Abstract
Experts, news media, and social media commentators struggled to make sense of SARS-CoV-2 January–May 2020 as disease caused by this virus, COVID-19, circulated the globe. This paper represents a longitudinal analysis of the primary narratives produced across expert, media, and social media sources to describe the virus, its phylogenetic origins, and biological effects. High expert uncertainty coupled with amplifying representations of risk across time drove collective sensemaking and conspiratorial narratives.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams
M.
(2020 , February 20). Prof. Francis Boyle exposes the bioweapons origins of the COVID-19 coronavirus . NaturalNews . https://www.naturalnews.com/2020-02-20-full-transcript-smoking-gun-interview-prof-frances-boyle-coronavirus-bioweapons.html
2.
Allen
N.
Landauro
I.
(2020 , June 26). Coronavirus traces found in March 2019 sewage sample, Spanish study shows . Reuters . https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-spain-science-idUSKBN23X2HQ
3.
Andersen
K.
Rambaut
A.
Lipkin
W.
Holmes
E
Garry
R.
(2020 ). The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2 . Nature Medicine , 26 (4 ), 450 –452 . https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-020-0820-9.
4.
Associated Press
(2020 , June 2). China delayed releasing coronavirus info, frustrating WHO June . https://apnews.com/3c061794970661042b18d5aeaaed9fae
5.
Barnes
J.
Rosenberg
M.
Wong
E.
(2020 , March 28). As virus spreads, China and Russia see openings for disinformation . The New York Times . https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/28/us/politics/china-russia-coronavirus-disinformation.html
6.
Bordia
P.
Difonzo
N.
(2004 ). Problem solving in social interactions on the internet: Rumor as social cognition . Social Psychology Quarterly , 67 (1 ), 33 –49 . https://doi.org/10.1177/019027250406700105.
7.
Brazell
E.
(2020 , April 21). Coronavirus “escaped from US lab”, China’s state TV anchor claims . Metro (UK) . https://metro.co.uk/2020/04/21/coronavirus-escaped-us-lab-chinas-state-tv-anchor-claims-12586026/
8.
Brennan
D.
(2020 , May 12). Chinese state media pushes conspiracy theory that coronavirus escaped from Maryland military base . Newsweek . https://www.newsweek.com/chinese-state-media-pushes-conspiracy-theory-coronavirus-escaped-maryland-military-base-1503345
9.
Broad
W.
(2020 , July 8). 8 Questions from a disease detective on the pandemic’s origins . The New York Times . https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/08/health/coronavirus-origin-china-lucey.html
10.
CDC Inspection
. (2019 , November 24). CDC Inspection findings reveal more about Fort Detrick research suspension . Military Times . https://www.military.com/daily-news/2019/11/24/cdc-inspection-findings-reveal-more-about-fort-detrick-research-suspension.html
11.
Chakraborty
B.
Diaz
A.
(2020 , July 10). Chinese virologist accuses Beijing of coronavirus cover-up, flees Hong Kong . Fox News . https://www.foxnews.com/world/chinese-virologist-coronavirus-cover-up-flee-hong-kong-whistleblower
12.
Chin
J.
(2020 , May 16). China told labs to destroy coronavirus samples to reduce biosafety risks . The Wall Street Journal . https://www.wsj.com/articles/china-told-labs-to-destroy-coronavirus-samples-to-reduce-biosafety-risks-11589684291
13.
Connolly
A.
(2020 , May 13). Trudeau says world has questions “particularly” for China on COVID-19 origin . Global News . https://globalnews.ca/news/6938258/justin-trudeau-coronavirus-china-questions/
14.
Coutard
B.
Valle
C.
de Lamballerie
X.
Canard
B.
Seidah
N. G.
Decroly
E.
(2020 ). The spike glycoprotein of the new coronavirus 2019-nCoV contains a furin-like cleavage site absent in CoV of the same clade . Antiviral Research , 176 (12 ), 104742 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.antiviral.2020.104742.
15.
Ding
H.
(2014 ). Rhetoric of a global epidemic: Transcultural communication about SARS . Southern Illinois University Press .
16.
Durden
T.
(2020 a, January 9). Chinese officials confirm latest health crisis caused by SARS-like coronavirus. ZeroHedge . https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/chinese-health-officials-confirm-latest-outbreak-caused-sars-coronavirus
17.
Durden
T.
(2020 b, January 14). First case of SARS-like pneumonia reported outside China as scientists scramble to develop new test. ZeroHedge . https://www.zerohedge.com/health/first-case-sars-pneumonia-reported-outside-china-scientists-0scramble-develop-new-test
18.
Durden
T.
(2020 c, January 22). Chinese officials warn of “virus mutation spreading ” – 4402020 cases confirmed , 9 Dead. ZeroHedge. January, 22, 2022 . https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/stocks-slide-cnn-report-suggesting-coronavirus-has-reached-us.
19.
Durden
T.
(2020 d, January 24). The real Umbrella Corp: Wuhan ultra-biohazard lab was studying “the world’s most dangerous pathogens”. ZeroHedge . https://www.zerohedge.com/economics/real-umbrella-corp-wuhan-ultra-biohazard-lab-was-studying-worlds-most-dangerous-pathogens
20.
Durden
T.
(2020 e, April 2). “One of the worst coverups in human history.” ZeroHedge. https://www.zerohedge.com/health/one-worst-coverups-human-history-msm-turns-gaze-chinese-biolab-near-COVID-19-ground-zero
21.
Durden
T.
(2020 f, February 7). White House asks scientists to investigate whether 2019-nCoV was bio-engineered. ZeroHedge . https://www.zerohedge.com/health/white-house-asks-scientists-investigate-whether-2019-ncov-was-bio-engineered
22.
Eichinger
B.
Hadida
S.
Bolt
J.
(Producer) Anderson
P.
(2002 ). (Director) . In Resident evil . Germany : Constantin Film .
23.
Fottrell
Q.
(2020 , June 12). Asymptomatic transmission of coronavirus appears to be worse than SARS or influenza . MarketWatch . https://www.marketwatch.com/story/asymptomatic-transmission-of-coronavirus-may-be-worse-than-sars-or-influenza-2020-06-12?siteid=yhoof2&yptr=yahoo
24.
Gardner
B.
(2020 , June 3). Exclusive: Coronavirus began ‘as an accident’ in Chinese lab, says former MI6 boss . The Telegraph . https://advance-lexis-com.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/api/document?collection=news&id=urn:contentItem:6026-2HH1-F021-60M4-00000-00&context=1516831
25.
Geraghty
J.
(2020 , April 3) The trail leading back to the Wuhan labs . The National Review . https://www.nationalreview.com/2020/04/coronavirus-china-trail-leading-back-to-wuhan-labs/. Yahoo. https://news.yahoo.com/trail-leading-back-wuhan-labs-172025888.html
26.
Gertz
B.
(2020 , January 26). Coronavirus may have originated in lab linked to China’s biowarfare program . The Washington Times . https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/jan/26/coronavirus-link-to-china-biowarfare-program-possi/
27.
Grady
D.
(2019 , August 5). Deadly germ research is shut down at army lab over safety concerns . The New York Times . https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/05/health/germs-fort-detrick-biohazard.html
28.
Gupta
P.
Goyal
K.
Kanta
P.
Ghosh
A.
Singh
M. P.
(2019 ). Novel 2019-coronavirus on new year’s eve . Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology , 37 (374 ), 459 –477 . https://doi.org/10.4103/ijmm.IJMM_20_54.
29.
Hou
Y.
Peng
C.
Yu
M.
Li
Y.
Han
Z.
Li
F.
Wang
L.
Shi
Z.
(2010 ). Angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) proteins of different bat species confer variable susceptibility to SARS-CoV entry . Archives of Virology , 155 (10 ), 1563 –1569 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s00705-010-0729-6.
30.
How furin
. (2020 , April 23). How furin and ACE2 interact with the spike protein on SARS-CoV-2 . Assay Genie . https://www.assaygenie.com/how-furin-and-ace2-interact-with-the-spike-on-sarscov2
31.
Huang
C.
Wang
Y.
Li
X.
Ren
L.
Zhao
J.
Hu
Y.
Zhang
L.
Fan
G.
Xu
J.
Gu
X.
Cheng
Z.
Yu
T.
Xia
J.
Wei
Y.
Wu
W.
Xie
X.
Yin
W.
Li
H.
Liu
M.
Cao
B.
(2020 ). Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China . Lancet , 395 (10223 ), 497 –506 . https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30183-5.
32.
Huddleston
T.
(2020 , April 17). Bill Gates is the top target for coronavirus conspiracy theories . CNBC . https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/17/bill-gates-is-top-target-for-coronavirus-conspiracy-theories-report.html
33.
Ibbetson
R.
(2020 , February 16). Did coronavirus originate in Chinese government laboratory? Daily Mail . https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8009669/Did-coronavirus-originate-Chinese-government-laboratory.html
34.
John Hopkins Center for Health Security
(2019 a). Event 201 . https://www.centerforhealthsecurity.org/event201/scenario.html.
35.
John Hopkins Center for Health Security
. (2019 b, November 4). Event 201 pandemic exercise: Highlights reel . YouTube . https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AoLw-Q8X174
36.
Kellermann
K.
Reynolds
R.
(1990 ). When ignorance is bliss: The role of motivation to reduce uncertainty in uncertainty reduction theory . Human Communication Research , 17 (1 ), 5 –75 . https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2958.1990.tb00226.x.
37.
Kou
Y.
Gui
X.
Chen
Y.
Pine
K.
(2017 , December). Conspiracy talk on social media: Collective sensemaking during a public health crisis . Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction , 1 (CSCW ):1 –21 . https://doi.org/10.1145/3134696
38.
Li
A. J.
(2020 , February 12). Coronavirus crisis: How the death of Li Wenliang, a doctor and ordinary citizen, sparked Chinese demands for freedom of speech. South China Morning Post . https://www.scmp.com/comment/opinion/article/3049910/coronavirus-crisis-how-death-li-wenliang-doctor-and-ordinary
39.
Li
J.
(2020 ). A conspiracy theory linking the US army to the coronavirus now has official Chinese endorsement. Quartz . https://qz.com/1817736/china-fuels-coronavirus-conspiracy-theory-blaming-us-army/.
40.
Liua
B.
Bartz
L.
Duke
N.
(2016 ). Communicating crisis uncertainty: A review of the knowledge gaps . Public Relations Review , 42 (3 ), 479 –487 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2016.03.003.
41.
Liu
P.
Jiang
J-Z.
Wan
X-F.
Hua
Y.
Li
L.
Zhou
J.
Wang
X.
Hou
F.
Chen
J.
Zou
J.
Chen
J.
(2020 , May 14). Are pangolins the intermediate host of the 2019 novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) . PLOS Pathogens . 16 (5 ), Article e1008421 . https://doi: 10.1371/journal.ppat.1008421
42.
Ma
J.
(2020 , March 13). Coronavirus: China’s first confirmed COVID-19 case traced back to November 17 . South China Morning Post . https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3074991/coronavirus-chinas-first-confirmed-COVID-19-case-traced-back
43.
Menachery
V.
Yount
B.
Debbink
K.
Agnihothram
S.
Gralinski
L.
Plante
J.
Graham
R.
Scobey
T.
Ge
X.
Donaldson
E.
Randell
S.
Lanzavecchia
A.
Marasco
W.
Shi
Z.
Baric
R.
(2015 ). A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence . Nature Medicine , 21 (12 ), 1508 –1513 . https://doi.org/10.1038/nm.3985.
44.
Miller
R.
(2020 , April 17). Chinese coronavirus is a man-made virus according to Luc Montagnier the man who discovered HIV . Gilmore Health . https://www.gilmorehealth.com/chinese-coronavirus-is-a-man-made-virus-according-to-luc-montagnier-the-man-who-discovered-hiv/
45.
Nadesan
M.
(2016 ). Crisis communications, liberal democracy and ecological sustainability . Lexington Books .
46.
Nadesan
M.
(2019 ). Governmentality: Genealogical analysis of modern logics of government . Sage Research Method Cases Pt.2 . https://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781526495525.
47.
Pinghui
Z.
(2020 , February 28). Chinese laboratory that first shared coronavirus genome with world ordered to close for ‘rectification’, hindering its COVID-19 research . South China Morning Post . https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3052966/chinese-laboratory-first-shared-coronavirus-genome-world-ordered
48.
Piplani
S.
Singh
P.
Winkler
D.
Petrovsky
N.
(2020 , May 13). In silico comparison of spike protein-ACE2 binding affinities across species; significance for the possible origin of the SARS-CoV-2 virus . https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2005/2005.06199.pdf
49.
Pradhan
P.
Pandey
A.
Mishra
A.
Gupta
P.
Tripathi
P.
Menon
M.
Gomes
J.
Vivekanandan
P.
Kundu
B.
(2020 , January 31). Uncanny similarity of unique inserts in the 2019-nCoV spike protein to HIV-1 gp120 and Gag . bioRxiv . Pre Print . https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.01.30.927871
50.
Rahhal
N.
(2020 , January 23). China built a lab to study SARS and Ebola in Wuhan . Daily Mail . https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-7922379/Chinas-lab-studying-SARS-Ebola-Wuhan-outbreaks-center.html
51.
Rincon
P.
(2020 , May 1). Coronavirus: Is there any evidence for lab release theory . BBC . https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-52318539
52.
Schmidt
F.
(2020 , April 18). Did coronavirus really originate in a Chinese laboratory? DW . https://www.dw.com/en/did-coronavirus-really-originate-in-a-chinese-laboratory/a-53171292
53.
Seligmann
L. J.
Estes
B. P.
(2019 ). Innovations in ethnographic methods . American Behavioral Scientists , 64 (2 ), 176 –197 . https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764219859640.
54.
Silva
C.
(2011 ). Miraculous plagues: An epidemiology of early New England narrative . Oxford University Press .
55.
Sullman
A.
Clark
K.
Kube
C.
Shi
A.
Bauculinao
E.
(2020 , April 18). Laboratory in Wuhan breaks silence to deny claims that the coronavirus originated there . Yahoo . https://news.yahoo.com/laboratory-wuhan-breaks-silence-deny-144054739.html
56.
US
. US Sounded alarm on Wuhan Lab studying coronavirus two years ago, report says (2020 , April 14). Fox . Yahoo . https://news.yahoo.com/us-sounded-alarm-wuhan-lab-160443838.html
57.
Varga
Z.
Flammer
A. J.
Steiger
P.
Haberecker
M.
Andermatt
R.
Zinkernagel
A. S.
Mehra
M. R.
Schuepbach
R. A.
Ruschitzka
F.
Moch
H.
(2020 ). Endothelial cell infection and endothelitis in COVID-19 . Nature Correspondence , 395 (10234 ), 1417 –1418 . https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30937-5.
58.
WHO
(2020 ). WHO timeline - COVID-19 (27, April 2020) . World Health Organization . https://www.who.int/news-room/detail/27-04-2020-who-timeline---COVID-19.
59.
Winter
L.
(2020 , March 13) Chinese officials blame US army for coronavirus . The Scientist . https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/chinese-officials-blame-us-army-for-coronavirus-67267
60.
Wu
F.
Zhao
S.
Yu
B.
Chen
Y.
Wang
W.
Song
Z.
Hu
Y.
Tao
Z.
Tian
J.
Pei
Y.
Yuan
M.
Zhang
Y.
Dai
F.
Liu
Y.
Wang
Q.
Zheng
J.
Xu
L.
Holmes
E.
Zhang
Y.
(2020 ). A new coronavirus associated with human respiratory disease in China . Nature , 579 (7798 ), 265 –269 . https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2008-3.
61.
Xiao
B.
Xiao
L.
(2020 , February). The possible origins of 2019-nCoV coronavirus . Research Gate . https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.21799.2960
62.
Zhang
Y-Z.
Wu
F.
Chen
Y-M.
Pei
Y-Y.
Xu
L.
Wang
W.
Zhao
S.
Yu
B.
Hu
Y.
Tao
Z-W.
Song
Z-G.
Tian
J-H.
Zhang
Y-L.
Liu
Y.
Zheng
J-J.
Dai
F-H.
Wang
Q-M.
She
J-L.
Zhu
T-Y.
(2020 ). A novel coronavirus associated with a respiratory disease in Wuhan of Hubei province, China . GenBank: MN908947.1. GenBank: MN908947.2; GenBank: MN908947.3 . https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/nuccore/MN908947.1
63.
Zhou
P
Yang
X. L.
Wang
X. G.
Hu
B.
Zhang
L.
Zhang
W.
Si
H. R.
Zhu
Y.
Li
B.
Huang
C. L.
Chen
H. D.
Chen
J.
Luo
Y.
Guo
H.
Jiang
R. D.
Liu
M. Q.
Chen
Y.
Shen
X. R.
Wang
X.
Zheng
X. S.
Shi
Z. L.
(2020 ). A pneumonia outbreak associated with a new coronavirus of probable bat origin . Nature , 579 (7798 ), 270 –273 . https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2012-7.
64.
Zhu
N
Zhang
D
Wang
W
Li
X
Yang
B
Song
J
Zhao
X
Huang
B
Shi
W
Lu
R
Niu
P
Zhan
F
Ma
X
Wang
D
Xu
W
Wu
G
Gao
GF
Tan
W
(2020 ). A novel coronavirus from patients with pneumonia in China, 2019 . New England Journal of Medicine , 382 (8 ), 727 –733 . https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2001017.