Though the concept of social justice is widely used in the social sciences, we know little about the amount of income inequality that is perceived as just and why perceptions vary across social contexts. In this paper, we argue the ways people define the causes of poverty are related to how they perceive and justify existing income inequality. We examine internal and external attributions of poverty using survey data from the 2006 International Social Justice Project (ISJP). We compare two culturally and structurally distinct regions—East and West Germany. The results support our hypothesis that the amount of income inequality people perceive as just is related to how they explain the causes of poverty, that is, internal and/or external attributions. Poverty attributions are crucial mediators and explain contextual differences in the perceived justice of income inequality between East and West Germany.
AalbergToril. 2003. Achieving Justice. Comparative Public Opinion on Income Distribution. Boston: Brill.
2.
AlesinaAlbertoFuchs-SchündelnNicola. 2007. “Good Bye Lenin (or Not?): The Effect of Communism on People’s Preferences.” American Economic Review97:1507–8.
3.
BergerJosephZelditchMorrisAndersonBo, eds. 1972. Sociological Theories in Progress. New York: Houghton Mifflin.
4.
BollenKenneth A.1989. Structural Equation Models with Latent Variables. New York: Wiley & Sons.
5.
BrownTimothy A.2006. Confirmatory Factor Analysis for Applied Research. New York: Guilford Press.
6.
BullockHeather E.1999. “Attributions for Poverty: A Comparison of Middle-Class and Welfare Recipient Attitudes.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology29:2059–82.
7.
BullockHeather E.WilliamsWendy R.M. LimbertWendy. 2003. “Predicting Support for Welfare Policies: The Impact of Attributions and Beliefs about Inequality.” Journal of Poverty7:35–56.
8.
BurgoyneCarole B.RouthDavidSidorenko-StephensonSvetlana. 1999. “Perceptions, Attributions and Policy in the Economic Domain: A Theoretical and Comparative Analysis.” International Journal of Comparative Sociology40:79–93.
9.
CastilloJuan C.2009. “¿Cuál es la Brecha Salarial Justa? Opinión Pública y Legitimación de la Desigualdad Económica en Chile.” Estudios Públicos113:237–66.
10.
CozzarelliCatherineWilkinsonAnna V.TaglerMichael J.2001. “Attitudes toward the Poor and Attributions for Poverty.” Journal of Social Issues57:207–27.
11.
da CostaLeonor P.DiasJosé G.2014. “Perceptions of Poverty Attributions in Europe: A Multilevel Mixture Model Approach.” Quality & Quantity48:1409–19.
12.
EvansM. D. R.KelleyJonathanPeoplesClayton D.2010. “Justification of Inequality: The Normative Basis of Pay Differentials in 31 Nations.” Social Science Quarterly91:1405–31.
13.
FeaginJoe R.1972. “Poverty: We Still Believe That God Helps Those Who Help Themselves.” Psychology Today6:101–29.
14.
FeaginJoe R.1975. Subordinating the Poor: Welfare and American Beliefs. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.
15.
GerlitzJean-YvesMühleckKaiSchellerPercySchrenkerMarkus. 2012. “Justice Perception in Times of Transition: Trends in Germany, 1991–2006.” European Sociological Review28:263–82.
16.
GruskyDavid D.1994. Social Stratification: Class, Race, and Gender in Sociological Perspective. Boulder: Westview Press.
17.
HegtvedtKaren A.JohnsonCathryn. 2009. “Power and Justice: Toward an Understanding of Legitimacy.” American Behavioral Scientist53:376–99.
18.
HeiderFritz. 1958. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York: John Wiley.
19.
Hoffmeyer-ZlotnikJürgen H. P.2003. “The Classification of Education as a Sociological Background Characteristic.” Pp. 245–56 in Advances in Cross-National Comparison: A European Working Book for Demographic and Socio-Economic Variables, edited by Hoffmeyer-ZlotnikJ.WolfC.New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
20.
HomansGeorge. 1961. Social Behavior: Its Elementary Forms. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
21.
HomansGeorge. 1976. “Commentary.” Pp. 231–44 in Equity Theory: Toward a General Theory of Social Interaction, edited by BerkowitzL.WalsterE.New York: Academic Press.
22.
HuntMatthew O.1996. “The Individual, Society, or Both? A Comparison of Black, Latino, and White Beliefs about the Causes of Poverty.” Social Forces75:293–322.
23.
HuntMatthew O.2004. “Race/Ethnicity and Beliefs about Wealth and Poverty.” Social Science Quarterly85:827–53.
24.
Infas. 2006. Soziale Gerechtigkeit und Generationengerechtigkeit.: Bevölkerungsbefragung 2006: Methodenbericht. Bonn: Infas Institut für angewandte Sozialwissenschaft.
25.
JassoGuillermina. 1978. “On the Justice of Earnings: A New Specification of the Justice Evaluation Function.” American Journal of Sociology83:1398–419.
26.
JassoGuillermina. 1980. “A New Theory of Distributive Justice.” American Sociological Review45:3–32.
27.
JassoGuillermina. 1999. “How Much Injustice Is There in the World? Two New Justice Indexes.” American Sociological Review64:133–68.
28.
JassoGuillermina. 2007. “Studying Justice: Measurement, Estimation, and Analysis of the Actual Reward and the Just Reward.” Pp. 225–53 in Distributive and Procedural Justice. Research and Social Applications, edited by TörnblomK.VermuntR.Hampshire, UK: Ashgate.
29.
JassoGuillerminaWegenerBernd. 1997. “Methods for Empirical Justice Analysis: Part 1. Framework, Models, and Quantities.” Social Justice Research10:393–430.
30.
JostJohn T.MajorBrenda, eds. 2001. The Psychology of Legitimacy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
31.
KallioJohannaNiemeläMikko. 2014. “Who Blames the Poor?” European Societies16:112–34.
32.
KerboHarold. 1983. Social Stratification and Inequality. New York: McGraw-Hill.
33.
KluegelJames R.CsepeliGyörgyKolosiTamásOrkenyAntalNemenyiMária. 1995. “Accounting for the Rich and the Poor: Existencial Justice in Comparative Perspective.” Pp. 179–207 in Social Justice and Political Change: Public Opinion in Capitalist and Post-Communist States, edited by KluegelJ. R.MasonD. S.WegenerB.New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
34.
KluegelJames R.MasonDavid S.WegenerBernd. 1999. “The Legitimation of Capitalism in the Postcommunist Transition. Public Opinion about Market Justice, 1991–1996.” European Sociological Review15:251–83.
35.
KluegelJames R.SmithEliot R.1986. Beliefs about Inequality: Americans’ Views of What Is and What Ought to Be. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
36.
KreidlMartin. 2000. “Perceptions of Poverty and Wealth in Western and Post-Communist Countries.” Social Justice Research13:151–76.
37.
KrullDouglas S.LoyMichelle H.-M.LinJenniferWangChing-FuChenSuhongZhaoXudong. 1999. “The Fundamental Fundamental Attribution Error: Correspondence Bias in Individualist and Collectivist Cultures.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin25:1208–19.
38.
LaneRobert E.1986. “Market Justice, Political Justice.” The American Political Science Review80:383–402.
39.
LeeFionaHallahanMarkHerzogThaddeus. 1996. “Explaining Real-Life Events: How Culture and Domain Shape Attributions.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin22:732–41.
40.
LenskiGerhard E.1966. Power and Privilege: A Theory of Social Stratification. New York: McGraw-Hill.
41.
LepiankaDorotaGelissenJohnvan OorschotWim. 2010. “Popular Explanations of Poverty in Europe: Effects of Contextual and Individual Characteristics across 28 European Countries.” Acta Sociologica53:53–72.
42.
LepiankaDorotavan OorschotWimGelissenJohn. 2009. “Popular Explanations of Poverty: A Critical Discussion of Empirical Research.” Journal of Social Policy38:421–38.
43.
LernerMelvin J.1980. The Belief in a Just World. A Fundamental Delusion. New York: Plenum Press.
44.
LipplBodo. 1999. Justice Evaluation and the Welfare State in Europe. Paper presented to the 4th European Conference of Sociology, Amsterdam.
45.
McLeodJane D.LivelyKathryn J.2003. “Social Structure and Personality.” Pp. 77–102 in Handbook of Social Psychology, edited by DeLamaterJ.New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
46.
MikulaGerold. 2003. “Testing an Attribution-of-Blame Model of Judgments of Injustice.” European Journal of Social Psychology33:793–811.
47.
MelamedDavid. 2012. “Deriving Equity from Expectations: A Cross-Cultural Evaluation.” Social Science Research41:170–81.
NiemeläMikko. 2008. “Perceptions of the Causes of Poverty in Finland.” Acta Sociologica51:23–40.
50.
OsbergLarsSmeedingTimothy M.2006. “‘Fair’ Inequality? Attitudes toward Pay Differentials: The United States in Comparative Perspective.” American Sociological Review71:450–73.
51.
PettigrewThomas F.1979. “The Ultimate Attribution Error: Extending Allport’s Cognitive Analysis of Prejudice.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 5:461–76.
52.
RavallionMartin. 2003. “The Debate on Globalization, Poverty and Inequality: Why Measurement Matters.” International Affairs79:739–53.
53.
RobinsonJames W.2009. “American Poverty Cause Beliefs and Structured Inequality Legitimation.” Sociological Spectrum29:489–518.
54.
RobinsonRobert V.BellWendell. 1978. “Equality, Success, and Social Justice in England and the United States.” American Sociological Review43:125–43.
55.
SaundersPeter. 2003. “Stability and Change in Community Perceptions of Poverty: Evidence from Australia.” Journal of Poverty7:1–20.
56.
SchneiderSimone M.2012. “Income Inequality and Its Consequences for Life Satisfaction: What Role Do Social Cognitions Play?”Social Indicators Research106:419–38.
57.
SmithKevin B.1985. “I Made It Because of Me: Beliefs about the Causes of Wealth and Poverty.” Sociological Spectrum5:255–67.
58.
SmithKevin B.StoneLorene H.1989. “Rags, Riches and Bootstraps: Beliefs about the Causes of Wealth and Poverty.” The Sociological Quarterly30:93–107.
59.
StephensonSvetlana. 2000. “Public Beliefs in the Causes of Wealth and Poverty and Legitimization of Inequalities in Russia and Estonia.” Social Justice Research13:83–100.
60.
TylerTom R.2006. “Psychological Perspectives on Legitimacy and Legitimation.” Annual Review of Psychology5:375–400.
61.
van OorschotWimHalmanLoek. 2000. “Blame of Fate, Individual or Social? An International Comparison of Popular Explanations of Poverty.” European Societies1:1–28.
62.
VerwiebeRolandWegenerBernd. 2000. “Social Inequality and the Perceived Income Justice Gap.” Social Justice Research13:123–49.
63.
WegenerBernd. 1995. “Gerechtigkeitstheorie und empirische Gerechtigkeitsforschung.” Pp. 195–220 in Soziale Ungleichheit und soziale Gerechtigkeit, edited by MüllerH.WegenerB.Opladen: Leske+Budrich.
64.
WegenerBerndLiebigStefan. 2000. “Is the ‘Inner Wall’ Here to Stay? Justice Ideologies in Unified Germany.” Social Justice Research13:177–97.
65.
YzerbytVincentRogierAnouk. 2001. “Blame it on the Group: Entitativity, Subjective Essentialism, and Social Attribution.” Pp. 103–34 in The Psychology of Legitimacy, edited by JostJ. T.MajorB.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
66.
ZuckerGail S.WeinerBernard. 1993. “Conservatism and Perceptions of Poverty: An Attributional Analysis.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology23:925–43.
