Procedures for Investigating the Effect of Light on Impression

Abstract

This paper reports findings concerning the effect of environmental lighting as a medium that affects user impressions and judgments. Our previous work on this problem used both multidimensional scaling and semantic differential techniques to assess changes in impression as a function of variation in the lighting arrangements. This research was conducted in a lighting demonstration room at the General Electric Lighting Institute at Nela Park in Cleveland. Six different lighting arrangements were used. Results from both multidimensional scaling and ratings on semantic differential scales showed that user impression changed in orderly ways for different lighting arrangements. The present study assessed whether slides of the lighting arrangements could adequately simulate results from the real space. Comparable results would indicate that slides are a useful simulation tool, and would also be of general theoretical interest. The data indicated that in many important respects the results for the slides matched the results for the real space for ratings on semantic differential scales, but that less consistent results were obtained for multidimensional scaling.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

BRODIN, C. (1973) "A study of preferences for simulated outdoor environments with different intensities of feeling of enclosed space," pp. 310-322 in P. Kuller (ed.) Architectural Psychology: Proceedings of the Lund Conference. Stroudsburg, PA: Dowden, Hutchinson & Ross.

CHANG, J. J. and J. D. CARROLL (1972) "How to use INDSCAL: a computer program for canonical decomposition of N-way tables and individual differences in multi-dimensional scaling." Bell Telephone Laboratories, Murray Hill, N. J. (mimeographed).

FLYNN, J. E. (1972) "The psychology of light: article 1 - the value of light." Electrical Consultant (December`: 7-11.

FLYNN, J. E. (1973) "The psychology of light: article 3 - visual meaning in lighting design." Electrical Consultant (March): 22-25.

FLYNN, J. E. , T. J. SPENCER , O. MARTYNIUK , and C. HENDRICK (1973) "Interim study of procedures for investigating the effect of light on impression and behavior." J. of the Illuminating Engineering Society 3: 87-94.

HESSELGREN, S. (1971) Experimental Studies on Architectural Perception. Stockholm: The National Swedish Institute for Building Research, Document D2.

KAPLAN, S. , R. KAPLAN , and J. S. WENDT (1972) "Rated preference and complexity for natural and urban visual material." Perception and Psychophysics 12: 354-356.

MARTYNIUK, O. , J. E. FLYNN , T. J. SPENCER , and C. HENDRICK (1973) "Effect of environmental lighting on impression and behavior," pp. 51-63 in R. Kuller (ed.) Architectural Psychology: Proceedings of the Lund Conference. Stroudsburg, PA: Dowden, Hutchinson & Ross.

WINKEL, G. (1973) "Introduction, chapter iii," pp. 53-57 in W. H. Ittelson (ed.) Environment and Cognition. New York: Seminar Press.

10.

WINKEL, G. H. and R. SASANOFF (1970) "An approach to an objective analysis of behavior in architectural space," pp. 619-631 in H. M.'Proshansky , W. H. lttelson , and L. G. Rivlin (eds.) Environmental Psychology: Man and his Physical Setting. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.