The 1996 U.S. presidential campaign represents an unusual and important case for research on the social construction of drug problems. Presidential candidate Robert Dole and other prominent politicians made dramatic claims about a growing teenage “drug crisis” based on supportive evidence from several national surveys. However, these claims were often ignored and even criticized by the news media. This paper examines how and why journalists responded so differently to this putative crisis than they did to earlier drug crises, such as the media “feeding frenzy” about crack cocaine in the 1980s. An analysis of news stories, political statements, and editorial commentary that appeared in major news outlets during 1995 and 1996 reveals a number of tactics that media workers employed to deconstruct politicians' claims and to frame the drug issue as an election-year strategy rather than as an authentic crisis.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AltheideD.L.1997The news media, the problem frame, and the production of fear. Sociological Quarterly, 38, 647–668.
2.
BeckerH.S.1963Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of deviance. New York: Free Press.
3.
BestJ.1999Random Violence: How we talk about new crimes and new victims. Berkeley: University of California Press.
4.
BrownL.1995White House drug czar and HHS secretary announce national drug survey results and unveil new youth education materials. Press release, Executive Office of the President, Office of National Drug Control Policy, Washington, D.C., September 12.
5.
ChiricosT.1996Moral panic as ideology: Drugs, violence, race and punishment in America. In LynchM.PattersonE.B. (Eds.), Justice with Prejudice. (pp. 19–47) Guilderland, NY: Harrow and Heston.
6.
DiamondE.AccostaF.ThorntonL.1987Is TV news hyping American's cocaine problem?TV Guide, February 7, pp. 4–9.
DuffyB.1986War on drugs: More than a “short-term high”?U.S. News & World Report, September 29, pp. 28–29.
9.
FriendT.1996Teens and drugs: Today's youth just don't see the dangers. USA Today, August 21, p. A1.
10.
GestT.1996Popgun politics. U.S. News & World Report, September 30, pp. 30–42.
11.
GlassnerB.1999The culture of fear: Why Americans are afraid of the wrong things. New York: Basic Books.
12.
GoldbergC.1996Survey reports more drug use by teenagers. New York Times, August 21, p. A8.
13.
GoodeE.Ben-YehudaN.1994Moral panics: The social construction of deviance. Oxford: Blackwell.
14.
GusfieldJ.1963Symbolic crusade: Status politics and the American temperance movement. University of Illinois Press: Urbana.
15.
GusfieldJ.1989Constructing the ownership of social problems: Fun and profit in the welfare state. Social Problems, 36, 431–441.
16.
HardenB.1996Media miss drug story, Dole says. Washington Post, September 20, p. A14.
17.
HatchO.1995Losing ground against drugs: A report on increasing illicit drug use and national drug policy. Senate Committee on the Judiciary, December 19.
18.
HatchO.1996Teen drug use: Recent upward trends. Statement before the Senate Judiciary Committee Hearing, September 4.
19.
HilgartnerS.BoskC.L.1988The rise and fall of social problems: A public arena model. American Journal of Sociology, 94, 53–78.
20.
JensenE.GerberJ.BabcockG.1991The new war on drugs: Grass roots movement or political construction?Journal of Drug Issues, 21, 651–667.
21.
KaplanJ.1970Marijuana–-The new prohibition. New York: World.
22.
KennedyE.1996Teen drug use–-Recent upward trends. Statement before the Senate Judiciary Committee Hearing, September 4.
23.
KerrP.1986Anatomy of the drug issue: How after years, it erupted. New York Times, November 17, p. A1.
24.
KlaidmanD.1996aThe politics of drugs: Back to war. Newsweek, August 26, pp. 57–58.
25.
KlaidmanD.1996bHere's the straight dope: Making sense out of the candidates' claims about drugs. Newsweek, October 21, p. 37.
26.
KurtzH.1996Clinton ad is barbed response and concession to Dole agenda. Washington Post, September 4, p. A11.
27.
LelandJ.1996The fear of heroin is shooting up. Newsweek, August 26, pp. 55–56.
28.
MayerJ.D.2002Running on race: Racial politics in presidential campaigns, 1960–2000. New York: Random House.
29.
MustoD.F.1996Everybody's problem: The increase in pot use among young people can't be pinned on the president. Washington Post, August 22, p. A31.
30.
MustoD.F.1999The American disease: Origins of narcotic control, third edition. New York: Oxford.
31.
NagourneyA.1996Politics: The ad campaign; an attack in black and white on Clinton's drug Policy. New York Times, September 21, p. A9.
32.
New York Times1995Drug and alcohol use rising among teen-agers, a study finds. December 17, p. A1.
33.
New York Times1996aDrug use by teen-agers (Editorial). August 23, p. A18.
34.
New York Times1996bDrugs, guns and just don't do it (Editorial). September 23, p. A14.
35.
NicholsB.1996White House, GOP spar on drug report. USA Today, August 21, p. A1.
36.
OrcuttJ.D.TurnerJ.B.1993Shocking numbers and graphic accounts: Quantified images of drug problems in the print media. Social Problems, 40, 190–206.
37.
Public Broadcasting System1996aThey're not saying no (television broadcast). NewsHour, August 20.
38.
Public Broadcasting System1996bPlacing the blame (television broadcast). NewsHour, September 4.
39.
RandallD.M.ShortJ.F.Jr.1983Women in toxic work environments: A case study of social problem development. Social Problems, 30, 410–424.
40.
ReinarmanC.2006The social construction of drug scares. In AdlerP.A.AdlerP. (Eds.), Constructions of deviance: Social power, context, and interaction, fifth edition. (pp. 139–150) Belmont, CA: Thomson Wadsworth.
41.
ReinarmanC.LevineH.1989aCrack in context: Politics and media in the making of a drug scare. Contemporary Drug Problems, 16, 535–577.
42.
ReinarmanC.LevineH.1989bThe crack attack: Politics and media in America's latest drug scare. In BestJ. (Ed.), Images of issues: Typifying contemporary social problems. (pp. 115–137) New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
43.
RosenthalA.M.1996Betrayal of the kids. New York Times, August 23, p. A27.
44.
SaadL.1995Americans still support the war on drugs. The Gallup Poll Monthly, 363, December, pp. 16–20.
45.
SafireW.1986The drug bandwagon. New York Times, September 11, p. A27.
46.
SavageD.1996Clinton not to blame for rise in teen drug use, experts say. Los Angeles Times, September 18, p. 5.
47.
SeelyeK.1996aDole promises wider role for military in drug war. New York Times, August 26, p. A1.
48.
SeelyeK.1996bFor Dole camp, apocalypse as metaphor. New York Times, August 27, A12.
49.
ShalalaD.1995aNational Household Survey Press Conference. Washington, D.C., September 12.
50.
ShalalaD.1995bMonitoring the Future Survey Press Conference. Washington, D.C., December 15.
51.
ShapiroW.1996The drug issue: Stats may be all smoke. USA Today, September 17.
52.
ShoemakerP.J. (Ed.) 1989Communication campaigns about drugs: Government, media, and the public. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
53.
SpectorM.KitsuseJ.1977Constructing social problems. New York. Aldine de Gruyter.
54.
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA)1995Preliminary estimates from the 1994 National Household Survey on Drug Abuse. Office of Applied Studies.Washington, DC, September.
55.
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA)1996aResults of the 1995 National Household Survey on Drug Abuse. Office of Applied Studies.Washington, DC.
56.
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA)1996bNational drug survey results released. Press Release, Office of Applied Studies. Washington, DC, August 20.
57.
SuroR.1996a Teens' use of drugs still rising: GOP seizes on survey showing a doubling to 10.9% since 1992. Washington Post, August 21, p. A1.
58.
SuroR.1996bPolitical rhetoric overlooks change in drug-use patterns. Washington Post, September 24, p. A1.
59.
ThomasE.1986America's crusade. Time, September 15, pp. 60–68.
60.
ThomasP.1995Teens use more drugs, worry less about consequences. Washington Post, December 16, p. A1.
61.
TonerR.1996Parties try to exploit teen-age drug rise. New York Times, August 22, p. A15.
62.
WalshE.1996Dole tries to crash party with drug issue. Washington Post, August 13, p. A20.
63.
Washington Post1995Marijuana use by teens rises sharply. September 13, p. A16.
64.
WeaverP.H.1994News and the culture of lying: How journalism really works. New York: Free Press.
65.
WitkinG.1996Why this country is losing the drug war. U.S. News & World Report, September 16.
66.
WrenC.S.1996aMarijuana use by youths continues to rise. New York Times, February 20, p. A10.
67.
WrenC.S.1996bDrug policy surges as a campaign issue. New York Times, September 17, p. A1.
