This multiple-case study sought to understand what ambitious history teachers focus their reflections on throughout a unit of study. Through video-stimulated recall methodology, reflective interviews were conducted with participants in four different schools within the same high-poverty public school district. The study built upon findings from research on ambitious teachers and found that teachers fixated on a range of problems while reflecting, among them: students” historical thinking, cultural relevant pedagogy, and their framing of history through essential questions. That the teachers focused on these issues could be linked to their values and broader educational aims.
BartonK.C.I'm not saying these are going to be easyYeagerE.A.DavisO.L.Wise social studies teaching in an age of high-stakes testing2005Information Age PublishingCT11–31
2.
BartonK.C.AveryP.G.Research on social studies education: Diverse students, settings, and methodsGitomerD.H.BellC.A.Handbook of research on teaching5th ed.2016American Educational Research AssociationWashington D.C.985–1038
3.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.Teaching history for the common good2004RoutledgeNew York
4.
BigelowB.Constitution role play: Whose “more perfect union?2015” The Zinn Education Project
5.
BraunV.ClarkV.Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology32200677–101
6.
CastroA.HawkmanA.DiazJ.Teaching race in high school social studies: Lessons from the fieldChandlerP.T.Doing race in social studies: Critical perspectives2015Information Age PublishingCharlotte, N.C.127–149
7.
ClarkC.M.Asking the right questions about teacher preparation: Contributions of research on teacher thinkingEducational Researcher17219885–12
8.
CornblethC.What constrains meaningful social studies teaching?Social Education6632002186–191
9.
CroccoM.S.LivingstonE.Becoming an “expert” social studies teacherManfraM.M.BolickC.M.The Wiley handbook of social studies research2017John Wiley & SonsWest Sussex360–384
10.
DeweyJ.ArchambaultR.John Dewey on education1964University of Chicago PressChicago, IL
11.
DiCamilloL.GradwellJ.M.Using simulations to teach middle grades US history in an age of accountabilityRMLE Online35720121–16
12.
EndacottJ.L.SturtzJ.Historical empathy and pedagogical reasoningJournal of Social Studies Research39120151–16
13.
EpsteinT.MayorgaE.NelsonJ.Teaching about race in an urban history class: The effects of culturally responsive teachingJournal of Social Studies Research35120112–21
14.
EricksonF.Qualitative methods in research on teachingWittrockM.C.Handbook of research on teaching: A project of the American educational research association3rd ed.1986MacmillanNew York119–161
15.
EthelR.G.McMenimanM.M.Unlocking the knowledge in action of an expert practitionerJournal of Teacher Education512200087–101
16.
FogoB.Core practices for teaching history: The results of a Delphi panel surveyTheory & Research in Social Education4222014151–196
17.
GaudinC.ChalièsS.Video viewing in teacher education and professional development: A literature reviewEducational Research Review16201541–67
18.
GradwellJ.M.Teaching in spite of rather than because of, the testGrantS.G.Measuring history: Cases of state-level testing across states2006Rowman & Littlefield EducationLanham157–176
19.
GrantS.G.History lessons: Teaching, learning, and testing in US high school classrooms2003Lawrence Erlbaum AssociatesMahwah, NJ
20.
GrantS.G.More journey than end: A case study of ambitious teachingYeagerE.DavisO.L.Wise social studies teaching in an age of high-stakes testing2005Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT117–130
21.
GrantS.From inquiry arc to instructional practice: The potential of the C3 frameworkSocial Education7762013322–326
22.
GrantS.Teaching practices in history educationMetzgerS.A.HarrisL.M.The wiley international handbook of history teaching and learning2018Wiley BlackwellHoboken, NJ419–448
23.
GrantS.GradwellJ.The road to ambitious teaching: Creating big idea units in history classesJournal of Inquiry and Action in Education2120091–26
24.
GrantS.G.GradwellJ.GrantS.G.GradwellJ.Teaching history with big ideas: Cases of ambitious teachers2010R&L EducationLanham, Maryland
25.
GreeneM.J.On the inside looking in: Methodological insights and challenges in conducting qualitative insider researchQualitative Report192920141–13
26.
GrossmanP.WineburgS.WoolworthS.Toward a theory of teacher communityTeachers College Record1032001942–1012
27.
HammernessK.Seeing through teachers’ eyes: Professional ideals and classroom practicesVol. 462006Teachers College PressNew York
28.
HelsingD.Regarding uncertainty in teachers and teachingTeaching and Teacher Education23820071317–1333
29.
HowardT.C.Culturally relevant pedagogy: Ingredients for critical teacher reflectionTheory and Practice4232003195–202
30.
HubermanM.Professional careers and professional development: Some intersectionsGuskeyT.R.HubermanM.Professional development in education: New paradigms and practices1995Teachers College PressNew York193–224
31.
KennedyM.M.Chapter 4: Inexact sciences: Professional education and the development of expertiseReview of Research in Education1411987133–167
32.
KimY.SilverR.E.Provoking reflective thinking in post observation conversationsJournal of Teacher Education6732016203–219
33.
KohlmeierJ.The impact of having 9th graders “do historyThe History Teacher3842005499–524
34.
Ladson-BillingsG.Crafting a culturally relevant social studies approachRossW.The social studies curriculum: Purposes, problems, and possibilities (Reviseded.2001State University of New York PressAlbany201–215
35.
Ladson-BillingsG.Lies my teacher still tells: Developing a critical race perspective toward the social studiesLadson-BillingsG.Critical race theory perspectives on social studies: The profession, policies, and curriculum2003Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT1–11
36.
LeinhardtG.StaintonC.VirjiS.M.A sense of historyEducational Psychologist292199479–88
37.
LyleJ.Stimulated recall: A report on its use in naturalistic researchBritish Educational Research Journal2962003861–878
38.
ManfraM.M.Critical inquiry in the social studies classroom: Portraits of critical teacher researchTheory & Research in Social Education3722009156–19110.1080/00933104.2009.10473393
39.
ManfraM.M.Practitioner research in the social studiesThe Wiley handbook of social studies researchManfraM.M.BolickC.M.Vol. 52017John Wiley & SonsUK132–167
40.
MarriA.R.Building a framework for classroom-based multicultural democratic education: Learning from three skilled teachersTeachers College Record107520051036–1059
41.
MartellC.C.Learning to teach history as interpretation: A longitudinal study of beginning teachersJournal of Social Studies Research371201317–31
42.
MartellC.C.Race and histories: Examining culturally relevant teaching in the US history classroomTheory & Research in Social Education411201365–88
43.
MartellC.C.Learning to teach culturally relevant social studies: A white teacher's retrospective self-studyChandlerP.T.Doing race in social studies: Critical perspectives2015Information Age PressCharlotte, N.C.41–60
44.
MartellC.C.Hashimoto-MartellE.A.Throwing out the textbook: A teacher research study of changing texts in the history classroomHickmanH.PorfilioB.J.The new politics of the textbook: Critical analysis in the core content areas2012Sense PublishersBoston305–320
45.
MartellC.C.SequenziaM.R.Working the dialectic: Teaching and learning teacher research in social studiesThe Educational Forum8042016407–41610.1080/00131725.2016.1206156
46.
McCormickT.M.Historical inquiry with fifth graders: An action research studySocial Studies Research and Practice322008119–129
47.
McMillanJ.H.SchumacherS.Research in education: Evidence-based inquiry7th ed.2010PearsonBoston
48.
Monte-SanoC.BudanoC.Developing and enacting pedagogical content knowledge for teaching history: An exploration of two novice teachers’ growth over three yearsThe Journal of the Learning Sciences2222013171–211
49.
NagleJ.F.Becoming a reflective practitioner in the age of accountabilityThe Educational Forum731200976–86
50.
OlsonJ.Understanding teaching: Developing teachers and teaching1992Open University PressPhiladelphia
51.
PattonM.Qualitative research and evaluation methods3rd ed.2002Sage PublicationsThousand Oaks, CA
52.
PaxtonR.J.WineburgS.Expertise and the teaching of historyMoonB.BrownS.Ben-PeretzM.Routledge international companion to education2000855–864(New York)
53.
ReitanoP.The value of video stimulated recall in reflective teaching practicesACSPRI) social science methodology conference2006Paper presented at the Australian Consortium for Social and Political Research IncNew South Wales
54.
RitterJ.K.Modeling self-study in social studies teacher education: Facilitating learning about teaching for democratic citizenshipCroweA.R.Advancing social studies education through self-study methodology2010SpringerNew York87–102
55.
RodgersC.Defining reflection: Another look at John Dewey and reflective thinkingTeachers College Record10442002842–866
56.
SabarN.Ethical concerns in teacher-thinking researchCarlgrenI.HandalG.VaageS.Teachers’ minds and actions: Research on teachers’ thinking and practice1994The Falmer PressLondon109–124
57.
SantoroD.A.Demoralized: Why teachers leave the profession they love and how they can stay2018Harvard Education PressCambridge
58.
SchönD.A.The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action1983Basic booksNew York
59.
Seltzer-KellyD.Adventures in critical pedagogy: A lesson in US historyTeacher Education Quarterly3612009149–162
60.
SensoyO.DiAngeloR.Is everyone really equal?An introduction to key concepts in social justice education2nd ed.2017Teachers College PressNew York
61.
ServageL.Critical and transformative practices in professional learning communitiesTeacher Education Quarterly351200863–77
62.
ShulmanL.Knowledge and teaching: Foundations of the new reformHarvard Educational Review57119871–23
63.
SilcockP.The process of reflective teachingBritish Journal of Educational Studies4231994273–285
64.
SimonN.S.JohnsonS.M.Teacher turnover in high-poverty schools: What we know and can doTeachers College Record117320151–36
65.
StakeR.E.Multiple case study analysis2006Guilford PressNew York
66.
Stanford History Education GroupNew deal SAC | Stanford history education groupThe Stanford history education group: Charting the future of teaching the past2014Stanford History Education GroupRetrieved fromhttps://sheg.stanford.edu/new-deal
67.
StanleyW.B.Teacher competence for social studiesShaverJ.P.Handbook of research on social studies teaching and learning: A project of the national council for the social studies1991Macmillan Publishing CompanyNew York249–262
68.
SturtzJ.HessbergK.Examining teacher development: The role of teacher thinking, observation, and reflectionRussellW.B.Contemporary social studies: An essential reader2012Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT547–563
69.
Van ManenM.Linking ways of knowing with ways of being practicalCurriculum Inquiry631977205–228
70.
VanSledrightB.Confronting history's interpretive paradox while teaching fifth graders to investigate the pastAmerican Educational Research Journal39420021089–1115
71.
VanSledrightB.Fifth graders investigating history in the classroom: Results from a researcher-practitioner design experimentThe Elementary School Journal10322002131–160
72.
VanSledrightB.A.The challenge of rethinking history education: On practices, theories, and policy2011RoutledgeNew York
73.
VanSledrightB.LimónM.Learning and teaching social studies: A review of cognitive research in history and geographyAlexanderP.A.WinneP.H.Handbook of educational psychology2nd ed.2006Lawrence Erlbaum AssociatesMahwah, NJ
74.
VinsonK.Oppression, anti-oppression, and citizenship educationRossE.W.The social studies curriculum: Purposes, problems, and possibilities2001State University of New York PressAlbany57–85
75.
VirginR.Connecting learning: How revisiting big idea questions can help in history classroomsThe Social Studies10542014201–212
76.
WebeckM.L.SalinasC.S.FieldS.L.A good teacher in Texas: Conversations about wisdom in middle school social studies practiceYeagerE.A.DavisO.L.Wise social studies teaching in an age of high-stakes testing: Essays on classroom practices and possibilities2005Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT69–88
77.
WestermanD.A.Expert and novice teacher decision makingJournal of Teacher Education4241991292–305
78.
WigginsG.McTigheJ.Understanding by design2nd ed.2005Association for Supervision and Curriculum DevelopmentAlexandria, VA
79.
WilsonS.M.Research on history teachingHandbook of research on teachingRichardsonV.Vol. 42001American Educational Research Association
80.
WilsonS.M.WineburgS.S.Wrinkles in time and place: Using performance assessments to understand the knowledge of history teachersAmerican Educational Research Journal3041993729–76910.3102/00028312030004729
81.
WineburgS.S.The psychology of learning and teaching historyBerlinerD.C.CalfeeR.C.Handbook of educational psychology1996Siman & Schuster MacMillanNew York423–437
82.
WineburgS.S.WilsonS.M.Models of wisdom in the teaching of historyPhi Delta Kappan701198850–58
83.
YeagerE.A.DavisO.YeagerE.A.DavisO.Wise Social Studies in an Age of High-Stakes Testing: Essays on Classroom Practices and Possibilities. Research in Curriculum and Instruction2005Information Age PublishingGreenwich, CT
84.
YinR.K.Case study research: Design and methods (applied social research methods)4th ed.2009Sage PublicationsLondon and Singapore
85.
ZeichnerK.M.Research on teacher thinking and different views of reflective practice in teaching and teacher educationCarlgrenI.HandalG.VaageS.Teachers’ minds and actions: Research on teachers’ thinking and practice1994The Falmer PressLondon9–27
86.
ZeichnerK.M.ListonD.P.Reflective teaching: An introduction2nd ed.2014RoutledgeNew York
