Differences in Cohesion between High School and College Football Teams and Starters and Nonstarters

Abstract

The Group Environment Questionnaire was administered at the end of the season to 44 football players from a large high school, 25 players from a medium-sized high school, and 52 players from a National Collegiate Athletic Association Division III university. It was hypothesized that starters would be more cohesive than nonstarters and that high school teams would be more cohesive than the university team. Scores from the four sub-scales were analyzed with two-way (High School/University X Starter/Nonstarter) analysis of variance. Main effects for Team and for Starter/Nonstarter were significant for the Individual Attraction to Group-Task and Group Integration-Task scales. Starters scored higher than nonstarters on both scales, and high school teams scored higher than the university team on both scales. Results support Widmeyer, Brawley, and Carron's 1985 model, which specifies that teams' characteristics and players' characteristics are antecedents of team cohesion.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ball

Carron

A. V.

(1976) The influence of team cohesion and participation motivation upon performance success in intercollegiate ice hockey. Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences, 1, 271–275.

Bird

A. M.

(1977) Development of a model for predicting team performance. Research Quarterly, 48, 24–32.

Brawley

L. R.

Carron

A. V.

Widmeyer

W. N.

(1987) Assessing the cohesion of teams: Validity of the Group Environment Questionnaire. Journal of Sport Psychology, 9, 275–294.

Carron

A. V.

(1982) Cohesiveness in sport groups: Interpretation and considerations. Journal of Sport Psychology, 4, 123–138.

Carron

A. V.

Chelladurai

(1981) The dynamics of group cohesion in sport. Journal of Sport Psychology, 3, 123–129.

Carron

A. V.

Widmeyer

W. N.

Brawley

L. R.

(1985) The development of an instrument to assess cohesion in sport teams: The Group Environment Questionnaire. Journal of Sport Psychology, 7, 244–266.

Gruber

J. J.

Gray

G. R.

(1981) Factor patterns of variables influencing cohesiveness at various levels of basketball competition. Research Quarterly, 52, 19–30.

Klein

Christiansen

(1969) Group composition, group structure, and group effectiveness of basketball teams. In Loy

J. W.

Kenyon

G. S.

(Eds.), Sport, culture, and society: A reader on the sociology of sport. London: Macmillan. Pp. 397–408.

Landers

Crum

(1971) The effect of team success and formal structure on interpersonal relations and cohesiveness of baseball teams. International Journal of Sport Psychology, 2, 88–96.

10.

Landers

D. M.

Lueschen

(1974) Team performance outcome and cohesiveness of competitive co-acting groups. International Review of Sport Psychology, 2, 57–69.

11.

Landers

D. M.

Wilkinson

M. O.

Hatfield

B. D.

Barber

(1982) Causality and the cohesion-performance relationship. Journal of Sport Psychology, 4, 170–183.

12.

Lenk

(1969) Top performance despite internal conflicts: An antithesis to a functionalistic proposition. In Loy

J. W.

Kenyon

G. S.

(Eds.), Sport, culture, and society: A reader on the sociology of sport. London: Macmillan. Pp. 393–397.

13.

Martens

Peterson

(1971) Group cohesiveness as a determinant of success and member satisfaction in team performance. International Review of Sport Psychology, 6, 49–71.

14.

McGrath

The influence of positive interpersonal relations on adjustment and effectiveness in rifle teams. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 65, 365–375.

15.

Robinson

Carron

A. V.

(1983) Personal and situational factors associated with dropping out versus maintaining participation in competitive sport. Journal of Sport Psychology, 4, 364–378.

16.

Widmeyer

Brawley

Carron

(1985) The measurement of cohesion in sport teams: The Group Environment Questionnaire. London, Ontario: Sports Dynamics.

17.

Widmeyer

Martens

(1978) When cohesion predicts performance outcome in sport. Research Quarterly, 49, 372–380.

18.

Williams

J. M.

Hacker

C. M.

(1982) Causal relationships among cohesion, satisfaction and performance in women's intercollegiate field hockey teams. Journal of Sport Psychology, 4, 324–337.