The market for supplemental educational programs (SEPs)—tutorials, educational materials, summer programs—has burgeoned. Thus, it is important to understand factors that may influence parents’ choices for SEPs. This article examines how parents’ political identity affects their preference for SEPs contingent on their focus on self. Using two main educational orientations—conformance orientation and independence orientation—the authors argue that SEPs with conformance-oriented pedagogy may be preferred more by conservative parents due to their higher need for structure. This association of political identity with preference for SEPs is moderated by self-focus. Counterintuitively, when using political orientation to target messages for SEPs, firms should frame messages to focus parents on themselves for identity-consistent effects to manifest. Five studies, including a field study, test this theorizing and replicate key results using different measures of political identity and self-focus.
AngleJustin W.Dagogo-JackSokiente W.ForehandMark R.PerkinsAndrew W. (2017), “Activating Stereotypes with Brand Imagery: The Role of Viewer Political Identity,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 27 (1), 84–90.
2.
BelkRussell W. (1988), “Possessions and the Extended Self,” Journal of Consumer Research, 15 (2), 139–68.
3.
BergerJonahHeathChip (2007), “Where Consumers Diverge from Others: Identity Signaling and Product Domains,” Journal of Consumer Research, 34 (2), 121–34.
4.
BergerJonahRandLindsay (2008), “Shifting Signals to Help Health: Using Identity Signaling to Reduce Risky Health Behaviors,” Journal of Consumer Research, 35 (3), 509–18.
5.
BrewerMarilynn B.GardnerWendi (1996), “Who is This ‘We’? Levels of Collective Identity and Self Representations,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 71 (1), 83–93.
6.
BroughAaron R.WilkieJames E.B.MaJingjingIsaacMathew S.GalDavid (2016), “Is Eco-Friendly Unmanly? The Green-Feminine Stereotype and Its Effect on Sustainable Consumption,” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (4), 567–82.
7.
BurnkrantRobert E.UnnavaH. Rao (1995), “Effects of Self-Referencing on Persuasion,” Journal of Consumer Research, 22 (1), 17–26.
8.
CarneyDana R.JostJohn T.GoslingSamuel D.PotterJeff (2008), “The Secret Lives of Liberals and Conservatives: Personality Profiles, Interaction Styles, and the Things They Leave Behind,” Political Psychology, 29 (6), 807–40.
9.
CarverCharles S.ScheierMichael F. (1981), “The Self-Attention-Induced Feedback Loop and Social Facilitation,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 17 (6), 545–68.
10.
ChanEugene Y. (2020), “Political Conservatism and Anthropomorphism: An Investigation,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 30 (3), 515–24.
11.
ChangHannah H.HungIris W. (2018), “Mirror, Mirror on the Retail Wall: Self-Focused Attention Promotes Reliance on Feelings in Consumer Decisions,” Journal of Marketing Research, 55 (4), 586–99.
12.
ChernevAlexander (2003), “Product Assortment and Individual Decision Processes,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 85 (1), 151–62.
13.
ChomaBecky L.HanochYanivHodsonGordonGummerumMichaela (2014), “Risk Propensity Among Liberals and Conservatives: The Effect of Risk Perception, Expected Benefits, and Risk Domain,” Social Psychological and Personality Science, 5 (6), 713–21.
CohenJoel B.ReedAmericus (2006), “A Multiple Pathway Anchoring and Adjustment (MPAA) Model of Attitude Generation and Recruitment,” Journal of Consumer Research, 33 (1), 1–15.
16.
ColemanNicole VerrochiWilliamsPatti (2013), “Feeling Like My Self: Emotion Profiles and Social Identity,” Journal of Consumer Research, 40 (2), 203–22.
17.
CornelisIlseHielAlain Van (2006), “The Impact of Cognitive Styles on Authoritarianism Based Conservatism and Racism,” Basic and Applied Social Psychology, 28 (1), 37–50.
18.
CrawfordJarret T. (2012), “The Ideologically Objectionable Premise Model: Predicting Biased Political Judgments on the Left and Right,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 48 (1), 138–51.
19.
DellaPostaDanielShiYongrenMacyMichael (2015), “Why Do Liberals Drink Lattes?” American Journal of Sociology, 120 (5), 1473–511.
20.
DominoGeorge (1968), “Differential Prediction of Academic Achievement in Conforming and Independent Settings,” Journal of Educational Psychology, 59 (4), 256–60.
21.
DominoGeorge (1971), “Interactive Effects of Achievement Orientation and Teaching Style on Academic Achievement,” Journal of Educational Psychology, 62 (5), 427–31.
22.
DuckittJohn (2001), “A Dual-Process Cognitive-Motivational Theory of Ideology and Prejudice,” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 33, 41–114.
23.
DuckittJohnSibleyChris G. (2010), “Personality, Ideology, Prejudice, and Politics: A Dual-Process Motivational Model,” Journal of Personality, 78 (6), 1861–94.
FarmerAdamKidwellBlairHardestyDavid M. (2020a), “Helping a Few a Lot or Many a Little: Political Ideology and Charitable Giving,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 30 (4), 614–30.
28.
FarmerAdamKidwellBlairHardestyDavid M. (2020b), “The Politics of Choice: Political Ideology and Intolerance of Ambiguity,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 31 (1), 6–21.
29.
FenigsteinAllanLevineMichael P. (1984), “Self-Attention, Concept Activation, and the Causal Self,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 20 (3), 231–45.
30.
FenigsteinAllanScheierMichael F.BussArnold H. (1975), “Public and Private Self-Consciousness: Assessment and Theory,” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 43 (4), 522–27.
31.
FernandesDanielMandelNaomi (2014), “Political Conservatism and Variety-Seeking,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 24 (1), 79–86.
GoughHarrison G. (2000), The California Psychological Inventory. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.
34.
GoukensCarolineDewitteSiegfriedWarlopLuk (2009), “Me, Myself, and My Choices: The Influence of Private Self-Awareness on Choice,” Journal of Marketing Research, 46 (5), 682–92.
35.
GrahamJesseHaidtJonathanNosekBrian A. (2009), “Liberals and Conservatives Rely on Different Sets of Moral Foundations,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 96 (5), 1029–46.
36.
GroveD. JohnRemyRichard C.ZeiglerL. Harmon (1974), “The Effects of Political Ideology and Educational Climates on Student Dissent,” American Politics Quarterly, 2 (3), 259–75.
37.
HanKyuhongJungJihyeMittalVikasZyungJinyong DanielAdamHajo (2019), “Political Identity and Financial Risk Taking: Insights from Social Dominance Orientation,” Journal of Marketing Research, 56 (4), 581–601.
38.
HayesAndrew F. (2013), Introduction to Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Process Analysis: A Regression-Based Approach. New York: Guilford Publications.
39.
HessFrederick M. (2015), Common Sense School Reform. New York: Macmillan.
40.
HormuthStefan E. (1982), “Self-Awareness and Drive Theory: Comparing Internal Standards and Dominant Responses,” European Journal of Social Psychology, 12 (1), 31–45.
41.
HullJay G.LevyAlan S. (1979), “The Organizational Functions of the Self: An Alternative to the Duval and Wicklund Model of Self-Awareness,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37 (5), 756–68.
42.
HullJay G.Van TreurenRonald R.AshfordSusan J.PropsomPamelaAndrusBruce W. (1988), “Self-Consciousness and the Processing of Self-Relevant Information,” Journal of Personality and Social psychology, 54 (3), 452–65.
43.
HungIris W.WyerRobert S.Jr. (2011), “Shaping Consumer Imaginations: The Role of Self-Focused Attention in Product Evaluations,” Journal of Marketing Research, 48 (2), 381–92.
44.
IrmakCaglarMurdockMitchel R.KanuriVamsi K. (2020), “When Consumption Regulations Backfire: The Role of Political Ideology,” Journal of Marketing Research, 57 (5), 966–84.
45.
JostJohn T.GlaserJackKruglanskiArie W.SullowayFrank J. (2003), “Political Conservatism as Motivated Social Cognition,” Psychological Bulletin, 129 (3), 339–75.
46.
JostJohn T.NosekBrian A.GoslingSamuel D. (2008), “Ideology: Its Resurgence in Social, Personality, and Political Psychology,” Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3 (2), 126–36.
47.
JungJihyeMittalVikas (2020), “Political Identity and the Consumer Journey: A Research Review,” Journal of Retailing, 96 (1), 55–73.
48.
JungKijuGarbarinoEllenBrileyDonnel A.WynhausenJesse (2017), “Blue and Red Voices: Effects of Political Ideology on Consumers’ Complaining and Disputing Behavior,” Journal of Consumer Research, 44 (3), 477–99.
49.
KaikatiAndrew M.TorelliCarlos J.WinterichKaren PageRodasMaría A. (2017), “Conforming Conservatives: How Salient Social Identities Can Increase Donations,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 27 (4), 422–34.
50.
KanaiRyotaFeildenTomFirthColinReesGeraint (2011), “Political Orientations Are Correlated with Brain Structure in Young Adults,” Current Biology, 21 (8), 677–80.
51.
KashmiriSaimMahajanVijay (2017), “Values That Shape Marketing Decisions: Influence of Chief Executive Officers’ Political Ideologies on Innovation Propensity, Shareholder Value, And Risk,” Journal of Marketing Research, 54 (2), 260–78.
KidwellBlairFarmerAdamHardestyDavid M. (2013), “Getting Liberals and Conservatives to Go Green: Political Ideology and Congruent Appeals,” Journal of Consumer Research, 40 (2), 350–67.
54.
KimClaire HeeryungHanDaHeeDuhachekAdamTormalaZakary L. (2018a), “Political Identity, Preference, and Persuasion,” Social Influence, 1–15.
55.
KimJeehye ChristineParkBrianDuboisDavid (2018), “How Consumers’ Political Ideology and Status-Maintenance Goals Interact to Shape Their Desire for Luxury Goods,” Journal of Marketing, 82 (6), 132–49.
56.
KruglanskiArie W.WebsterDonna M. (1991), “Group Members’ Reactions to Opinion Deviates and Conformists at Varying Degrees of Proximity to Decision Deadline and of Environmental Noise,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 61 (2), 212–25.
LopataChristopherWallaceNancy V.FinnKristin V. (2005), “Comparison of Academic Achievement Between Montessori and Traditional Education Programs,” Journal of Research in Childhood Education, 20 (1), 5–13.
59.
McConnellAllen R.ShodaTonya M.SkulborstadHayley M. (2012), “The Self as a Collection of Multiple Self-Aspects: Structure, Development, Operation, and Implications,” Social Cognition, 30 (4), 380–95.
60.
MercurioKathryn R.ForehandMark R. (2011), “An Interpretive Frame Model of Identity-Dependent Learning: The Moderating Role of Content-State Association,” Journal of Consumer Research, 38 (3), 555–77.
61.
NeubergSteven L.NewsomJason T. (1993), “Personal Need for Structure: Individual Differences in the Desire for Simpler Structure,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 65 (1), 113–31.
62.
O’HearAnthony (1981), Education, Society and Human Nature: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
OrdabayevaNailyaFernandesDaniel (2018), “Better or Different? How Political Ideology Shapes Preferences for Differentiation in the Social Hierarchy,” Journal of Consumer Research, 45 (2), 227–50.
65.
OysermanDaphna (2001), “Self-Concept and Identity,” in The Blackwell Handbook of Social Psychology: Intraindividual Processes, SchwarzNorbertTesserAbraham, eds. Malden, MA: Blackwell, 499–517.
66.
OysermanDaphna (2009), “Identity-Based Motivation: Implications for Action-Readiness, Procedural-Readiness, and Consumer Behavior,” Journal of Consumer Psychology, 19 (3), 250–60.
67.
PahariaNeeruSwaminathanVanitha (2019), “Who Is Wary of User Design? The Role of Power-Distance Beliefs in Preference for User-Designed Products,” Journal of Marketing, 83 (3), 91–107.
68.
PayneStephanie C.YoungcourtSatoris S.BeaubienJ. Matthew (2007), “A Meta-Analytic Examination of the Goal Orientation Nomological Net,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 92 (1), 128–50.
69.
PetersonPenelope L. (1977), “Interactive Effects of Student Anxiety, Achievement Orientation, and Teacher Behavior on Student Achievement and Attitude,” Journal of Educational Psychology, 69 (6), 779–92.
70.
PhamMichel TuanGoukensCarolineLehmannDonald R.StuartJennifer Ames (2010), “Shaping Customer Satisfaction Through Self-Awareness Cues,” Journal of Marketing Research, 47 (5), 920–32.
71.
PitesaMarkoThauStefan (2013), “Compliant Sinners, Obstinate Saints: How Power and Self-Focus Determine the Effectiveness of Social Influences in Ethical Decision Making,” Academy of Management Journal, 56 (3), 635–58.
72.
PyszczynskiTomHoltKathleenGreenbergJeff (1987), “Depression, Self-Focused Attention, and Expectancies for Positive and Negative Future Life Events for Self and Others,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52 (5), 994–1001.
73.
RavitchDiane (2000), The Great School Wars: A History of the New York City Public Schools. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
74.
ReedAmericus, IIForehandMark R.PuntoniStefanoWarlopLuk (2012), “Identity-Based Consumer Behavior,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 29 (4), 310–21.
75.
RietzschelEric F.De DreuCarsten K.W.NijstadBernard A. (2007), “Personal Need for Structure and Creative Performance: The Moderating Influence of Fear of Invalidity,” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 33 (6), 855–66.
76.
RossHelgola G. (1980), “Matching Achievement Styles and Instructional Environments,” Contemporary Educational Psychology, 5 (3), 216–26.
77.
RubinsteinGidi (2003), “Authoritarianism and Its Relation to Creativity: A Comparative Study Among Students of Design, Behavioral Sciences and Law,” Personality and Individual Differences, 34 (4), 695–705.
78.
SaucierGerard (2000), “Isms and the Structure of Social Attitudes,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78 (2), 366–85.
79.
ScheierMichael F.BussArnold H.BussDavid M. (1978), “Self-Consciousness, Self-Report of Aggressiveness, and Aggression,” Journal of Research in Personality, 12 (2), 133–40.
80.
ScheierMichael F.CarverCharles S. (1977), “Self-Focused Attention and the Experience of Emotion: Attraction, Repulsion, Elation, and Depression,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35 (9), 625–36.
81.
ScheierMichael F.CarverCharles S. (1985), “The Self-Consciousness Scale: A Revised Version for Use with General Populations 1,” Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 15 (8), 687–99.
82.
SowellThomas (2007), A Conflict of Visions: Ideological Origins of Political Struggles. New York: Basic Books.
83.
SujanMitaBettmanJames R.BaumgartnerHans (1993), “Influencing Consumer Judgments Using Autobiographical Memories: A Self-Referencing Perspective,” Journal of Marketing Research, 30 (4), 422–36.
84.
ThompsonM.M.NaccaratoM.E.ParkerK.E. (1992), “Measuring Cognitive Needs: The Development and Validation of the Personal Need for Structure (PNS) and Personal Fear of Invalidity (PFI) Measures,” unpublished manuscript.
85.
TrudelRemiArgoJennifer J.MengMatthew D. (2016), “The Recycled Self: Consumers’ Disposal Decisions of Identity-Linked Products,” Journal of Consumer Research, 43 (2), 246–64.
86.
Van HielAlainKossowskaMalgorzataMervieldeIvan (2000), “The Relationship Between Openness to Experience and Political Ideology,” Personality and Individual Differences, 28 (4), 741–51.
87.
WatkinsLeahAitkenRobertMatherDamien (2016), “Conscientious Consumers: A Relationship Between Moral Foundations, Political Orientation and Sustainable Consumption,” Journal of Cleaner Production, 134, 137–46.
88.
WhiteKatherineArgoJennifer J.SenguptaJaideep (2012), “Dissociative Versus Associative Responses to Social Identity Threat: The Role of Consumer Self-Construal,” Journal of Consumer Research, 39 (4), 704–19.
89.
WhiteKatherineDahlDarren W. (2007), “Are All Out-Groups Created Equal? Consumer Identity and Dissociative Influence,” Journal of Consumer Research, 34 (4), 525–36.
90.
WinterichKaren PageZhangYinlongMittalVikas (2012), “How Political Identity and Charity Positioning Increase Donations: Insights from Moral Foundations Theory,” International Journal of Research in Marketing, 29 (4), 346–54.
91.
ZhangYinlongFeickLawrenceMittalVikas (2013), “How Males and Females Differ in Their Likelihood of Transmitting Negative Word of Mouth,” Journal of Consumer Research, 40 (6), 1097–108.
92.
ZimmerRonGillBrianRazquinPaulaBookerKevinLockwoodJ.R.VernezGeorges, et al. (2007), “Do Title I School Choice and Supplemental Educational Services Affect Student Achievement?” Rand (accessed March 23, 2019), http://www.rand.org/pubs/research_briefs/RB9273/.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
