Evaluation of dose calculations with inhomogeneity correction in intensity-modulated radiation therapy for esophagus cancer

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

Differences often exist in the dose calculation accuracy caused by using different dose calculation algorithms in non-uniform tissues.

OBJECTIVE:

To evaluate the accuracy of dose calculation with inhomogeneity correction in intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) by comparing dose calculated in Monaco with measurements in lung-chest phantom for esophagus cancer treatments.

METHODS:

Finite size pencil beam (FSPB) and X-ray voxel Monte Carlo (XVMC) were used respectively for IMRT dose recalculations. Ten IMRT plans were recalculated and measured in the chest-lung phantom. The dose measurements using the Gafchromic^® (EBT3) dosimetry films were validated with open fields in the interfaces of materials with various physical densities. The accuracy of dose calculations was then evaluated by both point dose comparison and Gamma analysis against the film measurements.

RESULTS:

For regular open fields, the discrepancies of the point doses were less than 3.0% and 2.0% between measurement and calculations by FSPB and XVMC, respectively. For 6 MV IMRT plans, the average passing rates based on 3% /3 mm Gamma criteria were 82.8±1.0% and 96.4±0.7% for FSPB and XVMC, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS:

The XVMC algorithms more accurate in IMRT dose calculations with inhomogeneity correction for esophagus cancer.

Keywords

Dose calculation intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT)inhomogeneity correction X-ray voxel Monte Carlo (XVMC)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Fotina

, Winkler

, Künzler, T, Reiterer

, Simmat

and Georg

, Advanced kernel methods vs. Monte Carlo-based dose calculation for high energy photon beams, Radiother Oncol 93(3) (2009), 645–653.

Kragl

, Albrich

and Georg

, Radiation therapy with unflattened photon beams: Dosimetric accuracy of advanced dose calculation algorithms, Radiother Oncol 100(3) (2011), 417–423.

Zarza-Moreno

, Carreira

, Madureira

, Miras

Del Rio, F.J.

Salguero, A. Leal, et al. . Dosimetric effect by shallow air cties in high energy electron beams, Phys Med 30(2) (2014), 234–241.

Ali

, Alsbou

, Taguenang

and Ahma

, Quantitative evaluation by measurement and modeling of the variations in dose distributions deposited in mobile targets, J Xray Sci Technol 25(4) (2017), 573–583.

Altunbas

, Kavanagh

, Dzingle

, Stuhr

, Gaspar

and Miften

, Dosimetric errors during treatment of centrally located lung tumors with stereotactic body radiation therapy: Monte Carlo evaluation of tissue inhomogeneity corrections, Med Dosim 38(4) (2013), 436–441.

Bueno

, Paganetti

, Duch

M.A.

and Schuemann

, An algorithm to assess the need for clinical Monte Carlo dose calculation for small proton therapy fields based on quantification of tissue heterogeneity, Med Phys 40(8) (2013), 081704.

Mampuya

W.A.

, Matsuo

, Nakamura

, Mukumoto

, Miyabe

et al. Differences in dose-volumetric data between the analytical anisotropic algorithm and the x-ray voxel Monte Carlo algorithm in stereotactic body radiation therapy for lung cancer, Med Dosim 38(1) (2013), 95–99.

Fippel

, Fast Monte Carlo dose calculation for photon beams based on the VMC electron algorithm, Med Phys 26(8) (1999), 1466–1475.

Jeleń

and Alber

, A finite size pencil beam algorithm for IMRT dose optimization: Density corrections, Phys Med Biol 52 (2007), 617–633.

10.

Chang

, Ho

S.Y.

, Ding

H.J.

, Lee

T.F.

and Chen

P.Y.

, Dependency of EBT2 film calibration curve on post irradiation time, Med Phys 41(2) (2014), 021726.

11.

Absolute dose calibration of EBT3 Gafchromic films, Journal of Instrumentation 12(8) (2017), P08015–P08015.

12.

Shalek

R.J.

, Determination of absorbed dose in a patient irradiated by beams of X or gamma rays in radiotherapy procedures, Med Phys 4(5) (1977), 461.

13.

Butson

M.J.

, Yu

P.K.

, Cheung

and Metcalfe

, High sensitivity radiochromic film dose comons, Phys Med Biol 47(22) (2002), 291–295.

14.

, Wang

, Fogarty

and Liu

, Developing a novel method to analyse Gafchromic EBT2 films in intensity modulated radiation therapy quality assurance, Australas Phys Eng Sci Med 36(4) (2013), 487–494.

15.

Zhou

, Huang

S.M.

and Deng

X.W.

, Characteristics of radiochromic film and its applications in radiation dosimetry, International Oncology 34(1) (2007), 28–31.

16.

Carrasco

, Jornet

, Duch

M.A.

, Weber

, Ginjaume

and Eudaldo

, Comon of dose calculation algorithms in phantoms with lung equivalent heterogeneities under conditions of lateral electronic disequilibrium, Med Phys 31(10) (2004), 2899–2911.

17.

Jones

A.O.

and Das

I.J.

, Comon of inhomogeneity correction algorithms in small photon fields, Med Phys 32(3) (2005), 766–776.

18.

, Hu

and Dai

, The influence of lateral electron disequilibrium on the radiation treatment planning for lung cancer irradiation, Chinese Journal of Biomedical Engineering 23(1) (2004), 49–54.