Few educators are well-equipped to bridge cultural differences to ensure that all students have opportunities to learn and succeed. Existing frameworks for culturally responsive practices (CRP) suggest its potential for promoting equitable learning environments, yet the state of the science has not been assessed. This systematic review aimed to (a) describe the features of empirically examined inservice CRP interventions, (b) analyze the quality of the empirical studies, and (c) characterize study measures, outcomes, and conclusions regarding intervention impact. We found a total of just 10 empirical studies of the impact of CRP inservice training models (two quantitative and eight qualitative). Study methods universally failed to meet standards of evidence for efficacy, effectiveness, and dissemination; none employed rigorous design features to allow causal inference. Findings suggest that the research base is inadequate to draw conclusions regarding effectiveness and that more rigorous CRP inservice intervention research is needed.
ArtilesA. J.KozleskiE. B.TrentS. C.OsherD.OrtizA. (2010). Justifying and explaining disproportionality, 1968-2008: A critique of underlying views of culture. Exceptional Children, 76, 279-299.
2.
AuK. (2009). Isn’t culturally responsive instruction just good teaching?Social Education, 73, 179-183.
3.
AuK.JordanC. (1981). Teaching reading to Hawaiian 164 children: Finding a culturally appropriate solution. In TruebaH.GuthrieG.AuK. (Eds.), Culture and the bilingual classroom: Studies in classroom ethnography (pp. 69-86). Rowley, MA: Newbury House.
4.
AuerbachS. (2009). Walking the walk: Portraits in leadership for family engagement in urban schools. School Community Journal, 19, 9-32.
5.
BeroL. A.GrilliR.GrimshawJ. M.HarveyE.OxmanA. D.ThomsonM. A. (1998). Closing the gap between research and practice: An overview of systematic reviews of interventions to promote the implementation of research findings. British Medical Journal, 317, 465-469.
6.
BickmanL.RiemerM.BrownJ. L.JonesS. M.FlayB. R.LiK. K.. . . MassettiG. M. (2009). Approaches to measuring implementation fidelity in school-based program evaluations. Journal of Research in Character Education, 7, 75.
7.
BonnerE. P.AdamsT. L. (2012). Culturally responsive teaching in the context of mathematics: A grounded theory case study. Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education, 15, 25-38. doi:10.1007/s10857-011-9198-4
8.
BottianiJ. H.BradshawC. P.RosenbergM. S.HershfeldtP. A.PellK. L.DebnamK. D. (2012). Applying Double Check to Response to Intervention: Culturally responsive practices for students with learning disabilities. Insights on Learning Disabilities, 9, 93-107.
9.
BradshawC. P.MitchellM. M.LeafP. J. (2010). Examining the effects of schoolwide positive behavioral interventions and supports on student outcomes results from a randomized controlled effectiveness trial in elementary schools. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 12(3), 133-148.
10.
BrantlingerE.JimenezR.KlingnerJ.PugachM.RichardsonV. (2005). Qualitative studies in special education. Exceptional Children, 71, 195-207.
11.
Brown-JeffyS.CooperJ. E. (2011). Toward a conceptual framework of culturally relevant pedagogy: An overview of the conceptual and theoretical literature. Teacher Education Quarterly, 38, 65-84. Retrieved from http://www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/EJ914924.pdf
12.
CazdenC.LeggettE. (1981). Culturally responsive education: Recommendations for achieving Lau remedies II. In TruebaH.GuthrieG.AuK. (Eds.), Culture and the bilingual classroom: Studies in classroom ethnography (pp. 69-86). Rowley, MA: Newbury House.
13.
ChambersD.WilsonP. M.ThompsonC. A.HanburyA.FarleyK.LightK. (2011). Maximizing the impact of systematic reviews in health care decision making: A systematic scoping review of knowledge-translation resources. Milbank Quarterly, 89(1), 131-156.
14.
ConstantineM. G.LadanyN. (2000). Self-report multicultural counseling competence scales: Their relation to social desirability attitudes and multicultural case conceptualization ability. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 47, 155-164. doi:10.1037//0022-0167.47.2.155
15.
CookT. D.CampbellD. T.DayA. (1979). Quasi-experimentation: Design & analysis issues for field settings (Vol. 351). Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
16.
CreswellJ. W.MillerD. L. (2000). Determining validity in qualitative inquiry. Theory into practice, 39(3), 124-130. doi:10.1207/s15430421tip3903_2
17.
DebnamK.PasE.BottianiJ. H.CashA. H.BradshawC. P. (2015). An examination of the association between observed and self-reported culturally responsive teaching practices. Psychology in the Schools, 52, 533-548.
18.
DelpitL. (2006). Other people’s children: Cultural conflict in the classroom. New York, NY: The New Press.
19.
*EberlyJ. L.JoshiA.KonzalJ.GalenH. (2010). Crossing cultures: Considering ethnotheory in teacher thinking and practices. Multicultural Education, 18, 25-32.
20.
EhrenbergR. G.GoldhaberD. D.BrewerD. J. (1995). Do teachers’ race, gender, and ethnicity matter? Evidence from the National Educational Longitudinal Study of 1988. Industrial & Labor Relations Review, 48, 547-561.
21.
EpsteinT.MayorgaE.NelsonJ. (2011). Teaching about race in an urban history class: The effects of culturally responsive teaching. Journal of Social Studies Research, 35, 2-21.
22.
EricksonF.MohanC. (1982). Cultural organization and participation structures in two classrooms of Indian students. In SpindlerG. (Ed.), Doing the ethnography of schooling (pp. 131-174). New York, NY: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
23.
*FickelL. H. (2005). Teachers, tundra, and talking circles: Learning history and culture in an Alaska Native village. Theory and Research in Social Education, 33, 476-507. doi:10.1080/00933104.2005.10473292
24.
FiedlerC.ChiangB.Van HarenB.JorgensenJ.HalbergS.BoresonL. (2008). Culturally responsive practices in schools: A checklist to address disproportionality in special education. Teaching Exceptional Children, 40, 52-59.
25.
FlayB. R.BiglanA.BoruchR. F.CastroF. G.GottfredsonD.KellamS.. . . JiP. (2005). Standards of evidence: Criteria for efficacy, effectiveness and dissemination. Prevention Science, 6, 151-175. doi:10.1007/s11121-005-5553-y
26.
GarzaR. (2009). Latino and White high school students’ perceptions of caring behaviors: Are we culturally responsive to our students?Urban Education, 44, 297-321. doi:10.1177/0042085908318714
27.
GayG. (1995). Building cultural bridges: A bold proposal for teacher education. Multicultural Education: Strategies for Implementation in Colleges and Universities, 4, 95-106.
28.
GayG. (2002). Preparing for culturally responsive teaching. Journal of Teacher Education, 53, 106-116. doi:10.1177/0022487102053002003
29.
GayG. (2010). Culturally responsive teaching: Theory, research, and practice. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
30.
GottfredsonD. C.CookT. D.GardnerF. E.Gorman-SmithD.HoweG. W.SandlerI. N.. . . ZafftK. M. (2015). Standards of evidence for efficacy, effectiveness, and scale-up research in prevention science: Next generation. Prevention Science, 16, 893-926. doi:10.1007/s11121-015-0555-x
31.
GranelloD. H.WheatonJ. E. (1998). Self-perceived multicultural competencies of African American and European American vocational rehabilitation counselors. Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin, 42, 2-15.
32.
GregoryA.AllenJ.MikamiA.HafenC.PiantaR. (2013, January). The promise of a teacher professional development program in reducing the racial disparity in classroom exclusionary discipline. Center for Civil Rights Remedies National Conference, Closing the School to Research Gap: Research to Remedies Conference, Washington, DC.
33.
GregoryA.RipskiM. B. (2008). Adolescent trust in teachers: Implications for behavior in the high school classroom. School Psychology Review, 37, 337-353.
34.
GrinerA. C.StewartM. L. (2013). Addressing the achievement gap and disproportionality through the use of culturally responsive teaching practices. Urban Education, 48, 585-621. doi:10.1177/0042085912456847
GutierrezK. D.RogoffB. (2003). Cultural ways of learning: Individual traits or repertoires of practice. Educational Researcher, 32, 19-25. doi:10.3102/0013189x032005019
37.
*HammernessK.MatskoK. K. (2013). When context has content: A case study of new teacher induction in the University of Chicago’s Urban Teacher Education Program. Urban Education, 48, 557-584. doi:10.1177/0042085912456848
HornerR. H.ToddA. W.Lewis-PalmerT.IrvinL. K.SugaiG.BolandJ. B. (2004). The school-wide evaluation tool (SET) a research instrument for assessing school-wide positive behavior support. Journal of positive behavior interventions, 6(1), 3-12.
40.
*JonesC.CaravacaL.CizekS.HornerR. H.VincentC. G. (2006). Culturally Responsive Schoolwide Positive Behavior Support: A case study in one school with a high proportion of Native American students. Multiple Voices for Ethnically Diverse Exceptional Learners, 9, 108-119.
41.
KatzA. D.HoytW. T. (2014). The influence of multicultural counseling competence and anti-Black prejudice on therapists’ outcome expectancies. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 61, 299-305. doi:10.1037/a0036134
42.
KenaG.Musu-GilletteL.RobinsonJ.WangX.RathbunA.ZhangJ.. . . VelezE. (2015). The Condition of Education 2015 (NCES 2015-144). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. Retrieved from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch
43.
KeppelK.PamukE.LynchJ.Carter-PokrasO.KimI.MaysV.. . . WeissmanJ. S. (2005). Methodological issues in measuring health disparities. National Center for Health Statistics. Vital Health Statistics, 141, 495-499. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_02/sr02_141.pdf
44.
Ladson-BillingsG. (1994). The dreamkeepers: Successful teaching for African-American students. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
45.
Ladson-BillingsG. (1995). Toward a theory of culturally relevant pedagogy. American Journal of Educational Research, 32, 465-491. doi:10.3102/00028312032003465
46.
LalasJ. (2007). Teaching for social justice in multicultural urban schools: Conceptualization and classroom implication. Multicultural Education, 14, 17-21.
47.
LiuW. M.SheuH. B.WilliamsK. (2004). Multicultural competency in research: Examining the relationships among multicultural competencies, research training and self-efficacy, and the multicultural environment. Cultural Diversity & Ethnic Minority Psychology, 10, 324-339. doi:10.1037/1099-9809.10.4.324
48.
LosenD. J.OrfieldG. (2002). Racial inequity in special education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education.
49.
*McAllisterG.IrvineJ. J. (2002). The role of empathy in teaching culturally diverse students: A qualitative study of teachers’ beliefs. Journal of Teacher Education, 53, 433-443. doi:10.1177/002248702237397
50.
*McCormickT. M.EickC. J.WomackJ. S. (2013). Culturally responsive teaching: Awareness and professional growth through a school-university collaboration. School-University Partnerships, 6, 6-14.
51.
MollL.AmantiC.NeffD.GonzalezN. (2005). Funds of knowledge for teaching: Using a qualitative approach to connect homes and classrooms. In GonzalezN.MollL.AmantiC. (Eds.), Funds of knowledge: Theorizing practices in households, communities, and classrooms (pp. 71-88). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
52.
Moore-ThomasC.Day-VinesN. L. (2008). Culturally competent counseling for religious and spiritual African American adolescents. Professional School Counseling, 11, 159-165. doi:10.5330/psc.n.2010-11.159
53.
MorganP. L.FarkasG.HillemeierM. M.MattisonR.MaczugaS.LiH.. . . CookM. (2015). Minorities are disproportionately underrepresented in special education longitudinal evidence across five disability conditions. Educational Researcher, 44, 278-292.
NietoS. (2013). Finding joy in teaching students of diverse backgrounds: Culturally responsive and socially just practices in U.S. classrooms. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
57.
OgbuJ. U. (1994). Racial stratification and education in the United States: Why inequality persists. Teachers College Record, 96, 264-298.
58.
OhmR.RosenL. (2011). Psychometric evaluation of the Perceived Prejudice in Health Care Scale–Modified (PPHC-M) among baccalaureate student nurses. Journal of Transcultural Nursing, 22, 282-289. doi:10.1177/1043659611404430
59.
ParisD. (2012). Culturally sustaining pedagogy: A needed change in stance, terminology, and practice. Educational Researcher, 41, 93-97. doi:10.3102/0013189x12441244
60.
PettigrewM.RobertsH. (2006). Systematic reviews in the social sciences: A practical guide. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.
61.
PhillippoK. (2012). “You’re trying to know me”: Students from nondominant groups respond to teacher personalism. The Urban Review, 44, 441-467. doi:10.1007/s11256-011-0195-9
62.
PorowskiA.O’ConnerR.PassaA. (2014). Disproportionality in school discipline: An assessment of trends in Maryland, 2009-12. REL 2014-017. Regional Educational Laboratory Mid-Atlantic. Retrieved from http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/edlabs/projects/project.asp?projectID=365
63.
ReynoldsW. M. (1982). Development of reliable and valid short forms of the Marlowe-Crowne Social Desirability Scale. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 38, 119-125.
64.
RiskoV.Walker-DalhouseD. (2008). Tapping students’ cultural funds of knowledge to address the achievement gap. Reading Teacher, 61, 98-100. doi:10.1598/rt.61.1.12
65.
*RyanK. E.ChandlerM.SamuelsM. (2007). What should school-based evaluation look like?Studies in Educational Evaluation, 33, 197-212. doi:10.1016/j.stueduc.2007.07.001
66.
SampsonD.Garrison-WadeD. (2011). Cultural vibrancy: Exploring the preferences of African American children toward culturally relevant and non-culturally relevant lessons. Urban Review, 43, 279-309. doi:10.1007/s11256-010-0170-x
67.
SchardtC.AdamsM.OwensT.KeitzS.FonteloP. (2007). Utilizing the PICO framework to improve searching PubMed for clinical questions. Biomedical Informatics and Decision Making, 7, 16. doi:10.1186/1472-6947-7-16
68.
ShadishW.R.CookT. D.CampbellD. T. (2002). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
69.
*ShribergD.SchumacherR.McMahonK. C.FloresS.MoyG. E.SwidzinskiJ.TompkinsN. A. (2012). Utilizing participatory action research to foster effective family/school collaboration at an urban pre-K-8 Catholic school. Catholic Education: A Journal of Inquiry and Practice, 15, 226-252.
70.
SkibaR.HornerR.ChungC.RauschM.MayS.TobinT. (2011). Race is not neutral: A national investigation of African American and Latino disproportionality in school discipline. School Psychology Review, 40, 85-107.
71.
SodowskyG. R.Kuo-JacksonP. Y.RichardsonM. F.CoreyA. T. (1998). Correlates of self-reported multicultural competencies: Counselor multicultural social desirability, race, social inadequacy, locus of control racial ideology, and multicultural training. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 45, 256-264. doi:10.1037//0022-0167.45.3.256
72.
SugaiG.HornerR. H. (2002). The evolution of discipline practices: School-wide positive behavior supports. In LuiselliJ. K.DiamentC. (Eds.), Behavior psychology in the schools: Innovations in evaluation, support, and consultation (pp. 23-50). New York, NY: Haworth.
73.
SugaiG.HornerR. H.Lewis-PalmerT. (2001). Team implementation checklist. Eugene, OR: Educational and Community Supports, University of Oregon.
74.
SullivanA. L. (2011). Disproportionality in special education identification and placement of English language learners. Exceptional Children, 77, 317-334. doi:10.1177/001440291107700304
75.
*ThompsonJ.ByrnesD. (2011). A more diverse circle of friends. Multicultural Perspectives, 13, 93-99. doi:10.1080/15210960.2011.571552
76.
ToldsonI. A.LemmonsB. P. (2013). Social demographics, the school environment, and parenting practices associated with parents’ participation in schools and academic success among Black, Hispanic, and White students. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment, 23, 237-255. doi:10.1080/10911359.2013.747407
77.
U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance. (2015). What Works Clearinghouse. Retrieved from http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc
78.
VillegasA. (1988). School failure and cultural mismatch: Another view. The Urban Review, 20, 153-265. doi:10.1007/bf01120137
79.
VillegasA. M.LucasT. (2002). Preparing culturally responsive teachers rethinking the curriculum. Journal of Teacher Education, 53, 20-32.
80.
VincentC. G.RandallC.CartledgeG.TobinT. J.Swain-BradwayJ. (2011). Toward a conceptual integration of cultural responsiveness and schoolwide positive behavior support. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 13, 219-229. doi:10.1177/1098300711399765
81.
*VincentC. G.Swain-BradwayJ.TobinT. J.MayS. (2011). Disciplinary referrals for culturally and linguistically diverse students with and without disabilities: Patterns resulting from school-wide positive behavior support. Exceptionality, 19, 175-190. doi:10.1080/09362835.2011.579936
82.
WareF. (2006). Warm demander pedagogy: Culturally responsive teaching that supports a culture of achievement for African American students. Urban Education, 41, 427-456. doi:10.1177/0042085906289710
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
