35.

Maloy

Kwapisz

M. B.

Hughes

B. E.

(2022). Factors influencing retention of transgender and gender nonconforming students in undergraduate STEM majors. CBE—Life Sciences Education, 21, Article ar13. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.21-05-0136

36.

Mannix

Neale

M. A.

(2005). What differences make a difference? The promise and reality of diverse teams in organizations. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 6, 31–55.

37.

Marshman

E. M.

Kalender

Z. Y.

Nokes-Malach

Schunn

C. D.

Singh

(2018). Female students with A’s have similar physics self-efficacy as male students with C’s in introductory courses: A cause for alarm? Physical Review Physics Education Research, 14, Article 020123. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.14.020123

38.

Marshman

Kalender

Z. Y.

Schunn

Nokes-Malach

Singh

(2017). A longitudinal analysis of students’ motivational characteristics in introductory physics courses: Gender differences. Canadian Journal of Physics, 96, 391–405.

39.

Muragishi

G. A.

Aguilar

Carr

P. B.

Walton

G. M.

(2023). Microinclusions: Treating women as respected work partners increases a sense of fit in technology companies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspi0000430

40.

Murphy

M. C.

Steele

C. M.

Gross

J. J.

(2007). Signaling threat: How situational cues affect women in math, science, and engineering settings. Psychological Science, 18, 879–885.

41.

Okonofua

J. A.

Harris

L. T.

Walton

G. M.

(2022). Sidelining bias: A situationist approach to reduce the consequences of bias in real-world contexts. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 31(5), 395–404.

42.

Page

S. E.

(2007). Making the difference: Applying a logic of diversity. Academy of Management Perspectives, 21, 6–20.

43.

Pettigrew

T. F.

(1998). Intergroup contact theory. Annual Review of Psychology, 49, 65–85.

44.

Post

Byron

(2015). Women on boards and firm financial performance: A meta-analysis. Academy of Management Journal, 58, 1546–1571.

45.

Powers

J. T.

Cook

J. E.

Purdie-Vaughns

Garcia

Apfel

Cohen

G. L.

(2016). Changing environments by changing individuals: The emergent effects of psychological intervention. Psychological Science, 27, 150–160.

46.

Quinn

K. N.

Kelley

M. M.

McGill

K. L.

Smith

E. M.

Whipps

Holmes

N. G.

(2020). Group roles in unstructured labs show inequitable gender divide. Physical Review Physics Education Research, 16, Article 010129. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.16.010129

47.

Sanchez

K. L.

Kalkstein

D. A.

Walton

G. M.

(2022). A threatening opportunity: The prospect of conversations about race-related experiences between Black and White friends. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 122(5), 853–872.

48.

Sawtelle

Brewe

Kramer

L. H.

(2012). Exploring the relationship between self-efficacy and retention in introductory physics. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 49, 1096–1121.

49.

Shadish

W. R.

Cook

T. D.

Campbell

D. T.

(2002). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Houghton Mifflin.

50.

Smith

E. N.

Rozek

C. S.

Manke

K. J.

Dweck

C. S.

Walton

G. M.

(2021). Teacher- versus researcher-provided affirmation effects on students’ task engagement and positive perceptions of teachers. Journal of Social Issues, 77(3), 751–768.

51.

Spybrook

Bloom

Congdon

Hill

Martinez

Raudenbush

(2011). Optimal design for longitudinal and multilevel research: Documentation for the “Optimal Design” software (through Version 3.0). Survey Research Center of the Institute of Social Research at University of Michigan.

52.

Steele

C. M.

(1997). A threat in the air: How stereotypes shape intellectual identity and performance. American Psychologist, 52, 613–629.

53.

Stout

J. G.

Ito

T. A.

Finkelstein

N. D.

Pollock

S. J.

(2013). How a gender gap in belonging contributes to the gender gap in physics participation. In AIP conference proceedings (Vol. 1513, No. 1, pp. 402–405). American Institute of Physics.

54.

Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 600 U.S. (2023). https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/600/20-1199/

55.

Unzueta

M. M.

Binning

K. R.

(2012). Diversity is in the eye of the beholder: How concern for the in-group affects perceptions of racial diversity. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 38, 26–38.

56.

Walton

G. M.

Brady

S. T.

(2020). The social-belonging intervention. In Walton

G. M.

Crum

A. J.

(Eds.), Handbook of wise interventions: How social-psychological insights can help solve problems (pp. 36–62). Guilford Press.

57.

Walton

G. M.

Cohen

G. L.

(2007). A question of belonging: Race, social fit, and achievement. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 92, 82–96.

58.

Walton

G. M.

Logel

Peach

J. M.

Spencer

S. J.

Zanna

M. P.

(2015). Two brief interventions to mitigate a “chilly climate” transform women’s experience, relationships, and achievement in engineering. Journal of Educational Psychology, 107, 468–485.

59.

Walton

G. M.

Murphy

M. C.

Logel

Yeager

D. S.

Goyer

J. P.

Brady

S. T.

Emerson

K. T. U.

Paunesku

Fotuhi

Blodorn

Boucher

K. L.

Carter

R. E.

Gopalan

Henderson

Kroeper

K. M.

Murdock-Perriera

L. A.

Reeves

S. L.

Ablorh

T. T.

Ansari

. . . Krol

(2023). Where and with whom does a brief social-belonging intervention promote progress in college? Science, 380, 499–505.

60.

Walton

G. M.

Yeager

D. S.

(2020). Seed and soil: Psychological affordances in contexts help to explain where wise interventions succeed or fail. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 29, 219–226.

61.

West

Zimmerman

D. H.

(1987). Doing gender. Gender & Society, 1, 125–151.

62.

Yeager

D. S.

Carroll

J. M.

Buontempo

Cimpian

Woody

Crosnoe

Muller

Murray

Mhatre

Kersting

Hulleman

Kudym

Murphy

Duckworth

A. L.

Walton

G. M.

Dweck

C. S.

(2022). Teacher mindsets help explain where a growth-mindset intervention does and doesn’t work. Psychological Science, 33(1), 18–32.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.05 MB