The Competency-Based Training program in Intensive Care Medicine in Europe identified 12 competency domains. Professionalism was given a prominence equal to technical ability. However, little information pertaining to fellows’ views on professionalism is available.
A nationwide qualitative study was performed. The moderator asked participants to clarify the terms professionalism and professional behaviour, and to explore the questions “How do you learn the mentioned aspects?” and “What ways of learning do you find useful or superfluous?”. Qualitative data analysis software (MAXQDA2007) facilitated analysis using an inductive coding approach. Thirty-five fellows across eight groups participated. The themes most frequently addressed were communication, keeping distance and boundaries, medical knowledge and expertise, respect, teamwork, leadership and organisation and management. Medical knowledge, expertise and technical skills seem to become more tacit when training progresses. Topics can be categorised into themes of workplace-based learning, by gathering practical experience, by following examples and receiving feedback on action, including learning from own and others’ mistakes. Formal teaching courses (e.g. communication) and scheduled sessions addressing professionalism aspects were also valued.
The emerging themes considered most relevant for intensivists were adequate communication skills and keeping boundaries with patients and relatives. Professionalism is mainly learned ‘on the job’ from role models in the intensive care unit. Formal teaching courses and sessions addressing professionalism aspects were nevertheless valued, and learning from own and others’ mistakes was considered especially useful. Self-reflection as a starting point for learning professionalism was stressed.
StephensonA.E., AdsheadL.E., HiggsR.H.The teaching of professional attitudes within UK medical schools: reported difficulties and good practice.Med Educ2006; 40: 1072–1080.
2.
LeeA.G., BeaverH.A., BoldtH.C., OlsonR., OettingT.A., AbramoffM.Teaching and assessing professionalism in ophthalmology residency training programs.Surv Ophthalmol2007; 52: 300–314.
3.
PapadakisM.A., TeheraniA., BanachM.A., KnettlerT.R., RattnerS.L., SternD.T.Disciplinary action by medical boards and prior behavior in medical school.N Engl J Med2005; 353: 2673–2682.
4.
PapadakisM.A., ArnoldG.K., BlankL.L., HolmboeE.S., LipnerR.S.Performance during internal medicine residency training and subsequent disciplinary action by state licensing boards.Ann Intern Med2008; 148: 869–876.
5.
Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education.ACGME Outcome Project enhancing residency education throught outcomes assessment: General competencies1999. From http://www.acgme.org/outcome/comp/compFull.asp Accessed February 2006.
BionJ.F., BarrettH.Development of core competencies for an international training programme in intensive care medicine.Intensive Care Med2006; 32: 1371–1383.
9.
HoffT.J., PohlH., BartfieldJ.Creating a learning environment to produce competent residents: the roles of culture and context.Acad Med2004; 79: 532–539.
10.
BrownJ., ChapmanT., GrahamD.Becoming a new doctor: a learning or survival exercise?Med Educ2007; 41: 653–660.
11.
TeunissenP.W.Unravelling learning by doing. Thesis. Amsterdam 2009. ISBN 978-90-9023787-9.
12.
BrownellA.K., CoteL.Senior residents’ views on the meaning of professionalism and how they learn about it.Acad Med2001; 76: 734–737.
13.
van MookWNKA, de GraveW.S., GorterS.L., MuijtjensA.M.M., ZwavelingJ.H., SchuwirthL.W.Fellows’ in intensive care medicine views on professionalism and how they learn it.Intensive Care Med2010; 36: 296–303.
14.
GorterS., ScherpbierA., BrauerJ., RethansJ-J, van der HeijdeD., HoubenH.Doctor-patient interaction: standardized patients’ reflections from inside the rheumatological office.J Rheumatol2002; 29: 1496–1500.
15.
Visschers-PleijersAJSF, DolmansDHJM, de GraveW.S., WolfhagenIHAP, JacobsJ.A., van der VleutenC.P.M.Student perceptions about the characteristics of an effective discussion during the reporting phase in problem-based learning.Med Educ2006; 40: 924–931.
KruegerR.A., CaseyM.A.Focus Groups. A practical guide for applied research, 3rd ed.Sage Publications, Inc., California2000.
18.
MAXQDA.Verbi Gmbh, Marburg, Germany2007.
19.
GlaserB.G., StraussA.The Discovery of Grounded Theory.Strategies for qualitative research.Aldine de Gruyter, New York1967.
20.
BoeijeH.Analysis in Qualitative Research.Sage Publications Ltd, London2009.
21.
WagnerP., HendrichJ., MoseleyG., HudsonV.Defining medical professionalism: a qualitative study.Med Educ2007; 41: 288–294.
22.
EphgraveK., StansfieldR.B., WoodheadJ., SharpW.J., GeorgeT., LawrenceJ.The resident view of professionalism behavior frequency in outstanding and “not outstanding” faculty.Am J Surg2006; 191: 701–705.
23.
RatanawongsaN., BolenS., HowellE.E., KernD.E., SissonS.D., LarriviereD.Residents’ perceptions of professionalism in training and practice: barriers, promoters, and duty hour requirements.J Gen Intern Med2006; 21: 758–763.
24.
RowleyB.D., BaldwinD.C.Jr., BayR.C., CannulaM.Can professional values be taught? A look at residency training.Clin Orthop Relat Res2000; n/a: 110–114.
25.
ReedD.A., WestC.P., MuellerP.S., FicaloraR.D., EngstlerG.J., BeckmanT.J.Behaviors of highly professional resident physicians.JAMA2008; 300: 1326–1333.
26.
HauraniM.J., RubinfeldI., RaoS., BeaubienJ., MusialJ.L., ParkerA.Are the communication and professionalism competencies the new critical values in a resident's global evaluation process?J Surg Educ2007; 64: 351–356.
27.
WhitcombM.E.Communication and professionalism.Patient Educ Couns2000; 41: 137–144.
28.
HodgesB., TurnbullJ., CohenR., BienenstockA., NormanG.Evaluating communication skills in the OSCE format: reliability and generalizability.Med Educ1996; 30: 38–43.
29.
ReesC., SheardC., McPhersonA.Medical students’ views and experiences of methods of teaching and learning communication skills.Patient Educ Couns2004; 54: 119–121.
30.
SchnablG.K., HassardT.H., KopelowM.L.The assessment of interpersonal skills using standardized patients.Acad Med1991; 66: S34–36.
31.
LewinL.O., Cole-KellyK., GreenfieldM.A year-long course for third-year students on ethics, professionalism, and communication.Acad Med2001; 76: 511.
AzoulayE., PochardF., ChevretS., LemaireF., MokhtariM., Le GallJ.R.Meeting the needs of intensive care unit patient families: a multicenter study.Am J Respir Crit Care Med2001; 163: 135–139.
34.
AngusD.C.Charting (and publishing) the boundaries of critical illness.Am J Respir Crit Care Med2005; 171: 938–939.
35.
SturmbergJ.P., MartinC.M.Knowing – in medicine.J Eval Clin Pract2008; 14: 767–770.
36.
WyattJ.C.Management of explicit and tacit knowledge.J R Soc Med2001; 94: 6–9.
37.
PellegrinoE.D.Professionalism, profession and the virtues of the good physician.Mt Sinai J Med2002; 69: 378–384.
38.
HuddleT.S.Viewpoint: teaching professionalism: is medical morality a competency?Acad Med2005; 80: 885–891.
39.
MolterN.C.Needs of relatives of critically ill patients: a descriptive study.Heart Lung1979; 8: 332–339.
40.
HolderK.V., SchenthalS.J.Watch your step: nursing and professional boundaries.Nurs Manage2007; 38: 24–29; quiz 29-30.
41.
SheetsV.R.Staying in the lines.Nurs Manage2000; 31: 28–33; quiz 33-34.
42.
van MookWNKA, de GraveW.S., WassV., O'SullivanH., ZwavelingJ.H., SchuwirthL.W.Professionalism: evolution of the concept.Eur J Intern Med2009; 20: e81–84.
43.
PageD.W.Professionalism and team care in the clinical setting.Clin Anat2006; 19: 468–472.
44.
CharapM.Reducing resident work hours: unproven assumptions and unforeseen outcomes.Ann Intern Med2004; 140: 814–815.
45.
MiedemaB., EasleyJ., FortinP., HamiltonR., TatemichiS.Crossing boundaries: family physicians’ struggles to protect their private lives.Can Fam Physician2009; 55: 286–287.e5.
46.
LapidM., MoutierC., DunnL., HammondK.G., RobertsL.W.Professionalism and ethics education on relationships and boundaries: psychiatric residents’ training preferences.Acad Psychiatry2009; 33: 461–469.
47.
VeloskiJ.J., HojatM.Measuring specific elements of professionalism: empathy, teamwork and lifelong learning. In: SternD.T., ed. Measuring Medical Professionalism.New York: Oxford University Press2006.
48.
KnausW.A., DraperE.A., WagnerD.P., ZimmermanJ.E.An evaluation of outcome from intensive care in major medical centers.Ann Intern Med1986; 104: 410–418.
49.
GibsonS.J., MartinS.M., JohnsonM.B., BlueR., MillerD.S.CNS-directed case management. Cost and quality in harmony.J Nurs Adm1994; 24: 45–51.
50.
General Medical Council.Tomorrow's Doctors: recommendations on undergraduate medical education.General Medical Council, London2003.
51.
TallisR.C.Doctors in society: medical professionalism in a changing world.Clin Med2006; 6: 7–12.
52.
TeunissenP.W., ScheeleF., ScherpbierAJJA, van der VleutenC.P.M., BoorK., van LuijkS.J.How residents learn: qualitative evidence for the pivotal role of clinical activities.Med Educ2007; 41: 763–770.
53.
BoeninkA.D.Teaching and learning reflection on medical professionalism. Thesis. Gildeprint Drukkerijen B.V., Enschede2006. ISBN 90-8659-031-4.
54.
WrightS., WongA., NewillC.The impact of role models on medical students.J Gen Intern Med1997; 12: 53–56.
55.
WrightS.M., CarreseJ.A.Excellence in role modelling: insight and perspectives from the pros.CMAJ2002; 167: 638–643.
56.
WrightS.M., KernD.E., KolodnerK., HowardD.M., BrancatiF.L.Attributes of excellent attending-physician role models.N Engl J Med1998; 339: 1986–1993.
57.
JonesW.S., HansonJ.L., LongacreJ.L.An intentional modeling process to teach professional behavior: students’ clinical observations of preceptors.Teach Learn Med2004; 16: 264–269.
58.
HicksL.K., LinY., RobertsonD.W., RobinsonD.L., WoodrowS.I.Understanding the clinical dilemmas that shape medical students’ ethical development: questionnaire survey and focus group study.BMJ2001; 322: 709–710.
59.
HaffertyF.Measuring medical professonalism: a commentary. In: SternDT, ed. Measuring Medical Professionalism.New York: Oxford University Press2006.
60.
ShrankW.H., ReedV.A., JernstedtG.C.Fostering professionalism in medical education: a call for improved assessment and meaningful incentives.J Gen Intern Med2004; 19: 887–892.
61.
WassersteinA.G., BrennanP.J., RubensteinA.H.Institutional leadership and faculty response: fostering professionalism at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine.Acad Med2007; 82: 1049–1056.
62.
HumphreyH.J., SmithK., ReddyS., ScottD., MadaraJ.L., AroraV.M.Promoting an environment of professionalism: the University of Chicago “Roadmap”.Acad Med2007; 82: 1098–1107.
63.
SmithK.L., SaavedraR., RaekeJ.L., O'DonellA.A.The journey to creating a campus-wide culture of professionalism.Acad Med2007; 82: 1015–1021.
64.
SuchmanA.L., WilliamsonP.R., LitzelmanD.K., FrankelR.M., MossbargerD.L., InuiT.S.Toward an informal curriculum that teaches professionalism. Transforming the social environment of a medical school.J Gen Intern Med2004; 19: 501–504.
65.
ChristiansonC.E., McBrideR.B., VariR.C., OlsonL., WilsonH.D.From traditional to patient-centered learning: curriculum change as an intervention for changing institutional culture and promoting professionalism in undergraduate medical education.Acad Med2007; 82: 1079–1088.
66.
Fryer-EdwardsK., Van EatonE., GoldsteinE.A., KimballH.R., VeithR.C., PellegriniC.A.Overcoming institutional challenges through continuous professionalism improvement: the University of Washington experience.Acad Med2007; 82: 1073–1078.
67.
HortonR.The uses of error.Lancet1999; 353: 422–423.
68.
CoBaTrICE (Competence based training in intensive care in Europe). From www.cobatrice.org Accessed September 2009.
