Legal precedent for criminalizing the behavior of pregnant women has been established in an attempt to protect the fetus. Elevating fetal rights over maternal rights is based on questionable assumptions and inconclusive medical evidence. These criminalization policies are sexist and serve to victimize poor, pregnant women. This paper examines the evidence and policies and suggests an alternative policy approach to dealing with families with parental drug use issues.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbelE.L.SokelR.J.1987Incidence of fetal alcohol syndrome and economic impact of FAS related anomalies. Drug and Alcohol Dependence19:51–70.
2.
AmaroH.FriedL.CabralH.1990Violence during pregnancy and substance abuse. American Journal of Public Health80:5.
3.
American Bar Association1989Crime and Pregnancy. American Bar Journal14–16.
4.
BandstraE.SteeleB.BurketteG.PaltrowD.LevandowskiN.RodriguezB.1989Prevalence of perinatal exposure in an urban multi-ethnic population (Summary). Program Issues of Pediatric Research25(2):247.
5.
BarryE.1985Quality of prenatal care for incarcerated women challenged. Youth Law News6(6):1–4.
6.
BenowitzN.L.1991Nicotine replacement therapy during pregnancy. Journal of the American Medical Association266(22):3174–3177.
7.
BeratisN.G.PanagouliasD.VarvarigouA.1996Increased blood pressure in neonates and infants whose mothers smoked during pregnancy. Journal of Pediatrics128(6):806–812.
8.
Bureau of Justice Statistics1995aPrisoners in 1994, Washington D.C.: U.S. Department of Justice.
9.
Bureau of Justice Statistics1995bCorrectional populations in the United States. Washington D.C.U.S. Department of Justice.
10.
BumsK.MelamedM.BurnsW.ChasnoffI.HatcherR.1985Chemical dependency and clinical depression in pregnancy. Journal of Clinical Psychology41(6):851–854.
11.
CartenA.J.1996Mothers in recovery: Rebuilding families in the aftermath of addiction. Social Work41:214–223.
12.
Center for Substance Abuse Treatment1993Pregnant, substance-using women. Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
13.
ChasnoffI.J.1989Drug use and women: Establishing a standard of care. Annals of New York Academy of Sciences562:2008–10.
14.
ChasnoffI.J.GriffithD.FreierC.MurrayJ.1992Cocaine/polydrug use in pregnancy: Two year followup. Pediatrics89:284–289.
15.
ChasnoffI.J.LandressH.J.BarrettM.E.1990The prevalence of illicit drug or alcohol use during pregnancy and the discrepancies in mandatory reporting in Pinellas County, Florida. New England Journal of Medicine322(17):1202–1206.
16.
Child Welfare League of America1990Crack and other addictions: Old realities and new challenges. Washington D.C.Author.
CloseC.RobertsP.BergerR.1990Cigarettes, alcohol and marijuana are related to pyospermia in infertile men. Journal of Urology144(4):900–903.
19.
Committee on Ways and Means1991Background material and data on programs within the jurisdiction of the Committee on Ways and Means. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
20.
CorderoL.CustardM.1990Effects of maternal cocaine abuse on perinatal and infant outcomes. Ohio Medicine86(5)410–412.
21.
DavisD.L.FriedlerG.MattisonR.MorrisR.1992Male-mediated teratogenesis and other reproductive effects: Biologic and epidemiologic findings and a plea for clinical research. Reproductive Toxicology6:289–292.
22.
DayN.L.RichardsonG.A.GoldschmidtL.RoblesN.TaylorP.M.StofferD.S.CorneliusM.D.GevaD.1994Effect of prenatal marijuana exposure on the cognitive development of offspring at age three. Neurotoxicology and Teratology16(2):169–175.
23.
DiFranzaJ.R.LewR.A.1996Morbidity and mortality in children associated with the use of tobacco products by other people. Pediatrics97(4):560–568.
24.
EisenL.N.FieldT.M.BandstraE.S.RobertsJ.P.MorrowC.LarsonS.K.SteeleB.M.1991Perinatal cocaine effects on neonatal stress behavior and performance on the Brazelton scale. Pediatrics88:477–480.
25.
FriedP.A.MakinJ.E.1987Neonatal behavioral correlates of prenatal exposure to marijuana, cigarettes, and alcohol in a low risk population. Neurotoxicology and Teratology9:1–7.
26.
FriedP.A.WatkinsonB.GrayR.1992A follow-up study of attentional behavior in 6 year old children exposed prenatally to marijuana, cigarettes, and alcohol. Neurotoxicology and Teratology14:299–311.
27.
GombyD.S.ShionoP.H.1991Estimating the number of substance-exposed infants. The Future of Children1(1):17–25.
28.
GustavssonN.S.1991aChemically exposed children: The child welfare response. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal8(4):297–307.
29.
GustavssonN.S.1991bThe war metaphor: A threat to vulnerable populations. Social Work36:277–278.
30.
GustavssonN.S.1992Drug exposed children and their mothers: Facts, myths, and needs. Social Work in Health Care16(4):87–100.
31.
GustavssonN.S.SegalE.A.1994Critical issues in child welfare. California: Sage.
32.
HawkM.A.1994How social policies make matters worse: The case of maternal substance abuse. Journal of Drug Issues24(3):517–526.
33.
HutchingsD.1985Prenatal opioid exposure and the problem and casual inference. In Current research on the consequences of maternal drug abuse, ed. PinkertT., 6–19. Maryland: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
34.
HutchingsD.1990Issues of risk assessment: Lessons from the use and abuse of drugs during pregnancy. Neurotoxicology and Teratology12(3):183–189.
35.
JonesK.SmithD.1973Recognition of fetal alcohol syndrome in early infancy. LancetII(7836):999–1001.
36.
KorenG.ShearH.GrahamK.EinarsonT.1989Bias against the null hypothesis: The reproductive hazards of cocaine. Lancet2(December 16):1440–1442.
37.
KumpferK.1991Treatment programs for drug abusing women. The Future of Children1(1):50–60.
38.
LandD.KushnerR.1991Drug abuse during pregnancy in an inner-city hospital: Prevalence and patterns. Journal of the American Osteopathic Association90(5):421–426.
39.
LiD.K.DalingJ.R.1991Maternal smoking, low birth weight, and ethnicity in relation to sudden infant death syndrome. American Journal of Epidemiology134:958–964.
40.
LiD.K.MuellerB.A.HickokD.E.DalingJ.R.FantelA.G.CheckowayH.WeissN.S.1996Maternal smoking during pregnancy and the risk of congenital urinary tract anomalies. American Journal of Public Health86(2):249–253.
41.
McFarlaneJ.ParkerB.SoekenK.BullockL.1992Assessing for abuse during pregnancy. Journal of the American Medical Association267(23):3176–3178.
42.
McNultyM.1990Pregnancy police: Implications of criminalizing fetal abuse. Youth Law News11(1):33–37.
43.
National Institute of Justice1994Drug-abusing women offenders: Results of a national survey. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
44.
National Institute on Drug Abuse1993aConference Highlights from the 2nd National Conference on Drug Abuse Research and Practice. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
45.
National Institute on Drug Abuse1993bNational household survey on drug abuse. Rockville, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse.
46.
NeuspielD.R.1993Cocaine and the fetus: Mythology of Severe Risk. Neurotoxicology and Tetratology15:305–306.
47.
NordentoftM.LouH.C.HansenD.NimJ.PrydsO.RubinP.HemmingsenR.1996Intrauterine growth retardation and premature delivery: The influence of maternal smoking and psychosocial factors. American Journal of Public Health86(3):347–354.
48.
Office of National Drug Control Policy1995National drug control strategy. Washington, DC: Executive Office of the President.
49.
Office on Smoking and Health1988The health consequences of smoking: Nicotine addiction. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
50.
Office of Technology Assessment1985Reproductive health hazards in the workplace. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
51.
ReganD.EhrlichS.FinneganL., 1987Infants of drug addicts: At risk for child abuse, neglect, and placement in foster care. Neurotoxicology and Teratology9:315–319.
52.
RosengrenJ.1990Alcohol: A bigger drug problem?Minnesota Medicine73:33–34.
53.
Select Committee on Children, Youth, and Families1989Born hooked: Confronting the impact of perinatal substance abuse. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
54.
ShaferD.DunbarV.FalekA.DonahoeR.MaddenR.BokosP.1990Enhanced assays detect increased chromosome damage and sister-chromatid exchanges in heroin addicts. Mutation Research234(5):327–336.
55.
ShawG.M.WassermanC.R.LammerE.J.O'MalleyC.D.MurraJ.C.BassartA.M.TolarovaM.M.1996Craniofacial clefts, parental cigarette smoking, and transforming growth factor-alpha gene variants. American Journal of Human Genetics58(3):551–561.
56.
Subcommittee on Human Resources1990The impact of crack cocaine on the child welfare system. Hearing held in Washington DC.
57.
TelseyA.MerritA.DixonS.1988Cocaine exposure in a term neonate. Necrotizing enterocolitis as a complication. Clinical Pediatrics258(11):547–550.
58.
U.S. General Accounting Office1990Drug exposed infants: A generation at risk. Washington D.C.Government Printing Office.
59.
U.S. General Accounting Office1995aChild welfare: Complex needs strain capacity to provide services. Washington D.C.U.S. Government Printing Office.
60.
U.S. General Accounting Office1995bDrug courts: Information on a new approach to address drug-related crime. Washington D.C.U.S. Government Printing Office.
61.
U.S. General Accounting Office1995cDrug war: Observations on the U.S. international drug control strategy. Washington D.C.U. S. Government Printing Office.
62.
WebbG.1996Drug network linked street gangs, contras. The Arizona Republic, August 25, A23.
63.
WilliamsM.A.MittendorfR.LeibermanE.MonsonR.R.SchoenbaumS.C.GenestD. R.1991Cigarette smoking during pregnancy in relation to placenta previa. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology165:28–32.
64.
WilsonG.1989Clinical studies of infants and children prenatally exposed to heroin. In Prenatal abuse of licit and illicit drugs, ed. HutchingsD.E., 183–194. New York:New York Academy of Sciences.
65.
WoodsN.S.EylerF.D.BehnkeM.ConlonM.1993Cocaine use during pregnancy: Maternal depressive symptoms and infant neurobehavior over the first month. Infant Behavior Development16:83–98.
66.
ZuckermanB.FrankD.1992Crack kids not broken. Pediatrics89:337–339.
67.
ZuckermanB.FrankD.HingsonR.AmaroH.LevensonS.KayneH.ParkerS.VinciR.AboagyeK.FriedL.CabralH.TimperiR.BauchnerH.1989Effect of maternal marijuana and cocaine use on fetal growth. New England Journal of Medicine320(12):762–767.
68.
In re A.C., 573 A.2d 1235 (D.C. App. 1990).
69.
In re Baby X, 293 N.W. 2d 736, 739 (Mich. Ct. App. 1980).
70.
In re Jamaica Hospital, 491 N.Y.S.2d at 900 (N.Y. 1985).
71.
Jackson v. State, 833 S.W. 2d 220, 221 (Tex. 1992).
72.
Johnson v. State, 578 So. 2d 419, 419 (Fla. 1991).
73.
People v. Stewart, No. M508097 (San Diego County Court, February 23, 1987).
74.
Reinesto v. Superior Court of the State of Arizona (ICA-SA 94-0348 1994).
75.
Reyes v. Superior Court 141 Cal. Rptr. 912 (Cal. Ct. App. 1977).
