Many welfare states have increased their regulatory role, but little attention has been given to historical changes in the regulatory role of government ministries. This study embraces a mezzo perspective and explores the regulatory role of the Welfare Ministry of Israel in the field of personal social services, asking the following questions: 1) What are the changes in regulatory expectations versus practices over the last five decades? and 2) How can we explain these changes and their outcomes? The study is based on the qualitative analysis of comptroller reports and other resources. It reveals a growing gap between society’s expectations of the Ministry as a regulator and the Ministry’s capacities over five decades. Notably, it points to the variety of regulatory spaces that have appeared in a regulatory welfare state. The Israeli case is relevant for other countries that have experienced processes of outsourcing and privatization in the welfare state and whose ministries had to change their role.
AhdutAvnerAharonShabiGalitShaulDevoraEltosDinaBen-LaviHayaDaskalChanaNeubergerYoramAzulayIitzhakYoelRozenbawmNavaet al. 2007. Policy paper: The regional inspection in the welfare and social services ministry. Jerusalem: Mandel Institute. (in Hebrew)
2.
AuerbachGedalia. 2007. The relationship of local government and the third sector in Israel (in Hebrew) (Position Paper). Jerusalem: Knesset Research and Information Center and Hebrew University School of Social Work.
3.
AyresIanBraithwaiteJohn. 1992. Responsive regulation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
BaldwinRobertCaveMartinLodgeMartin. 2012. Understanding regulation: Theory, strategy, and practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
5.
BaliAzad S.CapanoGilibertoRameshM.2019. Anticipating and designing for policy effectiveness. Policy and Society38 (1): 1–13.
BenishAvishai. 2018. The privatization of social services in Israel. The privatization of Israel, 173–200. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
8.
BenishAvishaiHalevyDanaSpiroShimon. 2018. Regulating social welfare services: Between compliance and learning. International Journal of Social Welfare27 (3): 226–35.
9.
BlackJulia. 2002. Regulatory conversations. Journal of Law and Society29 (1): 163–96.
10.
BraithwaiteJohn. 2006. Responsive regulation and developing economies. World Development34:884–98.
11.
BraithwaiteJohnMakkaiToniBraithwaite VValerie. 2007. Regulation aged care. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.
12.
ChristensenTomLægreidPer, eds. 2006. Agencification and regulatory reforms. In Autonomy and regulation. Coping with agencies in the modern state, 8–49. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
13.
CorbinJulietStraussAnselm. 1990. Grounded theory research: Procedures, canons and Evaluation. Qualitative Sociology13 (1): 3–21.
14.
DowneJamesMartinSteve J.2007. Regulation inside government: Processes and impacts of inspection of local public services. Policy & Politics35 (2): 215–32.
15.
DuboisVincent. 2019. Welfare fraud inspectors between standardization and discretion. In Inspectors and enforcement at the front line of government, eds. WalleSteven Van deRaaphorstNadine, 167–86. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
16.
EbimoboweiAppah. 2010. An evaluation of audit expectation gap: Issues and challenges. International Journal of Economic Development Research and Investment1 (2): 129–41.
17.
ElkomyShimaaCooksonGrahamJonesSimon. 2019. Cheap and dirty: The effect of contracting out cleaning on efficiency and effectiveness. Public Administration Review79 (2): 193–202.
18.
FreemanJodyRossiJim. 2011. Agency coordination in shared regulatory space. Harvard Law Review125:1131–1209.
19.
FurnessSheila. 2009. A hindrance or a help? The contribution of inspection to the quality of care in homes for older people. British Journal of Social Work39:488–505.
20.
GalH.Ben-MordechaiA.2017. The welfare ministry set the bar (RAF): From a service supplier to a regulator. Methods of regulation in the out of home services (in Hebrew). Jerusalem: The Federman School, The Hebrew University, Jerusalem.
21.
GalJohnMadhalaShavit. 2016. Public spending on social welfare. In State of the nation report: Society economy and policy in Israel 2016, ed. WeissAvi, 233–60 (in Hebrew). Jerusalem: Taub Center.
22.
GilardiFabrizioJordanaJacintLevi-FaurDavid. 2006. Regulation in the age of globalization: The diffusion of regulatory agencies across Europe and Latin America. In Privatisation and market development: Global movements in public policy ideas, ed. HodgeGraeme, 127–47. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.
23.
GoodshipJoJacksKavinGummersonMattLathleanJudithCopeStephen. 2004. Modernising regulation or regulating modernisation? The public, private and voluntary interface in adult social care. Public Policy and Administration19 (2): 13–27.
24.
GunninghamNeilSinclairDarren. 1998. Designing smart regulation. In Economic aspects of environmental compliance assurance. OECD global forum on sustainable development. Available from http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/18/39/33947759.pdf.
25.
HaberHanan. 2017. Rise of the regulatory welfare state? Social regulation in utilities in Israel. Social Policy & Administration51 (3): 442–63.
26.
HillMichaelHupePeter. 2002. Implementing public policy: Governance in theory and in practice. London: SAGE Publications.
27.
HogwoodW. BrianGunnA. Lewis. 1984. Policy analysis for the real world. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
28.
HoodChristopherScottColinJamesOliverJonesGeorgeTraversToni. 1999. Regulation inside government: Waste-watcher, quality police and sleaze-busters. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
29.
HovavM.1998. The supervision of social services in Israel. Development, practices and model (in Hebrew). Tel-Aviv: Chrikover.
30.
HowlettMichaelMukherjeeIshaniWooJun Jie. 2015. From tools to toolkits in policy design studies: the new design orientation towards policy formulation research. Policy & Politics43 (2): 291–311.
31.
Inspector Guide. 1985. State of Israel the labour and welfare ministry. Haifa and North district - The Labor and Welfare Ministry the state of Israel (in Hebrew).
32.
Inspector Guide. 1989. ELCA- association for the development and promotion of manpower in the social services in Israel. JDC Institute for Leadership and Governance Founded by the Joint Israel and supported by the Israeli government and Joint Israel. (in Hebrew).
33.
JordanaJacintSanchoDavid. 2004. Regulatory designs, institutional constellations and the study of the regulatory state. In The politics of regulation: Institutions and regulatory reforms for the age of governance, eds. JacintJordanaLevi-FaurDavid, 296–319. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
34.
KadushinAlfredHarknessDaniel. 2014. Supervision in social work. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
35.
KatanYoseph. 1996. Personal social services: Trends and contributions (in Hebrew). Tel Aviv: Ramot.
36.
TanjaKlenk. 2020. Street-level bureaucrats as market regulators – The case of the German long-term care market. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (this volume).
37.
The Labor and Welfare Ministry. Committee Report. 1997. A summary of the committee work and suggestion for discussion prepared to the management on the subject of the roles of the inspection in the Ministry of Labor and Welfare. (in Hebrew)
38.
LahatLihiSabahYakutiel. 2018. Adapted regulation as a possible model for personal social services: Theoretical and practical aspects (in Hebrew). Society and Welfare (38): 149–74.
39.
LahatLihiTalitGal. 2015. Regulation of personal social services: The Israeli experience. Social Policy & Administration49:335–55.
40.
LahatLihiSher-HadarNeta. 2015. Public value failure and the 2011 social protests in Israel (in Hebrew). Journal of Welfare and Social Security Studies96:29–53.
Levi-FaurDavid. 2011. Regulation and regulatory governance. Handbook on the Politics of Regulation1 (1): 1–25.
43.
Levi-FaurDavid. 2014. The welfare state: A regulatory perspective. Public Administration92:599–614.
44.
Levi-FaurDavidBenishAvishai. 2020. The reassertion of the regulatory welfare state: A preface. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (this volume).
45.
Madhala-BrikShavitGalJohn. 2016. The outsourcing of welfare services: Trends and changes. State of the Nation Report: Society, Economy, and Policy. Jerusalem: Taub Center for Social Policy Studies in Israel.
46.
MajoneGiandomenico. 1994. The rise of the regulatory state in Europe. West European Politics17 (3): 77–101.
47.
MandelkernRonen. 2012. The politics of partial privatization of social services in Israel: The case of housing for people with intellectual disabilities (in Hebrew). Social Security Journal90:121–53.
48.
MandelkernRonenPaz-FuchsAmir. 2018. Privatizing Israel: An introduction. In The privatization of Israel: The withdrawal of state responsibility, eds. Paz-FuchsAmirMandelkernRonenGalnoorItzhak, 1–18. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
49.
MarthinsenEdgar. 2019. Neoliberalisation, the social investment state and social work. European Journal of Social Work22 (2): 350–61.
McBethMark K.ShanahanElizabeth A.ArnellRuth J.HathawayPaul L.2007. The intersection of narrative policy analysis and policy change theory. Policy Studies Journal35 (1): 87–108.
52.
McLaughlinKenneth. 2007. Regulation and risk in social work: The general social care council and the social care register in context. British Journal of Social Work37: 1263–1277.
53.
MunroEileen. 2004. The impact of audit on social work practice. British Journal of Social Work34:1075–1095.
OngaroEdoardoValottiGiovanni. 2008. Public management reform in Italy: Explaining the implementation gap. International Journal of Public Sector Management21 (2): 174–204.
56.
ScottColin. 2001. Analysing regulatory space: fragmented resources and institutional design. Public Law summer:283–305.
57.
Sher-HadarNeta. 2019. Pick and roll: Expanded roles for a state auditor. Financial Accountability & Management33 (3): 229–43.
58.
ShikdarMohammad AlamFarukOmarChowdhuryMohammad Mojahid Hossain. 2018. Reducing the audit expectation gap: A model for Bangladesh perspective. International Journal of Management, Accounting & Economics5 (3): 169–80.
59.
SpiroShimonFromerDaphna. 2010. Quality control in the era of privatization: Examination of the RAF method in boarding schools (in Hebrew). Social Security84:105–27.
60.
StakeRobert E.2010. Qualitative research - studying how things work. New York, NY: The Guilford Press.
61.
Steering Committee. 2012. The inspector as the initiator of regulation in the welfare and social services ministry: Formulation framework and suggestions for implementation. Jerusalem: The Ministry of Welfare and Social Services.
62.
Van de WalleStevenRaaphorstNadine. 2019. Introduction: The social dynamics of daily inspection work. In Inspectors and enforcement at the front Line of government, 1–10. Cheltenham, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
63.
YinRobert K.2003. Applications of case study research. 2nd ed.Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
64.
YanaiU.2006. The Welfare Law, 5718-1958: Is it really the basis and guarantee for the population’s welfare? (in Hebrew). Jerusalem: Hebrew University, The Paul Baerwald School of Social Work and Social Welfare.
65.
Zemach-MaromTamar. 2008. RAF method in after-school programs in Israel. In Research for action: Cross-national perspective on connecting knowledge policy and practice for children, eds. ChaskinR.RosenfeldJ.Jerusalem: Myers-JDC-Brookdale Institute–Leader in Applied Social Research.
