Using cross-national data containing information on the status rank of network alters, this study investigates the potential negative effects of “upward status heterophily,” ties to and perceived interaction with higher status others. According to our main finding, upward status heterophily is associated with poor physical health and lower subjective well-being. We also find that this focal relationship varies across individual and contextual moderators. For subjective well-being only, it is weaker among people who are better educated, have larger nonkin network, and possess greater self-efficacy. Moreover, there is a significant cross-level interaction: For both health outcomes, the relationship is more pronounced in subnational regions that are economically more unequal. Our findings shed light on the mechanisms of the “dark side of social capital” by operationalizing perceived status differential as a proxy for upward social comparison and showing its deleterious consequences in the East Asian context.
AldersonArthur S.Katz-GerroTally. 2016. “Compared to Whom? Inequality, Social Comparison and Happiness.” Social Forces95(1):25–53.
2.
AustinPeter C.StuartElizabeth C.2015. “Moving towards Best Practice when Using Inverse Probability of Treatment Weighting (IPTW) Using the Propensity Score to Estimate Causal Treatment Effects in Observational Studies.” Statistics in Medicine34:3661–79.
3.
BaldwinMatthewMussweilerThomas. 2018. “The Culture of Social Comparison.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences115(43):E9067–74.
4.
BanduraAlbert. 2012. “On the Functional Properties of Perceived Self-Efficacy Revisited.” Journal of Management38(1):9–44.
5.
BianYanjieIkedaKen’ichi. 2018. “East Asian Social Networks.” Pp. 679–836 in Encyclopedia of Social Network Analysis and Mining, edited by AlhajjR.RokneJ.New York, NY: Springer.
6.
Campos-MatosInesSubramanianS. V.KawachiIchiro. 2016. “The ‘Dark Side’ of Social Capital: Trust and Self-Rated Health in European Countries.” European Journal of Public Health26(1):90–95.
7.
DaviesJames B.ShorrocksAnthony F.1989. “Optimal Grouping of Income and Wealth Data.” Journal of Econometrics42:97–108.
8.
DienerEdLucasRichard E.OishiShigehiro. 2002. “Subjective Well-Being: The Science of Happiness and Life Satisfaction.” Pp. 63–73 in Handbook of Positive Psychology, edited by LopezS. J.SnyderC. R.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
9.
DiMaggioPaulGaripFiliz. 2012. “Network Effects and Social Inequality.” Annual Review of Sociology38:93–118.
10.
DominaThurstonPennerAndrewPennerEmily. 2017. “Categorical Inequality: Schools as Sorting Machines.” Annual Review of Sociology43:311–30.
11.
EhsanAnnahitaKlaasHannah SophieBastianenAlexanderSpiniDario. 2019. “Social Capital and Health: A Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews.” SSM – Population Health8:100425. doi:10.1016/j.ssmph.2019.100425.
12.
FirebaughGlennSchroederMatthew B.2009. “Does Your Neighbor’s Income Affect Your Happiness?” American Journal of Sociology115(3):805–31.
13.
FischerClaude S.HoutMichael. 2006. Century of Difference: How America Changed in the Last One Hundred Years. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
14.
FiskeSusan. 2011. Envy up, Scorn down: How Status Divides US. New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
15.
GanzeboomHarry B. G.TriemanDonald J.1996. “Internationally Comparable Measures of Occupational Status for the 1988 International Standard Classification of Occupations.”Social Science Research25(3):201–39.
16.
GartrellC. David. 2002. “The Embeddedness of Social Comparison.” Pp. 164–84 in Relative Deprivation: Specification, Development, and Integration, edited by WalkerI.SmithH. J.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
17.
GrangerEmilySergeantJamie C.LuntMark. 2019. “Avoiding Pitfalls When Combining Multiple Imputation and Propensity Scores.” Statistics in Medicine38(5):1–13.
18.
HoogerbruggeMarloes M.BurgerMartijn J.2018. “Neighborhood-Based Social Capital and Life Satisfaction: The Case of Rotterdam, the Netherlands.” Urban Geography39(10):1484–509.
19.
HuangXianbiWesternMarkBianYanjieLiYaojunCôtéRochelleHuangYangtao. 2019. “Social Networks and Subjective Well-Being in Australia: New Evidence from a National Survey.” Sociology53(2):401–21.
20.
JouYuh HueyFukudaHiromi. 2002. “Stress, Health, and Reciprocity and Sufficiency of Social Support: The Case of University Students in Japan.” The Journal of Social Psychology142(3):353–70.
21.
KawachiIchiroBerkmanLisa F.2003. Neighborhoods and Health. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
22.
KawachiIchiroKennedyBruce P.1997. “Health and Social Cohesion: Why Care about Income Inequality?” BMJ314(7086):1037–40.
23.
KimH. HarrisJungJong Hyun. 2022. “Relational Burden, Loneliness, and Depression among American Older Adults: An Inquiry into the ‘Dark Side of Social Capital.’” Aging & Mental Health. doi:10.1080/13607863.2022.2045564.
24.
LeeMin-AhKawachiIchiro. 2017. “The Company You Keep: Is Socialising with Higher Status People Bad for Mental Health?” Sociology of Health & Illness39(7):1206–26.
25.
LinNan. 2001. Social Capital: A Theory of Social Structure and Action. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
26.
LinNanEricksonBonnie, eds. 2012. Social Capital: An International Research Program. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
27.
LinYanweiZhangQuiChenWenLingLi. 2017. “The Social Income Inequality, Social Integration, and Health Status of Internal Migrants in China.” International Journal of Equity in Health16:139. doi:10.1186/s12939-017-0640-9.
28.
MaassRucaKloecknerChristian A.LindstrømBengtLillefjellMonica. 2016. “The Impact of Neighborhood Social Capital on Life Satisfaction and Self-Rated Health: A Possible Pathway for Health Promotion?” Health & Place42:120–28.
29.
McPhersonMillerSmith-LovinLynnCookJames M.2001. “Birds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks.” Annual Review of Sociology27:415–44.
30.
MelitaDavideWillisGuillermo B.Rodríguez-BailónRosa. 2021. “Economic Inequality Increases Status Anxiety through Perceived Contextual Competitiveness.” Frontiers in Psychology12:637365. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2021.637365.
31.
MooreSpencerChildStephanieWuYun-HsuanMandelbaumJennifer. 2018. “Network Approaches to the Study of Social Capital and Health.” Pp. 221–31 in Elgar Companion to Social Capital and Health, edited by FollandS.NauenbergE.Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
32.
MooreSpencerDanielMarkGauvinLiseDubéLaurette. 2009. “Not All Social Capital Is Good Capital.” Health & Place15:1071–77.
33.
MurayamaHiroshiNofujiYuMatsuoEriNishiMarikoTaniguchiYuFujiwaraYoshinoriShinkaiShoji. 2015. “Are Neighborhood Bonding and Bridging Social Capital Protective against Depressive Mood in Old Age? A Multilevel Analysis in Japan.” Social Science & Medicine124:171–79. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2014.11.042.
34.
OfferShira. 2012. “The Burden of Reciprocity: Processes of Exclusion and Withdrawal from Personal Networks among Low Income Families.” Current Sociology60(6):788–805.
35.
OfferShiraFisherClaude S.2018. “Difficult People: Who Is Perceived to Be Demanding in Personal Networks and Why Are They There?” American Sociological Review83(1):111–42.
36.
OlivosFranciscoOlivos-JaraPabloBrowneMagdalena. 2021. “Asymmetric Social Comparison and Life Satisfaction in Social Networks.” Journal of Happiness Studies22:363–84.
37.
Pham-KanterGenevieve. 2009. “Social Comparisons and Health: Can Having Richer Friends and Neighbors Make You Sick?” Social Science & Medicine69(3):335–44.
38.
PickettKate E.WilkinsonRichard G.2015. “Income Inequality and Health: A Causal Review.” Social Science & Medicine128:316–26.
39.
PortesAlejandro. 1998. “Social Capital: Its Origins and Applications in Modern Sociology.” Annual Review of Sociology24:1–24.
40.
PrägPatrickMillsMelinda C.WittekRafael. 2016. “Subjective Socioeconomic Status and Health in Cross-National Comparison.” Social Science & Medicine149:84–92.
41.
PrimoDavid M.JacobsmeierMatthew L.MilyoJeffrey. 2007. “Estimating the Impact of State Policies and Institutions with Mixed-Level Data.” States Politics & Policy Quarterly7(4):446–59.
42.
RambottiSimone. 2015. “Recalibrating the Spirit Level: An Analysis of the Interaction of Income Inequality and Poverty and Its Effect on Health.” Social Science & Medicine139:123–31.
43.
RaudenbushStephen W.BrykAnthony S.CongdonRichard T.2019. HLM 8 for Windows [Computer software]. Skokie, IL: Scientific Software International, Inc.
44.
RookKaren. 1984. “The Negative Side of Social Interaction: Impact on Psychological Well-Being.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology46(5):1097–108.
45.
RothsteinBoUslanerEric M.2005. “All for All: Equality, Corruption, and Social Trust.” World Politics58(1):41–72.
46.
RoystonPatrickWhiteIan R.2011. “Mutiple Imputation by Chained Equations (MICE): Implementation in Stata.” Journal of Statistical Software45(4):1–20.
47.
SahuF. M.RathSangeeta. 2003. “Self-Efficacy and Well-Being in Working and Nonworking Women: The Moderating Role of Involvement.” Psychology and Developing Societies15(2):187–200.
48.
SasakiJoni Y.KoDeborah M.KimHeejung S.2014. “Culture and Self-Worth: Implications for Social Comparison Processes and Coping with Threats to Self-Worth.” Pp. 230–52 in Communal Functions of Social Comparison, edited by KrižanZ.GibbonsF. X.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
49.
SmithHeather J.HuoYuen J.2014. “Relative Deprivation: How Subjective Experiences of Inequality Influence Social Behavior and Health.” Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences1(1):231–38.
50.
SmithHeather J.PettigrewThomas F.PippinGina M.BialosiewiczSilvana. 2012. “Relative Deprivation: A Theoretical and Meta-analytic Review.” Personality and Social Psychology Review16(3):203–32.
51.
SongLijun. 2011. “Social Capital and Psychological Distress.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior52(4):478–92.
52.
SongLijun. 2015. “Does Knowing People in Authority Protect or Hurt? Authoritative Contacts and Depression in Urban China.” American Behavioral Scientist59(9):1173–88.
53.
SongLijun. 2020. “Social Capital, Social Cost, and Relational Culture in Three Societies.” Social Psychology Quarterly83(4):443–62.
54.
SongLijunChenWenhong. 2014. “Does Receiving Unsolicited Support Help or Hurt? Receipt of Unsolicited Job Leads and Depression.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior55(2):144–60.
55.
SongLijunPettisPhilip J.2020. “Does Whom You Know in the Status Hierarchy Prevent or Trigger Health Limitation? Institutional Embeddedness of Social Capital and Social Cost Theories in Three Societies.” Social Science & Medicine257:111959. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2018.09.035.
56.
SongLijunPettisPhilip J.ChenYvonneGoodson-MillerMarva. 2021. “Social Cost and Health: The Downside of Social Capital and Social Networks.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior62(3):371–87. doi:10.1177/00221465211029353.
57.
StataCorp. 2019. Stata Statistical Software: Release 16 [Computer software]. College Station, TX: StataCorp LLC.
58.
StoryWilliam T.GlanvilleJennifer L.2019. “Comparing the Association between Social Capital and Self-Rated Health in Poor and Affluent Nations.” SSM – Population Health9:100508. doi:10.1016/j.ssmph.2019.100508.
59.
SungPildooSonJoonmo. 2020. “In-Group Trust and Self-Rated Health in East Asia Using Quadrinational Survey Data.” International Journal of Comparative Sociology61(1):27–58.
60.
TakYuli R.BrunwasserSteven M.Lichtwarck-AschoffAnnaEngelsRutger C. M. E.2017. “The Protective Associations between Self-Efficacy and Depressive Symptoms from Early to Middle Adolescence: A Cross-Lagged Model.” Journal of Youth Adolescence46:744–56.
61.
TakagiDaisukeKondoKatsunoriKondoNaokiCableNorikoIkedaKenichiKawachiIchiro. 2013. “Social Disorganization/Social Fragmentation and Risk of Depression among Older People in Japan: Multilevel Investigation of Indices of Social Distance.” Social Science & Medicine83:81–89. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2013.01.001.
62.
TanJacinth J. X.KrausMichaelCarpenterNichelle C.AdlerNancy E.2020. “The Association between Obejctive and Subjective Socioecononic Standing and Subjective Well-Being: A Meta-analytic Review.” Psychological Bulletin146(11):970–1020.
63.
ThoitsPeggy A.2011. “Mechanisms Linking Social Ties and Support to Physical and Mental Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior52(2):145–61.
64.
TruesdaleBeth C.JencksChristopher. 2016. “The Health Effects of Income Inequality: Averages and Disparities.” Annual Review of Public Health37:413–30.
65.
UmbersonDebraCrosnoeRobertReczekCorinne. 2010. “Social Relationships and Health Behavior across Life Course.” Annual Review of Sociology36:139–57.
66.
UmbersonDebraMontezJennifer K.2010. “Social Relationships and Health: A Flashpoint for Health Policy.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(Suppl.):S54–66.
67.
Van der GaagMartinSnijdersTom A. B.FlapHenk. 2008. “Position Generator Measures and Their Relationship to Other Social Capital Measures.” Pp. 27–48 in Social Capital: An International Research Program, edited by LinN.EricksonB.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
68.
Van der MeerTomTe GrotenhuisManfredPlezerBen. 2010. “Influential Cases in Multilevel Modeling: A Methodological Comment.” American Sociological Review75(1):173–78.
69.
VerhaeghePieter-PaulLiYaojun. 2015. “Socioeconomic and Ethnic Inequalities in Social Capital from the Family among Labour Market Entrants.” European Sociological Review29(4):683–94.
70.
VerhaeghePieter-PaulPattynEliseBrackePietVerhaegheMiekeVan De PutteBart. 2012. “The Association between Network Social Capital and Self-Rated Health: Pouring Old Wine in New Bottles?” Health & Place18:358–65.
71.
Villalonga-OlivesEsterKawachiIchiro. 2017. “The Dark Side of Social Capital: A Systematic Review of the Negative Health Effects of Social Capital.” Social Science & Medicine194:105–27.
72.
WeigelDaniel J.ShroutM. Rosie. 2020. “Relational Turbulence and Health-Compromising Behaviors: Integrating Relational Turbulence and Stress Theories.” Personal Relationships27(4):785–800.
73.
WilkinsonRichard G.PickettKate E.2006. “Income Inequality and Population Health: A Review and Explanation of the Evidence.” Social Science & Medicine62(7):1768–84.
74.
XueXindongReedW. RobertMenclovaAndrea. 2020. “Social Capital and Health: A Meta-analysis.” Journal of Health Economics72:102317. doi:10.1016/j.jhealeco.2020.102317.
75.
YangXiaozhao YousefHuAnningSchiemanScott. 2019. “Relative Deprivation in Context: How Contextual Status Homogeneity Shapes the Relationship between Disadvantaged Social Status and Health.” Social Science Research81:157–69.
76.
ZajacovaAnnaLawrenceElizabeth M.2018. “The Relationship between Education and Health: Reducing Disparities through a Contextual Approach.” Annual Review of Public Health39:273–89.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
