This article examines the role recruitment agents play in the complex web of forced labour. Our focus is the abusive treatment of Indonesian crew onboard South Korean factory trawlers fishing in New Zealand’s waters. We gathered data from multiple sources: (1) documents, including Indonesia’s national legislation and migrants’ employment contracts; (2) 27 interviews with Indonesian crew; and (3) translation work for New Zealand government ministries, court cases, and film productions. We analyse how recruitment agents are implicated, as seen through the crew’s eyes, in three phases – before departure, onboard the vessels, and following their return home.
Advocates for Public Interest Law (APIL) and International Organization for Migration (IOM) (2017) Tied at sea: Human rights violations of migrant workers on Korean fishing vessels. Available at: https://issuu.com/apilkorea/docs/tied_at_sea_english (accessed 6 June 2020).
2.
AllainJCraneALeBaronG, et al. (2013) Forced Labour’s Business Models and Supply Chains. Belfast: Joseph Rowntree Foundation & Queens University.
AsisMBPiperNRaghuramP (2019) From Asia to the world: ‘Regional’ contributions to global migrant research. Revue Européenne des Migrations Internationales35: 13–37.
5.
AtkinsonPACoffeyA (2004) Analysing documentary realities. In: SilvermanD (ed.) Qualitative Research: Theory, Method and Practice. 2nd ed.London: SAGE, pp. 56–75.
6.
BarrientosS (2013) ‘Labour chains’: Analysing the role of labour contractors in global production networks. The Journal of Development Studies49: 1058–1071.
7.
BarrientosSMayerFPicklesJ, et al. (2011) Decent work in global production networks: Framing the policy debate. International Labour Review150: 297–317.
8.
BastiaTMcGrathT (2011) Temporality, migration and unfree labour: Migrant garment workers. Manchester papers in political economy, working paper no. 6. Manchester: University of Manchester.
9.
BattistellaG (2014) Migration in Asia: In search of a theoretical framework. In: BattistellaG (ed.) Global and Asian Perspectives on International Migration: Global Migration Issues, vol. 4. Cham: Springer, pp. 1–25.
10.
BowenGA (2009) Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qualitative Research Journal9: 27–40.
11.
ChantavanichSLaodumrongchaiSStringerC (2016) Under the shadow: Forced labour among sea fishers in Thailand. Marine Policy68: 1–7.
12.
ChiX (2007) Challenging managed temporary labor migration as a model for rights and development for labor-sending countries. New York University Journal of International Law and Politics40: 497–540.
13.
CorbinJStraussA (2008) Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. 3rd ed.Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
14.
CraneALeBaronGAllainJ, et al. (2019) Governance gaps in eradicating forced labor: From global to domestic supply chains. Regulation & Governance13: 86–106.
15.
CranstonSSchapendonkJSpaanE (2018) New directions in exploring the migration industries: Introduction to special issue. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies44: 543–557.
16.
CumbersANativelCRoutledgeP (2008) Labour agency and union positionalities in global production networks. Journal of Economic Geography8: 369–387.
17.
DavidFBryantKLarsenJ (2019) Migrants and Their Vulnerability to Human Trafficking, Modern Slavery and Forced Labour. Geneva: International Organization for Migration.
18.
DeshingkarPAwumbilaMTeyeJK (2019) Victims of trafficking and modern slavery or agents of change? Migrants, brokers, and the state in Ghana and Myanmar. Journal of the British Academy7: 77–106.
19.
EdmondsonACMcManusSE (2007) Methodological fit in management field research. Academy of Management Review32: 1155–1179.
20.
EnrightB (2013) (Re)considering new agents: A review of labour market intermediaries within labour geography. Geography Compass7: 287–299.
21.
EveredRLouisMR (1981) Alternative perspectives in the organizational sciences: ‘Inquiry from the inside’ – And ‘inquiry from the outside’. Academy of Management Review6: 385–395.
22.
FarbenblumB (2017) Governance of migrant worker recruitment: A rights-based framework for countries of origin. Asian Journal of International Law7: 152–184.
23.
FarbenblumBNolanJ (2017) The business of migrant worker recruitment: Who has the responsibility and leverage to protect rights?Texas International Law Journal52: 1–44.
GereffiG (2014) Global value chains in a post-Washington consensus world. Review of International Political Economy21: 9–37.
26.
GereffiGHumphreyJSturgeonTJ (2005) The governance of global value chains. Review of International Political Economy12: 78–104.
27.
GohCWeeKYeohBS (2017) Migration governance and the migration industry in Asia: Moving domestic workers from Indonesia to Singapore. International Relations of the Asia-Pacific17: 401–433.
28.
GordonJ (2015) Global labour recruitment in a supply chain context. International Labour Organization fundamentals working paper, 24 June. International Labour Organisation, Geneva.
29.
Indonesian Government Regulation 3/2013 concerning Protection of Indonesian Migrant workers Abroad.
30.
International Labour Organization (ILO) (2005) A Global Alliance Against Forced Labour: Global Report under the Follow-up to the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, International Labour Conference, 93rd Session. Geneva: International Labour Organisation.
31.
International Labour Organization (ILO) Private Employment Agencies Convention, 1997 (No. 181).
32.
International Organization for Migration (IOM) (2010) Labour Migration from Indonesia: An Overview of Indonesian Migration to Selected Destinations in Asia and the Middle East. Jakarta, Indonesia: IOM.
KarimMF (2017) Institutional dynamics of regulatory actors in the recruitment of migrant workers. Asian Journal of Social Science45: 440–464.
36.
Law on Placement and Protection of Indonesian Workers Abroad No. 39/2004 (Indonesia).
37.
LeeJ (2016) Global supply chain dynamics and labour governance: Implications for social upgrading. ILO research paper no. 14. Geneva: International Labour Office.
38.
LercheJ (2007) A global alliance against forced labour? Unfree labour, neo-liberal globalization and the International Labour Organization. Journal of Agrarian Change7: 425–452.
39.
LindquistJXiangBYeohBS (2012) Opening the black box of migration: Brokers, the organization of transnational mobility and the changing political economy in Asia. Pacific Affairs85: 7–19.
40.
McCollumDFindlayA (2018) Oiling the wheels? Flexible labour markets and the migration industry. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies44: 558–574.
41.
McCollumDShubinSApsiteE, et al. (2013) Re-thinking labour migration channels: The experience of Latvia from EU accession to economic recession. Population, Space and Place19: 688–702.
42.
MarschkeMVandergeestP (2016) Slavery scandals: Unpacking labour challenges and policy responses within the off-shore fisheries sector. Marine Policy68: 39–46.
43.
MartinPL (2017) Merchants of Labor: Recruiters and International Labor Migration. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
44.
MichailovaSStringerC (2018) Tackling the ugliest phenomenon of our times, modern slavery: An invitation to the IB scholarly community. AIB Insights18: 7–10.
45.
Ministry of Foreign Affairs Regulation 4/2008 concerning Services to Citizens at Foreign Missions of the Republic of Indonesia; and Guideline on Providing Services to and Protection of Indonesian Citizens Abroad (Indonesia).
46.
Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration Ministerial Regulation 7/2010 concerning Insurance for Indonesian Migrant Workers (PER.07/MEN/V/2010) (Indonesia).
47.
Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration Ministerial Regulation 14/2010 on the Implementation of Placement and Protection of Migrant workers (PER.14/MEN/X/2010) (Indonesia).
48.
Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration Ministerial Regulation 12/2011 concerning Labor Attachés and Labor Technical Staff in Indonesian Foreign Missions Abroad (PER.12/MEN/X/2011) (Indonesia).
49.
PalmerWJ (2014) Discretion and the building of institutions: A critical examination of the administration of Indonesia’s overseas labour migration programme. PhD Thesis, The University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
PhillipsN (2013) Unfree labour and adverse incorporation in the global economy: Comparative perspectives on Brazil and India. Economy and Society42: 171–196.
52.
PhillipsNMieresF (2015) The governance of forced labour in the global economy. Globalizations12: 244–260.
53.
PhillipsNSakamotoL (2012) Global production networks, chronic poverty and ‘slave labour’ in Brazil. Studies in Comparative International Development47: 287–315.
54.
PiperNRosewarneSWithersM (2017) Migrant precarity in Asia: ‘Networks of labour activism’ for a rights-based governance of migration. Development and Change48: 1089–1110.
55.
PosthumaARossiA (2017) Coordinated governance in global value chains: Supranational dynamics and the role of the International Labour Organization. New Political Economy22: 186–202.
56.
PrattMG (2009) For the lack of boilerplate: Tips on writing up (and reviewing) qualitative research. Academy of Management Journal52: 856–862.
57.
Protection of Indonesian Migrant Workers Act (Perlindungan Pekerja Migran Indonesia) (No. 18/2017) (Indonesia).
58.
RaiP (2020) The geographies of intermediation: Labor intermediaries, labor migration, and cane harvesting in rural western India. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 52: 1221–1236.
59.
RapleyT (2007) Doing Conversation, Discourse and Document Analysis. London: SAGE.
60.
ReineckeJDonagheyJWilkinsonA, et al. (2018) Global supply chains and social relations at work: Brokering across boundaries. Human Relations71: 459–480.
61.
RogalyB (2008) Migrant workers in the ILO’s global alliance against forced labour report: A critical appraisal. Third World Quarterly29: 1431–1447.
62.
SetyawatiD (2013) Assets or commodities? Comparing regulations of placement and protection of migrant workers in Indonesia and the Philippines. Aseas-Österreichische Zeitschrift für Südostasienwissenschaften6: 264–280.
63.
SkrivankovaK (2014) Forced Labour in the United Kingdom. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
64.
SoundararajanVKhanZTarbaSY (2018) Beyond brokering: Sourcing agents, boundary work and working conditions in global supply chains. Human Relations71: 481–509.
65.
StakeRE (1995) The Art of Case Study Research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
66.
StakeRE (2000) Case studies. In: DenzinNKLincolnYS (eds) Handbook of Qualitative Research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, pp. 435–454.
67.
StraussK (2013) Unfree again: Social reproduction, flexible labour markets and the resurgence of gang labour in the UK. Antipode45: 180–197.
68.
StringerCMichailovaS (2018) Why modern slavery thrives in multinational corporations’ global value chains. Multinational Business Review26: 194–206.
69.
StringerCHughesSWhittakerDH, et al. (2016) Labour standards and regulation in global value chains: The case of the New Zealand fishing industry. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space48: 1910–1927.
70.
StringerCSimmonsGCoulstonD, et al. (2014) Not in New Zealand’s waters, surely? Linking labour issues to GPNs. Journal of Economic Geography14: 739–758.
71.
VandergeestPMarschkeM (2020) Modern slavery and freedom: Exploring contradictions through labour scandals in the Thai fisheries. Antipode52: 291–315.
WeeKGohCYeohBS (2020) Translating people and policy: The role of maid agents in brokering between employers and migrant domestic workers in Singapore’s migration industry. International Migration Review54: 992–1015.
74.
World Bank (2017) Indonesia’s Global Workers: Juggling Opportunities and Risks. Jakarta, Indonesia: World Bank.
75.
YeaS (2014) Trafficking on the high seas: The exploitation of migrant fishermen in southeast Asia’s long haul fishing industry. In: HofmeisterWRueppelP (eds) Trafficking in Human Beings Learning from Asian and European Experiences. Singapore: Konrad-Adenauer Stiftung, East Asian Institute, European Policy Centre and European Union Centre in Singapore, pp. 85–96.
76.
ZajakSEgels-ZandénNPiperN (2017) Networks of labour activism: Collective action across Asia and beyond – An introduction to the debate. Development and Change48: 899–921.
