Budget sheets and buy-in: financing community-based waste management in Siem Reap,Cambodia

Abstract

This paper details some of the difficulties in financing a community-based waste management (CBWM) project for the collection of waste in Siem Reap, Cambodia. It presents a series of financing scenarios based on several potential logistical arrangements. The financial variables investigated include labour costs and honorariums, collection fees, charges for secondary collection, land and equipment costs, and educational programmes. The case study illustrates how the loss of a political champion and a lack of cooperation by a private waste collection company derailed the financing of a CBWM project despite the presence of other favourable conditions for its success. The waste collection company's participation was fundamental to ensuring the affordability of secondary waste collection, and this one financial element greatly affected the feasibility of the entire system. The paper concludes that without buy-in and financial cooperation from all stakeholders, the best laid plans for CBWM (and the accompanying budget sheets) are rendered irrelevant.

Keywords

Cambodia community-based waste management project financing Siem Reap waste collection

References

Ali, M. and M. Snel (1999), "WELL study - lessons from community-based initiatives in solid waste", London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK, and WEDC, Loughborough University, UK.

Anand, P.B. (1999), "Waste management in Madras revisited", Environment and Urbanization Vol 11, No 2, October, pages 161-176.

Anschütz, J. (1996), "Community-based solid waste management and water supply projects: problems and solutions compared, a survey of the literature ", Working Document 2, Urban Waste Expertise Programme , accessible online at www.waste.nl.

Assaad, R. (1996), "Formalizing the informal? The transformation of Cairo's refuse collection system", Journal of Planning Education and Research Vol 16, pages 115-126.

Cissé, G. (2003), "From community-based organization to low-income private contract for solid waste collection in a poor settlement", CWG Workshop, 9-14 March, Dar es Salaam.

D'Monte, D. (2005), "How much difference does UNESCO make?", The Art Newspaper, accessible online at www.globalheritagefund.org .

Enayetullah, I. and A H M M Sinha (2000), "Communitybased decentralized composting: experience of Waste Concern in Dhaka", in A H M M Sinha and I Enayetullah (editors), Community-based Solid Waste Management: The Asian Experience, Waste Concern, Dhaka, Bangladesh, pages 63-77.

ENDA/WASTE co-publication (1997), "La participation de la communauté à la gestion des déchets solides à Burkina Faso: collecte des ordures ménagères à Ouagadougou", accessible online at www.waste.nl.

Khulna City Corporation and Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (2000), "Communitybased pilot project on solid waste management in Khulna city: general project description", accessible online at www.wsp.org/publications/sa.

10.

Kingdon, J.W. (2003), Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policy, Second Edition, Longman, New York, 280 pages.

11.

Moningka, L. (2000), "Community participation in solid waste management: factors favouring the sustainability of community participation, a literature review", UWEP Occasional Paper, WASTE, Gouda, The Netherlands.

12.

Muller, M.S. , A. Iyer , M. Keita , B. Sacko and D. Traore (2002), "Differing interpretations of community participation in waste management in Bamako and Bangalore: some methodological considerations ", Environment and Urbanization Vol 14, No 2, October, pages 241-257.

13.

Parizeau, K. , V. Maclaren and Lay Chanthy (2006), "Waste characterization as an element of waste management planning: lessons learned from a study in Siem Reap, Cambodia", Resources, Conservation and Recycling Vol 49, No 20, pages 110-128.

14.

Pfammatter, R. and R. Schertenleib (1996), "Nongovernmental refuse collection in low-income urban areas: lessons learned from selected schemes in Asia, Africa and Latin America", Swiss Federal Institute for Environmental Science and Technology (EAWAG) and SANDEC , Duebendorf, Switzerland.

15.

Romeo, L. and L. Spyckerelle (2004), "Decentralization reforms and commune level services delivery in Cambodia ", Case Study submitted at a Workshop on Local Government Pro-Poor Service Delivery , 9-13 February, Manila .

16.

Salequzzamana, M. , and S. Awal and M. Alam (accessed October2003),"Willingness-to-payforcommunitybased solid waste management and its sustainability in Bangladesh", accessible online at http://www.mesa.edu.au/aaee_conf/Salequzzaman_Awal-Alam.PDF .

17.

Siem Reap Province, Department of Planning ( 2008), "Siem Reap in figures," accessible online at www.siemreap-town.gov.kh/en.

18.

Siem Reap Department of Environment (2003), "Report on solid waste management in Siem Reap", Siem Reap, Cambodia.

19.

van de Klundert, A. and J. Anschütz (2001), "Integrated sustainable waste management - the concept", WASTE, Gouda, The Netherlands.

20.

Wang'ombe, J. (1995), "Public health crises of cities in developing countries" Social Sciences and Medicine Vol 41, pages 857-862.

21.

Zurbrügg, C. , S. Drescher , I. Rytz , A H Md Maqsood Sinha and I. Enayetullah (2005), "Decentralized composting in Bangladesh, a win-win situation for all stakeholders", Resources, Conservation and Recycling Vol 43, pages 281-292.