We investigate the association between continuity of care mechanisms and a patient's risk of readmission in the context of one chronic condition, heart failure. We define continuity of care as the level of consistency across patient care episodes. We dynamically measure continuity of individual referring provider; continuity of physical location, which links multiple individual providers; and continuity of Accountable Care Organization, which spans a variety of individual and institutional providers. We compile a unique large‐scale dataset that includes patient‐level claims, to follow heart failure patients throughout inpatient and outpatient settings in 2014. Our final sample covers 44,129 episodes of care for 3263 patients. Using a competitive‐risks survival model, we find that all three continuity mechanisms are associated with a patient's lower risk of readmission. This exploratory study contributes to operations management literature by identifying effective integration mechanisms in the setting of healthcare delivery. In addition, by providing the first quantitative evidence for the critical role of multiple simultaneous mechanisms in ensuring continuity of care, this study offers important preliminary insights for public policy efforts.
AllisonP. D.2014. Event History and Survival Analysis: Regression for Longitudinal Event Data, Vol. 46. SAGE publications Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA.
2.
AmbrosyA. P.FonarowG. C.ButlerJ.ChioncelO.GreeneS. J.VaduganathanM.NodariS.LamC. S.SatoN.ShahA. N.GheorghiadeM.. 2014. The global health and economic burden of hospitalizations for heart failure: Lessons learned from hospitalized heart failure registries. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol.63(12): 1123–1133.
3.
AngstC.DevarajS.QueenanC.GreenwoodB.. 2011. Performance effects related to the sequence of integration of healthcare technologies. Prod. Oper. Manag.20(3): 319–333.
4.
BeadlesC. A.VoilsC. I.CrowleyM. J.FarleyJ. F.MaciejewskiM. L.. 2014. Continuity of medication management and continuity of care: Conceptual and operational considerations. SAGE Open Med.2: 2050312114559261.
5.
BerryS.NgoL.SamelsonE.KielD.. 2010. Competing risk of death: An important consideration in studies of older adults. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc.58(4): 783–787.
6.
BerwickD. M.2011. Launching accountable care organizations—The proposed rule for the Medicare Shared Savings Program. N. Engl. J. Med.364(16): e32.
7.
BerwickD. M.NolanT. W.WhittingtonJ.. 2008. The triple aim: Care, health, and cost. Health Aff.27(3): 759–769.
8.
BiceT. W.BoxermanS. B.. 1977. A quantitative measure of continuity of care. Med. Care15(4): 347–349.
9.
BodenheimerT.LoB.CasalinoL.. 1999. Primary care physicians should be coordinators, not gatekeepers. J. Am. Med. Assoc.281(21): 2045–2049.
10.
BraunsteinJ. B.AndersonG. F.GerstenblithG.WellerW.NiefeldM.HerbertR.WuA. W.. 2003. Noncardiac comorbidity increases preventable hospitalizations and mortality among Medicare beneficiaries with chronic heart failure. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol.42(7): 1226–1233.
11.
BrennanN.OrnsteinC.FraktA. B.. 2018. Time to release medicare advantage claims data. J. Am. Med. Assoc.319(10): 975–976.
12.
CebulR. D.RebitzerJ. B.TaylorL. J.VotrubaM. E.. 2008. Organizational fragmentation and care quality in the U.S. healthcare system. J. Econ. Perspect.22(4): 93–113.
13.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). 2011. Medicare program; Medicare shared savings program; Accountable care organizations, Final rule. Fed. Regist.76(212): 67801–67990.
14.
ChaseR. B.1981. The customer contact approach to services: Theoretical bases and practical extensions. Oper. Res.29(4): 698–706.
15.
CoxD.1972. Survival models and life tables. J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. B Methodol.34(2): 187–220.
16.
DharmarajanK.HsiehA. F.KulkarniV. R.LinZ.RossJ. S.HorwitzL. I.KimN.SuterL. G.LinH.NormandS. L.. 2015. Trajectories of risk after hospitalization for heart failure, acute myocardial infarction, or pneumonia: Retrospective cohort study. Br. Med. J.350: h411.
17.
DobrzykowskiD. D.TarafdarM.. 2017. Linking electronic medical records use to physicians’ performance: A contextual analysis. Decis. Sci.48(1): 7–38.
18.
EisenbergJ. M.1985. The internist as gatekeeper: Preparing the general internist for a new role. Ann. Intern. Med.102(4): 537–543.
19.
ElhaugeE.2010. The Fragmentation of U.S. Health Care: Causes and Solutions. Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
20.
FineJ. P.GrayR. J.. 1999. A proportional hazards model for the subdistribution of a competing risk. J. Am. Stat. Assoc.94(446): 496–509.
21.
FonarowG. C.AbrahamW. R.AlbertN. M.StoughW. G.GheorghiadeM.GreenbergB. H.O'ConnorC. M.PieperK.SunJ. L.YancyV.. 2007. Association between performance measures and clinical outcomes for patients hospitalized with heart failure. J. Am. Med. Assoc.297(1): 61–70.
22.
FrandsenB. R.JoyntK. E.RebitzerJ. B.JhaA. K.. 2015. Care fragmentation, quality, and costs among chronically ill patients. Am. J. Manag. Care21(5): 355–362.
23.
FryD. E.PineM.NedzaS. M.LockeD. G.RebandA. M.PineG.. 2016. The appropriate measurement of postdischarge readmissions in Medicare colon surgery. Am. J. Surg.211(3): 577–582.
24.
GheorghiadeM.VaduganathanM.FonarowG.BonowR.. 2013. Rehospitalization for heart failure: Problems and perspectives. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol.61(4): 391–403.
25.
GoreJ. M.PetersonE.AminA.AndersonF. A.DastaJ. F.LevyP. D.O'NeilB. J.SungG. Y.VaronJ.WymanA.. 2010. Predictors of 90‐day readmission among patients with acute severe hypertension. The cross‐sectional observational Studying the Treatment of Acute hyperTension (STAT) study. Am. Heart J.160(3): 521–527, e521.
26.
GrambschP. M.TherneauT. M.. 1994. Proportional hazards tests and diagnostics based on weighted residuals. Biometrika81(3): 515–526.
27.
GrayR. J.1988. A class of K‐sample tests for comparing the cumulative incidence of a competing risk. Ann. Stat.16(3): 1141–1154.
28.
GreggH.2013. Why hospitals need to look beyond 30‐day readmissions. Becker's Hospital Review, available at http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/quality/why-hospitals-need-to-look-beyond-30-day-readmissions.html (accessed date March 26, 2019).
29.
HaJ. F.LongneckerN.. 2010. Doctor‐patient communication: A review. Ochsner J.10(1): 38–43.
30.
HaggertyJ. L.ReidR. J.FreemanG. K.StarfieldB. H.AdairC. E.McKendryR.. 2003. Continuity of care: A multidisciplinary review. Br. Med. J.327(7425): 1219–1221.
31.
HeinekeJ.DavisM. M.. 2007. The emergence of service operations management as an academic discipline. J. Oper. Manag.25(2): 364–374.
32.
HelmJ. E.AlaeddiniA.StaufferJ. M.BretthauerK. M.SkolarusT.. 2016. Reducing hospital readmissions by integrating empirical prediction with resource optimization. Prod. Oper. Manag.25(2): 233–257.
33.
HernandezA. F.GreinerM. A.FonarowG. C.HammillB. G.HeidenreichP. A.YancyC. W.PetersonE. D.CurtisL. H.. 2010. Relationship between early physician follow‐up and 30‐day readmission among Medicare beneficiaries hospitalized for heart failure. J. Am. Med. Assoc.303(17): 1716–1722.
34.
HirschmanA. O.1964. The paternity of an index. Am. Econ. Rev.54(5): 761–762.
35.
Hoffer GittellJ.2002. Coordinating mechanisms in care provider groups: Relational coordination as a mediator and input uncertainty as a moderator of performance effects. Management Sci.48(11): 1408–1426.
36.
HolmanH.LorigK.. 2000. Patients as partners in managing chronic disease. Br. Med. J.320(7234): 526–527.
37.
HuckmanR. S.PisanoG. P.. 2006. The firm specificity of individual performance: Evidence from cardiac surgery. Management Sci.52(4): 473–488.
38.
HuckmanR. S.StaatsB. R.. 2011. Fluid tasks and fluid teams: The impact of diversity in experience and team familiarity on team performance. Manuf. Serv. Oper. Manag.13(3): 310–328.
39.
HuckmanR. S.StaatsB. R.UptonD. M.. 2009. Team familiarity, role experience, and performance: Evidence from Indian software services. Management Sci.55(1): 85–100.
40.
HusseyP. S.SchneiderE. C.RudinR. S.FoxD. S.LaiJ.PollackC. E.. 2014. Continuity and the costs of care for chronic disease. JAMA Intern. Med.174(5): 742–748.
41.
Institute of Medicine (IoM). 2003. Priority Areas for National Action: Transforming Health Care Quality. National Academies Press, Washington, DC.
42.
JeeS. H.CabanaM. D.. 2006. Indices for continuity of care: A systematic review of the literature. Med. Care Res. Rev.63(2): 158–188.
43.
KaminskiM.2015. A doctor discovers an important question patients should be asked. The Washington Post, March 9.
44.
KaplanS. H.GreenfieldS.WareJ. E.. 1989. Assessing the effects of physician‐patient interactions on the outcomes of chronic disease. Med. Care27: S110–S127.
45.
KautterJ.PopeG. C.IngberM.FreemanS.PattersonL.CohenM.KeenanP.. 2014. The HHS‐HCC risk adjustment model for individual and small group markets under the Affordable Care Act. Medicare Medicaid Res. Rev.4(3): mmrr2014‐004‐03‐a03.
46.
KelloggD. L.NieW.. 1995. A framework for strategic service management. J. Oper. Manag.13(4): 323–337.
47.
KieslerS.CummingsJ. N.. 2002. What do we know about proximity and distance in work groups?HindsP.KieslerS., eds. Distributed Work. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 57–80.
48.
KocherR.AdashiE.. 2011. Hospital readmissions and the Affordable Care Act: Paying for coordinated quality care. J. Am. Med. Assoc.306(16): 1794–1795.
49.
KrumholzH.NormandS. L.KeenanP.LinZ.DryeE.BhatK.WangY.RossJ.SchuurJ.StaufferB.BernheimS. M.EpsteinA.HerrinJ.FedererJ.MatteraJ.WangY.MulveyG.SchreinerG.. 2008. Hospital 30‐day heart failure readmission measure methodology. Report prepared for the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Available at https://www.qualitynet.org/dcs/ContentServer?cid=%201219069855841&pagename=QnetPublic%2FPage%2FQnetTier3&c=Page (accessed date March 26, 2019).
50.
LeslieD.MarcantonioE.ZhangY.Leo‐SummersL.InouyeS.. 2008. One‐year health care costs associated with delirium in the elderly population. Arch. Intern. Med.168(1): 27–32.
51.
LovelockC. H.1983. Classifying services to gain strategic marketing insights. J. Market.47(3): 9–20.
52.
LoxterkampD.1991. Being there: On the place of the family physician. J. Am. Board Fam. Pract.4(5): 354–360.
53.
MarcouxR. M.LarratE. P.VogenbergF. R.. 2012. Accountable care organizations: An improvement over HMOs?Pharm. Ther.37(11): 629–630, 650.
54.
MartinL. R.WilliamsS. L.HaskardK. B.DiMatteoM. R.. 2005. The challenge of patient adherence. Ther. Clin. Risk Manag.1(3): 189–199.
McWhinneyI. R.1975. Continuity of care in family practice. Part 2: Implications of continuity. J. Fam. Pract.2(5): 373–374.
57.
McWilliamsJ. M.LandonB. E.ChernewM. E.ZaslavskyA. M.. 2014. Changes in patients’ experiences in Medicare accountable care organizations. N. Engl. J. Med.371(18): 1715–1724.
58.
McWilliamsJ. M.ChernewM. E.LandonB. E.SchwartzA. L.. 2015. Performance differences in year 1 of pioneer accountable care organizations. N. Engl. J. Med.372(20): 1927–1936.
59.
McWilliamsJ. M.HatfieldL. A.ChernewM. E.LandonB. E.SchwartzA. L.. 2016. Early performance of accountable care organizations in Medicare. N. Engl. J. Med.374(24): 2357–2366.
60.
MonteverdeK.1995. Technical dialog as an incentive for vertical integration in the semiconductor industry. Management Sci.41(10): 1624–1638.
61.
MustardC. A.DerksenS.BerthelotJ. M.WolfsonM.. 1999. Assessing ecologic proxies for household income: A comparison of household and neighbourhood level income measures in the study of population health status. Health Place5(2): 157–171.
62.
National Priorities Partnership. 2008. National Priorities and Goals: Aligning Our Efforts to Transform America's Healthcare. National Quality Forum, Washington, DC. Available at https://psnet.ahrq.gov/resources/resource/8745/national-priorities-and-goals-aligning-our-efforts-to-transform-americas-healthcare (accessed date March 26, 2019).
63.
National Quality Forum. 2014. Evaluating Episode Groupers: A Report from the National Quality Forum. National Quality Forum, Washington, DC. Available at https://www.qualityforum.org/Publications/2014/09/Evaluating_Episode_Groupers__A_Report_from_the_National_Quality_Forum.aspx (accessed date March 26, 2019).
64.
NieW.KelloggD. L.. 1999. How professors of operations management view service operations?Prod. Oper. Manag.8(3): 339–355.
65.
NyweideD. J.AnthonyD. L.BynumJ. P.StrawdermanR.WeeksW. B.CasalinoL. P.FisherE. S.. 2013. Continuity of care and the risk of preventable hospitalization in older adults. JAMA Intern. Med.173(20): 1879–1885.
66.
NyweideD. J.LeeW.CuerdonT. T.PhamH. H.CoxM.RajkumarR.ConwayP. H.. 2015. Association of Pioneer Accountable Care Organizations vs traditional Medicare fee for service with spending, utilization, and patient experience. J. Am. Med. Assoc.313(21): 2152–2161.
67.
O'ConnorC. M.2017. High heart failure readmission rates: Is it the health system's fault?JACC Heart Failure5(5): 393.
68.
OhJ.ZhengZ.BardhanI. R.. 2018. Sooner or later? Health information technology, length of stay, and readmission risk. Prod. Oper. Manag.27(11): 2038–2053.
69.
OkieS.2012. The evolving primary care physician. N. Engl. J. Med.366(20): 1849–1853.
70.
PenmJ.MacKinnonN. J.StrakowskiS. M.YingJ.DotyM. M.. 2017. Minding the gap: Factors associated with primary care coordination of adults in 11 countries. Ann. Fam. Med.15(2): 113–119.
71.
PepeM. S.MoriM.. 1993. Kaplan—meier, marginal or conditional probability curves in summarizing competing risks failure time data?Stat. Med.12(8): 737–751.
72.
PhamH. H.SchragD.O'malleyA. S.WuB.BachP. B.. 2007. Care patterns in Medicare and their implications for pay for performance. N. Engl. J. Med.356(11): 1130–1139.
73.
PollackC. E.HusseyP. S.RudinR. S.FoxD. S.LaiL.SchneiderE. C.. 2016. Measuring care continuity: A comparison of claims‐based methods. Med. Care54(5): e30–e34.
74.
PopeG. C.KautterJ.EllisR. P.AshA. S.AyanianJ. Z.IezzoniL. I.RobstJ.. 2004. Risk adjustment for medicare capitation payments using the CMS‐HCC model. Health Care Financ. Rev.25(4): 119–141.
75.
PopeG. C.BachoferH.PearlmanA.KautterJ.HunterE.MillerD.KeenanP.. 2014. Risk transfer formula for individual and small group markets under the affordable care act. Medicare Medicaid Res. Rev.4(3): e1–e23.
76.
PutterH.FioccoM.GeskusR. B.. 2007. Tutorial in biostatistics: Competing risks and multi‐state models. Stat. Med.26(11): 2389–2430.
77.
RamasubbuN.KemererC. F.. 2016. Technical debt and the reliability of enterprise software systems: A competing risks analysis. Management Sci.62(5): 1487–1510.
78.
RandallT.NetessineS.RudiN.. 2006. An empirical examination of the decision to invest in fulfillment capabilities: A study of internet retailers. Management Sci.52(4): 567–580.
79.
RawsonA.DuncanE.JonesC.. 2013. The truth about customer experience. Harv. Bus. Rev.91(9): 90–98.
80.
ReidR.HaggertyJ.McKendryR.. 2002. Defusing the Confusion: Concepts and Measures of Continuity of Healthcare. Canadian Health Services Research Foundation, Ottawa.
81.
RoosN.MustardC.. 1997. Variation in health and health care use by socioeconomic status in Winnipeg, Canada: Does the system work well? Yes and NoMilbank Q.75(1): 89–111.
82.
RothA. V.MenorL. J.. 2003. Insights into service operations management: A research agenda. Prod. Oper. Manag.12(2): 145–164.
83.
SandersL.2004. The end of primary care. The New York Times, April 18.
84.
SaultzJ. W.2003. Defining and measuring interpersonal continuity of care. Ann. Fam. Med.1(3): 134–143.
85.
SaultzJ. W.AlbedaiwiW.. 2004. Interpersonal continuity of care and patient satisfaction: A critical review. Ann. Fam. Med.2(5): 445–451.
86.
SchoenfeldD.1982. Partial residuals for the proportional hazards regression model. Biometrika69(1): 239–241.
87.
SenotC.ChandrasekaranA.WardP. R.TuckerA. L.Moffatt‐BruceS.. 2016. The impact of combining conformance and experiential quality on health care clinical and cost performance. Management Sci.62(3): 829–848.
88.
ShortellS. M.1976. Continuity of medical care: Conceptualization and measurement. Med. Care14(5): 377–391.
89.
SmedbyÖ.EklundG.ErikssonE. A.SmedbyB.. 1986. Measures of continuity of care: A register‐based correlation study. Med. Care24(6): 511–518.
90.
StaatsB. R.2012. Unpacking team familiarity: The effects of geographic location and hierarchical role. Prod. Oper. Manag.21(3): 619–635.
91.
StarfieldB.1998. Primary Care: Balancing Health Needs, Services, and Technology. Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
92.
TsaoC.DayR.. 1971. A process analysis model of the US steel industry. Management Sci.17(10): B588–B608.
93.
Van WalravenC.DavisD.ForsterA. J.WellsG. A.. 2004. Time‐dependent bias was common in survival analyses published in leading clinical journals. J. Clin. Epidemiol.57(7): 672–682.
94.
Von KorffM.GrumanJ.SchaeferJ.CurryS. J.WagnerE. H.. 1997. Collaborative management of chronic illness. Ann. Intern. Med.127(12): 1097–1102.
95.
VossC.RothA. V.ChaseR. B.. 2008. Experience, service operations strategy, and services as destinations: Foundations and exploratory investigation. Prod. Oper. Manag.17(3): 247–266.
96.
WaibelS.VargasI.AllerM. B.CoderchJ.FarréJ.VázquezM. L.. 2016. Continuity of clinical management and information across care levels: Perceptions of users of different healthcare areas in the Catalan national health system. BMC Health Serv. Res.16(1): 466.
97.
WeissM. E.BobayK. L.BahrS. J.CostaL.HughesR. G.HollandD. E.. 2015. A model for hospital discharge preparation: From case management to care transition. J. Nurs. Adm.45(12): 606–614.
98.
WorrallG.KnightJ.. 2011. Continuity of care is good for elderly people with diabetes. Can. Fam. Physician57(1): e16–e20.
