Vanished Classmates: The Effects of Local Immigration Enforcement on School Enrollment

Abstract

For over a decade, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has formed partnerships allowing local police to enforce immigration law by identifying and arresting undocumented residents. Prior studies, using survey data with self-reported immigrant and citizenship status, provide mixed evidence on their demographic impact. This study presents new evidence based on Hispanic public school enrollment. We find local ICE partnerships reduce the number of Hispanic students by 10% within 2 years. We estimate partnerships enacted before 2012 displaced more than 300,000 Hispanic students. These effects are concentrated among elementary school students. We find no corresponding effects on the enrollment of non-Hispanic students and no evidence that ICE partnerships reduced pupil-teacher ratios or the percentage of students eligible for the National School Lunch Program.

Keywords

immigration enforcement student mobility police ICE enrollment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alsan

Yang

(2019). Fear and the safety net: Evidence from secure communities. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

Amuedo-Dorantes

Arenas-Arroyo

Sevilla

(2018). Immigration enforcement and economic resources of children with likely unauthorized parents. Journal of Public Economics, 158(C), 63–78.

Amuedo-Dorantes

Lopez

M. J.

(2015). Falling through the cracks? Grade retention and school dropout among children of likely unauthorized immigrants. American Economic Review, 105, 598–603.

Amuedo-Dorantes

Lopez

M. J.

(2017). The hidden educational costs of intensified immigration enforcement. Southern Economic Journal, 84, 120–154.

Angrist

J. D.

Pischke

J. S.

(2009). Mostly harmless econometrics: An empiricist’s companion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Baker

Lesaux

Jayanthi

Dimino

Proctor

C. P.

Morris

. . . Newman-Gonchar

(2014). Teaching academic content and literacy to English language learners in elementary and middle school. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education.

Beatty

(2010). Student mobility: Exploring the impacts of frequent moves on achievement—Summary of a workshop. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.

Bertrand

Duflo

Mullainathan

(2004). How much should we trust difference-in-difference estimates? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 119, 249–275.

Blau

F. D.

Mackie

(Eds.). (2016). The economic and fiscal consequences of immigration. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.

10.

Borusyak

Jaravel

(2017). Revisiting event study designs, with an application to the estimation of the marginal propensity to consume. Retrieved from https://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/bacd2d_6ce575dacc4e4154be019a01a83a0a62.pdf

11.

Boushey

Luedtke

(2011). Immigrants across the U.S. federal laboratory: Explaining state-level innovation in immigration policy. State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 11, 390–414.

12.

Bowen

W. G.

Bok

Loury

G. C.

Shulman

J. L.

Nygren

T. I.

Dale

S. B.

Meserve

L. A.

(2016). The shape of the river: Long-term consequences of considering race in college and university admissions (Vol. 96). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

13.

Brown

J. D.

Heggeness

M. L.

Dorinski

S. M.

Warren

(2018). Understanding the quality of alternative citizenship data sources for the 2020 Census. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau, Center for Economic Studies.

14.

Capps

Rosenblum

M. R.

Rodriguez

Chishti

(2011). Delegation and divergence: A study of 287(g) state and local immigraton enforcement (Vol. 2). Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute.

15.

Chaudry

Capps

Pedroza

J. M.

Castaneda

R. M.

Santos

Scott

M. M.

(2010). Facing our future: Children in the aftermath of immigration enforcement. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.

16.

Domina

Pharris-Ciurej

Penner

A. M.

Penner

E. K.

Brummet

Porter

S. R.

Sanabria

(2018). Is free and reduced-price lunch a valid measure of educational disadvantage? Educational Researcher, 47, 539–555.

17.

Executive Order No. 13767, 82 Fed. Reg. 8793 (January 25, 2017).

18.

Forrester

Nowrasteh

(2018). Do immigration enforcement programs reduce crime? Evidence from the 287(g) program in North Carolina. Washington, DC: Cato Institute.

19.

Garcetti

Feuer

Wesson

H. J.

(2017). Letter to ICE from Los Angeles. Los Angeles, CA: City of Los Angeles. Retrieved from https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3474587-022417-LALetter-ICE.html

20.

Garcia

(2016). Treating toxic stress in immigrant children. Communiqué, 46(7), 30–32.

21.

Gelatt

Bernstein

Koball

(2017). State immigration policy resource. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.

22.

Gibbons

Serrato

J. C. S.

Urbancic

M. B.

(2018). Broken or fixed effects? Journal of Econometric Methods, 8(1), 1–12. doi:10.1515/jem-2017-0002

23.

Gonzales

R. G.

Raphael

(2017). Illegality: A contemporary portrait of immigration. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 3(4), 1–17.

24.

Goodman-Bacon

(2018). Difference-in-differences with variation in treatment timing. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

25.

Hanushek

E. A.

Kain

J. F.

Rivkin

S. G.

(2004). Disruption versus tiebout improvement: The costs and benefits of switching schools. Journal of Public Economics, 88, 1721–1746.

26.

Heissel

J. A.

Levy

D. J.

Adam

E. K.

(2017). Stress, sleep, and performance on standardized tests: Understudied pathways to the achievement gap. AERA Open, 3(3), 1–17.

27.

Hill

C. J.

Bloom

H. S.

Black

A. R.

Lipsey

M. W.

(2008). Empirical benchmarks for interpretting effect sizes in research. Child Development Perspectives, 2, 172–177.

28.

Imberman

S. A.

Kugler

A. D.

Sacerdote

B. I.

(2012). Katrina’s children: Evidence on the structure of peer effects from hurricane evacuees source. American Economic Review, 102, 2048–2082.

29.

Jones

N. A.

Bullock

(2012). The two or more races population: 2010—2010 Census briefs. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau.

30.

Kostandini

Mykerezi

Escalante

(2014). The impact of immigration enforcement on the U.S. farming sector. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 96, 172–192.

31.

Lee

Orfield

(2006). Data proposals threaten education and civil rights accountability. Cambridge, MA: Civil Rights Project at Harvard University.

32.

Lee

Bowen

N. K.

(2006). Parent involvement, cultural capital, and the achievement gap among elementary school children. American Education Research Journal, 43, 193–218.

33.

Michelmore

Dynarski

(2017). The gap within the gap: Using longitudinal data to understand income differences in educational outcomes. AERA Open, 3(1), 1–18.

34.

Misra

(2017, August 22). “Anti-sanctuary” cities continue to multiply under Trump. City Lab. Retrieved from https://www.citylab.com/equity/2017/08/the-anti-sanctuary-cities-have-nearly-doubled/537516/

35.

Nowrashteh

(2018, April 11). 287(g) Does not fight crime, but it does increase assaults against police officers [Web log post]. Retrieved from https://www.cato.org/blog/287g-does-not-fight-crime-it-does-increase-assaults-against-police-officers

36.

O’Neil

K. S.

(2013). Immigration enforcement by local police under 287(g) and growth of unauthorized immigrant and other populations. Retrieved from https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2210765

37.

Parrado

E. A.

(2012). Immigration enforcement policies, the economic recession, and the size of local mexican immigrant populations. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 641, 16–37.

38.

Passel

J. S.

(2005). Estimates of the size and characteristics of the undocumented population. Washington, DC: Pew Hispanic Center.

39.

Passel

J. S.

Clark

R. L.

(1997, March). How many naturalized citizens are there? An assessment of data quality in the decennial census and CPS. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Population Association of America, Washington, DC.

40.

Passel

J. S.

Cohn

(2009). A portrait of unauthorized immigrants in the United States. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center.

41.

Passel

J. S.

Cohn

(2011). Unauthorized immigrant population: National and state trends, 2010. Washington, DC: Pew Hispanic Center.

42.

Passel

J. S.

Cohn

Gonzalez-Barrera

(2012). Net migration from Mexico falls to zero—and perhaps less. Washington, DC: Pew Hispanic Center.

43.

Passel

J. S.

Taylor

(2010). Unauthorized immigrants and their U.S.-born children. Washington, DC: Pew Hispanic Center.

44.

Passel

J. S.

Van Hook

Bean

F. D.

(2004). Estimates of the legal and unauthorized foreign-born population for the United States and selected states, based on Census 2000. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau.

45.

Pedroza

J.M.

(2019). Where Immigration Enforcement Agreements Stalled: The Location of Local 287(g) Program Applications and Inquiries (2005-2012). SocArXiv Papers. Retrieved from https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/2a8kz/

46.

Pham

(2018). 287(g) Agreements in the Trump era. Washington and Lee Law Review, 75, 1253–1286.

47.

Pham

Van

P. H.

(2010). The economic impact of local immigration regulation: An empirical analysis. Cardozo Law Review, 32, 485–518.

48.

Potochnick

Chen

J. H.

Perreira

(2017). Local-level immigration enforcement and food insecurity risk among Hispanic immigrant families with children: National-level evidence. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 19, 1042–1049.

49.

Rhodes

S. D.

Mann

Simán

F. M.

Song

Alonzo

Downs

. . . Hall

M. A.

(2015). The impact of local immigration enforcement policies on the health of immigrant Hispanics/Latinos in the United States. American Journal of Public Health, 105, 329–337.

50.

Rojas-Flores

Clements

M. L.

Hwang Koo

London

(2017). Trauma and psychological distress in Latino citizen children following parental detention and deportation. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 9, 352–361.

51.

Rugh

Hall

(2016). Deporting the American dream: Immigration enforcement and Latino foreclosures. Sociological Science, 3, 1053–1076.

52.

Rumberger

R. W.

(2015). Student mobility: Causes, consequences, and solutions. Boulder, CO: National Education Policy Center.

53.

Rumberger

R. W.

Larson

K. A.

Ream

R. K.

Palardy

G. J.

(1999). The educational consequences of mobility for California students and schools. Berkeley, CA: Policy Analysis for California Education.

54.

Shahani

Greene

(2009). Local democracy on ICE: Why state and local governments have no business in federal immigration law enforcement. Brooklyn, NY: Justice Strategies.

55.

U.S. Department of Education. (2012). Children classified as having an emotional disturbance: First step to success. Washington, DC: Institute of Education Sciences, What Works Clearinghouse.

56.

Van Hook

Bachmeier

J. D

. (2013). How well does the American community survey count naturalized citizens? Demographic Research, 29, 1–32.

57.

Watson

(2013). Enforcement and immigrant location choice. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

58.

Welsh

R. O.

(2017). School hopscotch: A comprehensive review of K–12 student mobility in the United States. Review of Educational Research, 87, 475–511.

59.

Hannaway

D’Souza

(2009). Student transience in North Carolina: The effect of school mobility on student outcomes using longitudinal data. Washington, DC: National Center for Analysis of Longitudinal Data in Education Research.