We analyzed tear film changes, ocular surface tissue alterations and inflammatory conditions in Frequent Replacement Soft (FRS) Contact Lens (CL) or Conventional Soft (CS)-CL wearers suffering from eye discomfort, by applying complementary diagnostic tests. Our data suggest the following conclusions: i) eye discomfort symptoms begin after 1–3 years of successful wear, mainly in FRS-CL wearers; ii) tear film stability is affected by CL wear, mainly in FRS-CL wearers; iii) CL wear produces a subclinical moderate inflammation based on mononuclear cell recruitment in 3 out of 4 patients of both types of lenses; iv) CL wear induces dry eye conditions, more pronounced in FRS-CL users; v) discomfort symptoms, presence of subclinical inflammation, degree of dryness are not directly related to a clinical presentation of intolerance, mainly in FRS-CL wearers; vi) CL wear-related discomfort symptoms should never be underestimated, since a hidden inflammation or dryness can be present beyond an apparently good clinical picture.
IhanB., IrkecM., OrhanM., CelikH.. Surface deposits on frequent replacement and conventional daily wear soft contact lenses: a scanning electron microscopic study.CLAO J1998; 24: 232–5.
3.
MaissaC., FranklinV., GuillonM., TigheB.. Influence of contact lens material surface characteristics and replacement on protein and lipid deposition.Optom Vis Sci1998; 75: 697–705.
4.
SolomonO.D., FreemanM.I., BoshnickE.L.. A 3-years prospective study of the clinical performance of daily disposable contact lenses compared with frequent replacement and conventional daily wear contact lenses.CLAO J1996; 22: 250–7.
5.
LiesegangT.J.. Contact lens-related microbial keratitis: Part I: Epidemiology.Cornea1997; 16: 125–31.
6.
SchaumbergD.A., SnowK.K., DanaM.R.. The epidemic of Acanthamoeba keratitis: where do we stand?Cornea1998; 17: 3–10.
BrewittH.. Contact lenses. Infections and hygiene.Ophthalmologe1997; 94: 311–6.
14.
CoopersmithL., WeinstockF.J.. Current recommendations and practice regarding soft lens replacement and disinfection.CLAO J1997; 23: 172–6.
15.
EggerS.F.. Disposable contact lenses and their complications.Wien Med Wochenschr1997; 147: 295–7.
16.
LempM.A.. Report of the National Eye Institute/Industry Workshop on Clinical Trials in Dry Eyes.CLAO J1995; 21: 221–32.
17.
RavazzoniL., GhiniC., MacriA., RolandoM.. Forecasting of hydrophilic contact lens tolerance by means of tear ferning test?Graefe's Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol1998; 236: 354–8.
18.
GarcherC., BronA., RoyerJ.. Techniques recentes d'exploration de la surface conjonctivale. Editions Techniques. Encycl Med Chir (Paris-France), Optalmologie, 21–130-B, 15:1994; 4.
19.
KogbeO., LiotetS., TiffanyJ.M.. Factors responsible for tear ferning.Cornea1991; 10: 433–44.
20.
VersuraP., ProfazioV., CelliniM., TorreggianiA., CaramazzaR.. Eye discomfort and air pollution.Opththalmologica1999; 213: 103–9.
21.
BoccatoP.O.. Modification of Fisher's method for urine cytology.Acta Cytol1981; 25: 5–6.
22.
OrsoniJ.G., TombaM.C., BonaciniM., ChiariM.. A new filter imprint technique in cytology for ocular lesions.Proc Ass for Eye Res, Sept 16–19, 1987, Leuven-Belgium.
23.
TsengS.C.G.. Staging of conjunctival squamous metaplasia by impression cytology.Ophthalmology1985; 92: 728–33.
24.
WolffE.. The muco-cutaneous junction of the lid-margin and the distribution of the tear fluid.Trans Ophthalmol Soc UK1946; 66: 291–308.
25.
TiffanyJ.M.. Tear film stability and contact lens wear.J Br Contact Lens Assoc (Meeting Suppl),1988; 11: 35–8.
26.
EhlersN.. The precorneal film-biomicroscopical, histological and chemical investigations.Acta Ophthalmol1965; 81(suppl): S5–186.
27.
PrydalJ.I., CampbellF.W.. Study of precorneal tear film thickness and structure by interferometry and confocal microscopy.Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci1992; 33: 1996–2005.
28.
PrydalJ.I., AtalP., WoonH.. Study of human precorneal tear film thickness and structure using laser interferometry.Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci1992; 33: 2006–11.
29.
TomlinsonA., CedarstaffT.H.. Tear evaporation from the human eye. The effects of contact lens wear.J Br Contact Lens Assoc1982; 5: 141–50.
30.
BrennanN.A., EfronN.. Symptomatology of HEMA contact lens wearers.Optom Vis Sci1989; 66: 834–8.
31.
GuillonM., StylesE., GuillonJ.P., MaissaC.. Preocular tear film characteristics of nonwearers and soft contact lens wearers.Optom Vis Sci1997; 74: 273–9.
32.
SharmaA., RuckensteinE.. Mechanism of tear film rupture and its implications for contact lens tolerance.Am J Optom Physiol Opt1985; 62: 246–53.
33.
ItohR., YokoiN., KinoshitaS.. Tear film instability induced by rigid contact lenses.Cornea1999; 18: 440–3.
34.
MannucciL.L., PozzanM., FregonaI., SecchiA.G.. The effect of extended wear contact lenses on tear immunoglobulins.CLAO J1984; 10: 163–5.
35.
TemelA., KazokogluH., TagaY., OrkanA.L.. The effect of contact lens wear on tear immonoglobulins.CLAO J1991; 17: 69–71.
36.
SainiJ.S., DharS., SharmaA.. Role of tear secretory IgA in hard contact lens-related changes in the tarsal conjunctiva.Can J Ophthalmol1992; 27: 299–301.
37.
KijlstraA., PolackB.C., LuyendijkL.. Transient decrease of secretory IgA in tear during rigid gas permeable contact lens wear.Curr Eye Res1992; 11: 123–6.
38.
PearceD.J., DemirciG., WillcoxM.D.. Secretory IgA epitopes in basal tears of extended-wear soft contact lens wearers and in non-lens wearers.Aust NZJ Ophthalmol1999; 27: 221–3.
39.
McCellanK.A., CrippsA.W., ClancyR.L., BillsonF.A.. The effect of successful contact lens wear on mucosal immunity of the eye.Ophthalmology1998; 105: 1471–7.
40.
LundhR.L., LiotetS., PouliquenY.. Study of the human blood-tear barrier and the biochemical changes in the tears of 30 contact lens wearers (50 eyes).Ophthalmologica1984; 188: 100–5.
41.
LanJ.X., WillcoxM.D., JacksonG.D., ThakurA.. Effect of tear secretory IgA on chemotaxis of polymorphonuclear leukocytes.Aust N Z J Ophthalmol1998; 26(Suppl 1): S36–9.
42.
ThakurA., WillcoxM.D.. Contact lens wear alters the production of certain inflammatory mediators in tears.Exp Eye Res2000; 70: 255–9.
43.
ConnorC.G., CampbellJ.B., SteelS.A., BurkeJ.H.. The effects of daily wear contact lenses on goblet cell density.J Omptom Assoc1994; 65: 792–4.
44.
ConnorC.G., CampbellJ.B., SteelS.A.. The effects of disposable daily wear contact lenses on globet cell count.CLAO J1997; 23: 37–9.
45.
SainiJ.S., RajwanshiA., DharS.. Clinicopathological correlation of hard contact lens related changes in tarsal conjunctiva by impression cytology.Acta Ophthalmol1990; 68: 65–70.
