Although there is strong evidence that segregation on socioeconomic lines has risen in many countries over the last few decades, comparatively little is known about the processes by which this happens. While it is often assumed that selective migration is the dominant process, this has rarely been demonstrated. This paper proposes a more comprehensive framework to analyse processes driving changes in segregation—a ‘neighbourhood accounts’ framework. The framework is tested using data from the Scottish Longitudinal Study for 1991–2001, focusing on the working-age population. Contrary to what many have assumed, selective migration is shown to have only a very weak impact on changes in spatial segregation, and is certainly not the dominant factor—at least in this particular context. The effects of ageing or cohort replacement and of uneven rates of status change or social mobility appear much more important. This raises important issues for policies to tackle segregation.
AllenRVignolesA, 2007, “What should an index of school segregation measure?”Oxford Review of Education33643–668
2.
AnderssonRBråmåÅ, 2004, “Selective migration in Swedish distressed neighbourhoods: can area-based urban policies counteract segregation processes?”Housing Studies19517–539
3.
BaileyNBarnesHLivingstonMMcLennanD, 2012, “Spatial segregation and population dynamics; a review of recent evidence and data source developments”, in Understanding Neighbourhood Dynamics: New Insights for Neighbourhood Effects Research Eds van HamMManleyDBaileyNSimpsonLMaclennanD (Springer, Dordrecht) forthcoming
4.
BaileyNLivingstonM, 2007Population Turnover and Area Deprivation (Policy Press, Bristol)
5.
BaileyNLivingstonM, 2008, “Selective migration and area deprivation: evidence from 2001 Census migration data for England and Scotland”Urban Studies45: 943–961
6.
BoltGvan KempenR, 2012, “Neighbourhood based policies in the Netherland”, in Neighbourhood Effects: Neighbourhood-based Policy and International Comparisons Eds van HamMManleyDBaileyNSimpsonLMaclennanD (Springer, Dordrecht) forthcoming
7.
BoyleP JFeijtenPFengZHattersleyLHuangZNolanJRaabG, 2009, “Cohort profile: the Scottish Longitudinal Study (SLS)”International Journal of Epidemiology38385–392
8.
CarstairsVMorrisR, 1991Deprivation and Health in Scotland (Aberdeen University Press, Aberdeen)
9.
CheshirePMonastiriotisVSheppardS, 2003, “Income inequality and residential segregation: labour market sorting and the demand for positional goods”, in Geographies of Labour Market Inequality Eds MartinRMorrisonP S (Routledge, London) pp 83–109
10.
ClarkW A V, 1992, “Residential preferences and residential choices in a multiethnic context”Demography29451–466
11.
DorlingDReesP, 2003, “A nation still dividing: the British census and social polarisation 1971–2001”Environment and Planning A351287–1313
12.
DuncanODuncanB, 1955, “A methodological analysis of segregation indexes”American Sociological Review20210–217
13.
EllenI GTurnerM A, 1997, “Does neighbourhood matter? Assessing recent evidence”Housing Policy Debate8833–866
14.
EvansA W, 1985Urban Economics: An Introduction (Blackwell, Oxford)
15.
ExeterD JBoylePFengZFlowerdewRSchierlohN, 2005, “The creation of ‘Consistent Areas Through Time’ (CATTs) in Scotland, 1981–2001”Population Trends number 119, 28–36
16.
FahmyEGordonDDorlingDRigbyJWheelerB, 2011, “Poverty and place in Britain, 1968–99”Environment and Planning A43594–617
17.
FinneyNSimpsonL, 2009, “Population dynamics: the roles of natural change and migration in producing the ethnic mosaic”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies351479–1496
18.
FlowerdewRFengZ, 2002Scottish Neighbourhood Statistics Neighbourhood Definitions Project: Phase 2, Stage C and DSchool of Geography and Geosciences, University of St Andrews
19.
GalsterG, 2007, “Should policy makers strive for neighbourhood social mix? An analysis of the Western European evidence base”Housing Studies22523–545
20.
GalsterG, 2012, “US housing programs to deconcentrate poverty: a critical geographic review”, in Neighbourhood Effects: Neighbourhood-based Policy and International Comparisons Eds van HamMManleyDBaileyNSimpsonLMaclennanD (Springer, Dordrecht) forthcoming
21.
GorardS, 2007, “What does an index of school segregation measure? A commentary on Allen and Vignoles”Oxford Review of Education33669–677
22.
GorardSTaylorC, 2002, “What is segregation? A comparison of measures in terms of strong and weak compositional invariance”Sociology36875–895
23.
GramlichELarenDSealandN, 1992, “Moving into and out of Poor Urban Areas”Journal of Policy Analysis and Management11273–287
24.
GrigsbyWBaratzMGalsterGMaclennanD, 1987, “The dynamic of neighborhood change and decline”Progress in Planning281–76
25.
GROS, 20062001 Census: Data Quality General Registers Office for Scotland, Edinburgh Home Office, 2001 Community Cohesion: A Report of the Independent Review Team The Cantle Report, Home Office, London
26.
HoughtonJ, 2009Global Warming: The Complete Briefing4th edition (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
27.
JargowskyP A, 1997Poverty and Place: Ghettos, Barrios and the American City (Russel Sage Foundation, New York)
28.
JohnstonRJonesK, 2010, “Measuring segregation—a cautionary tale”Environment and Planning A421264–1270
29.
KearnsAParkesA, 2003, “Living in and leaving poor neighbourhood conditions in England”Housing Studies18827–851
30.
MasseyD SDentonN A, 1988, “The dimensions of residential segregation”Social Forces67281–315
31.
MasseyD SEggersM L, 1990, “The ecology of inequality: minorities and the concentration of poverty, 1970–1980”American Journal of Sociology951153–1188
MasseyD SGrossA BShibuyaK, 1994, “Migration, segregation and the geographic concentration of poverty”American Sociological Review59425–445
34.
MusterdSDe VosS, 2007, “Residential dynamics in ethnic concentrations”Housing Studies22333–353
35.
National Records of Scotland, 2011Mid-2010 Population Estimates for ScotlandNational Records of Scotland, Edinburgh
36.
OECD, 1998Integrating Distressed Urban Areas (OECD, Paris)
37.
QuillianL, 1999, “Migration patterns and the growth of high-poverty neighborhoods, 1970–1990”American Journal of Sociology1051–37
38.
RabeBTaylorM, 2010, “Residential mobility, quality of neighbourhood and life course events”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series A (Statistics in Society)173531–555
SEU, 1998Bringing Britain Together: A National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal Cm 4045 Social Exclusion Unit (The Stationery Office, London)
41.
SEU, 2000National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal: A Framework for ConsultationSocial Exclusion Unit, Cabinet Office, London
42.
SimpsonL, 2004, “Statistics of racial segregation: measures, evidence and policy”Urban Studies41661–681
43.
SimpsonL, 2007, “Ghettos of the mind: the empirical behaviour of indices of segregation and diversity”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (Statistics in Society)170405–424
44.
van HamMManleyDBaileyNSimpsonLMaclennanD, 2011Neighbourhood Effects Research: New Perspectives (Springer, Dordrecht)
45.
WilsonW J, 1987The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, The Underclass and Public Policy (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
