Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery

This article examines ethical dilemmas related to cochlear implant surgery in children. These dilemmas arise from the existence of a linguistic and cultural minority called the Deaf World. Organizations of culturally Deaf adults in the United States and abroad, as well as the World Federation of the Deaf, have, on ethical grounds, strongly criticized the practice of cochlear implant surgery in children. Three ethical dilemmas are examined. (1) The surgery is of unproven value for the main significant benefit sought, language acquisition, whereas the psychological, social, and linguistic risks have not been assessed. Thus the surgery appears to be innovative, but innovative surgery on children is ethically problematic. (2) It is now widely recognized that the signed languages of the world are full-fledged natural languages, and the communities that speak those languages have distinct social organizations and cultures. Deaf culture values lead to a different assessment of pediatric cochlear implant surgery than do mainstream (hearing) values, and both sets of values have standing. (3) The fields of otology and audiology want to provide cochlear implants to Deaf children but also, their leaders say, want to protect Deaf culture; those appear to be conflicting goals in principle because, if there were perfect implants, the ranks of the Deaf World would diminish.

The composition of the lamina propria in human vocal folds has been shown to affect vocal performance. Elastin plays a significant role in the biomechanical effects of the lamina propria. We obtained 19 larynges from the state medical examiner from subjects whose cause of death was unrelated to the trachea and laryngeal regions. The sample contained male and female subjects in the infant, adult, and geriatric age groups. We stained the vocal folds for elastin with Verhoeff's elastic tissue stain and studied them with use of an image analysis system configured for light microscopy. Distributions of elastin were measured from superficial to deep within the lamina propria (from epithelium to vocal muscle). These elastin distributions were then compared with the use of statistical software. The data showed that there was an increase in elastin content from the infant through geriatric stages. No gender-related differences were found. Infant folds had about 23% of the elastin found in adults, and geriatric subjects had about 879% of the elastin found in adults. Both of these results were statistically significant (p < 0.05). The distributions were consistent with previous observations that the lamina propria is a layered structure with most of the elastin present in the intermediate layer. This layer was larger in geriatric subjects than in adult and pediatric subjects. We observed that the fiber diameter appeared to be larger in geriatric subjects (this observation is currently being verified with electron microscopy) whereas smaller, spiraled fibers appeared in pediatric subjects.

OBJECTIVE: In the cochlea, excitatory amino acid receptor overstimulation induces toxicity in spiral ganglion neurons by an unknown mechanism. In the central nervous system, excitatory amino acid-induced toxicity is mediated by nitric oxide, which induces apoptosis in neurons. This study tested the hypothesis that cochlear nitric oxide-mediated toxicity is the result of induction of apoptosis in spiral ganglion neurons.

METHODS: The cochleas of 15 gerbils randomly assigned to different groups were perfused for 30 minutes with a test solution of 1 mmol/L sodium nitroprusside, a nitric oxide donor, or a control solution of artificial perilymph. Animals were killed at varying times, including 2, 3, 4, 8, and 18 hours after perfusion. DNA fragmentation or in situ terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate-biotin nick end-labeling analysis was done on cochleas for detection of apoptosis.

RESULTS: Analysis by both techniques demonstrated marked apoptotic cell changes in spiral ganglion neurons of sodium nitroprusside-treated cochleas evident 4 to 8 hours after perfusion, as compared with minimal to no evidence of apoptosis in spiral ganglion neurons of control specimens.

CONCLUSIONS: Exposure to high levels of nitric oxide induces apoptosis in spiral ganglion neurons. Because apoptosis is a delayed, potentially reversible cell death pathway, this may present an opportunity for intervention to prevent or attenuate hearing damage induced by excitotoxic stimuli.

Gene transfer offers the possibility of novel therapies for head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC). To this end, we demonstrate that a replication deficient adenovirus vector (Ad.RSVlacZ) can efficiently transduce foreign genes into human HNSCC cell lines in vitro, and that adenoviral mediated transfer of herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (Ad.RSVtk) followed by exposure to ganciclovir results in tumor cell killing in vitro and in vivo. Exposure to Ad.RSVlacZ resulted in lacZ expression at multiplicities of infection (MOIs) of 10 and 100 for the cell lines HEp-2 and FaDu, respectively. This increased to 97% (HEp-2) and 49% (FaDu) at an MOI of 10,000. For HEp-2, maximum expression occurred during the first 48 hours after exposure (52% at 24 hours, 48% at 48 hours; MOI 500), then declined by 40% per day. This rapid decline may be caused by dilution of the gene through cell proliferation, because normalizing for the increase in total protein shows that the total number of cells expressing lacZ is stable from days 1 to 4. FaDu and HEp-2 were then transduced by AD.RSVtk and exposed to 20 μM ganciclovir for 24 hours. Significant tumor cell killing, as measured by a colony forming assay, occurred at an MOI of 2 for HEp-2 and 20 for FaDu. At an MOI of 200, 100% of HEp-2 and 97% of FaDu cells were killed. Next, subcutaneous tumor nodules derived from FaDu and HEp-2 were established in the flanks of SCID mice. Direct intratumoral injection of Ad.RSVtk followed by 7 days of ganciclovir therapy resulted in an adenovirus dose dependent reduction of tumor growth, and an actual size reduction of established tumor nodules at the highest does (10 10 plaque forming units). In conclusion, an adenovirus vector can efficiently transduce HNSCC cell lines in vitro. Maximum marker gene expression occurred during the first 48 hours after transduction. Transduction by Ad.RSVtk followed by exposure to ganciclovir resulted in tumor cell killing in vitro and in vivo.

This study evaluated long-term reinnervation of an end-to-side neurorraphy and the resultant functional recovery in a rat model. The divided distal posterior tibial nerve was repaired to the side of an intact peroneal nerve. Control groups included a cut-and-repair of the posterior tibial nerve and an end-to-end repair of the peroneal nerve to the posterior tibial nerve. Evaluations included walking-track analysis, nerve conduction studies, muscle mass measurements, retrograde nerve tracing, and histologic evaluation. Walking tracks indicated poor recovery of posterior tibial nerve function in the experimental group. No significant difference in nerve conduction velocities was seen between the experimental and control groups. Gastrocnemius muscle mass measurements revealed no functional recovery in the experimental group. Similarly, retrograde nerve tracing revealed minimal motor neuron staining in the experimental group. However, some sensory staining was seen within the dorsal root ganglia of the end-to-side group. Histologic study revealed minimal myelinated axonal regeneration in the experimental group as compared with findings in the other groups. These results suggest that predominantly sensory regeneration occurs in an end-to-side neurorraphy at an end point of 6 months.

Various cytokines are presently known to be associated with the regulation of inflammatory responses. In pediatric otitis media, cytokines that correlate with various degrees of inflammation are present in middle ear effusions as inflammatory mediators. The present study was undertaken to examine the potential role of the early-response cytokines, interleukin-1β and tumor necrosis factor-ex, in adult otitis media. Fifty-nine adults with otitis media underwent tympanocentesis, and the effusion specimens were analyzed for the presence of both cytokines by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay methods. Eighty-eight percent of the effusions were serous in nature. Sixty-seven percent of the patients had a known history of head and neck malignancy and radiation to the temporal bone. Twelve percent of the effusions were positive for interleukin-1β expression, compared with 85% of effusions in children with otitis media. Eight percent of the effusions contained tumor necrosis factor-α, compared with 85% of those collected in pediatric otitis media. All of the specimens that contained tumor necrosis factor-α also contained interleukin-ip. In the present study, there was no correlation with head and neck malignancy/radiation or the clinical degree of inflammation with the presence of either cytokine. We conclude that adult otitis media is associated with lower expression of an acute inflammatory response, as judged by the levels of interleukin-1β and tumor necrosis factor-α in the effusions. Additionally, adult otitis probably represents a less severe and more chronic inflammatory state in comparison with pediatric otitis media. Further analysis of inflammatory mediators in adult otitis media is necessary to evaluate the contribution of cytokines in relation to various etiologic factors.

Cronic otitis media is a common problem associated with a nonintact tympanic membrane frequently involving Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The virulence of Pseudomonas bacteria is related to the production of two matrix metalloproteinases, elastase and alkaline protease. Serine proteases, such as neutrophil elastase, are produced by the host inflammatory response. These proteases are thought to contribute to tissue destruction and assist bacterial invasion during infection. This preliminary study was done to identify protease activity in otorrhea samples from patients with otitis media and a nonintact tympanic membrane and to examine the ability of selective protease inhibitors to decrease protease activity. Ilomostat (galardin) is a synthetic, specific inhibitor of matrix metalloproteinases including P. aeruginosa elastase and alkaline protease, where-as α₁-antitrypsin inhibits serine proteases including neutrophil elastase. Samples were collected and cultured from 20 patients with otorrhea resulting from tympanic membrane perforations or pressure-equalization tubes. A protease assay that used azocasein as the substrate was used to quantify protease activity, with and without addition of selective protease inhibitors. Cultures revealed P. aeruginosa alone in 7 samples, P. aeruginosa plus other organisms in 10, and S. aureus alone in 3. Protease activity was detected in 15 (75%) of the samples. A statistically significant (p < 0.05) decrease in protease activity was seen with the addition of α₁-antitrypsin or Ilomostat plus α₁-antitrypsin, but not with Ilomostat alone. Analyzing the 10 samples with the highest protease activity, a statistically significant decrease in activity was seen with Ilomostat or αα₁-antitrypsin alone and with both Ilomostat and α₁-antitrypsin together. Bacteriologic type, source of sample, age and gender of the subject, and duration of infection were not significantly related to protease activity. This is the first study to quantify protease activity and inhibition by selective protease inhibitors in human otorrhea. Protease inhibitors effectively decrease protease activity in most cases and in addition to standard antibiotic therapy might prove beneficial in the treatment of otitis media with a nonintact tympanic membrane. This study supports future clinical investigations into the role of proteases and inhibition of protease activity in the treatment of otitis media.

We conducted a retrospective review of 347 consecutive patients who underwent surgical treatment for obstructive sleep apnea syndrome. We analyzed perioperative data to identify the nature and rate of complications in an attempt to determine whether intensive care unit monitoring is needed after uvulopalatopharyngoplasty (UPPP) and associated procedures including septoplasty, tonsillectomy, turbinate reduction, geniohyoid advancement, and tracheostomy. In the 347 cases, 14 complications occurred (4%), including 5 involving the airway, 5 postoperative hemorrhages, and 4 complications classed as “other,” including dehiscence of a tracheostomy flap, abdominal ileus, urine retention, and increased creatinine concentration. We found no difference between preoperative lowest oxygen saturation and oxygen-saturation readings in the postoperative period and no correlation between complication rate and apnea severity. An association was detected between multiple simultaneous procedures and the development of complications: 50% of the patients in whom complications developed had undergone nasal procedures along with UPPP, compared with only 15% of the patients without complications. Except for one patient, all complications that occurred on the surgical ward were treated without transfer to the intensive care unit. Although surgery on the upper airway must be performed with caution in patients with sleep apnea, our findings suggest that UPPP is a safe procedure and that postoperative monitoring in an intensive care setting is not necessary for most patients.

The microbiologic features of infected sinus aspirates in nine children with neurologic impairment were studied. Anaerobic bacteria, always mixed with aerobic and facultative bacteria, were isolated in 6 (67%) aspirates and aerobic bacteria only in 3 (33%). There were 24 bacterial isolates, 12 aerobic or facultative and 12 anaerobic. The predominant aerobic isolates were Klebsiella pneumoniae, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus aureus (2 each) and Proteus mirabilis, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Haemophilus influenzae, Moraxella catarrhalis, and Streptococcus pneumoniae (1 each). The predominant anaerobes were Prevotella sp. (5), Peptostreptococcus sp. (4), Fusobacterium nucleatum (2), and Bacteroides fragilis (1). β-Lactamase-producing bacteria were isolated from 8 (89%) patients. Organisms similar to those recovered from the sinuses were also isolated from tracheostomy site and gastrostomy wound aspirates in five of seven instances. This study demonstrates the uniqueness of the microbiologic features of sinusitis in neurologically impaired children, in which, in addition to the organisms known to cause infection in children without neurologic impairment, facultative and anaerobic gram-negative organisms that can colonize other body sites are predominant.

Controversy continues to exist regarding the routine histologic examining of tonsillectomy specimens. Proponents suggest that among other reasons, missing an important diagnosis such as occult malignancy or granulomatous disease and possible medicolegal consequences argue in favor of routine histologic examination. Others state that we should consider the very low yield of significant histologic findings in routine tonsillectomy specimens and its added cost. We performed a retrospective evaluation of all cases of patients who underwent tonsillectomy with or without adenoidectomy between January 1992 and July 1996. Two hundred eighty-eight charts were evaluable. Group 1 consisted of all tonsillectomy specimens that were subjected to gross examination only. Group 2 consisted of all tonsillectomy specimens that were subjected to gross examination as well as microscopic examination. In group 1, no abnormal gross findings were noted. Group 2 consisted of specimens from an older population with a mean age of 21.6 years. There were 43 patients older than 20 years old in group 2, and in all cases except four the preoperative clinical impression correlated with the microscopic findings. Occult malignancy was found in only one of these four patients. No cases of granulomatous disease were discovered. Overall, no patients except one had any change in postoperative treatment on the basis of the results of microscopic examination. We believe that routine microscopic examination of tonsillectomy specimens results in unnecessary cost and consumption of resources and time. Microscopic examination should be done in only selected cases such as in patients with grossly asymmetric tonsils or in patients with a history of malignancy.

The financial burden for the evaluation of patients for acoustic neuroma in an otolaryngology practice is substantial. Patients with sudden sensorineural hearing loss represent a portion of that population seen with unilateral, asymmetric auditory symptoms who require investigation for acoustic neuroma. For these patients, gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging is the diagnostic gold standard. Auditory brain stem response testing has been used in the past as a screening test for acoustic neuroma, but its apparent sensitivity has fallen as the ability to image smaller acoustic neuromas has improved. Fast spin echo magnetic resonance imaging techniques without gadolinium have been shown to be as effective in the detection of acoustic neuroma as contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging. Limited nonenhanced fast spin echo magnetic resonance imaging now provides an inexpensive alternative for high-resolution imaging of the internal auditory canal and cerebellopontine angle. Fast spin echo magnetic resonance imaging can now be done at a cost approximating auditory brain stem response testing while providing the anatomic information of contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging. Cost analysis was done in the cases of 58 patients with sudden sensorineural hearing loss by comparing the costs for routine workup and screening of acoustic neuroma with the cost of fast spin echo magnetic resonance imaging with the use of screening protocols based on literature review. The potential cost savings of evaluating patients with sudden sensorineural hearing loss with fast spin echo magnetic resonance imaging for acoustic neuroma was substantial, with a 54% reduction in screening costs. In an era of medical economic scrutiny, fast spin echo magnetic resonance imaging has become the most cost-effective method to screen suspected cases of acoustic tumors at our institution by improving existing technology while reducing the cost of providing that technology and eliminating charges for impedance audiometry, auditory brain stem response testing, and contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging.

One of the most common ossicular problems in revision stapedectomy is the eroded incus. Revision surgery has been reported as successful in 70% to 80% of cases at 1 year. Little is written about long-term results or the association of erosion with various prostheses. We evaluated 83 cases from 1 to 20 years, including multiple revisions. In 23 cases the erosion was seen at initial stapedectomy. Surgery was performed with the patient under local anesthesia, with the use of the Lippy modified prosthesis. Initial success was seen in 72% (41/57), satisfactory results in 90%, no change in 5%, and none worse. At 10 years, success had declined to 50% (7 of 14), with 80% satisfactory. The numbers for multiple revisions were lower. Success in nonrevision cases was 90% (21 of 23), dropping to 86% at 10 years, with satisfactory results in 100%. The type of prosthesis associated with erosion was a crimped wire in 34% (24 of 70), a plastic strut in 23%, and a Robinsion prosthesis in 17%. We conclude that the risk of incus erosion appears less with the Robinson prosthesis. The Lippy modified prosthesis yields good long-term results, particularly when erosion is seen at initial stapedectomy. Results worsen with subsequent revision.

We report the first endoscopic surgeries performed with patients under general anesthesia using intraoperative guidance with MRI. The procedures were experimental and intended to test (1) the unusual working environment of a unique new “open-configuration” MRI unit for head and neck surgery, and (2) real-time image guidance. Twelve patients underwent endoscopic sinus surgery while under general anesthesia in a new open MRI unit that provides the surgeon with access to the patient while imaging is performed. Eleven patients had chronic sinusitis (eight of them had bilateral disease), and one had a right nasoethmoid and antral tumor. All 12 surgeries were performed without complications. Both the endoscopic view and the MRI scans were available at the surgical field. The image plane was surgeon controlled, and the MRI updated images in as little as 14 seconds. MRI provided adequate visualization of both the disease and the related anatomy and allowed the surgeon to navigate during the procedure. The intraoperative data reflect the tissue changes during surgery and provide optimum feedback for surgical guidance. Although the operating environment poses some limitations, it has become apparent that intraoperative MRI has a role in the treatment of head and neck disorders and warrants further study.

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to determine whether maxillary sinus puncture caused an alteration in antibiotic treatment and thus affected the outcome of sinusitis in the intensive care unit.

STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review was done of cases of maxillary sinus puncture between 1991 and 1994.

RESULTS: Forty-two patients were identified. All patients had findings suggestive of sinusitis on plain sinus films or CT scans of the sinuses. Twenty-five punctures (60%) recovered pus, of which 80% grew organisms. Fourteen patients (33%) had a negative lavage, and 12% of these samples grew organisms (p = 0.001). Sixty-eight percent of the cultures identified a single organism compared with 32% with multiple organisms. Gram-negative organisms were found most commonly, followed by anaerobes. In 57% of the cases antibiotic therapy was changed. In 77% of the cases the change was directed by the culture result and in 35% the therapy was changed despite a negative culture result (p = 0.002). Resolution of symptoms occurred in 83% of patients who had antibiotics changed whereas with no change in antibiotics only 42% had resolution (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSION: A sinus puncture seems to be helpful in patients with fever and positive findings on sinus films. If pus is obtained by maxillary puncture, a positive culture may be found in 80% of the cases. Changes in antibiotic regimen on the basis of culture findings seem to give a better outcome.

One of the most difficult maneuvers in rhinoplasty is achieving a straight dorsum in the patient with a crooked nose. Often this deformity is a result of trauma involving the bony and cartilaginous vaults, resulting in nasal bone fractures and avulsion of the lateral cartilages into the nasal airway. Reduction of nasal bone fractures is fairly straightforward, but the repair of nasal cartilage trauma is more problematic. The cartilage of the nasal vault possesses fibrous attachments, which when disturbed, are difficult to reestablish. Overlay grafts are known to be effective in filling these defects and creating the illusion of a straight nose. In this series, during an 8-year period, 89 grafts were placed over lateral nasal wall concavities during rhinoplasty. Results after a minimum of 1 year follow-up are reviewed, as well as technique, materials, complications, revision rate, and patient satisfaction.

Acoustic rhinometry evaluates the geometry of the nasal cavity with acoustic reflections and provides information about nasal cross-sectional area and nasal volume within a given distance. Variations in internal nasal diameters have attracted increased interest since the advent of endoscopic surgical techniques. Race is known to be one of the most important factors affecting the nasal structure. In this study, we evaluated 106 healthy adult volunteers with acoustic rhinometry to determine internal nasal diameters and volumes and obtained normative data for four racial/ethnic groups. The data were analyzed with regard to race, sex, height, and weight. All measurements were made before and after the application of a topical nasal decongestant so that the effects of the nasal cycle were eliminated by decongestion.

Maximizing efficiency of staff and resources is one method of reducing costs without affecting quality. Using a methodology similar to that used to maximize efficiency of airline-gate use, we developed a model with which to evaluate nursing support staff and clinical examining-room resources in a general otolaryngology clinic. For 144 patients over 7 consecutive clinic days, with four otolaryngologists and various combinations of support staff and examining rooms, we measured space and staff resource use, including total clinic time, number of patients seen, patient waiting time, physician and nurse productivity, and examining-room use. A simulation model was used as the medium of analysis to define parameters of the patient encounter. We identified optimal efficiency when there were three examining rooms and one and one-half nursing staff per physician or five examining rooms and three nursing staff for two simultaneously practicing physicians. Compared with a model of two rooms and one nursing staff member, our ideal model increased the percentage of the physicians' time spent in direct contact with patients from 84% to 92%. Visit length decreased from 81 minutes to 57 minutes, the average time from check-in to examination decreased from 47 to 16 minutes, and it became possible for three additional patients to be seen each day. Additional rooms and support staff, in comparison with the optimally efficient distribution, did not significantly affect these parameters. Maximizing efficiency with the use of this methodology can decrease waiting times for patients, resulting in greater patient satisfaction, improved physician productivity, total number of patients seen, and increased total contact time between physicians and patients.

Mucoepidermoid carcinoma is a common type of salivary gland malignancy with metastasis to the cervical lymph nodes occurring in up to 29% of patients. 1 We describe three patients presenting with isolated mucoepidermoid carcinoma in a cervical lymph node without an obvious primary site of origin.

Patients with syphilis may go to an otolaryngologist for their initial evaluation. Given that the incidence of syphilis is increasing, otolaryngologists should be aware of the various presenting signs and symptoms. We describe here two patients who had oral manifestations of syphilis at presentation and review the natural history of the disease and the associated diagnostic and treatment options.

The mRNA differential display method detected increased expression of the mRNA of an immune recognition antigen known as Ly-6A/E after malignant transformation of the murine squamous cell carcinoma line Pam 212. Subsequent loss of expression of Ly-6A/E occurred with metastatic tumor progression of Pam in vivo. Ly-6 molecules have been implicated in immune cell recognition and signal transduction and are homologous to the human E48 SCC antigen that has been shown to be involved in cell-cell recognition. These observations suggest that loss of Ly-6A/E antigen may contribute to tumor progression and metastasis of squamous cell carcinoma through decreased tumor-lymphocyte or tumor-tumor recognition.

The effects of locoregional postoperative radiation therapy (60 Gy on average) on cellular immunity were investigated in 11 patients with squamocellular carcinomas of the oral cavity, pharynx, or larynx. During radiation treatment, the total lymphocyte counts, CD8⁺ T-lymphocyte count, and especially CD4⁺ T-lymphocyte count decreased significantly. The mean CD4⁺ T-lymphocyte counts dropped from an average of 739/μl to 183/μl (p <0.001), and the CD4⁺/CD8⁺ quotient also decreased significantly. Not only the lymphocyte counts but also the in vitro lymphocyte stimulation responses to several mitogens decreased, with reductions averaging 10% to 50% of normal responses by the end of radiation therapy. Within 3 to 4 weeks after radiation therapy, the CD4⁺ T-lymphocyte counts and the in vitro lymphocyte stimulation responses showed a tendency toward normalization. This study shows that postoperative locoregional radiation therapy in patients with head and neck cancer induces a severe generalized impairment of cellular immunity.

OBJECTIVE: To identify the influence of type and extent of surgery on postoperative voice parameters after endoscopic laser resection for glottic carcinoma.

SETTING AND DESIGN: A multidisciplinary university-based head and neck cancer center. Objective and subjective measures of voice were correlated with type and extent of surgery following a standardized classification in a prospective study including 80 patients.

SUBJECTS AND METHOD: The postoperative mechanism of phonation was assessed by videostroboscopy 6 months after surgery at the earliest. A phonetogram was produced, and its area was calculated (relative phonetogram [RP]) in relation to a gender-different normal phonetogram. Two speech therapists (ST) and a trained otolaryngologist (TO) rated each voice independently for communication ability in a grade from 1 (poor) to 5 (near normal).

RESULTS: After simple cordectomy the means were as follows: RP = 24.8%, TO = 3.26, and ST = 3.33. When the anterior commissure was completely preserved, mean results were better (RP = 34%, TO = 3.92, ST = 3.83). Results were worse after extended cordectomy (RP = 14.7%, TO = 2.82, ST = 3.00) and transglottic resection (RP = 13.7%, TO = 2.30, ST = 2.86) but were similar within these two groups. The parameters RP, TO, and ST do not differ significantly between the group who had speech therapy after surgery (n = 33) and the group who did not (n = 47). Voice production at glottic level yields better results for every parameter than supraglottic substitute phonation. The amount of tissue removed was less significant.

CONCLUSION: Postoperative phonatory results correlate with the postoperative mechanism of phonation. There is no linear correlation with the amount of tissue removed. Comparison of similar types of resection preservation of the anterior commissure plays a key role. From the data in this study, there is no evidence for a significant benefit from speech therapy. The parameter RP is an effective and relatively simple parameter to complete auditory voice assessment.