Representing the citizenship of mental health users in French mental health policy: A critical analysis of the official French texts on mental health policies since 2005

Abstract

Research has shown that mental healthcare policies aimed at achieving autonomy and integration for people with mental disorders have been developing all over the world. Critics working from a governmentality perspective have argued that these changes are associated with broader neoliberal strategies and aims. In France however, there is no systematic work on this development. In this study, we have applied Bacchi’s ‘What’s the Problem Represented to Be’ approach to the main texts published by the French Ministry of Health since 2005, in order to study how the citizenship of mental health users is problematized. According to our analysis, the objectives of the autonomization, responsibilization and self-management of users have become increasingly central, following the recognition of users’ rights, social inclusion and the fight against the stigma of mental disorders. These developments have many points of contact with neoliberal governmentality. We conclude with recommendations for empirical research on discourses and practices in the field, where mental health policies are translated into mental health projects and practice.

Keywords

France mental health neoliberalism policy analysis problematizations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bacchi

(2015) ‘Problematizations in Alcohol Policy: WHO’s “Alcohol Problems”’. Contemporary Drug Problems 42(2): 130–147.

Bacchi

(2016) ‘Problematizations in Health Policy: Questioning How “Problems” Are Constituted in Policies’. SAGE Open 6(2): 215824401665398.

Bletsas

Beasley

(eds) (2012) Engaging with Carol Bacchi: Strategic Interventions and Exchanges. Adelaide: University of Adelaide Press.

Bos

AER

Pryor

Reeder

, et al. (2013) ‘Stigma: Advances in Theory and Research’. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 35(1): 1–9.

Cnaan

Blankertz

Messinger

, et al. (1988) ‘Psychosocial Rehabilitation: Toward a Definition’. Psychosocial Rehabilitation Journal 11: 61–77.

Couty

Cecchi-Tenerini

Broudic

, et al. (2009) Missions et organisation de la santé mentale et de la psychiatrie. France: Ministère de la santé et des sports. Available at: http://www.ladocumentationfrancaise.fr/var/storage/rapports-publics/094000037.pdf (accessed 27 December 2019).

Cowden

Singh

(2007) ‘The “User”: Friend, Foe or Fetish? A Critical Exploration of User Involvement in Health and Social Care’. Critical Social Policy 27(1): 5–23.

Dreyfus

Rabinow

(1982) Michel Foucault, beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Dubret

Trémine

(2009) Quel avenir pour la psychiatrie à l’hôpital général? L’information psychiatrique 85(6): 559.

10.

Durand

(2011) Soins psychiatriques : le retour de la contrainte et de la stigmatisation. Les Tribunes de la santé 32(3): 43. DOI: 10.3917/seve.032.0043.

11.

EU Directorate General for Health and Food Safety (2015) Joint Action on Mental Health and Well-being. Mental Health in all Policies – Situation Analysis and Recommendations for Action. Available at: http://www.mentalhealthandwellbeing.eu/assets/docs/publications/MHiAP%20Final.pdf (accessed 2 May 2018).

12.

Foucault

(2004) Naissance de la Biopolitique: Cours au Collège de France, 1978–1979. Hautes études. Paris: Gallimard: Seuil.

13.

Friedner

(2010) ‘Biopower, Biosociality, and Community Formation: How Biopower Is Constitutive of the Deaf Community’. Sign Language Studies 10(3): 336–347.

14.

Gorman

Udegbe

(2010) ‘Disabled Woman/Nation: Re-narrating the Erasure of (Neo)colonial Violence in Ondjaki’s Good Morning Comrades and Tsitsi Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions’. Journal of Literary & Cultural Disability Studies 4(3): 309–326.

15.

Gostin

(2008) ‘“Old” and “New” Institutions for Persons with Mental Illness: Treatment, Punishment or Preventive Confinement?’ Public Health 122(9): 906–913.

16.

Haigh

(2016) ‘“Mad Pride France”: Disability, Mental Distress, and Citizenship’. Journal of Literary & Cultural Disability Studies 10(2): 191–206.

17.

Henderson

(2005) ‘Neo-liberalism, Community Care and Australian Mental Health Policy’. Health Sociology Review 14(3): 242–254.

18.

Henderson

Fuller

(2011) ‘“Problematising” Australian Policy Representations in Responses to the Physical Health of People with Mental Health Disorders’. Australian Journal of Social Issues 46(2): 183–203.

19.

Hustoft

Larsen

Auestad

, et al. (2013) ‘Predictors of Involuntary Hospitalizations to Acute Psychiatry’. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 36(2): 136–143.

20.

Ilcan

Basok

(2004) ‘Community Government: Voluntary Agencies, Social Justice, and the Responsibilization of Citizens’. Citizenship Studies 8(2): 129–144.

21.

Kalampalikis

Daumerie

Jodelet

(2007) De l’effet médiatique au fait politique : la santé mentale en question. L’information psychiatrique 83(10): 839. DOI: 10.3917/inpsy.8310.0839.

22.

Lafocarde

(2016) Rapport relatif à la santé mentale. France: Ministère des affaires sociales et de la santé. Available at: http://solidarites-sante.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/dgos_rapport_laforcade_mission_sante_mentale_011016.pdf (accessed 27 December 2019).

23.

LeFrançois

Beresford

Russo

(2016) ‘Destination Mad Studies’. Intersectionalities: A Global Journal of Social Work Analysis, Research, Polity, and Practice 5(3): 1–10.

24.

Ministère des Solidarités, de la Santé et de la Famille (2005) Psychiatrie et santé mentale 2005–2008. France: Ministère des Solidarités, de la Santé et de la Famille. Available at: http://solidarites-sante.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/plan_2005-2008.pdf (accessed 27 December 2019).

25.

Ministère du travail, de l’emploi et de la santé (2011) Plan psychiatrie et santé mentale 2011–2015. France: Ministère du travail, de l’emploi et de la santé. Available at: http://solidarites-sante.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/Plan_Psychiatrie_et_Sante_Mentale_2011-2015.pdf (accessed 27 December 2019).

26.

Norredam

Garcia-Lopez

Keiding

, et al. (2010) ‘Excess use of Coercive Measures in Psychiatry among Migrants Compared with Native Danes’. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 121(2): 143–151.

27.

Pattadath

(2016) ‘Experience as “Expert” Knowledge: A Critical Understanding of Survivor Research in Mental Health’. Philosophy, Psychiatry & Psychology 23(3/4): 203–205.

28.

Pattyn

Verhaeghe

Sercu

, et al. (2013) ‘Medicalizing Versus Psychologizing Mental Illness: What are the Implications for Help Seeking and Stigma? A General Population Study’. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 48(10): 1637–1645.

29.

Peacock

Bissell

Owen

(2014) ‘Dependency Denied: Health Inequalities in the Neo-liberal Era. Social Science & Medicine 118: 173–180.

30.

Peck

(2001) Workfare States. New York, NY: Guilford Press.

31.

Pescosolido

Medina

Martin

, et al. (2013) ‘The “Backbone” of Stigma: Identifying the Global Core of Public Prejudice Associated With Mental Illness’. American Journal of Public Health 103(5): 853–860.

32.

Piel

Roelandt

J-L

(2001) De la psychiatrie vers la santé mentale. France: Ministère de l’emploi et de la solidarité. Available at: http://www.ladocumentationfrancaise.fr/rapports-publics/014000522/index.shtml (accessed 27 December 2019).

33.

President’s New Freedom Commission on Mental and Health (2003) Achieving the Promise: Transforming Mental Health Care in America. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.

34.

Pulkingham

Fuller

Kershaw

(2010) ‘Lone Motherhood, Welfare Reform and Active Citizen Subjectivity. Critical Social Policy 30(2): 267–291.

35.

Rice

Kelman

Miller

(1992) ‘The Economic Burden of Mental Illness’. Psychiatric Services 43(12): 1227–1232.

36.

Roelandt

J-L

(2002) La démocratie sanitaire dans le champ de la santé mentale: la place des usagers et le travail en partenariat dans la cité. France: Ministère de la santé. Available at: http://solidarites-sante.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/democratie_sanitaire.pdf (accessed 27 December 2019).

37.

Roelandt

J-L

(2004) Psychiatrie citoyenne et promotion de la santé mentale. Revue française des affaires sociales 1: 205–213.

38.

Roelandt

J-L

El Ghozi

(2015) Santé mentale et citoyenneté: une histoire française. L’Information Psychiatrique 91(7): 539–548.

39.

Rose

(1996a) ‘Psychiatry as a Political Science: Advanced Liberalism and the Administration of Risk’. History of the Human Sciences 9(2): 1–23.

40.

Rose

(1996b) ‘The Death of the Social? Re-figuring the Territory of Government’. Economy and Society 25(3): 327–356.

41.

Rose

(1998) Inventing Our Selves: Psychology, Power and Personhood. 1. Cambridge Studies in the History of Psychology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

42.

Rose

Collier

(2003) ‘Biological Citizenship’. In: Global Assemblages: Technology, Politics and Ethics as Anthropological Problems. Global Anthropology. Oxford: Blackwell.

43.

Social Exclusion Unit (2004) Mental Health and Social Exclusion. Social Exclusion Unit Report Summary. London: The Office of the Deputy Prime Minister. Available at: http://www.nfao.org/Useful_Websites/MH_Social_Exclusion_report_summary.pdf (accessed 27 December 2019).

44.

Teghtsoonian

(2009) ‘Depression and Mental Health in Neoliberal Times: A Critical Analysis of Policy and Discourse’. Social Science & Medicine 69(1): 28–35.

45.

United Nations (2019) Visit to France : Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. A/HRC/40/54/Add.1. Geneva: UN. Available at: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/1663797 (accessed 9 June 2019).

46.

van Dijk

(1993) Principles of Critical Discourse Analysis. Discourse & Society 4(2): 249–283.

47.

Voronka

(2016) ‘The Politics of “People with Lived Experience” Experiential Authority and the Risks of Strategic Essentialism’. Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology 23(3/4): 189–201.

48.

WHO (2003) Investing in Mental Health. Geneva: World Health Organization.

49.

WHO (2009) Improving Health Systems and Services for Mental Health. Geneva: World Health Organization. Available at: http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/44219/1/9789241598774_eng.pdf (accessed 27 December 2019).

50.

WHO (2013) Mental Health Action Plan 2013–2020. Geneva: World Health Organization.

51.

Wilton

(2004) ‘Putting Policy into Practice? Poverty and People with Serious Mental Illness’. Social Science & Medicine 58(1): 25–39.