Abstract
BACKGROUND:
An enthusiasm for physical exercise is often developed in the paediatric age group through collective game-based sporting activities. Regular exercise via sports can create positive effects on the respiratory systems of boys as well as on their overall growth and development. To help identify deviations from positive trends in these areas, respiratory function tests have become an essential part of the diagnosis and assessment of pulmonary disease.
OBJECTIVE:
To investigate the effect of different types of sports on pulmonary functions and respiratory muscle strength and to help establish baseline reference values in healthy Turkish boys aged 8–12 years.
METHODS:
A total of 624 healthy boys, who train at least twice a week for football (128), basketball (105), archery (60), swimming (111) and wrestling (74), as well as 146 boys who do not perform regular physical activities voluntarily, participated in the study. To evaluate and potentially differentiate amongst the merits of these several sports, we obtained a variety of baseline measurements from our subjects, including forced vital capacity (FVC), forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), FEV1/FVC, maximal peak expiratory flow (PEF max), maximal voluntary ventilation (MVV), maximal inspiratory pressure (MIP) and maximal expiratory pressure (MEP).
RESULTS:
There were statistically significant differences amongst the types of sports regarding the various metrics we examined: FVC, FEV1, FEV1/FVC, PEF max, MVV, MIP and MEP (
CONCLUSIONS:
It was clear that exercise, especially regarding pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength, produced better outcomes in the active boys compared with our control group of relatively passive boys. The mechanisms responsible for this difference are likely due to the resistance effect of exercise.
Introduction
It is well known that the respiratory system is not fully developed in boys and that in this age category it generally has a weak structure, and as a result, many paediatric diseases involve respiratory conditions [1, 2]. The rapid development in paediatric medical science and technology has decreased the time required for the diagnosis and identification of respiratory tract diseases associated with factors such as infections and premature as well as congenital malformations, and this has enabled the development of new and effective treatment methods for many childhood illnesses [3]. Partly due to numerous innovative processes, scientists have developed special tools to invent new treatment approaches and diagnostic techniques for chronic respiratory system diseases which are increasing amongst boys, such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, asthma, cystic fibrosis, as well as neuromuscular diseases, and to better identify those who are susceptible to acute and chronic diseases at an early stage.
The process of human adaptation to diseases of the pulmonary system has been objectively evaluated [2, 4, 5], and many studies have been conducted on different patient and age groups regarding respiration [6, 7, 8]. These efforts have shown that physical activity has a positive effect on pulmonary functions as well as on respiratory muscle strength for athletes and in adults generally [9, 10, 11, 12, 13]. Although there have been many investigations of respiratory system diseases in boys [7, 14, 15, 16, 17] only a limited number have addressed the effects of different types of exercises, sports and school levels, on their pulmonary functions, and especially on their development of respiratory muscle strength and endurance [1, 18].
Descriptive characteristics of subjects
Descriptive characteristics of subjects
In light of this situation, we aimed to assess the pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength in boys aged 8–12 years, and then to compare these findings amongst those who regularly play sports and those who do not. To our knowledge, this is the first study to directly address these questions across a variety of different sports, using a large number of subjects and to investigate the characteristics of maximal inspiratory pressure (MIP) and maximal expiratory pressure (MEP) in healthy Turkish boys. We hypothesised that pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength in boys who exercise regularly would be greater compared with those who do not actively engage in sporting activities. In addition, we aimed to measure and define standard values for respiratory parameters in healthy Turkish boys so that these results could serve as baseline values in future research projects.
Subjects
A total of 624 healthy boys volunteered to participate in this study (Table 1). Their parents undertook a survey prior to the boys being enrolled and were queried with respect to any chronic or acute respiratory system diseases or severe injuries that the boys had. For all participants, a parent or guardian also provided written consent. The study was approved by the Clinical Research Ethics Committee of Ondokuz Mayıs University.
Experimental design
This study analysed respiration muscle strength and pulmonary functions in boys who are actively playing five types of sports (football, basketball, wrestling, archery, swimming) and then compared these results with values obtained from boys who did not engage in these activities. To this end, our subjects visited the laboratory two times. During the first visit, they were informed about the test protocols, a pilot application was performed to help them understand how the study would progress, and their height, weight and body mass index (BMI) were measured. During the second visit, pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength tests were performed. The subjects were asked to not engage in physical activity for at least several hours prior to their measurement sessions. This investigation was designed and implemented in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki.
Procedures
Pulmonary function assessment
Pulmonary function measurements were performed using a spirometer (CPFS/D USB Spirometer, MGC Diagnostics, Saint Paul, MN, USA). Forced vital capacity (FVC), forced expiration volume in one second (FEV1), the FEV1/FVC ratio, maximal peak expiratory flow (PEF max) and maximal voluntary ventilation (MVV) were recorded using this pulmonary function test. The best measurements for each subject were used in the subsequent analyses.
Respiratory muscle strength
MIP and MEP were measured with a portable hand-held mouth respiratory pressure meter (MicroRPM, CareFusion Micro Medical, Kent, UK). After the appropriate filters and holders were fixed, the nasal airway was closed with a clip. The MIP measurement started with the residual volume, and MEP assessment began with total lung capacity. Measurements were performed three times, and the best value was recorded.
Statistical analysis
Statistical analyses of the data generated were performed using SPSS version 22.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, Illinois, USA). Values are presented as means, standard deviations and effect sizes. The Kolmogorov – Smirnov test was used to evaluate normality before the statistical operations. Multivariate (MANOVA) tests were used for comparisons amongst the sports. In the multiple comparison tests, the Tukey and Tamhane tests were used according to the homogeneity distributions of the variances. The effect sizes were obtained from partial eta-squared data. Significance was defined as
Results
Age, height, weight, BMI and sports experience data are presented in Table 1. Our comparison of pulmonary functions and respiratory muscles across the five sports is presented in Table 2. Statistically significant differences were found for FVC, FEV1, PEF max, MVV, MIP and MEP (
Analysis of pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength measurements
Analysis of pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength measurements
This study aimed to investigate the effect of sports in general, and also five specific sports, on pulmonary functions and respiratory muscle strength in healthy Turkish boys between 8 and 12 years old. For this purpose, we conducted research on 624 healthy boys and generated three significant results: (1) the pulmonary functions and respiratory muscle strength of boys engaged in sports were significantly superior compared with those who were not involved with these activities, (2) the respiratory parameters of boys wrestlers were higher than those engaged in the other four sports we investigated and (3) we established standard reference values that can be used for future studies of healthy Turkish boys.
Numerous studies have revealed that in boys, factors such as age, height, weight [2, 4, 19] and physical activity level affect pulmonary functions and respiratory muscle strength [18, 20, 21, 22, 23]. It is also well known that boys who are overweight or obese or who have significant health problems, such as scoliosis, have lower pulmonary function [22, 23, 24].
In the present study, it was observed that the average values of respiratory muscle strength and function of boys aged 8–12 years differ with respect to the sports they played and that those who regularly engage in sports have better values compared with those who do not. We also found that wrestlers have better respiratory function values compared with players of the other sports we included in this study (
We found that the average values regarding the pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength of athletes in the fields of swimming, football and basketball are higher than those who do not actively engage in these activities. This finding can be explained by their aerobic exercise during training as it is well known that people who undertake intense aerobic activities have relatively high endurance gains in both respiratory and locomotor muscles and that their hyperpnoea levels peak, resulting in comparatively higher levels of pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength [1]. Additionally, constant stress applied on the muscles during an aerobic performance causes changes in mitochondrial and enzyme activity, especially in the diaphragm, which in turn increases the resistance against the oxygenation of respiratory muscles and fatigue [26]. This study showed that wrestlers, followed by archers, had better averages in these two metrics compared with other athletes studied. In archery, the strength and durability of the upper extremity and core muscles are directly associated with better performance [27]. It has been shown that the training procedures used in archery do not cause significant stress on the respiratory system [28]. It is also known that the lung capacity of archers is generally larger than for athletes in other sports [29]. Moreover, studies have revealed that archers have superior cardiovascular systems and better metrics regarding breathing and blood pressure compared with other athletes [28]. A successful shot in archery usually involves the highly effective use of breathing control and other pulmonary functions. Moreover, the special breathing exercises that are regularly included in the training of archers are likely the reason for their superior respiratory parameters compared with other athletes.
The different types of training systems used by athletes in various sports are significant factors helping to generate often substantial differences in the physiological development of boys [30, 31, 32, 33]. Although the best pulmonary and cardiovascular values produced in our study were acquired from wrestlers, it was found that the respiratory systems of swimmers and archers were also relatively well developed. Although it is known that the aerobic system can be improved in football and basketball like it is in swimming, a substantial literature now shows that both paediatric and adult swimmers have stronger values relating to pulmonary and cardiac function compared with athletes [1, 34]. This result is likely produced because the respiratory system of swimmers is under massive stress as they ventilate while performing in a horizontal position with the help of the buoyancy of water, enabling them to exert extraordinary levels of muscular strength and endurance over substantial lengths of time, even compared with the strenuous demands of many other sports [35].
In conclusion, it is widely thought that the differences in respiratory parameters of boys playing different sports differ by age, height, weight and sports experience. The central hypothesis of the current study, namely that the pulmonary function and respiratory muscle strength of boys performing regular exercise will be greater compared with inactive boys, was borne out. We found that athletes specialised in the five sports we examined had higher parameter values than boys who did not significantly engage in athletic activities. The mechanism producing this result is thought to be the positive effect of increased respiratory muscle strength on lung volume and capacity due to the resistance effect of exercise. It is believed that athletes in sports involving a substantial aerobic component have higher pulmonary function values. However, the impact of different sports is more marked in adults compared with boys due to the lower level of sports experience and the relatively incomplete physical development of the much younger athletes.
Similar studies on boys from various countries would be helpful in terms of determining baseline values for comparison. It is believed that physical activity starting at early ages would play a preventative role against chronic respiratory tract diseases, both during childhood and throughout the adult years, and moreover, that regular exercise in boys with respiratory tract diseases would have a significant positive effect on their quality of life.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
Our study entitled “The differential impact of several types of sports on pulmonary functions and respiratory muscle strength in boys aged 8–12” was conducted with support from Project 1901 of Ondokuz Mayıs University Scientific Research and Development Program (PYO.YDS.1901.16.004).
Conflict of interest
None to report.
