Climate change is a highly contested policy issue in Australia, generating fierce debate at every level of governance. In this paper we explore a crucial tension in both the policy and the public debate: a seeming lack of attention to social inclusion and broader equity implications. We pay special attention to the municipal scale, where concerns about social difference and democratic participation are often foregrounded in political discourse, using South East Queensland—a recognised climate change ‘hotspot’—as a case study. Mobilising critical discourse analysis techniques, we interrogate three local government climate change response strategies, and place these in the context of transscalar discourse networks which appear to sustain a technocratic, ‘ecological modernisation’ approach to the issue. Finally, we suggest a broad strategy for reimagining this approach to embed a notion of climate justice in our policy thinking about climate change.
AbbsD.McInnesK.RafterT., 2007The Impact of Climate Change on Extreme Rainfall and Coastal Sea Levels over South-East Queensland (CSIRO, Aspendale, Victoria).
2.
AbramS., 2000, “Planning the public: Some comments on empirical problems for planning theory”Journal of Planning Education and Research19351–357.
3.
Abu-LughodJ., 1998, “Civil/uncivil society: Confusing form with content”, in Cities for Citizens: Planning and the Rise of Civil Society in a Global Age Eds DouglassM.FriedmannJ. (John Wiley, New York) pp 227–238.
4.
AdgerJ.PaavolaS.HuqM.MaceM. (Eds) 2006Fairness to Adaptation to Climate Change (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
5.
AmundsenH.FrodeB.WestskokH., 2010, “Overcoming barriers to climate change adaptation—a question of multilevel governance?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy28276–289.
6.
AngusI., (Ed.) 2009The Global Fight for Climate Justice (Resistance Books, London).
7.
AnnandaleD.Morrison-SaundersA.DuxburyL., 2004, “Regional sustainability initiatives: The growth of green jobs in Australia”Local Environment981–87.
8.
AylettA., 2010, “Participatory planning, justice, and climate change in Durban, South Africa”Environment and Planning A4299–115.
9.
BaileyI.WilsonG., 2009, “Theorising transitional pathways in response to climate change: Technocentrism, ecocentrism, and the carbon economy”Environment and Planning A412324–2341.
10.
BakhtinM M, 1981The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays (University of Texas Press, Austin, TX).
11.
BarnettJ., 2003, “Security and climate change”Global Environmental Change137–17.
12.
BarnettJ., 2006, “Climate change, insecurity and injustice”, in Fairness to Adaptation to Climate Change Eds AdgerW.PaavolaJ.HuqS.MaceM. (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
13.
BaumS.HortonS.Low ChoyD.GleesonB., 2009, “Climate change, health impacts and urban adaptability: Case study of Gold Coast City”, Research Monograph 11, Urban Research Program, Griffith University, Brisbane.
14.
BellD., 2010, “Ethics, justice and climate change”Environmental Politics19475–479.
15.
BetsillM.BulkeleyH., 2006, “Cities and the multilevel governance of global climate change”Global Governance12141–159.
16.
BlowersA., 1997, “Environmental policy: Ecological modernisation or risk society?”Urban Studies34845–871.
Broadleaf Capital International and Marsden Jacob, 2006Climate Change Impacts and Risk Management: A Guide for Business and GovernmentAustralian Greenhouse Office, Canberra.
22.
Brotherhood of St Laurence, 2007, “Equity in response to climate change roundtable report”, copy available from Brotherhood of St Laurence, 67 Brunswick Street, Fitzroy, Vic 3065.
23.
BulkeleyH., 2000a, “Discourse coalitions and the Australian climate change policy network”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy18727–748.
24.
BulkeleyH., 2000b, “Common knowledge? Public understanding of climate change in Newcastle, Australia”Public Understanding of Science9313–333.
25.
BulkeleyH.BetsillM., 2003Cities and Climate Change: Urban Sustainability and Global Environmental Governance (Routledge, London).
26.
BuysL.MillerE.Van MeganK., 2012, “Conceptualising climate change in rural Australia: Community perceptions, attitudes and (in)actions”Regional Environmental Change12237–248.
27.
ByrneJ., 2008, “Equity mapping”, in Positive Development: From Vicious Circles to Virtuous Cycles Through Built Environment Design Ed. BirkelandJ. (Earthscan, London) page 336.
28.
ByrneJ.GleesonB.HowesM.SteeleW., 2009, “Climate change and Australian urban resilience: The limits of ecological modernization as an adaptive strategy”, in Planning for Climate Change: Strategies for Mitigation and Adaptation for Spatial Planners Eds DavoudiS.CrawfordJ.MehmoodA. (Earthscan, London) pp 136–154.
29.
CampbellD.SmithM. StaffordDaviesJ.KuipersP.WakermanJ.McGregorM., 2008, “Responding to health impacts of climate change in the Australian desert”Rural and Remote Health81–9.
30.
CapetolaT., 2008, “Climate change and social inclusion: Opportunities for justice and empowerment”Just Policy4723–29.
31.
ChouliarakiL.FaircloughN., 1999Discourse in Late Modernity: Rethinking Critical Discourse Analysis (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh).
Commonwealth of Australia, 2012bSocial Inclusion in Australia: How Australia is Faring2nd edition (Australian Social Inclusion Board, Canberra).
36.
Congressional Black Caucus Foundation, 2004African Americans and Climate Change: An Unequal Burden Available from Congressional Black Caucus Foundation, Inc., Washington, DC.
37.
ConnerT., 2008“Social vulnerability and adaptive capacity to climate change impacts: Identifying attributes in two remote coastal communities on Haida Gwaii, British Columbia”MA dissertation, Department of Geography, University of Victoria, BC, Canada.
38.
CrickF.Serrao-NeumannS.Low-ChoyD.BaumS., 2012, “A region at risk: Policy determination through vulnerability hotspot assessment”, in Resilient Cities 2, Local Sustainability Ed. Otto-ZimmermannK., (Springer, Dordrecht) pp 15–24.
39.
CrowleyK., 1999, “Jobs and environment: The ‘double dividend’ of ecological modernisation?”Economics261013–1026.
40.
CSIRO, 2007, “The impact of climate change on extreme rainfall and coastal sea levels over South East Queensland”, CSIRO, Canberra.
CurranG., 2011, “Modernising climate policy in Australia: Climate narratives and the undoing of a Prime Minister”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy291004–1017.
43.
DankelmanI., 2002, “Climate change: Learning from gender analysis and women's experiences of organising for sustainable development”Gender Development1021–29.
44.
DaviesA., 2001, “What silence knows: Planning, public participation and environmental values”Environmental Values1077–102.
45.
DemerittD.2001, “The construction of global warming and the politics of science”Annals of the Association of American Geographers91307–337.
46.
DemetriadesJ.EsplenE., 2008, “The gender dimensions of poverty and climate change adaptation”IDS Bulletin3924–31.
47.
DentonF., 2002, “Climate change vulnerability, impacts, and adaptation: Why does gender matter?”Gender Development1010–20.
48.
Department of Climate Change, 2009Climate Change Risks to Australia's CoastCommonwealth Government, Canberra.
49.
De VriesJ., 2006, “Climate change and spatial planning below sea-level: Water, water and more water”Planning Theory and Practice7223–227.
50.
DodsonJ.SipeN., 2008a, “Shocking the suburbs: Urban location, homeownership and oil vulnerability in the Australian city”Housing Studies23377–401.
EderK., 1996The Social Construction of Nature: A Sociology of Ecological Enlightenment (Sage, London).
53.
EdwardsT.FritzeJ.WisemanJ., 2009, “Community well-being in a changing climate: Challenges for the Australian community sector”Just Policy5080–86.
54.
EvansG R, 2008, “Transformation from ‘carbon valley’ to a ‘post-carbon society’ in a climate change hotspot: The coalfields of the Hunter Valley, New South Wales, Australia”Ecology and Society1339–59.
55.
FainsteinS., 2000, “New directions in planning theory”Urban Affairs Review35451–478.
56.
FainsteinS., 2010The Just City (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
57.
FaircloughN., 1989Language and Power (Longman, London).
58.
FaircloughN., 1995Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language (Longman, London).
59.
FaircloughN., 2003Analysing Discourse: Text Analysis for Social Research (Routledge, London).
60.
FaircloughN., 2005, “Critical discourse analysis in transdisciplinary research”, in A New Agenda in (Critical) Discourse Analysis Eds WodakR.ChiltonR P, (Benjamins, Amsterdam) pp 53–70.
61.
FewR.BrownK.TompkinsE., 2007, “Public participation and climate change adaptation: Avoiding the illusion of inclusion”Climate Policy746–59.
62.
FincherR.IvesonK., 2008Planning and Diversity in the City: Redistribution, Recognition and Encounter (Palgrave Macmillan, New York).
FisherS., 2012, “Policy storylines in Indian climate politics: Opening new political spaces?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy30109–127.
65.
FordJ.SmitB.WandelJ.AllurutM.ShappaK.IttusarjuatH.QrunnutK., 2008, “Climate change in the Arctic: Current and future vulnerability in two Inuit communities in Canada”Geographical Journal17445–62.
66.
FritzeJ.WisemanJ., 2009, “Climate justice: Key debates, goals and strategies”, in Climate Change and Social Justice Ed. MossJ. (Melbourne University Press, Melbourne) pp 187–211.
67.
FurgalC.SeguinJ., 2006, “Climate change, health, and vulnerability in Canadian Northern Aboriginal communities”Environmental Health Perspectives121964–1970.
68.
GarnautR., 2008The Garnaut Climate Change Review (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
69.
GasperR.BlohmA.RuthM., 2011, “Social and economic aspects of climate change on the urban environment”Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability3150–157.
70.
GibsonC.HeadL.GillN.WaittG., 2010, “Climate change and household dynamics: Beyond consumption, unbounding sustainability”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series363–8.
71.
Gibson-GrahamJ K, 2008, “Diverse economies: Performative practices for ‘other worlds’”Progress in Human Geography32613–632.
72.
Gibson-GrahamJ KRoelvinkG., 2009, “Social innovation for community economies”, in Social Innovation and Territorial Development Eds MacCallumD.MoulaertF.HillierJ.Vicari-HaddockS. (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 25–37.
73.
GiorgiF., 2006, “Climate change hot-spots”Geophysical Research Letters33L08707.
GoodmanJ., 2009, “From global justice to climate justice? Justice ecologism in an era of global warming”New Political Science31499–514.
82.
GouldC C, 1996, “Diversity and democracy: Representing differences”, in Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Boundaries of the Political Ed. BenhabibS. (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 171–186.
GreenD.NiallS.MorrisonJ., 2012, “Bridging the gap between theory and practice in climate change vulnerability assessments for remote Indigenous communities in northern Australia”Local Environment: The International Journal of Justice and Sustainability17295–315.
85.
GuptaJ., 2010, “A history of international climate change policy”Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change1635–653.
86.
HajerM A, 1995The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernization and the Policy Process (Clarendon Press, Oxford).
87.
HajerM A, 2003, “A frame in the fields: Policymaking and the reinvention of politics”, in Deliberative Policy Analysis: Understanding Governance in the Network Society Eds HajerM.WagenaarH. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 88–110.
88.
HallidayM., 1978Language as Social Semiotic: The social Interpretation of Language and Meaning (Edward Arnold, London).
89.
HallidayM., 1985An Introduction to Functional Grammar (Arnold, Sydney).
90.
HallidayM A KMartinJ R, 1993Writing Science: Literacy and Discursive Power (Falmer Press, London).
91.
HarlanS.BrazelA.JeneretteG.JonesN.LarsenL.PrashadL.StefanovW., 2008, “In the shade of affluence: The inequitable distribution of the urban heat island”Research in Social Problems and Public Policy15173–202.
92.
HastingsA., 1999, “Analysing power relations in partnerships: Is there a role for discourse analysis?”Urban Studies3691–106.
93.
HennessyK BFitzharrisB CBatesN.HarveyS MHowdenL.HughesL.SalingerJ.WarrickR., 2007, “Australia and New Zealand”, in Climate Change: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Eds ParryM LCanzianiO FPalutikofJ PVan der LindenP JHansonC E, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 507–540.
HobsonK., 2006, “Bins, bulbs, and shower timers: On the ‘techno-ethics’ of sustainable living”Ethics, Place and Environment9317–336.
96.
HowesM.McKenzieM.GleesonB.GrayR.ByrneJ.DanielsP., 2010, “Adapting ecological modernisation to the Australian context”Journal of Integrative Environmental Sciences75–21.
IedemaR.GrantS., 2004, “AIMS retrieval medicine incident reporting: An investigation of reporters' expressions of attitude and feeling”, University of New South Wales, Centre for Clinical Governance Research, Sydney, http://www.med.unsw.edu.au/medweb.nsf/resources/Projects4/$file/AIMS.pdf.
99.
IkemeJ., 2003, “Equity, environmental justice and sustainability: Incomplete approaches in climate change politics”Global Environmental Change13195–206.
100.
IPCC, 2007, “Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability”, Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Working Group II Report, United Nations, New York.
101.
JacobsK., 2004, “Waterfront redevelopment: A critical discourse analysis of the policy-making process within the Chatham maritime project”Urban Studies41817–832.
102.
JessopB.OosterlynckS., 2008, “Cultural political economy: On making the cultural turn without falling into soft economic sociology”Geoforum391155–1169.
103.
KeilR.DesforG., 2003, “Ecological modernisation in Los Angeles and Toronto”Local Environment827–44.
104.
KellyP.AdgerW., 2000, “Theory and practice in assessing vulnerability to climate change and facilitating adaptation”Climate Change47325–352.
105.
KerrR A, 2008, “Climate change hotspots mapped across the United States”Science321909.
106.
KretzmannJ PMcKnightJ L, 1993Building Communities from the Inside Out: A Path Toward Finding and Mobilizing a Community's AssetsInstitute for Policy Research, Evanston, IL.
107.
KumarS.PallathucherilV G, 2004, “Analyzing planning and design discourses”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design31829–846.
LucasK., 2006, “Providing transport for social inclusion within a framework for environmental justice in the UK”Transportation Research, Part A40801–809.
110.
MacCallumD., 2008, “Participatory planning and means–ends rationality: A translation problem”Planning Theory and Practice9325–343.
111.
MacCallumD., 2009Discourse Dynamics in Participatory Planning: Opening the Bureaucracy to Strangers (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants).
112.
MacCallumD.HopkinsD., 2011, “The changing discourse of city plans: Rationalities of planning in Perth, 1955–2010”Planning Theory and Practice12485–510.
113.
MacCallumD.SteeleW.ByrneJ.HoustonD., 2011, “Environmental imaginaries: Climate change as an object of urban governance”, State of Australian Cities, Melbourne, November.
114.
MarcuseP.ConnellyJ.NovyJ.OlivoI.PotterC.SteilJ. (Eds), 2009Searching for the Just City: Debates in Urban Theory and Practice (Routledge, London).
MartinJ R, 2004, “Positive discourse analysis: Solidarity and change”Revista Canaria de Estudios Ingleses49179–201.
117.
MathieA.CunninghamG., 2003, “From clients to citizens: Asset-based community development as a strategy for community-driven development”Development in Practice13474–486.
118.
Maunsell Australia, 2007, “Climate Change and Energy Taskforce final report: A call for action”, Brisbane City Council, Brisbane.
119.
MendelsohnR.DinarA.WilliamsL., 2006, “The distributional impact of climate change on rich and poor countries”Environment and Development Economics11159–178.
120.
MillsS., 1997Discourse (Routledge, London).
121.
MolA P JSonnenfeldD A, 2000, “Ecological modernisation around the world: An introduction”Environmental Politics93–14.
122.
MossJ. (Ed.) 2009Climate Change and Social Justice (Melbourne University Press, Melbourne).
123.
MoulaertF.MartinelliF.SwyngedouwE.GonzalezS., 2005, “Towards alternative models, of local innovation”Urban Studies421969–1990.
124.
MuntiglP.WeissG.WodakR., 2000European Union Discourses on Un/employment: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Employment Policy-making and Organizational Change (John Benjamins, Amsterdam).
125.
MyersonG.RydinY., 1996The Language Of Environment: A New Rhetoric (UCL Press, London).
126.
NelsonV.MeadowsK.CannonT.MortonJ.MartinA., 2002, “Uncertain predictions, invisible impacts, and the need to mainstream gender in climate change adaptations”Gender Development1051–59.
127.
NicholsonT., 2007Equity in Response to Climate Change Roundtable (Brotherhood of St Lawrence, Melbourne).
128.
NyongA.AdesinaF.ElashaB. Osman, 2007, “The value of indigenous knowledge in climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies in the African Sahel”Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change12787–797.
129.
O'BrienK.EriksenS.NygaardL PSchjoldenA., 2007, “Why different interpretations of vulnerability matter in climate change discourses”Climate Policy773–88.
130.
Office of Climate Change, 2008Climate Change in Queensland: What the Science is Telling UsQueensland Government, Brisbane.
131.
PaolissoM.DouglasE.EnriciA.KirshenP.WatsonC.RuthM., 2012, “Climate change, justice, and adaptation among African American communities in the Chesapeake Bay Region”Weather, Climate and Society434–47.
132.
PatzJ AKovatsR S, 2002, “Hotspots in climate change and human health”British Medical Journal3251094–1096.
133.
PellingM.HighC.DearingJ.SmithD., 2008, “Shadow spaces for social learning: A relational understanding of adaptive capacity to climate change within organisations”Environment and Planning A40867–884.
134.
PietschJ.McAllisterI., 2010, “A diabolical challenge: Public opinion and climate change policy”Environmental Politics19217–236.
135.
PortugaliJ.AlfasiN., 2008, “An approach to planning discourse analysis”Urban Studies45251–272.
136.
Queensland Government, Brisbane.
137.
2009aClimateQ: Toward a Greener Queensland.
138.
2009bSouth East Queensland Climate Change Management Plan: Draft for Public Consultation.
139.
2009cSouth East Queensland Regional Plan 2009–2031.
140.
2011, “Climate change: Adaptation for Queensland”, Issues Paper.
RichardsonT.JensenO B, 2003, “Linking discourse and space: Towards a cultural sociology of space in analysing spatial policy discourses”Urban Studies407–22.
147.
RutlandT.AylettA., 2008, “The work of policy: Actor networks, governmentality and local action on climate change in Portland, Oregon”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space25627–646.
148.
RydinY.PenningtonM., 2000, “Public participation and local environmental planning: The collective action problem and the potential of social capital”Local Environment5153–169.
SteeleW.GleesonB., 2010, “Planning in climate change”, in A Climate for Growth: Planning South-East Queensland (University of Queensland Press, Brisbane) pp 108–123.
152.
SteeleW.GleesonB., 2011, “The great risk shift: The securitization of Australian housing”Housing Studies26235–250.
153.
SteeleW.MacCallumD.ByrneJ.HoustonD., 2012, “Planning the climate-just city”International Planning Studies1767–83.
154.
StibbeA., 2001, “Language, power and the social construction of animals”Society and Animals9145–161.
155.
SumN L, 2011Towards a Cultural Political Economy (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos).
156.
TettA.WolfJ M, 1991, “Discourse analysis and city plans”Journal of Planning Education and Research10195–200.
157.
ThrogmortonJ A, 1996, “Impeaching’ research: Planning as persuasive and constitutive discourse”, in Explorations in Planning Theory Eds MandelbaumS JMazzaL.BurchellR W, (Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, New Brunswick, NJ) pp 345–364.
158.
ThrogmortonJ A, 2000, “On the virtues of skillful meandering: Acting as a skilled-voice-in-the-flow of persuasive argumentation”Journal of the American Planners Association66367–379.
159.
Van LeeuwenT., 1993, “Genre and field in cricital discourse analysis: A synopsis”Discourse and Society4193–223.
160.
WalkerG., 2009, “Globalizing environmental justice”Global Social Policy9355–382.
161.
WeissG.WodakR. (Eds) 2003Critical Discourse Analysis: Theory and Interdisciplinarity (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants).
162.
WelfordR.HillsP., 2004, “Ecological modernisation, environmental policy and innovation priorities for the Asia Pacific Region”International Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development2324–340.
163.
WilsonS MRichardR.JosephL.WilliamsE., 2010, “Climate change, environmental justice, and vulnerability”Environmental Justice313–19.
164.
WodakR., 2009The Discourse of Politics in Action: Politics as Usual (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants).
165.
YoungI M, 1990Justice and the Politics of Difference (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
166.
YoungI M, 2000Inclusion and Democracy (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
167.
ZahranS.BrodyS DVedlitzA.GroverH.MillerC., 2008, “Vulnerability and capacity: Explaining local commitment to climate-change policy”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy26544–562.
