Objective: This paper reports the findings of a prospective longitudinal study of 272 nulliparous pregnant women, which investigated as one of its objectives the psychological sequelae of obstetric procedures.
Method: Participants completed structured interviews and standardised, published psychometric questionnaires, including the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale and the Profile of Mood States late in pregnancy and again early in the postpartum period. Results: Little evidence was found to support the notion that the total number of obstetric interventions was linked to a deterioration in postpartum mood. Significant adverse psychological effects were associated with the mode of delivery. Those women who had spontaneous vaginal deliveries were most likely to experience a marked improvement in mood and an elevation in self-esteem across the late pregnancy to early postpartum interval. In contrast, women who had Caesarean deliveries were significantly more likely to experience a deterioration in mood and a diminution in self-esteem. The group who experienced instrumental intervention in vaginal deliveries fell midway between the other two groups, reporting neither an improvement nor a deterioration in mood and self-esteem.
Conclusions: The findings of this study suggest that operative intervention in first childbirth carries significant psychological risks rendering those who experience these procedures vulnerable to a grief reaction or to posttraumatic distress and depression.
BiggsJSGThe rise of the caesarian section: a review. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology1984; 24:67–71.
2.
NotzonFCPlacekPJTaffelSMComparisons of national cesarean-section rates. New England Journal of Medicine1987; 316:386–389.
3.
KozakLJSurgical and nonsurgical procedures associated with hospital delivery in the United States: 1980–1987. Birth1989; 16:209–213.
4.
LomasJEnkinM.Variations in operative delivery rates. In: ChalmersIEnkinMKeirseMJNC, eds. Effective care in pregnancy and childbirth. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 1989:1182–1195.
5.
LancasterPALPedisichELCaesarean births in Australia, 1985–1990. Sydney: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare National Perinatal Statistics Unit, 1993.
6.
NotzonFCChattingiusSBergsjoPCesarean section delivery in the 1980s: international comparison by indication. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology1994; 170:495–504.
7.
LancasterPLHuangJLinM.Australia's mothers and babies 1993. Sydney: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare National Perinatal Statistics Unit, 1996.
8.
ChalmersB.WHO appropriate technology for birth revisited. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology1992; 99:709–710.
9.
StephensonPABakoulaCHemminkiEPatterns of use of obstetrical interventions in 12 countries. Paediatric and Perinatal Epidemiology1993; 7:45–54.
10.
ChardTRichardsM.Lessons for the future. In: ChardTRichardsM, eds. Clinics in developmental medicine no. 64: benefits and hazards of the new obstetrics. London: Spastics International Medical Publications, 1977:157–163.
11.
ChalmersIRichardsM.Intervention and causal inference in obstetric practice. In: ChardTRichardsM, eds. Clinics in developmental medicine no. 64: benefits and hazards of the new obstetrics. London: Spastics International Medical Publications, 1977:34–61.
12.
LumleyJAstburyJ.Birth rights, birth rites: childbirth alternatives for Australian parents. Melbourne: Sphere, 1980.
13.
LumleyJWoodC.Caesarean section in Australia. In: Report of the working party to investigate variations in caesarean section rates in Australia. Canberra: National Health and Medical Research Council, 1984.
14.
ChardTRichardsMPM, eds. Clinics in developmental medicine nos. 123/124. Obstetrics in the 1990s: current controversies. London: Mac Keith Press, 1992.
15.
PettitiDCefaloRShapiroSWhalleyP.In-hospital maternal mortality in the United States: time trends and relation to method of delivery. Obstetrics and Gynecology1982; 59:6–12.
16.
RattanGJChanges in obstetric practice in our time. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology1985; 25:241–244.
17.
SavageWFrancomeC.British caesarean section rates: have we reached a plateau?British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology1993; 100:493–496.
18.
BassellGMAnesthesia for cesarean section. Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology1985; 28:722–734.
19.
PettitiD.Maternal mortality and morbidity in cesarean section. Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology1985; 28:763–769.
20.
EnkinM.Labour and delivery following previous caesarean section. In: ChalmersIEnkinMKeirseMJNC, eds. Effective care in pregnancy and childbirth. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989:1196–1215.
21.
MarieskindHICesarean section in the United States: has it changed since 1979?Birth1989; 16:196–202.
22.
BeischerNAMaternal mortality in Australia. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology1992; 32:183–185.
23.
AstburyJ.The crisis of childbirth: can information and childbirth education help?Journal of Psychosomatic Research1980; 24:9–13.
24.
ElliottSARuggAJWatsonJPBroughDIMood changes during pregnancy and after the birth of a child. British Journal of Clinical Psychology1983; 22:295–308.
25.
LittlefieldVMAdamsBNPatient participation in alternative perinatal care: impact on satisfaction and health locus of control. Research in Nursing and Health1987; 10:139–148.
26.
FisherJRWStanleyROBurrowsGDPsychological adjustment to caesarean delivery: a review of the evidence. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology1990; 11:91–106.
27.
MutrynP.Psychosocial impact of cesarean section on the family: a literature review. Social Science and Medicine1993; 37:1271–1281.
28.
HottJRBest laid plans. Pre and postpartum comparison of self and spouse concepts in primiparous Lamaze couples who share delivery, and those who do not. Birth Defects1981; 17:153–180.
29.
MarutJSMercerRTComparison of primiparas’ perceptions of vaginal and caesarean births. Nursing Research1979; 28:260–266.
30.
MarutJSMercerRTThe cesarean birth experience: implications for nursing. Birth Defects1981; 17:129–152.
31.
CoxBESmithECThe mother's self-esteem after a cesarean delivery. Maternal and Child Nursing Journal1982; 7:309–314.
32.
BradleyCFRossSEWarnycaJ.A prospective study of mother's attitudes and feelings following cesarean and vaginal births. Birth1983; 10:79–83.
33.
CranleyMSHedahlKJPeggSHWomen's perceptions of vaginal and cesarean deliveries. Nursing Research1983; 32:10–15.
34.
MercerRTHackleyKCBostromAGRelationship of psychosocial and perinatal variables to perception of childbirth. Nursing Research1983; 32:202–207.
35.
MercerRTStaintonMCPerceptions of the birth experience: a cross-cultural comparison. Health Care for Women International1984; 5:29–46.
36.
GarelMLelongNKaminskiM.Psychological consequences of caesarean childbirth in primiparas. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology1987; 6:197–209.
37.
GarelMLelongNKaminskiM.Follow-up study of psychological consequences of childbirth. Early Human Development1988; 16:271–282.
38.
GarelMLelongNMarchandAKaminskiM.Psychosocial consequences of caesarean childbirth: a four-year follow-up study. Early Human Development1990; 21:105–114.
39.
PadawerJAFaganCJanoff-BulmanRStricklandBRChorowskiM.Women's adjustment following emergency caesarean vs. vaginal delivery. Psychology of Women Quarterly1988; 12:25–34.
40.
TulmanLFawcettJ.Return of functional ability after childbirth. Nursing Research1988; 37:77–81.
41.
CumminsLHScrimshawSCMEnglePLViews of caesarean birth among primiparous women of Mexican origin in Los Angeles. Birth1988; 15:164–170.
42.
KearneyMCronenwettLRPerceived perinatal complications and childbirth satisfaction. Applied Nursing Research1989; 2:140–142.
43.
KendellREMackenzieWEWestCMcGuireRJCoxJLDay-to-day mood changes after childbirth: further data. British Journal of Psychiatry1984; 145:620–625.
44.
KnightRGThirkettleJAAnxiety and depression in the immediate post-partum period: a controlled investigation of a primiparous sample. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1986; 20:430–436.
45.
KnightRGThirkettleJAThe relationship between expectations of pregnancy and birth, and transient depression in the immediate postpartum period. Journal of Psychosomatic Research1987; 31:351–357.
46.
CondonJTWatsonTLThe maternity blues: exploration of a psychological hypothesis. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica1987; 76:164–171.
47.
HapgoodCCElkindGSWrightJJMaternity blues: phenomena and relationship to later postpartum depression. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1988; 22:299–306.
48.
OakleyA.Women confined: towards a sociology of childbirth. Oxford: Martin Robertson, 1980.
49.
BallingerCBEmotional disturbance during pregnancy and following delivery. Journal of Psychosomatic Research1982; 26:629–634.
50.
PittB.‘Atypical’ depression following childbirth. British Journal of Psychiatry1968; 114:1325–1335.
51.
NilssonAAlmgrenPEParanatal emotional adjustment. A prospective investigation of 165 women. Part II. The influence of background factors, psychiatric history, parental relations and personality characteristics. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica1970; 47(Suppl. 220):62.
52.
PaykelESEmmsEMFletcherJRassabyESLife events and social support in puerperal depression. British Journal of Psychiatry1980; 136:339–346.
53.
ElliottSAAndersonMBroughDIWatsonJPRuggAJRelationship between obstetric outcome and psychological measures in pregnancy and the postnatal year. Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology1984; 2:18–32.
54.
O'HaraMWSocial support, life events, and depression during pregnancy and the puerperium. Archives of General Psychiatry1986; 43:569–573.
55.
DaltonK.Prospective study into puerperal depression. British Journal of Psychiatry1971; 118:689–692.
56.
DennersteinLLehertPRiphagenF.Postpartum depression—risk factors. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology1989; Suppl. 10:53–65.
57.
CampbellSBCohnJFPrevalence and correlates of postpartum depression in first-time mothers. Journal of Abnormal Psychology1991; 100:594–599.
58.
BirdsongLSLoss and grieving in cesarean mothers. In: KehoeCF, ed. The Cesarean experience: theoretical and clinical perspectives for nurses. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1981:188–209.
59.
TrowellJAPossible effects of emergency caesarian section on the mother-child relationship. Early Human Development1982; 7:41–51.
60.
TrowellJ.Emotional effects of a caesarean. Nursing Times1986; 82:64–65.
61.
GottliebSEBarrettDEEffects of unanticipated cesarean section on mothers, infants and their interaction in the first month of life. Journal of Developmental and Behavioural Pediatrics1986; 7:180–187.
62.
CoxJLHoldenJMSagovskyR.Detection of postnatal depression. Development of the 10–item Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale. British Journal of Psychiatry1987; 150:782–786.
63.
O'NeillTMurphyPGreeneVTPostnatal depression—aetiological factors. Irish Medical Journal1990; 83:17–18.
64.
HannahPAdamsDLeeAGloverVSandlerM.Links between early post-partum mood and postnatal depression. British Journal of Psychiatry1992; 160:777–780.
65.
BoycePMToddALIncreased risk of postnatal depression after emergency caesarean section. The Medical Journal of Australia1992; 157:172–174.
66.
AstburyJBrownSLumleyJSmallR.Birth events, birth experiences and social differences in postnatal depression. Australian Journal of Public Health1994; 18:176–184.
67.
CulpREOsofskyHJEffects of cesarean delivery on parental depression, marital adjustment, and mother–infant interaction. Birth1989; 16:53–58.
68.
KendellRERennieDClarkeJADeanC.The social and psychiatric correlates of psychiatric admission in the puerperium. Psychological Medicine1981; 11:341–350.
69.
KendellREChalmersJCPlatzC.Epidemiology of puerperal psychoses. British Journal of Psychiatry1987; 150:662–673.
70.
McNeilTFBlenowG.A prospective study of postpartum psychoses in a high-risk group. Relationship to birth complications and neonatal abnormalities. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica1988; 78:478–484.
71.
FisherJRWSmithAMAstburyJAPrivate health insurance and a healthy personality: new risk factors for obstetric intervention?Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gyneacology1995; 16:1–9.
72.
CartwrightASmithC.Some comparisons of data from medical records and from women who recently had a live birth or stillbirth. Journal of Biosocial Science1979; 11:49–64.
73.
JoffeMGrissoJAComparison of antenatal hospital records with retrospective interviewing. Journal of Biosocial Science1985; 17:113–119.
74.
RoféYAlgomD.Accuracy of remembering postdelivery pain. Perceptual and Motor Skills1985; 60:99–105.
75.
HarlowSDLunetMSAgreement between questionnaire data and medical records: the evidence for accuracy of recall. American Journal of Epidemiology1990; 129:233–248.
76.
SimkinP.Just another day in a woman's life? Women's long-term perceptions of their first birth experience. Part I. Birth1991; 18:203–210.
77.
SimkinP.Just another day in a woman's life? Part II: Nature and consistency of women's long-term memories of their first birth experiences. Birth1992; 19:64–81.
78.
RosenbergM.Society and the adolescent self-image. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1965.
79.
McNairDMLorrMDropplemanLFManual of the Profile of Mood States. San Diego: Educational and Industrial Testing Service, 1971.
80.
Statistical package for the social sciences user's guide. Chicago: SPSS, 1988.
81.
Commonwealth Department of Employment and Industrial Relations.Australian standard classification of occupations. Canberra: Commonwealth Department of Employment and Industrial Relations, 1987.
82.
SkujaEGrudzinskasJGSkujaK.What do expectant mothers want? A preliminary report on consumer demand for obstetric services. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology1982; 22:206–211.
83.
BarnettBParkerG.Possible determinants, correlates and consequences of high levels of anxiety in primiparous mothers. Psychological Medicine1986; 16:177–185.
84.
HumenickSSBugenLAMastery: the key to childbirth satisfaction. Birth and the Family Journal1981; 8:84–90.
85.
SalmonPDrewNCMultidimensional assessment of women's experience of childbirth: relationship to obstetric procedure, antenatal preparation and obstetric history. Journal of Psychosomatic Research1992; 36:317–332.
86.
GreenJMCouplandVAKitzingerJVExpectations, experiences, and psychological outcomes of childbirth: a prospective study of 825 women. Birth1990; 17:15–24.
87.
BrownSLumleyJSmallRAstburyJ.Missing voices. The experience of motherhood. Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1994.
88.
DeutschH.The psychology of women. A psychoanalytic interpretation. Vol. 2. Motherhood. New York: Grune and Stratton, 1945.
89.
American Psychiatric Association.Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 4th ed.Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, 1994.
