This research examines how identity claims constructed in narratives by borrowers influence lender decisions about unsecured personal loans. Specifically, do the number of identity claims and their content influence lending decisions, and can they predict the longer-term performance of funded loans? Using data from the peer-to-peer lending website Prosper.com, the authors find that unverifiable information affects lending decisions above and beyond the influence of objective, verifiable information. As the number of identity claims in narratives increases, so does loan funding, whereas loan performance suffers, because these borrowers are less likely to pay back the loan. In addition, identity content plays an important role. Identities focused on being trustworthy or successful are associated with increased loan funding but ironically are less predictive of loan performance than other identities (i.e., moral and economic hardship). Thus, some identity claims aim to mislead lenders, whereas others provide true representations of borrowers.
AquinoKarl F., FreemanDan, ReedAmericusII, LimVivien K.G., and FelpsWill (2009), “Testing a Social-Cognitive Model of Moral Behavior: The Interactive Influence of Situations and Moral Identity Centrality,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 97(1), 123–41.
2.
ArrowKenneth (1974) The Limits of Organization.New York: Norton.
3.
BaumeisterRoy F., BratslavskyEllen, FinkenauerCartin, and VohsKathleen D. (2001), “Bad Is Stronger than Good,”Review of General Psychology, 5(4), 323–70.
4.
BergerJonah, and HeathChip (2007), “When Consumers Diverge from Others: Identity Signaling and Product Domains,”Journal of Consumer Research, 34(2), 121–34.
5.
BrunerJerome S. (1990) Acts of Meaning.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
6.
ButlerJohn K. (1991), “Toward Understanding and Measuring Conditions of Trust: Evolution of a Conditions of Trust Inventory,”Journal of Management, 17(3), 643–63.
7.
CaspiAmer, and GorskyPaul (2006), “Online Deception: Prevalence, Motivation, and Emotion,”CyberPsychology and Behavior, 9(1), 54–59.
8.
ChenXiao-Ping, YaoXin, and KothaSuresh (2009), “Passion and Preparedness in Entrepreneurs’ Business Plan Presentations: A Persuasion Analysis of Venture Capitalists’ Funding Decisions,”Academy of Management Journal, 52(1), 199–214.
9.
CialdiniRobert B., and TrostMelanie R. (1998), “Social Influence: Social Norms, Conformity, and Compliance,” in The Handbook of Social Psychology, 4th ed., GilbertDaniel T., FiskeSusan T., and LindzeyGardner, eds. Boston: McGraw-Hill, 151–92.
10.
CoxDonald F., and RichStuart U. (1964), “Perceived Risk and Consumer Decision-Making: The Case of Telephone Shopping,”Journal of Marketing Research, 1 (November), 32–39.
11.
CramtonCatherine Durnell (2001), “The Mutual Knowledge Problem and Its Consequences for Dispersed Collaboration,”Organization Science, 12(3), 346–71.
12.
DawesRobyn M., and CorriganBernard (1974), “Linear Models in Decision Making,”Psychological Bulletin, 81(2), 95–106.
13.
DuarteJefferson, SiegelStephen, and YoungLance (2009), “Trust and Credit,” working paper, Jones Graduate School of Business, Rice University.
14.
FarrellJoseph, and RabinMatthew (1996), “Cheap Talk,”Journal of Economic Perspectives, 10(3), 103–118.
FriestadMarian, and WrightPeter (1994), “The Persuasion Knowledge Model: How People Cope with Persuasion Attempts,”Journal of Consumer Research, 21(1), 1–31.
17.
GalakJeff, SmallDeborah, and StephenAndrew T. (2011), “Micro-Finance Decision Making: A Field Study of Prosocial Lending,”Journal of Marketing Research, 48(Special Issue), S130–S137.
18.
GergenKenneth J., and GergenMary K. (1997), “Narratives of the Self,” in Memory, Identity, Community: The Idea of Narrative in the Human Sciences, HinchmanLewis P., and HinchmanSandra, eds. Albany: State University of New York, 161–84.
19.
GilbertDaniel T., MalonePatrick S. (1995), “The Correspondence Bias,”Psychological Bulletin, 117(1), 21–38.
20.
GoffmanErving (1959) The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.New York: Doubleday.
21.
HerzensteinMichal, DholakiaUtpal M., and AndrewsRick L. (2011), “Strategic Herding Behavior in Peer-to-Peer Online Loan Auctions,”Journal of Interactive Marketing, 25(1), 27–36.
22.
HoffmanRobert R., and Frank YatesJ. (2005), “Decision Making,”IEEE Intelligent Systems, 20(4), 76–83.
23.
LandisJ. Richard, and KochGary G. (1977), “The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data,”Biometrics, 33(1), 159–74.
24.
LearyM., and KowalskiR. (1990), “Impression Management: A Literature Review and a Two-Component Model,”Psychological Bulletin, 107(1), 34–47.
25.
LevySidney J. (1981), “Interpreting Consumer Mythology: A Structural Approach to Consumer Behavior,”Journal of Marketing, 45 (Summer), 49–62.
26.
MartensMartin L., JenningsJennifer E., and Devereaux JenningsP. (2007), “Do the Stories They Tell Get Them the Money They Need? The Role of Entrepreneurial Narratives in Resource Acquisition,”Academy of Management Journal, 50(5), 1107–32.
27.
MayerRoger C., DavisJames H., and David SchoormanF. (1995), “An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust,”Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 709–734.
28.
MichelsJeremy (2011), “Do Unverifiable Disclosures Matter? Evidence from Peer-to-Peer Lending,” working paper, University of Colorado.
29.
MilesMatthew B., and Michael HubermanA. (1994) Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2d ed.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
30.
NewallSusan, and SwanJacky (2000), “Trust and Inter-organizational Networking,”Human Relations, 53(10), 1287–328.
31.
OsborneRandall E., and GilbertDaniel T. (1992), “The Preoccupational Hazards of Social Life,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 62(2), 219–28.
32.
PettyRichard, and WegenerDuane T. (1998), “Matching Versus Mismatching Attitude Functions: Implications for Scrutiny of Persuasive Messages,”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 24(3), 227–40.
33.
PrattMichael G., RockmannKevin W., and KaufmannJeffrey B. (2006), “Constructing Professional Identity: The Role of Work and Identity Learning Cycles in the Customization of Identity among Medical Residents,”Academy of Management Journal, 49(2), 235–62.
34.
RiessmanCatherine Kohler (1993) Narrative Analysis.Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
35.
RosenfeldPaul, GiacaloneRobert A., and RiordanCatherine A. (1995) Impression Management in Organizations.London: Routledge.
36.
RyanJoe, ReukKatya, and WangCharles (2007), “To Fund or Not to Fund: Determinants of Loan Fundability in the Prosper.com Marketplace,” working paper, Graduate School of Business, Stanford University.
37.
SchauHope Jensen, and GillyMary C. (2003), “We Are What We Post? Self-Presentation in Personal Web Space,”Journal of Consumer Research, 30(3), 385–404.
38.
SchlenkerBarru R., and WeigoldMichael F. (1992), “Interpersonal Processes Involving Impression Regulation and Management,”Annual Review of Psychology, 43, 133–68.
39.
ShafirEldar, SimonsonItamar, and TverskyAmos (1993), “Reason-Based Choice,”Cognition, 49(1-2), 11–36.
40.
SonensheinScott (2010), “We're Changing or Are We? Untangling the Role of Progressive, Regressive and Stability Narratives during Strategic Change Implementation,”Academy of Management Journal, 53(3), 477–512.
41.
ThompsonCraig J. (1996), “Caring Consumers: Gendered Consumption, Meanings and the Juggling Lifestyle,”Journal of Consumer Research, 22(4), 388–407.
42.
WarrenElizabeth, and TyagiAmelia Warren (2003) The Two Income Trap: Why Middle-Class Mothers and Fathers Are Going Broke.New York: Basic Books.
43.
WeaverGary R., and AgleBradley R. (2002), “Religiosity and Ethical Behavior in Organizations: A Symbolic Interactionist Perspective,”Academy of Management Review, 27(1), 77–97.
44.
WeissAllen M., LurieNicholas H., and MacInnisDeborah J. (2008), “Listening to Strangers: Where Responses Are Valuable, How Valuable Are They and Why?”Journal of Marketing Research, 45 (August), 425–36.
45.
WittL.A., Michele KacmarK., CarlsonDawn S., and ZivnuskaSuzanne (2002), “Interactive Effects of Personality and Organizational Politics on Contextual Performance,”Journal of Organizational Behavior, 23(8), 911–26.
46.
WongNancy, and KingTracey (2008), “The Cultural Construction of Risk Understanding through Illness Narratives,”Journal of Consumer Research, 34(5), 579–94.
47.
WoolcockMichael J.V. (1999), “Learning from Failures in Microfinance: What Unsuccessful Cases Tell Us About How Group-Based Programs Work,”American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 58(1), 17–42.
