Choosing when to claim Social Security Administration (SSA) benefits is an important decision for older Americans’ financial health. While previous work has examined heterogeneity in claiming decisions, relatively little research has systematically tested the psychological factors that predict early or delayed SSA claiming or the effectiveness of theory-driven interventions meant to help with the claiming decision. A preregistered experiment and three replications examined the extent to which intended claiming age is a function of theory-driven interventions, individual difference measures, and relevant interactions between interventions and individual differences. The interventions that increased intended claiming age were those that suggest that delayed claiming may be the right choice (i.e., injunctive norm, information about the commonality of regret), those that highlight the financial benefits from delayed claiming (i.e., gains framing, focus on benefits to the future self), and those that guide preference construction through self-reflection (i.e., focus on right-tail longevity, reason generation). In addition, intertemporal discounting, subjective life expectancy, and perceived ownership of SSA benefits predicted intended claiming age. This research advances our understanding of which retirees will decide to claim earlier or later and offers practical insights for policy makers, financial planners, and consumer finance organizations.
AllcottHuntMullainathanSendhil (2010), “Behavior and Energy Policy,” Science, 327 (5970), 1204–05.
2.
AltigDavidKotlikoffLaurence J.YeVictor Yifan (2022), “How Much Lifetime Social Security Benefits Are Americans Leaving on the Table?” NBER Working Paper No. 30675.
BeardenWilliam O.NetemeyerRichard G.TeelJesse E. (1989), “Measurement of Consumer Susceptibility to Interpersonal Influence,” Journal of Consumer Research, 15 (4), 473–81.
5.
BertrandMarianneKarlanDeanMullainathanSendhilShafirEldarZinmanJonathan (2010), “What’s Advertising Content Worth? Evidence from a Consumer Credit Marketing Field Experiment,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 125 (1), 263–306.
6.
BlaisAnn-RenéeWeberElke U. (2006), “A Domain-Specific Risk-Taking (DOSPERT) Scale for Adult Populations,” Judgment and Decision Making, 1 (1), 33–47.
7.
BrownJeffrey R.KapteynArieMitchellOlivia S. (2016), “Framing and Claiming: How Information Framing Affects Expected Social Security Claiming Behavior,” Journal of Risk and Insurance, 83 (1), 139–62.
8.
BryanChristopher J.HershfieldHal E. (2012), “You Owe It to Yourself: Boosting Retirement Saving with a Responsibility-Based Appeal,” Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 141 (3), 429–32.
9.
ChandlerJesseRosenzweigCheskieMossAaron J.RobinsonJonathanLitmanLeib (2019), “Online Panels in Social Science Research: Expanding Sampling Methods Beyond Mechanical Turk,” Behavior Research Methods, 51 (5), 2022–38.
10.
ChenAnqiMunnellAlicia H. (2021), “Pre-COVID Trends in Social Security Claiming,” Issue in Brief 21-9, Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, http://hdl.handle.net/2345/bc-ir:109245.
DellaVignaStefanoLinosElizabeth (2022), “RCTs to Scale: Comprehensive Evidence from Two Nudge Units,” Econometrica, 90 (1), 81–116.
13.
DellaVignaStefanoPopeDevin (2018), “What Motivates Effort? Evidence and Expert Forecasts,” Review of Economic Studies, 85 (2), 1029–69.
14.
Ersner-HershfieldHalTess GartonM.BallardKaceySamanez-LarkinGregory R.KnutsonBrian (2009), “Don’t Stop Thinking About Tomorrow: Individual Differences in Future Self-Continuity Account for Saving,” Judgment and Decision Making, 4 (4), 280–86.
15.
FernandesDanielLynchJohn G.Jr.NetemeyerRichard G. (2014), “Financial Literacy, Financial Education, and Downstream Financial Behaviors,” Management Science, 60 (8), 1861–83.
16.
FetherstonhaughDavidRossLee (1999), “Framing Effects and Income Flow Preferences in Decisions About Social Security,” in Behavioral Dimensions of Retirement Economics, AaronHenry J., ed. Brookings, Russell Sage Foundation, 187–209.
17.
GalDavidRuckerDerek D. (2018), “The Loss of Loss Aversion: Will It Loom Larger Than Its Gain?” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 28 (3), 497–516.
18.
GilbertDaniel T.PinelElizabeth C.WilsonTimothy D.BlumbergStephen J.WheatleyThalia P. (1998), “Immune Neglect: A Source of Durability Bias in Affective Forecasting,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75 (3), 617–38.
19.
GodaGopi ShahManchesterColleen FlahertySojournerAaron (2014), “What Will My Account Really Be Worth? Experimental Evidence on How Retirement Income Projections Affect Saving,” Journal of Public Economics, 119, 80–92.
20.
GoldsteinNoah J.CialdiniRobert B.GriskeviciusVladas (2008), “A Room with a Viewpoint: Using Social Norms to Motivate Environmental Conservation in Hotels,” Journal of Consumer Research, 35 (3), 472–82.
21.
GoldsteinDaniel G.HershfieldHal E.BenartziShlomo (2016), “The Illusion of Wealth and Its Reversal,” Journal of Marketing Research, 53 (5), 804–13.
22.
GoslingSamuel D.RentfrowPeter J.SwannWilliam B. (2003), “A Very Brief Measure of the Big-Five Personality Domains,” Journal of Research in Personality, 37 (6), 504–28.
23.
GreenbergAdam Eric (2013), “When Imagining Future Wealth Influences Risky Decision Making,” Judgment and Decision Making, 8 (3), 268–77.
GreenbergAdam EricHershfieldHal E.PayneJohn W.ShuSuzanne B.SpillerStephen A. (2017), “Exploring How Uncertainty in Longevity Estimates Predicts Social Security Claiming Decisions,” NBER Retirement Research Center Paper No. 17-09.
26.
GreenbergAdam EricSussmanAbigail B.HershfieldHal E. (2020), “Financial Product Sensitivity Predicts Financial Health,” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 33 (1), 15–26.
27.
GustmanAlan L.SteinmeierThomas L. (2005), “The Social Security Early Entitlement Age in a Structural Model of Retirement and Wealth,” Journal of Public Economics, 89 (2–3), 441–63.
28.
GustmanAlan L.SteinmeierThomas L. (2015), “Effects of Social Security Policies on Benefit Claiming, Retirement and Saving,” Journal of Public Economics, 129, 51–62.
29.
HadarLiatSoodSanjayFoxCraig R. (2013), “Subjective Knowledge in Consumer Financial Decisions,” Journal of Marketing Research, 50 (3), 303–16.
30.
HalpernDavid (2015), Inside the Nudge Unit: How Small Changes Can Make a Big Difference. W.H. Allen.
31.
HarrisonGlenn W.LauMorten I.WilliamsMelonie B. (2002), “Estimating Individual Discount Rates in Denmark: A Field Experiment,” American Economic Review, 92 (5), 1606–17.
32.
HershfieldHal E. (2019), “The Self over Time,” Current Opinion in Psychology, 26, 72–5.
33.
HershfieldHal E.BartelsDaniel (2018), “The Future Self,” in Psychology of Thinking About the Future, OettingenGabrieleSevincerA. TimurGollwitzerPeter M., eds. Guilford Press, 89–109.
34.
HershfieldHal E.JohnEliciaReiffJoseph S. (2018), “Using Vividness Interventions to Improve Financial Decision-Making,” Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 5 (2), 209–15.
35.
HurdMichael D.RohwedderSusannDuckworthAngela LeeWeirDavid R. (2012), “Personality Traits and Economic Preparation for Retirement,” Working Paper 2012-79, University of Michigan Retirement Research Center.
36.
JaniszewskiChrisvan OsselaerStijn M.J. (2021), “The Benefits of Candidly Reporting Consumer Research,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 31 (4), 633–46.
37.
JohnsonEric J.ShuSuzanne B.DellaertBenedict G.C.FoxCraigGoldsteinDaniel G.HäublGeraldLarrickRichard P.PayneJohn W.PetersEllenSchkadeDavidWansinkBrianWeberElke U. (2012), “Beyond Nudges: Tools of a Choice Architecture,” Marketing Letters, 23 (2), 487–504.
38.
KhanMashfiqurRutledgeMatthewWuApril Yanyuan (2014), “How Do Subjective Longevity Expectations Influence Retirement Plans?” Working Paper 201411, Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.
39.
KnollMelissa A.Z. (2011), “Behavioral and Psychological Aspects of the Retirement Decision,” Social Security Bulletin, 71 (4), 15–32.
40.
KnollMelissa A.Z.AppeltKirstin C.JohnsonEric J.WestfallJonathan E. (2015), “Time to Retire: Why Americans Claim Benefits Early & How to Encourage Delay,” Behavioral Science & Policy, 1 (1), 53–62.
41.
LiXiaoyanHurdMichaelLoughranDavid S. (2008), The Characteristics of Social Security Beneficiaries Who Claim Benefits at the Early Entitlement Age, Vol. 19. AARP, Public Policy Institute.
42.
LiebmanJeffrey B.LuttmerErzo F. P. (2015), “Would People Behave Differently If They Better Understood Social Security? Evidence from a Field Experiment,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 7 (1), 275–99.
43.
LitmanLeibRobinsonJonathanAbberbockTzvi (2017), “TurkPrime.com: A Versatile Crowdsourcing Data Acquisition Platform for the Behavioral Sciences,” Behavior Research Methods, 49 (2), 433–42.
44.
LoewensteinGeorgeAschDavid A.VolppKevin G. (2013), “Behavioral Economics Holds Potential to Deliver Better Results for Patients, Insurers, and Employers,” Health Affairs, 32 (7), 1244–50.
45.
LusardiAnnamariaMitchellOlivia S. (2011), “Financial Literacy and Planning: Implications for Retirement Wellbeing,” in Financial Literacy: Implications for Retirement Security and the Financial Marketplace, MitchellOlivia S.LusardiAnnamaria, eds. Oxford University Press, 17–39.
46.
LynchJohn G.,Jr.NetemeyerRichard G.SpillerStephen A.ZammitAlessandra (2010), “A Generalizable Scale of Propensity to Plan: The Long and the Short of Planning for Time and For Money,” Journal of Consumer Research, 37 (1), 108–28.
MartinPatricia P.KintzelDale (2016), “A Comparison of Free Online Tools for Individuals Deciding When to Claim Social Security Benefits,” Research and Statistics Note No. 2016-03, https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/rsnotes/rsn2016-03.html.
49.
MerkleChristophSchreiberPhilippWeberMartin (2022), “Inconsistent Retirement Timing,” Journal of Human Resources (published online January 13), DOI: 10.3368/jhr.0920-11215R2.
50.
MertensStephanieHerberzMarioHahnelUlf J. J.BroschTobias (2022a), “The Effectiveness of Nudging: A Meta-Analysis of Choice Architecture Interventions Across Behavioral Domains,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119 (1), e2107346118.
51.
MertensStephanieHerberzMarioHahnelUlf J.J.BroschTobias (2022b), “Reply to Maier, et al., Szaszi et al., and Bakdash and Marusich: The Present and Future of Choice Architecture Research,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119 (31), e2202928119.
52.
MilkmanKatherine L.PatelMitesh S.GandhiLinneaGraciHeather N.GrometDena M.HoHungKayJoseph S.LeeTimothy W.AkinolaModupeBeshearsJohnBogardJonathan E.ButtenheimAlisonChabrisChristopher F.ChapmanGretchen B.ChoiJames J.DaiHengchenFoxCraig R.GorenAmirHilcheyMatthew D.HmurovicJillian, et al. (2021), “A Megastudy of Text-Based Nudges Encouraging Patients to Get Vaccinated at an Upcoming Doctor’s Appointment,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118 (20), e2101165118.
53.
MrkvaKellenPosnerNathaniel A.ReeckCrystalJohnsonEric J. (2021), “Do Nudges Reduce Disparities? Choice Architecture Compensates for Low Consumer Knowledge,” Journal of Marketing, 85 (4), 67–84.
PayneJohn W.SagaraNamikaShuSuzanne B.AppeltKirstin C.JohnsonEric J. (2013), “Life Expectancy as a Constructed Belief: Evidence of a Live-To or Die-By Framing Effect,” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 46 (1), 27–50.
56.
PeckJoannShuSuzanne B. (2018), Psychological Ownership and Consumer Behavior. Springer Publishing.
57.
RobitailleNicoleMazarNinaTsaiClaire I.HavivAvery M.HardyElizabeth (2021), “Increasing Organ Donor Registrations with Behavioral Interventions: A Field Experiment,” Journal of Marketing, 85 (3), 168–83.
58.
SchultzP. WesleyNolanJessica M.CialdiniRobert B.GoldsteinNoah J.GriskeviciusVladas (2007), “The Constructive, Destructive, and Reconstructive Power of Social Norms,” Psychological Science, 18 (5), 429–34.
59.
ShovenJohn B.SlavovSita Nataraj (2014), “Does it Pay to Delay Social Security?” Journal of Pension Economics & Finance, 13 (2), 121–44.
60.
ShuSuzanne B. (2018), “Psychological Ownership in Financial Decisions,” in Psychological Ownership and Consumer Behavior, PeckJoannShuSuzanne B., eds. Springer Publishing, 165–76.
ShuSuzanne B.ShuStephen D. (2018), “The Psychology of Decumulation Decisions During Retirement,” Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 5 (2), 216–23.
63.
ShuSuzanne B.ZeithammerRobertPayneJohn W. (2016), “Consumer Preferences for Annuity Attributes: Beyond Net Present Value,” Journal of Marketing Research, 53 (2), 240–62.
64.
SnowbergErikYarivLeeat (2021), “Testing the Waters: Behavior Across Participant Pools,” American Economic Review, 111 (2), 687–719.
StewartNeilUngemachChristophHarrisAdam J.L.BartelsDaniel M.NewellBen R.PaolacciGabriele, et al. (2015), “The Average Laboratory Samples a Population of 7,300 Amazon Mechanical Turk Workers,” Judgment and Decision Making, 10 (5), 479–91.
70.
SunsteinCass R. (2013), “Impersonal Default Rules vs. Active Choices vs. Personalized Default Rules: A Triptych,” SSRN (November 8), http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2171343.
71.
ThalerRichard H.SunsteinCass R. (2008), Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness. Yale University Press.
72.
WeberElke U.JohnsonEric J.MilchKerry F.ChangHannahBrodschollJeffrey C.GoldsteinDaniel G. (2007), “Asymmetric Discounting in Intertemporal Choice: A Query-Theory Account,” Psychological Science, 18 (6), 516–23.
73.
WellerJoshua A.DieckmannNathan F.TuslerMartinMertzC.K.BurnsWilliam J.PetersEllen (2013), “Development and Testing of an Abbreviated Numeracy Scale: A Rasch Analysis Approach,” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 26 (2), 198–212.
74.
WilsonTimothy D.GilbertDaniel T. (2005), “Affective Forecasting: Knowing What to Want,” Current Directions in Psychological Science, 14 (3), 131–34.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
